Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Retirement account rules Lesson 6 of 12

Retirement · Contributions, withdrawals and RMDs

Early withdrawal penalty: the 10% tax, its exceptions and 72(t) SEPPs

How the 10% additional tax on retirement withdrawals before 59½ works, every IRS exception, the rule of 55, and how 72(t) equal payments are calculated.

On this page
  1. The rule and what it costs
  2. Every exception, by account type
  3. The rule of 55
  4. Substantially equal periodic payments (72(t))
  5. Pitfalls and limits
  6. Options before 59½ compared
  7. How Finabase does it
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. Summary
  10. Check your understanding
  11. Exercise

Money in a traditional IRA or 401(k) can be withdrawn at any age. The tax code simply makes early withdrawals more expensive. Before age 59½, the taxable part of a distribution generally owes a 10% "additional tax" under section 72(t) of the Internal Revenue Code, on top of the ordinary income tax that any pre-tax withdrawal owes. People call it the early withdrawal penalty; the IRS calls it a tax, reported on Form 5329.

The 10% is not absolute. The IRS lists more than twenty exceptions, some for hardships such as disability or a disaster, some for planned income such as the "rule of 55" and a series of substantially equal periodic payments, often called 72(t) payments or SEPPs. Several of the exceptions apply only to IRAs or only to workplace plans, which makes the type of account matter as much as the reason. This lesson sets out the rule, every exception with its 2026 and 2027 amounts, and how the three IRS methods for equal payments are calculated.

The rule and what it costs

Section 72(t) adds 10% to the tax on the part of an early distribution that is included in income. Three things follow from that wording. The 10% applies only to taxable money, so returning a Roth IRA's own contributions, or after-tax money in a plan, does not trigger it. It is a tax for the year of the withdrawal, not a fee the account keeps. And it is paid on top of whatever income tax the distribution owes, federal and state.

Two account types sit outside the usual rule. Distributions from a governmental 457(b) plan, the plan offered by states and cities, are not subject to the 10% at all, except for money that was rolled into the 457(b) from another kind of plan or IRA. And SIMPLE IRAs carry the higher 25% rate in their first two years, as above.

Every exception, by account type

The table follows the IRS page "Retirement topics: exceptions to tax on early distributions." Income tax usually still applies to pre-tax money; the exception removes only the 10%. Dollar amounts are federal and current for 2026 and 2027.

Exception Workplace plans IRAs (incl. SEP, SIMPLE) Code section
Age 59½ or older Yes Yes 72(t)(2)(A)(i)
Death of the participant or owner (paid to a beneficiary) Yes Yes 72(t)(2)(A)(ii)
Total and permanent disability Yes Yes 72(t)(2)(A)(iii)
Series of substantially equal periodic payments Yes, after separation Yes 72(t)(2)(A)(iv)
Leaving the employer in or after the year of reaching 55 (50 for public safety) Yes No 72(t)(2)(A)(v)
Unreimbursed medical expenses above 7.5% of AGI Yes Yes 72(t)(2)(B)
Qualified domestic relations order (to the alternate payee) Yes No 72(t)(2)(C)
Health insurance premiums while unemployed No Yes 72(t)(2)(D)
Qualified higher education expenses No Yes 72(t)(2)(E)
First home, up to $10,000 lifetime No Yes 72(t)(2)(F)
Qualified reservist called to active duty Yes Yes 72(t)(2)(G)
Birth or adoption, up to $5,000 per child Yes Yes 72(t)(2)(H)
One emergency personal expense a year, up to $1,000 Yes Yes 72(t)(2)(I)
Domestic abuse victim: up to $10,500 (2026) / $10,900 (2027) or 50% of the account Yes Yes 72(t)(2)(K)
Federally declared disaster, up to $22,000 Yes Yes 72(t)(2)(M)
Terminal illness certified by a physician Yes Listed for plans by the IRS page; Publication 590-B also covers IRAs 72(t)(2)(L)
IRS levy on the account Yes Yes 72(t)(2)(A)(vii)
Timely corrective distributions of excess contributions Yes Returned IRA contributions by the extended due date 401(k)(8), 402(g), 408(d)(4)

The domestic-abuse amounts come from IRS Notice 2025-67 and Notice 2026-66, which index the statutory $10,000. The emergency, domestic-abuse, terminal-illness and birth or adoption exceptions were added or expanded by the SECURE Act of 2019 and SECURE 2.0 of 2022, so older articles may not list them. Each has its own conditions, and some of the newer ones allow the money to be paid back into the account; the IRS page links to the detail for each one.

The rule of 55

The "separation from service" exception is the most useful one for early retirees, and the most often misunderstood. A worker who leaves their employer in or after the calendar year they reach 55 can take money from that employer's plan without the 10%. Qualified public safety employees get the same treatment from age 50; the IRS's list includes state and local police and firefighters, federal law enforcement and corrections officers, customs and border protection officers, federal and private-sector firefighters and air traffic controllers.

