Save for retirement Lesson 1 of 11
Retirement · Planning for retirement
How much to save for retirement: replacement rates and savings rates
How a replacement rate is built, how much of it Social Security covers at four earnings levels under 2027 rules, and the savings rate a target needs by start age.
On this page
"How much should I save for retirement?" has no single answer, and any page that gives one without asking about the reader is guessing. What it does have is a method. Work out what share of today's pay the household would need once it stops working, subtract what Social Security will pay, and then ask what yearly saving, at a given rate of return over a given number of years, builds a pot large enough to pay the rest. Every step has an input only the reader knows: their pay, their spending, when they start, when they stop, and how their money is invested.
This lesson walks through the method with stated numbers. It builds a replacement rate for an example household and shows why it lands between about 60% and 80% of gross pay rather than 100%. It computes, with the Social Security Administration's (SSA) 2027 benefit formula, how much of that target Social Security covers for low, average, high and maximum earners. Then it solves for the savings rate needed when saving starts at 25, 35 or 45 and money earns 1%, 3% or 5% a year above inflation. The point is to see which inputs move the answer most, not to adopt any of these numbers.
Step 1: the replacement rate
A replacement rate is income in retirement divided by gross income just before it. Planners use it because most people know their salary better than they know their spending. The rate a household needs is rarely 100%, and the reasons are mechanical, not optimistic.
- Saving stops. Money that went into a 401(k), IRA or brokerage account while working was never spent. Once retired, it is not needed as income.
- Payroll tax stops. Employees pay 7.65% of wages for Social Security and Medicare (6.2% plus 1.45%, according to SSA's 2027 fact sheet). Retirement income such as withdrawals and benefits does not carry that tax.
- Income tax often falls. Lower total income, and the different treatment of Social Security and Roth withdrawals, usually mean a smaller share goes to income tax. How much depends on the household's mix of accounts and its state; the taxes section covers the rules.
- Some costs end. A mortgage paid off before retirement, commuting, and the cost of raising children are common examples. Other costs, chiefly health care, usually rise.
The same household, with the same lifestyle, needs anywhere from about 59% to 78% of its pay depending on one fact about its house. A household that saved 20% while working would need less again, because more of its pay was never spent. A household planning to travel heavily in the first decade, or expecting to pay for a parent's care, would need more. Rules of thumb in the 70% to 80% range describe an average across many households; they do not describe any single one. The more useful exercise is to list the household's actual spending and ask which lines will change.
Step 2: what Social Security covers
Social Security is the largest source of retirement income for most American households, and its formula is deliberately progressive. How Social Security benefits are calculated: AIME, PIA, bend points covers the mechanics. In short: earnings in each year up to age 60 are scaled up by the growth of the national average wage, the best 35 years are averaged into a monthly figure (the AIME), and the primary insurance amount (PIA) pays 90% of the first $1,340 of AIME, 32% of the AIME up to $8,077, and 15% above that, for workers who turn 62 in 2027.
To see what that means at different incomes, this lesson defines four workers born in 1965, who become eligible in 2027:
- Low: earns 45% of the national average wage in every year from age 25 to 61.
- Medium: earns exactly the average wage every year.
- High: earns 160% of the average wage every year.
- Maximum: earns the taxable maximum every year from age 22. This is SSA's own published example, with an AIME of $14,966.
Because the first three earn a fixed share of the average wage, every indexed year equals that share of the 2025 average wage index, $72,800.33, and the AIME is that share divided by 12. These paths are deliberately flat. Real careers rise and fall, and a worker with fewer than 35 years of earnings has zeros in the average. Each worker's "pay" below is their earnings at 2025 wage levels; for the maximum earner it is the 2026 taxable maximum, $184,500.
| Earner | Pay | AIME | PIA | Benefit at 67, a year | Share of pay at 62 | at 67 | at 70 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Low | $32,760 | $2,730 | $1,650.80 | $19,810 | 42.3% | 60.5% | 75.0% |
| Medium | $72,800 | $6,066 | $2,718.30 | $32,620 | 31.4% | 44.8% | 55.6% |
| High | $116,481 | $9,706 | $3,606.10 | $43,273 | 26.0% | 37.2% | 46.1% |
| Maximum | $184,500 | $14,966 | $4,395.10 | $52,741 | 20.0% | 28.6% | 35.4% |
The claiming-age columns apply SSA's reduction and credit rules for a full retirement age of 67: 70% of the PIA at 62 and 124% at 70 (When to claim Social Security: 62, 67 or 70, with break-even ages). The amounts are in 2027 terms; cost-of-living adjustments raise them from the year of eligibility onward.
