Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Social Security and pensions Lesson 8 of 8

Retirement · Social Security and pensions

Pension lump sum or annuity: how defined-benefit choices work

How a defined-benefit pension is calculated, how a lump sum is valued under §417(e), survivor options and spousal consent, PBGC limits, and the end of WEP and GPO.

On this page
  1. How a defined-benefit pension is calculated
  2. The payment forms
  3. How the lump sum is valued
  4. Annuity or lump sum: what each one buys
  5. What PBGC guarantees
  6. Pensions and Social Security after the Fairness Act
  7. Pitfalls
  8. Comparison of the payment options
  9. How Finabase does it
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. Summary
  12. Check your understanding
  13. Exercise

A defined-benefit pension promises an income, not an account balance. The employer's plan pays a monthly amount for life, set by a formula of salary and years of service, and bears the investment risk of funding it. At retirement, and sometimes earlier when an employer wants to shrink its plan, many workers face a choice that cannot be undone: take the pension as a lifetime annuity, choose how much of it continues to a spouse, or take a single lump sum and manage the money themselves.

The lump sum is not an arbitrary offer. US law sets a minimum, calculated from interest rates and a mortality table that the IRS publishes, so the same pension is worth a different lump sum depending on the month it is calculated. This lesson explains the pension formula, how a lump sum is valued, why rising rates shrink it, the joint-and-survivor rules and spousal consent required by federal law, what the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation (PBGC) insures, and how the 2025 repeal of the Windfall Elimination Provision changed the picture for people with pensions from jobs outside Social Security. The worked example values $2,000 a month for life at two interest rates.

How a defined-benefit pension is calculated

Most traditional pensions use a final-average-pay formula:

Final average pay is usually the average of the highest or last three to five years of salary; the multiplier is often between 1% and 2.5%, depending on the plan and on whether the job is also covered by Social Security. A worker with final average pay of $90,000, 30 years of service and a 1.5% multiplier has an annual pension of $90,000 × 30 × 0.015 = $40,500, or $3,375 a month, starting at the plan's normal retirement age, often 65. Plans may reduce the benefit for starting earlier, and most private-sector plans do not raise it with inflation after it starts, which matters over a retirement that can last 25 years or more.

Other designs exist. Career-average plans use pay across all years; cash-balance plans express the benefit as a notional account that grows with pay credits and interest credits but still must offer an annuity. Whatever the formula, the benefit is the plan's promise, and the plan document is the place to check it.

The payment forms

A plan states its benefit as a single-life annuity, paid only for the participant's life. Married participants, however, start from a different default. Federal law requires defined-benefit plans (and money purchase and target benefit plans) to pay a married participant a qualified joint and survivor annuity (QJSA) unless both spouses consent to something else, according to the IRS. A QJSA pays for the participant's life and then a survivor annuity to the spouse of at least 50% and no more than 100% of the amount paid during the participant's life. A participant who waives it can choose a qualified optional survivor annuity, another survivor percentage the plan offers.

Waiving the QJSA, for a single-life annuity or a lump sum, needs the spouse's written consent, witnessed by a notary or a plan representative, within the election period before payments begin. The consent rule exists because the pension is often a household's largest asset and the survivor annuity is the spouse's protection.

A survivor option costs something: because payments may continue for two lives, the monthly amount is lower. Using SSA's 2023 period life table at 4%, for a man and a woman both aged 65, a 100% joint-and-survivor annuity worth the same as a $2,000 single-life annuity on the man would pay about $1,600 a month, and a 50% joint-and-survivor about $1,778. At 6% the figures are $1,647 and $1,806. Actual plan factors use the plan's own assumptions and can differ.