Three details decide whether it works:

  • The year counts, not the birthday. Leaving in March of the year one turns 55 qualifies. Leaving at 54 in December does not, even if the withdrawals start after the 55th birthday.
  • Only the plan of the job being left. Money in a previous employer's 401(k) does not qualify unless it was rolled into the current plan before the separation.
  • Not IRAs. Section 72(t)(3)(A) switches this exception off for individual retirement plans. Rolling a 401(k) into an IRA after leaving at 56 turns penalty-free money into money that owes the 10% until 59½.

Substantially equal periodic payments (72(t))

The SEPP exception works at any age. The owner takes a series of payments, at least yearly, calculated by an IRS-approved method over their life expectancy, and keeps them going without change. From an IRA it can begin any time; from a workplace plan the series must begin after the worker has left that employer (section 72(t)(3)(B)).

The three methods

IRS Notice 2022-6 sets out three methods.

  1. Required minimum distribution method. Each year's payment is the account balance divided by a life-expectancy figure for that year's age. The payment changes every year with the balance, and switching to this method is never treated as a modification.
  2. Fixed amortization method. The balance is amortized over the life expectancy at a chosen interest rate, like a mortgage paying the owner. The payment is then fixed.
  3. Fixed annuitization method. The balance is divided by an annuity factor from a mortality table in the notice and the chosen rate. The payment is also fixed, and usually close to the amortization result.

The life expectancy may come from the Uniform Lifetime Table, the Single Life Table or the Joint and Last Survivor Table. For the fixed methods, Notice 2022-6 allows any interest rate up to the greater of 5% or 120% of the federal mid-term rate for either of the two months before the first payment. The 5% floor was new in 2022; earlier guidance tied the rate to the mid-term rate alone, which produced small payments when rates were low.

First-year SEPP payment from a $500,000 IRA at age 50 (Notice 2022-6 methods) RMD method (÷ 36.2) $13,812 Fixed amortization at 2% $19,542 Fixed amortization at 3% $22,831 Fixed amortization at 4% $26,377 Fixed amortization at 5% $30,156 Single Life Table (Pub 590-B) life expectancy 36.2 at 50. Allowed rate: up to the greater of 5% or 120% of the federal mid-term rate.
First-year 72(t) payment from a $500,000 IRA at age 50 under the RMD method and fixed amortization at four interest rates. Single Life Table life expectancy 36.2 (IRS Publication 590-B, 2025); methods from IRS Notice 2022-6.

The range is wide. The same account can support anything from about $13,800 to $30,200 in the first year, and a smaller payment can be made by splitting the IRA first and running the series from only one part. That flexibility is useful, but the choice is permanent.

How long and what breaks it

The payments must continue until the later of five years after the first payment or age 59½. The IRS gives an example: someone born on August 15, 1968 who started payments on December 1, 2024, at 56, cannot change them until December 1, 2029, even though they reach 59½ on February 15, 2028.

A modification before then, such as an extra withdrawal, a skipped payment, adding money to the account or changing the amount outside the rules, triggers a recapture tax under section 72(t)(4): the 10% that would have applied to every earlier payment, plus interest. Death and disability do not count as modifications. The one change allowed is a single switch from a fixed method to the RMD method, which usually lowers the payment.

Pitfalls and limits

  • Rolling over before using the rule of 55. Moving the old plan into an IRA removes the exception for that money; see Rollovers and the 60-day rule: 20% withholding and one per year.
  • Confusing "penalty-free" with "tax-free." Every exception removes only the 10%. Pre-tax money is still taxed as income.
  • Starting a SEPP from the whole account. A fixed payment from a large IRA may be far more than needed, and it cannot be reduced except by the one-time switch.
  • Running a SEPP through a market fall. A fixed amortization payment does not fall with the balance; a severe decline early can drain the account. The RMD method adjusts but pays less. How withdrawal order and market timing interact is covered in Safe withdrawal rates: how much can a portfolio pay out?.
  • Mixing up exception lists. The first-home exception, for example, does not apply to a 401(k) withdrawal, even a hardship withdrawal for a home purchase (401(k) loans and hardship withdrawals: limits, costs and traps).

Options before 59½ compared

Route Accounts Ages 10% tax? Flexibility
Ordinary withdrawal All Any Yes Full
Rule of 55 Plan of the employer left Separate in or after year of 55 (50) No Full, from that plan only
72(t) SEPP IRAs; plans after separation Any No Locked for 5 years or to 59½
Governmental 457(b) 457(b) of a government Any after separation No (except rolled-in money) Full
Specific exceptions (medical, birth, disaster …) Varies, see table Any No, up to the limit One purpose each
Roth IRA contributions Roth IRA Any No Contributions only, not earnings

How Finabase does it

Finabase does not hold accounts or know a reader's age, tax bracket or plan rules, so it cannot say whether an exception applies; that is a question for the plan administrator, the IRS rules and a tax professional. It can support the investment side of an early-retirement plan. The Portfolio page tracks the holdings of the account a SEPP will draw on, with dividends and distributions, and the Treasury page shows current yields, a useful reference when thinking about what interest rate a fixed SEPP payment assumes.