The pattern is the point. A low earner who claims at 67 gets about 61% of pay from Social Security alone, close to a full replacement target on its own. A worker at the taxable maximum gets 29%. The higher the pay, the more of retirement income has to come from the household's own savings. The claiming age moves every row by a third or more, which makes it one of the biggest levers a saver has, and one that is decided at the end rather than the start.
Step 3: the savings rate that fills the gap
Take the medium earner and a target of 70% of pay. Social Security at 67 covers 44.8%, so savings must supply the other 25.2% of $72,800, about $18,350 a year in today's money.
How large the pot must be
The pot has to pay that amount for as long as the household lives. This lesson assumes 30 years, from 67 to 96. Under SSA's 2023 period life table, 4.4% of 67-year-old men and 8.8% of 67-year-old women live to 97, and 24.9% of men and 35.6% of women reach 90, so 30 years is a long but not extreme horizon. Paying $1 a year for 30 years, at the start of each year, from a pot that keeps earning a real return of:
- 1% costs $26.07 today, so the pot must be 6.57 times pay, $478,057;
- 3% costs $20.19, so 5.09 times pay, $370,264;
- 5% costs $16.14, so 4.07 times pay, $296,034.
This treats the pot as a fixed annuity that is spent to zero. Real withdrawal plans must cope with returns that vary and with not knowing the date of death; Safe withdrawal rates: how much can a portfolio pay out? shows what that uncertainty does, and it usually means a larger pot than this arithmetic suggests.
How much to save each year
Saving a fixed share of a pay that stays flat in real terms, at the end of each year from the start age until 66, builds a pot equal to pay × rate × the future value of an annuity. The needed rate is the pot divided by that future value. Compound interest: how growth on growth builds wealth explains why the future value grows so fast with the number of years.
| Start age | Years of saving | 1% real | 3% real | 5% real |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 25 | 42 | 12.7% | 6.2% | 3.0% |
| 35 | 32 | 17.5% | 9.7% | 5.4% |
| 45 | 22 | 26.8% | 16.7% | 10.6% |
Two things stand out. Waiting ten years, from 25 to 35, raises the needed rate by about half; waiting twenty, to 45, nearly triples it at 3%. And the return assumption moves the answer as much as the start age: a 35-year-old needs 5.4% of pay if money earns 5% above inflation and 17.5% if it earns 1%. The rate includes everything saved, whether the worker's own deferrals or an employer's match. Catching up on retirement savings after 50: limits and levers looks at what the IRS limits allow someone who starts late.
The same calculation at other incomes and targets
Starting at 35 with a 3% real return:
| Earner | Gap savings must fill | Savings rate | A year in today's money |
|---|---|---|---|
| Low | 9.5% | 3.7% | $1,201 |
| Medium | 25.2% | 9.7% | $7,052 |
| High | 32.8% | 12.6% | $14,713 |
| Maximum | 41.4% | 15.9% | $29,381 |
For the medium earner, a 60% target needs 5.8% of pay and an 80% target 13.5%, against 9.7% for 70%. The progressive benefit formula means a higher earner needs to save a larger share of pay for the same replacement target, not just a larger amount.
Which return to assume
The calculation uses real returns, after inflation, because both the target and the pay are in today's dollars. Finabase's monthly data give a sense of the range. From March 1993 to September 2026, SPY, an S&P 500 fund, returned 8.0% a year after inflation as measured by the CPI-U, with dividends reinvested. From November 2003, when AGG's history starts, to September 2026, the bond fund AGG returned 0.3% a year after inflation and a 60/40 mix of the two, rebalanced monthly, 5.2%. (BLS published no CPI for October 2025; the calculation fills that month from its neighbours.)
