Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Investor psychology Lesson 10 of 15

Articles · Behavioral finance

Home bias and familiarity bias: why investors stay close to home

Why investors hold mostly their own country, their own region and their own employer, what the research measured, and what 25 years of US and foreign returns show.

On this page
  1. What the research measured
  2. What it looks like in an account
  3. Twenty-five years of home against away
  4. What helps
  5. How Finabase helps
  6. Frequently asked questions
  7. Summary
  8. Check your understanding
  9. Exercise

Home bias is the tendency to hold far more of your own country's investments than its share of the world market would suggest. Familiarity bias is the broader habit behind it: people prefer to invest in what they know, whether that is their country, their region, the company whose products they buy or the company that employs them.

Familiar feels safe. The research in this lesson shows that the feeling is mostly not information: investors who stay close to home do not, on the whole, earn more for it, and in one case, employer stock, they take a risk that can end a retirement plan. The lesson also looks honestly at the awkward fact for anyone preaching global diversification, which is that US investors who ignored the rest of the world for the past 15 years did better.

What the research measured

Across countries

Kenneth French and James Poterba published the classic measurement in 1991. Using data for the end of 1989, they estimated that US investors held 93.8% of their equity portfolios in US stocks, Japanese investors 98.1% in Japanese stocks and UK investors 82.0% in UK stocks. No country's market was anywhere near that share of the world total. To justify such portfolios on expected returns alone, they calculated, investors in each country would have to expect their home market to beat the others by several percentage points a year, and investors in different countries would have to hold opposite beliefs at the same time.

Costs and rules explained part of it in 1989, when buying foreign shares was expensive and sometimes restricted. Those barriers have mostly gone. A US investor can buy a fund holding thousands of foreign companies for a few hundredths of a percent a year. The bias has shrunk since 1991 but has not disappeared: Vanguard, using IMF data, still found US investors holding US stocks well above their weight in the world market in 2019. The barriers were never the whole story.

Inside one country

If the cause were only currencies or foreign law, the bias would stop at the border. It does not.

Joshua Coval and Tobias Moskowitz studied US mutual fund managers and found they held companies headquartered 9% to 11% closer to the fund's own office than the average company they could have held, and the preference was strongest for small, highly levered firms that produce goods sold locally. Gur Huberman looked at the seven regional phone companies created by the breakup of AT&T in 1984. At the end of 1996, in most states, more people held shares of their local company than of any of the other six, though the seven were similar businesses and holding the distant ones would have diversified a household whose income already depended on the local economy.

Mark Grinblatt and Matti Keloharju found the same pattern in Finland with unusually good data: investors preferred firms that were nearby, that published reports in the investor's own language and whose chief executive shared their cultural background.

Does local knowledge pay?

The natural defense of familiarity is that it is information. On this the evidence is mixed, and it is fair to say so. Zoran Ivković and Scott Weisbenner found that US households' local holdings outperformed their non-local holdings by about 3.2% a year in one large brokerage data set. Mark Seasholes and Ning Zhu re-examined individual investors' local portfolios with different methods and found no such advantage: local holdings earned no abnormal return, and the local stocks people bought did worse than the ones they sold. For professional managers, Coval and Moskowitz did find some advantage in local picks.

A cautious summary: a professional who lives near a company may learn something. An individual who shops there usually learns only what everyone already knows.

Employer stock

The form of familiarity bias with the clearest cost is holding your own employer's shares in a retirement plan. Shlomo Benartzi studied large US 401(k) plans and found that employees directed about a quarter of their own discretionary contributions to company stock. They put in far more when the stock had done well over the previous ten years: about 40% at the best past performers against about 10% at the worst. The past return did not predict the future one. Over the following year the plans with the most company stock earned less than those with the least, though the difference was not statistically significant.

The risk is not the stock's return on average. It is that a job and a portfolio fail together. At the end of 2000, about 62% of the assets in Enron's 401(k) plan were Enron shares. The stock fell from over $80 in January 2001 to under $1 a year later, and employees lost their savings in the same months that many lost their jobs. A paycheck is already a large, undiversified bet on one company. Concentration risk covers the arithmetic.

What it looks like in an account

An illustrative household, both earners working in the US, one at a listed technology company:

Holding Value Share
Employer stock (vested and 401(k)) $90,000 30%
US large-company index fund $150,000 50%
Five US stocks "we know" $45,000 15%
International fund $15,000 5%
Total $300,000 100%

The household would describe this as diversified: four kinds of holding, hundreds of companies. Measured by what it depends on, it is one bet three times over. Ninety-five percent is in US companies, against a US weight of 64.6% in the MSCI ACWI index of world stock markets (October 30, 2026). Thirty percent is in the one company that also pays a salary. And if the five familiar stocks are technology names, as they tend to be for people who work in technology, they will fall with the employer.