How the lump sum is valued

When a plan offers a lump sum, Internal Revenue Code §417(e)(3) sets the least it may pay: the present value of the annuity, using an applicable interest rate and an applicable mortality table, both prescribed by the IRS. The interest rates are three "segment rates", for payments due in roughly the first five years, the next fifteen, and beyond twenty, derived from investment-grade corporate bond yields. The IRS publishes them monthly. Recent values:

Month First segment Second segment Third segment
January 2026 4.03% 5.20% 6.12%
April 2026 4.27% 5.34% 6.22%
July 2026 4.62% 5.62% 6.51%
September 2026 5.06% 5.99% 6.72%

Each plan names a "lookback" month and a "stability period" in its document, so a lump sum paid in 2027 may use rates from a month in late 2026. Rates rose through 2026, so a lump sum computed with September 2026 rates would be smaller than one computed with January's.

Worked example: $2,000 a month for life from 65

A single interest rate shows the mechanics. The value at 65 of $1 a year for life is the sum, over every future year, of the chance of being alive to receive it, discounted at the interest rate. Using SSA's 2023 period life table and payments of $24,000 at the start of each year:

Interest rate Man aged 65: factor Lump sum Woman aged 65: factor Lump sum
2% 15.191 $364,577 16.939 $406,541
3% 13.855 $332,512 15.320 $367,690
4% 12.710 $305,033 13.948 $334,746
5% 11.722 $281,337 12.776 $306,616
6% 10.866 $260,779 11.768 $282,438
7% 10.118 $242,840 10.897 $261,523
8% 9.462 $227,100 10.138 $243,321

At 4% the man's annuity factor is 12.710, so the lump sum is $24,000 × 12.710 = $305,033. At 6% the factor falls to 10.866 and the lump sum to $260,779, 14.5% less. For the woman, who on average lives longer, the values are higher, $334,746 and $282,438, and fall 15.6%.

Lump sum equal in value to $2,000 a month for life from 65, by interest rate $200k $250k $300k $350k $400k $450k $500k 2% 3% 4% 5% 6% 7% 8% Man aged 65 Woman aged 65 $305,033 $260,779 $334,746 $282,438 Interest rate used to discount the payments Lump-sum equivalent
Present value at 65 of $2,000 a month for life, by interest rate, using the SSA 2023 period life table and annual payments. Real plans use IRS §417(e) mortality and segment rates. Computed by Finabase.

Three simplifications keep the example readable, and each would change the dollar answer a plan computes. Plans use the IRS's §417(e) mortality table, which is the same for men and women, not SSA's separate tables. They use three segment rates rather than one. And they pay monthly, not yearly in advance; monthly payments are worth roughly 3% to 5% less than the annual-in-advance figures here. The direction of every effect in the table is right, and so is its size: two points of interest rate move a pension's lump-sum value by about 15%.

Annuity or lump sum: what each one buys

Taking the annuity buys income that lasts as long as the retiree (and, with a survivor option, the spouse) lives. It removes investment risk and the risk of outliving savings, the same longevity protection discussed for Social Security in When to claim Social Security: 62, 67 or 70, with break-even ages. Its costs are that most private pensions are fixed in dollars, so inflation erodes them; the money cannot be passed on except through a survivor option; and the retiree depends on the plan and, if it fails, on PBGC.

Taking the lump sum buys control. The money can be invested, spent on a timetable the retiree chooses, left to heirs, or used to buy an annuity from an insurer later. Its costs are investment risk, the risk of withdrawals during a market fall early in retirement (Sequence of returns risk: why the order of returns matters), and the risk of running out. A sustainable withdrawal rate from a lump sum is usually well below the payout rate of the annuity it replaced; Safe withdrawal rates: how much can a portfolio pay out? explains why. Paid to an IRA by direct rollover, a lump sum stays tax-deferred; paid to the retiree, the plan must withhold 20% for federal income tax.

Which is worth more depends on health, other guaranteed income (Social Security above all), whether a spouse needs survivor income, the plan's financial strength and the rates at the time. The lump-sum minimum is a fair price only on the IRS's average assumptions; someone with a shorter life expectancy than the table gets more value from the lump sum, and someone with a longer one from the annuity.