Those are one period's results, with no fees and no taxes, and that period was good for US shares. Inflation and real returns: what an investment earns after prices has the longer history. A saver choosing an assumption is choosing how much risk to rely on: the 1% column is roughly what a mostly-bond portfolio earned in this sample, and the 5% column is roughly the 60/40 result. Planning on the upper number and getting the lower one means retiring with a pot that is a fraction of what was expected.
Pitfalls and limits
- Flat pay is unrealistic. Most careers have pay that rises in real terms, so a fixed percentage saves less in early years. A worker whose pay rises will need a somewhat higher rate than the table shows to reach a target set against final pay.
- Existing savings change everything. The table assumes a start from zero. A 45-year-old with savings already equal to a year's pay needs a much lower rate.
- The 30-year payout is a choice. A shorter payout lowers the pot needed; outliving it is the risk. Longevity, health and a spouse's age all bear on it.
- Social Security's future is not fixed. The 2026 Trustees Report projects that the combined trust funds can pay full benefits until 2034 and about 83% afterwards if Congress does not act (Social Security trust fund outlook: the 2026 Trustees Report). A saver who wants a margin can run the numbers with a smaller benefit.
- Taxes are averaged away. The calculation treats the target as gross income. Whether savings sit in pre-tax, Roth or taxable accounts changes what a dollar of pot buys.
- Not a recommendation. The table shows how the inputs interact. Which target, start age and return fit any one household depends on facts this page does not know.
Three ways to set a target, compared
| Method | What it asks | Strength | Weakness |
|---|---|---|---|
| Replacement rate (this lesson) | A share of pre-retirement pay | Simple; uses a number people know | Hides the spending detail behind one ratio |
| Spending budget | Each expected retirement cost, line by line | Fits the household's real plans | Hard to forecast decades ahead |
| Multiple of salary by age | A balance target such as "x times pay at 40" | Easy progress check | Assumes a return, a retirement age and a benefit |
| Withdrawal-rate rule | A pot that supports a set first withdrawal | Links the pot to market risk | Silent on Social Security and spending changes |
How Finabase does it
Finabase is a research app. It does not hold retirement accounts, know a reader's pay or taxes, or project anyone's benefit; SSA's own calculator and the my Social Security account do that from the actual earnings record. What it does offer are the market data behind the return assumptions. The comparison tab puts a bond fund and an S&P 500 fund on one chart, and the Treasury page shows today's yields, including those on inflation-protected Treasuries, a direct reading of the real return the bond market offers. Portfolio tracks the holdings in which savings are invested, with their dividends.
Frequently asked questions
What percentage of my income should I save for retirement?
It depends on when you start, what share of pay you want to replace, your Social Security benefit and the return you assume. For an average-wage worker aiming at 70% of pay, this lesson's arithmetic gives about 6% from age 25, 10% from 35 and 17% from 45 at a 3% real return, and much more at a lower return.
Why is the replacement rate less than 100%?
Because some of today's pay is not spent on living costs. Savings, the 7.65% payroll tax and often part of the income tax stop at retirement, and costs such as a mortgage may end. Health care and travel can push the other way.
How much of my income will Social Security replace?
Under 2027 rules, claimed at 67, it replaces about 61% of pay for a worker who always earned 45% of the average wage, 45% for an average earner, 37% at 160% of the average and 29% at the taxable maximum. Claiming at 62 or 70 changes those shares by roughly a third either way.
What rate of return should a retirement calculation use?
A real one, after inflation, that matches how the money is invested. From 2003 to 2026 a 60/40 mix of SPY and AGG returned 5.2% a year after inflation and AGG alone 0.3%; past returns are no promise. Running the calculation at a low and a high rate shows how much depends on it.
