Retirement · Retirement accounts
401(k) vs. Roth IRA: tax timing, access to money and funding order
How a pre-tax 401(k) and a Roth IRA differ on when tax is paid, income limits, early access and investments, with a real Roth IRA funded in SPY since 2017.
On this page
The question "401(k) or Roth IRA?" usually pits two different things against each other. A traditional 401(k) is a workplace plan that takes money before tax and taxes it on the way out. A Roth IRA is a personal account that takes money after tax and, if the rules are met, never taxes it again. So the choice mixes two decisions: plan or IRA, and tax now or tax later. It also hides a third difference that matters to many people under 59½: how easily the money can come back out.
This lesson separates the three. It compares the 2026 limits and income rules, the arithmetic of pre-tax against Roth for the same take-home cost, and the access rules, using a real Roth IRA funded to the limit every January since 2017 and invested in an S&P 500 fund.
The two accounts in brief
A traditional 401(k) takes elective deferrals from pay before income tax. They grow untaxed, and every dollar withdrawn later, contributions and growth alike, is ordinary income. Most withdrawals before 59½ also owe a 10% additional tax. Employers may add a match. Required minimum distributions start at 73 (75 for people born in 1960 or later). The plan's rules are in 401(k) plans: deferrals, limits, the match and auto-enrollment.
A Roth IRA is opened by the saver at a broker or bank. Contributions are made with after-tax money and give no deduction. A qualified distribution, one made after 59½ (or for death, disability or a first home, up to $10,000) and at least five years after the first Roth IRA contribution, is free of tax, growth included. The owner never has to take required distributions. The rules, including the two five-year clocks, are in Roth IRA rules: income limits, ordering and the five-year clocks.
Limits and who can contribute
| 2026 | Traditional 401(k) | Roth IRA |
|---|---|---|
| Employee limit | $24,500; +$8,000 at 50; +$11,250 at 60–63 | $7,500; +$1,100 at 50 |
| Income limit to contribute | None | Single $153,000–$168,000; joint $242,000–$252,000 |
| Who offers it | An employer | Any bank or broker |
| Employer match | If the plan has one | Not possible |
The Roth IRA's income test uses modified AGI, and pre-tax 401(k) deferrals lower AGI. A single worker earning $175,000 who defers $24,500 pre-tax has AGI near $150,500, under the start of the phase-out, and can make a full Roth IRA contribution. Above the range, the Backdoor Roth IRA: steps, the pro-rata rule and Form 8606 route is how many people still fund one.
For 2027 the numbers move to $25,500 for 401(k) deferrals and $158,000 to $173,000 for the single Roth IRA phase-out ($250,000 to $260,000 joint); the IRA limit stays at $7,500 (Notice 2026-66).
Tax now or tax later: the arithmetic
The fair way to compare is to hold take-home pay constant. Suppose a worker in the 22% bracket is willing to give up $7,500 of take-home pay this year.
- In a Roth IRA, $7,500 goes in. Tax on the wages was already paid.
- In a pre-tax 401(k), the same $7,500 cut in take-home pay allows a deferral of $7,500 ÷ (1 − 0.22) = $9,615, because the deferral also cuts the tax bill by $2,115.
Grown for 30 years at 6% a year, each dollar becomes 5.74 dollars. The Roth IRA ends at $43,076, all of it spendable. The 401(k) ends at $55,226 before tax. Withdrawn at a 22% rate it leaves exactly $43,076. At 12% it leaves $48,599; at 24%, $41,972.
The rule that falls out is simple and well known: pre-tax wins if the tax rate on withdrawals will be lower than the rate saved today; Roth wins if it will be higher. In practice two things complicate it. Withdrawals fill the brackets from the bottom, so the average rate on them is often below the marginal rate saved while working; Roth 401(k) vs. traditional 401(k): tax saved now vs tax paid later works through that with 2026 brackets. And at the limit the comparison changes: $7,500 in a Roth IRA shelters more after-tax money than $7,500 pre-tax, because the Roth dollar carries no future tax.
Access before 59½: the Roth IRA's quiet advantage
Roth IRA withdrawals follow an ordering rule set out in Publication 590-B: contributions come out first, then conversions, then earnings. Contributions are the saver's own after-tax money, so they can be withdrawn at any time, at any age, with no tax and no 10% additional tax. Only the earnings are locked until a qualified distribution.
A traditional 401(k) has no such layer. A withdrawal before 59½, where the plan even allows one while still employed, is taxed as income and usually owes the 10% additional tax unless an exception applies. On a $20,000 withdrawal in the 22% bracket, that is $6,400 of federal tax. Loans are possible in many plans, but they must be repaid.
A real example: the full limit every January since 2017
To see how large the reachable layer becomes, take a Roth IRA funded with the full IRA limit on the first trading day of each year from 2017 and invested in SPY, the S&P 500 ETF, with dividends reinvested. The limits were $5,500 in 2017 and 2018, $6,000 from 2019 to 2022, $6,500 in 2023, $7,000 in 2024 and 2025, and $7,500 in 2026.