What PBGC guarantees

PBGC, a federal corporation, insures private-sector defined-benefit plans. If a single-employer plan ends without enough money, PBGC pays benefits up to a legal maximum set by the year the plan terminates. For plans ending in 2026, the maximum at 65 is $7,789.77 a month as a straight-life annuity ($93,477 a year) or $7,010.79 as a joint-and-50% survivor annuity for spouses of the same age; for 2027 the figures are $8,113.64 and $7,302.28. The limit is lower for younger starting ages ($3,505.40 at 55 and $6,153.92 at 62 for 2026; $3,651.14 and $6,409.78 for 2027) and higher for older ones. Multiemployer plans have a separate, much lower guarantee, and government plans are not covered by PBGC at all.

Most pensions are well under the maximum, so the guarantee covers them in full. It matters mainly for high earners and for benefits granted shortly before a plan ends, which may be only partly guaranteed.

Pensions and Social Security after the Fairness Act

Until 2025, two Social Security rules reduced benefits for people with a pension from work not covered by Social Security, mostly some state and local government and some federal employees. The Windfall Elimination Provision lowered their own retirement benefit, and the Government Pension Offset cut spousal and survivor benefits, often to zero. The Social Security Fairness Act, signed January 5, 2025, repealed both for benefits payable after December 2023. A teacher with a state pension from non-covered work and enough covered work elsewhere now receives the Social Security benefit the formula gives, without an offset.

Pitfalls

  • Rates move the lump sum. A two-point rise in rates cut the example's value by about 15%. Knowing which month's rates the plan uses is part of the decision.
  • Inflation. A fixed $2,000 loses about a third of its purchasing power over 20 years at 2% inflation (Inflation and real returns: what an investment earns after prices).
  • The survivor. Choosing a single-life annuity raises the check but leaves nothing to a spouse; the law makes the spouse sign for that reason.
  • Comparing the lump sum with the annuity's total payments. The relevant comparison is with the present value, which depends on rates and life expectancy, not with the sum of all checks.
  • Withholding. A lump sum paid directly to the retiree has 20% withheld, even if they intend to roll it over.
  • Offers outside retirement. Employers sometimes offer lump-sum windows to former employees; the same valuation rules apply, and the decision is just as permanent.

Comparison of the payment options

Option Pays Survivor protection Inflation Risk borne by
Single-life annuity Highest monthly amount, for one life None Usually none Plan, then PBGC
Joint and 50% survivor Lower amount; half continues to spouse 50% for the spouse’s life Usually none Plan, then PBGC
Joint and 100% survivor Lowest amount; all continues to spouse 100% for the spouse’s life Usually none Plan, then PBGC
Lump sum (rolled to an IRA) One payment, at least the §417(e) value Whatever the account holds Depends on investments Retiree

How Finabase does it

Finabase cannot see a pension plan or value a specific offer; the plan administrator must give the exact figures and the rates and mortality used. As a research app, Finabase helps with the market side of the decision: the Treasury page shows government yields, a reference for the rate environment; a fund such as LQD shows how investment-grade corporate bond yields, from which the IRS segment rates are built, have moved; and Portfolio can track a rolled-over lump sum. The figures on this page come from a Finabase Learn script using SSA's 2023 period life table.

Frequently asked questions

Why did my pension lump-sum offer go down when nothing else changed?

Most likely because interest rates rose. The minimum lump sum is a present value; when the IRS segment rates the plan uses go up, the present value of the same monthly pension goes down.

Does my spouse have to agree if I take the lump sum?

Yes, if the plan is a defined-benefit, money purchase or target benefit plan and you are married. Waiving the joint-and-survivor annuity requires your spouse's written consent, witnessed by a notary or a plan representative.

How much of my pension does PBGC guarantee?

For a single-employer plan that ends in 2026, up to $7,789.77 a month at 65 as a straight-life annuity ($8,113.64 for 2027), less at younger ages. Most pensions fall under that limit and are covered in full.