Nothing in the table is forbidden or foolish on its own. The point of writing it out is that familiarity made each line feel like a separate, safe decision, and the total was never chosen.

Twenty-five years of home against away

Home bias has no fixed cost. Whether it helped or hurt depends on the period and on which country is "home". The figure compares two funds from January 2002 to October 2026: SPY for large US companies and EFA, which tracks developed markets in Europe, Australasia and the Far East. Both include dividends and are measured in US dollars.

US stocks and developed markets abroad: annualized total return by period S&P 500 (SPY) Developed markets outside North America (EFA) 6.0% 15.9% 2002–2007 1.7% −3.4% 2008–2012 15.7% 7.4% 2013–2017 9.3% 1.6% 2018–2022 20.9% 15.9% 2023–Oct 2026 Month-end prices with dividends added, in US dollars. EFA tracks the MSCI EAFE index.
SPY and EFA, annualized total return in US dollars by period, January 2002 to October 2026. Month-end prices with dividends added.
Period SPY (US) EFA (developed ex-North America)
2002–2007 6.0% 15.9%
2008–2012 1.7% −3.4%
2013–2017 15.7% 7.4%
2018–2022 9.3% 1.6%
2023–Oct 2026 20.9% 15.9%
Whole period 9.9% 7.2%

Over the whole period $10,000 grew to about $103,400 in SPY and $55,800 in EFA. A US investor with a strong home bias came out well ahead. Three cautions belong next to that result.

  1. It was not one-way. In the six years to 2007 the foreign fund returned almost 10 percentage points a year more. In January 2012, the ten-year record favored EFA by 3.3 points a year. Investors who extrapolated that moved abroad just before the US pulled ahead; see recency bias and performance chasing.
  2. The result depends on where home is. A Japanese investor who held only Japanese stocks from the 1989 peak waited more than three decades for the index to regain it. Home bias paid for Americans in this period. It is the same bias, with a different draw.
  3. Diversification did less than textbooks promise. The two funds' monthly returns had a correlation of 0.85. A 50/50 mix had a volatility of 15.1% a year against 14.8% for SPY alone, so in these years foreign stocks added no risk reduction to speak of. What international holdings insure against is not monthly swings. It is a long period in which one country, possibly yours, does badly.

The honest conclusion is not that global diversification always wins. It is that a 95% home weight is a large bet on one country continuing to lead, and most people holding it never decided to make that bet.

What helps

There is no experiment showing that a particular exercise cures home bias. The steps below make the bet visible, which is the most the evidence supports.

  • Add it up by exposure, not by account. List every holding by country and by what else in your life depends on the same thing (employer, local property, industry). The table above takes ten minutes.
  • Choose the home weight on purpose. There are defensible reasons to hold more than the market weight at home: your spending is in your own currency, foreign dividends can carry withholding tax, and costs are lowest at home. A chosen 75% is a different thing from an accidental 95%.
  • Set a ceiling for employer stock. Many advisers and plan sponsors use 10% of investable assets as a rule of thumb. The number is a convention, not a research finding, but any written ceiling turns later decisions into arithmetic.
  • Ask what you know that the price does not. Liking a product, or working in an industry, is information the market already has.

How Finabase helps

The comparison tab on any symbol page charts it against other symbols over the same dates, so you can redo the home-and-away comparison for any pair of funds and any period. A portfolio lists each position with its market value, which is the raw material for the exposure table above. The indices page shows the major indexes of other countries beside the US ones each day, a small antidote to seeing only the home market.

Frequently asked questions

What is home bias in investing?

Home bias is holding a much larger share of domestic investments than your country's weight in the world market. A US investor with 95% in US stocks, against a world weight of roughly 65%, has a home bias of about 30 percentage points.

Is home bias always a mistake?

No. It has been costly or profitable depending on the country and the period, and there are real reasons (currency, taxes, costs) to hold somewhat more at home. It becomes a mistake when the weight was never chosen, or when it rests on the belief that familiar means safe.

How much international stock should a US investor hold?

There is no agreed answer, and this lesson does not give advice. The market-weight answer is the foreign share of the world index, a bit over a third in October 2026. Many target-date funds hold less than that. What matters is that the figure is a decision with reasons attached.

Why is holding my employer's stock risky if I know the company well?

Because your salary already depends on the same company. If it struggles, your job and your savings are hit together. Employees' sense of knowing the firm did not help them in Benartzi's study: plans where employees held the most company stock did no better afterwards.