Summary
The savings question breaks into three answerable parts. The replacement rate is what share of pay retirement income must replace, usually 60% to 80% because saving and payroll tax stop and some costs end. Social Security covers a large part of it for low earners and a small part for high earners: 61% versus 29% of pay at 67 under the 2027 formula. The rest comes from a pot, and the savings rate that builds it depends on the start age and the real return: for an average earner aiming at 70%, from 6.2% of pay starting at 25 to 16.7% starting at 45 at 3%, and from 3.0% to 26.8% across the return assumptions. Each input belongs to the reader, and the honest output is a range.
Check your understanding
4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
A household spends $58,680 a year, including $14,400 of mortgage payments that end at retirement. Why might its replacement rate be closer to 59% than 78% of its $80,000 pay?
- Because Social Security pays the mortgage
- Because the mortgage, the 10% it saved and the payroll tax all stop, so far less income is needed
- Because retirement income is never taxed
Show the answer
B. Because the mortgage, the 10% it saved and the payroll tax all stop, so far less income is needed Without the mortgage the household needs $47,106 of gross income (58.9% of pay) after an assumed 6% tax. With the mortgage still running it needs $62,426 (78.0%). Saving and payroll tax stop in both cases.
Under the 2027 formula, why does Social Security replace about 61% of pay for a low earner but 29% for a maximum earner?
- Low earners claim earlier
- The benefit formula pays 90% of the first slice of average earnings and only 15% of the top slice
- High earners pay a lower payroll tax rate
Show the answer
B. The benefit formula pays 90% of the first slice of average earnings and only 15% of the top slice The PIA formula is progressive: 90% of AIME up to $1,340, 32% up to $8,077 and 15% above. A larger share of a low earner’s average falls in the generous first slice.
An average-wage worker starts saving at 35 for a 70% target. What happens to the needed savings rate if the assumed real return falls from 5% to 1%?
- It barely changes, because the start age is what matters
- It rises from about 5.4% to about 17.5% of pay
- It falls, because a lower return means less risk
Show the answer
B. It rises from about 5.4% to about 17.5% of pay A lower return means a larger pot is needed to pay the same income for 30 years, and less of that pot comes from growth. The return assumption moves the answer as much as starting ten years later.
Why does a higher earner need to save a larger share of pay for the same replacement target?
- Because Social Security covers a smaller share of their pay, leaving a bigger gap for savings
- Because the IRS requires it
- Because their investments earn less
Show the answer
A. Because Social Security covers a smaller share of their pay, leaving a bigger gap for savings At a 70% target the gap savings must fill is 9.5% of pay for the low earner and 41.4% for the maximum earner, so the needed savings rate from 35 at 3% runs from 3.7% to 15.9%.
Exercise
One task to do in Finabase. Nothing is graded or saved.
Open the Treasury page and note the 10-year yield, then take the latest year-over-year CPI inflation from the Economy page (or use 3%). Subtract one from the other for a rough real yield on bonds. Which column of the lesson’s table, 1%, 3% or 5% real, is it closest to? Read off the savings rate a medium earner starting at 35 would need for a 70% replacement rate in that column.
Open Treasury yieldsWhat you should find
If the 10-year yields about 4% and inflation runs near 3%, the real yield is about 1%: the table’s 1% column, 17.5% of pay from 35 against 9.7% at 3% real. A mostly-bond plan earns roughly the bond market’s real yield; planning on 5% real means relying on stocks to deliver it.
Sources and further reading
- Social Security Administration — Social Security benefit amounts (AIME, PIA and the maximum-earner example for 2027)
- Social Security Administration — Benefit formula bend points (2027: $1,340 and $8,077)
- Social Security Administration — National average wage index series (2025 = 72,800.33)
- Social Security Administration — 2027 cost-of-living adjustment fact sheet (tax rates, taxable maximum), October 2026
- Social Security Administration — Starting your retirement benefits early (reduction by year of birth)
- Social Security Administration, Office of the Chief Actuary — Period life table, 2023, as used in the 2026 Trustees Report
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics — Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers (CPI-U), seasonally adjusted, via FRED series CPIAUCSL
- Finabase chart data — monthly prices and dividends of SPY (from 1993) and AGG (from 2003) through September 2026; real returns computed by Finabase