Does a government pension still reduce my Social Security?

No, not since the Social Security Fairness Act of January 5, 2025, which repealed the Windfall Elimination Provision and the Government Pension Offset for benefits payable after December 2023.

Summary

A defined-benefit pension pays final average pay × years × a multiplier, $40,500 a year in the example. A married participant's default is a joint-and-survivor annuity, and choosing anything else requires the spouse's witnessed consent. A lump sum must be at least the present value under §417(e), which falls as rates rise: $2,000 a month from 65 is worth about $305,000 for a man at 4% and $261,000 at 6% on SSA's table, 15% less. PBGC guarantees single-employer pensions up to $7,789.77 a month at 65 for 2026 terminations ($8,113.64 for 2027), and since January 2025 non-covered pensions no longer reduce Social Security.

Check your understanding

4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. A pension pays final average pay × years of service × 1.5%. What is the annual pension for $90,000 of final average pay and 30 years?

    1. $27,000
    2. $40,500
    3. $135,000
    Show the answer

    B. $40,500 $90,000 × 30 × 0.015 = $40,500 a year, or $3,375 a month.

  2. Interest rates rise between two months. What happens to the minimum lump sum a plan must offer for the same monthly pension?

    1. It rises, because money earns more
    2. It falls, because future payments are discounted more heavily
    3. Nothing; the lump sum is fixed when you are hired
    Show the answer

    B. It falls, because future payments are discounted more heavily The §417(e) minimum is a present value. Higher discount rates make each future payment worth less today; in the example, moving from 4% to 6% cut the value of $2,000 a month from 65 by about 15%.

  3. A married participant in a defined-benefit plan wants a single-life annuity instead of the joint-and-survivor default. What is required?

    1. Nothing beyond the participant’s election
    2. The spouse’s written consent, witnessed by a notary or plan representative
    3. Approval from PBGC
    Show the answer

    B. The spouse’s written consent, witnessed by a notary or plan representative Federal law makes a qualified joint and survivor annuity the default for married participants in these plans. Waiving it requires the spouse’s written, witnessed consent.

  4. The lump-sum minimum is priced on average life expectancy. Who tends to get more value from taking the lump sum rather than the annuity?

    1. Someone expecting to live much longer than average
    2. Someone with a shorter life expectancy than the table assumes
    3. Everyone equally
    Show the answer

    B. Someone with a shorter life expectancy than the table assumes The lump sum equals the annuity’s present value on average assumptions. A person likely to die sooner than average would collect fewer payments than the table assumes, so the lump sum is worth more to them; a long-lived person gets more from the annuity.

Exercise

One task to do in Finabase. Nothing is graded or saved.

The lesson values a $2,000-a-month pension from 65 at about $305,000 for a man at 4% and $261,000 at 6%. Open the Treasury page and read the 20-year and 30-year yields. Lump sums are priced on corporate bond rates a little above Treasuries, so add about one point to the 20-year yield. Interpolate between the lesson’s two values: roughly what lump sum would that rate give, and how much does each point of rate move it?

Open Treasury yields
What you should find

Between 4% and 6% the value falls about $22,000 for each point, so a 5% rate gives roughly $283,000. When long yields rise, offered lump sums shrink for the same pension; when they fall, lump sums grow. The pension’s monthly payment is the same either way: only its price changes.

Sources and further reading

  1. Internal Revenue Service — Minimum present value segment rates (section 417(e)(3)(D)), page updated November 9, 2026
  2. Internal Revenue Service — Retirement topics: qualified joint and survivor annuity, page updated July 31, 2026
  3. Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation — Maximum monthly guarantee tables (2026 and 2027), updated October 19, 2026
  4. Social Security Administration, Office of the Chief Actuary — Period life table, 2023 (2026 Trustees Report)
  5. Internal Revenue Service — Rollovers of retirement plan and IRA distributions