Frequently asked questions

What is the penalty for withdrawing from a 401(k) before 59½?

Generally a 10% additional tax on the taxable amount, plus ordinary income tax. It is reported on Form 5329 with the tax return. It does not apply if an exception does, such as the rule of 55 or disability.

Does the rule of 55 work for an IRA?

No. The separation-from-service exception applies only to distributions from the plan of the employer you left in or after the year you reached 55. Once that money is rolled into an IRA, it loses the exception.

How is a 72(t) payment calculated?

By one of three IRS methods in Notice 2022-6: dividing the balance by a life expectancy each year, amortizing it over the life expectancy at a permitted interest rate, or dividing it by an annuity factor. For $500,000 at 50, the results range from about $13,800 to $30,200 a year.

What happens if I stop my 72(t) payments early?

The recapture tax applies: the 10% that was waived on every earlier payment comes due, with interest, in the year of the change. Death or disability are not treated as changes.

Is there a 10% penalty on Roth IRA withdrawals?

Not on your contributions, which can be withdrawn at any time without tax. Earnings withdrawn before 59½ that are not part of a qualified distribution can owe both income tax and the 10% unless an exception applies.

Summary

Before 59½, the taxable part of a withdrawal from an IRA or workplace plan generally owes a 10% additional tax under section 72(t), or 25% from a SIMPLE IRA in its first two years, on top of income tax. The IRS's exceptions remove that 10%, not the income tax, and they differ by account: the rule of 55 and QDROs only in plans; first home, education and unemployed health premiums only in IRAs; most others in both. A 72(t) series lets anyone draw penalty-free income at any age, by one of three IRS methods, provided the payments run unchanged for five years or until 59½, whichever is later.

Check your understanding

4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. A 56-year-old left his job in 2026 and rolled his whole 401(k) into an IRA. In 2027 he withdraws $20,000 from the IRA. Does the rule of 55 protect him from the 10%?

    1. Yes, he left the job after turning 55
    2. No, the separation-from-service exception applies only to the employer plan, and the money is now in an IRA
    3. Yes, but only for the first $10,000
    Show the answer

    B. No, the separation-from-service exception applies only to the employer plan, and the money is now in an IRA Section 72(t)(3)(A) turns off the age-55 exception for individual retirement plans. Had he left the money in the 401(k), withdrawals from it would have been free of the 10%.

  2. What does an exception to the 10% additional tax remove?

    1. All tax on the withdrawal
    2. Only the 10% additional tax; pre-tax money is still taxed as income
    3. Only state income tax
    Show the answer

    B. Only the 10% additional tax; pre-tax money is still taxed as income Every exception in section 72(t) waives the additional tax. Income tax on the taxable amount still applies.

  3. Someone starts 72(t) payments at 57. Until when must the series continue unchanged?

    1. Until 59½
    2. For five years from the first payment, because that ends later than 59½
    3. For ten years
    Show the answer

    B. For five years from the first payment, because that ends later than 59½ The series must run until the later of five years after the first payment or age 59½. Starting at 57, the five-year mark comes after 59½.

  4. Under Notice 2022-6, why can two people with $500,000 IRAs at 50 have very different SEPP payments?

    1. The IRS sets payments by income
    2. They can choose different methods, life-expectancy tables and interest rates up to the permitted maximum
    3. Payments depend on the stock market each year under every method
    Show the answer

    B. They can choose different methods, life-expectancy tables and interest rates up to the permitted maximum The RMD method on the Single Life Table gives about $13,800 in the first year, while fixed amortization at 5% gives about $30,200. Each choice is permitted; once made it is locked in, except a one-time switch to the RMD method.

Exercise

One task to do in Finabase. Nothing is graded or saved.

Open the Treasury page and note the 5-year and 7-year yields, a rough guide to the federal mid-term rate. A fixed 72(t) payment may use any rate up to the greater of 5% or 120% of that rate. Multiply the yields by 1.2: would the cap be above 5%, or would the 5% floor set it? Then read the lesson’s $500,000 IRA at 50: $30,156 a year at 5%, $26,377 at 4%.

Open Treasury yields
What you should find

With mid-term yields near 4%, 120% is about 4.8%, so the 5% floor is the cap and $30,156 the largest fixed payment. The yield is only a guide; the IRS publishes the mid-term rate monthly. A higher rate allows a larger payment, but the series still runs to 59½, and breaking it brings back the 10% on earlier payments.

Sources and further reading

  1. Internal Revenue Service — Retirement topics: exceptions to tax on early distributions
  2. Internal Revenue Service — Notice 2022-6, determination of substantially equal periodic payments
  3. Internal Revenue Service — Substantially equal periodic payments (FAQ with worked examples)
  4. 26 U.S.C. §72(t), 10-percent additional tax on early distributions, statute text via Cornell LII
  5. Internal Revenue Service — Publication 590-B (2025), Table I, Single Life Expectancy
  6. Internal Revenue Service — Notice 2026-66, 2027 amounts (domestic-abuse distribution limit)