Summary

Investors hold what is near and known: their own country, their own region, the companies they buy from and the company that pays them. French and Poterba measured domestic shares of 82% to 98% in 1989, and later studies found the same preference between regions of one country. For individuals, the evidence that familiarity brings an information edge is weak, and employer stock joins job risk to portfolio risk. Over 2002 to 2026 a US investor's home bias was rewarded, with SPY at 9.9% a year against 7.2% for developed markets abroad, yet the lead ran the other way in the first six of those years. The useful habit is to add up exposure across every account and decide the home weight on purpose.

Check your understanding

5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. A US household holds 95% of its stocks in US companies. The US is roughly 65% of the world’s listed market value. What does the gap represent?

    1. A guarantee of higher returns, because US stocks have done better
    2. A bet of about 30 percentage points that the US will keep leading, whether or not the household meant to make it
    3. Nothing, because US companies sell products worldwide
    Show the answer

    B. A bet of about 30 percentage points that the US will keep leading, whether or not the household meant to make it Any weight above the market weight is an active bet on that country. It has paid off for US investors since 2008, but the lesson’s point is that most holders never chose it.

  2. From 2002 to 2007 a developed-markets fund returned 15.9% a year against 6.0% for SPY. Over the following 19 years SPY was far ahead. What is the sound lesson?

    1. Foreign stocks are always the better choice
    2. US stocks are always the better choice
    3. Leadership between regions changes, and the recent winner is a poor guide to the next period
    Show the answer

    C. Leadership between regions changes, and the recent winner is a poor guide to the next period In January 2012 the ten-year record favored the foreign fund by 3.3 points a year, just before the US pulled ahead. Extrapolating either stretch would have misled.

  3. Why is employer stock in a 401(k) riskier than the same amount in an unrelated company of equal volatility?

    1. Employer stock is always more volatile
    2. The employee’s salary already depends on the same company, so job and savings can fail together
    3. Employer stock pays no dividends
    Show the answer

    B. The employee’s salary already depends on the same company, so job and savings can fail together The danger is the link between income and portfolio. Enron employees held about 62% of their plan in Enron shares and lost savings and jobs in the same months.

  4. An investor says “I shop at this retailer every week, so I understand the stock better than the market does.” Which finding bears on this?

    1. Individuals’ local and familiar holdings showed no reliable advantage in the stricter studies, because what a customer sees is already in the price
    2. Customers always know more than analysts
    3. Retail stocks cannot be valued
    Show the answer

    A. Individuals’ local and familiar holdings showed no reliable advantage in the stricter studies, because what a customer sees is already in the price Seasholes and Zhu found no outperformance from individuals’ local holdings. Familiarity produces comfort; an edge needs information the price does not already contain.

  5. Over 2002 to 2026 SPY and EFA had a monthly correlation of 0.85 and a 50/50 mix was about as volatile as SPY alone. What then is the case for holding both?

    1. There is none
    2. Protection against a long stretch in which one country does badly, not against month-to-month swings
    3. A guaranteed higher return
    Show the answer

    B. Protection against a long stretch in which one country does badly, not against month-to-month swings Highly correlated markets still diverge over a decade or more, as Japan after 1989 shows. International holdings insure against the single-country outcome.

Exercise

One task to do in Finabase. Nothing is graded or saved.

Open the Comparison tab for EFA (a fund of developed markets outside North America) and add SPY. Look at the longest range offered, then at one year. Which fund led in each? Then open your own portfolio or watchlist and estimate what share of it is US companies.

Open EFA comparison
What you should find

The leader often differs between the long and the short range, which is the point: neither stretch tells you the next one. For your own holdings, compare your US share with the US weight in a world index (roughly two thirds). A gap is not wrong in itself. The question is whether you chose it.

Sources and further reading

  1. French and Poterba — Investor diversification and international equity markets, American Economic Review 81(2), 1991
  2. Coval and Moskowitz — Home bias at home: local equity preference in domestic portfolios, Journal of Finance 54(6), 1999
  3. Huberman — Familiarity breeds investment, Review of Financial Studies 14(3), 2001
  4. Benartzi — Excessive extrapolation and the allocation of 401(k) accounts to company stock, Journal of Finance 56(5), 2001
  5. Grinblatt and Keloharju — How distance, language, and culture influence stockholdings and trades, Journal of Finance 56(3), 2001
  6. Ivković and Weisbenner — Local does as local is: information content of the geography of individual investors’ common stock investments, Journal of Finance 60(1), 2005
  7. Seasholes and Zhu — Individual investors and local bias, Journal of Finance 65(5), 2010
  8. Congressional Research Service — The Enron bankruptcy and employer stock in retirement plans (RS21115)
  9. MSCI — ACWI Index (USD) factsheet, country weights as of October 30, 2026
  10. Vanguard — Global equity investing: the benefits of diversification and sizing your allocation (Donaldson et al., April 2021)
  11. Finabase chart data — SPY and EFA monthly closes and dividends, January 2002 to October 2026