By the end of October 2026 the account held $141,019, of which $63,000 was contributions and $78,019 earnings. The $63,000 could be taken out tomorrow without tax or penalty; the $78,019 would be taxable and, before 59½, penalized unless an exception applied. The same deposits made pre-tax into a 401(k) would offer no tax-free layer at all.
This is why some people treat Roth IRA contributions as a back-up reserve. It is worth being clear about the cost: money withdrawn cannot be put back except within the year's limit, so the tax-free growth on it is lost for good. The example also uses one stretch of strong US stock returns; a different decade could look very different.
Investments and costs
A 401(k) offers the plan's menu; a Roth IRA can hold almost anything a broker lists. A plan with cheap index funds may cost less than a retail IRA; a plan with high-cost funds may cost more. Both can be checked on a fund's symbol page, as the next sections describe.
Side by side
| Feature | Traditional 401(k) | Roth IRA |
|---|---|---|
| Tax on money going in | None (deducted from wages) | Already paid |
| Tax on qualified money out | Ordinary income | None |
| Early access to deposits | Taxed, 10% extra before 59½ in most cases | Contributions any time, tax-free |
| Required distributions | From 73 (75 if born 1960+) | None for the owner |
| Employer match | Possible | No |
| Investment menu | Plan's choice | Saver's choice |
Which to use when
- The plan has a match not yet captured. Deferring enough to get the whole match usually comes first, since no Roth tax benefit is worth more than the match itself.
- The saver expects a higher tax rate later, for example early in a career, or with large pre-tax balances that will push retirement income up. The Roth IRA's tax-free withdrawals fit.
- The saver is in a high bracket now and expects a lower one later. Pre-tax 401(k) deferrals save tax at today's top rate and are taxed later as the brackets fill from the bottom.
- Flexibility before 59½ matters. Roth IRA contributions can come back out; pre-tax plan money generally cannot without tax.
- Income is above the Roth IRA limit. The 401(k), including a Roth 401(k) if offered, has no income test; a backdoor Roth is the other route.
- The aim is to save more than $7,500. The 401(k) holds more than three times as much. Many people use both: plan to the match, Roth IRA to its limit, then back to the plan.
The tax-rate question cannot be settled today, which is why many households keep money in both kinds of account and choose which to draw from each year in retirement.
How Finabase does it
Finabase does not open accounts or know anyone's tax rate. It shows the investments: SPY's symbol page lists its dividends, the data behind the example above, and any fund on a plan menu or in an IRA can be read the same way and compared with another on the comparison tool. Entering a Roth IRA and a 401(k) as two portfolios in Portfolio keeps the two tax treatments apart. The example's numbers come from a frozen snapshot of SPY's monthly closes and dividends, computed in the lesson's figure script.
Frequently asked questions
Should I contribute to a 401(k) or a Roth IRA first?
Many savers defer to the 401(k) up to the full employer match first, because the match is money only the plan can receive, then fund a Roth IRA, then return to the plan. Fund costs, income limits and expected tax rates can change that order.
Can I have both a 401(k) and a Roth IRA?
Yes. The limits are separate, $24,500 and $7,500 in 2026. Being covered by a 401(k) does not affect Roth IRA eligibility; only modified AGI does.
Is a Roth IRA better than a 401(k) if my income is low?
Often, when the saver's current rate is 10% or 12% and is likely to be higher later. But a match in the 401(k) can outweigh that, and many plans also offer a Roth 401(k), which combines the match with Roth treatment of the deferrals.
Can I take money out of a Roth IRA without penalty?
Contributions, yes, at any time. Earnings are tax-free only in a qualified distribution, after 59½ and five years; before then they are taxed and usually owe the 10% additional tax unless an exception applies.
Summary
A traditional 401(k) and a Roth IRA differ on when tax is paid, how much can go in and who can use them. The 401(k) takes $24,500 of pre-tax pay in 2026 with no income test and can carry a match; the Roth IRA takes $7,500 of after-tax money, phases out at higher incomes and pays out tax-free. For the same take-home cost, the two leave the same money when tax rates now and later are equal. The Roth IRA also lets contributions out at any time: filled to the limit in SPY since 2017, $63,000 of a $141,019 balance was reachable without tax or penalty in October 2026.
Check your understanding
4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
A worker in the 22% bracket can give up $7,500 of take-home pay. How much can go into a pre-tax 401(k) for that cost?
- $7,500
- About $9,615, because the deferral also lowers this year’s tax
- $5,850
Show the answer
B. About $9,615, because the deferral also lowers this year’s tax $7,500 ÷ (1 − 0.22) = $9,615. The tax saved on the deferral covers the difference, which is why the fair comparison holds take-home pay constant.
When do a pre-tax 401(k) and a Roth IRA leave the same spendable money, ignoring limits and fees?
- Never; the Roth always wins
- When the tax rate on withdrawals equals the rate saved when contributing
- Only if the money is invested in the same fund for exactly 30 years
Show the answer
B. When the tax rate on withdrawals equals the rate saved when contributing Multiplication is order-free: (1 − t) × growth is the same whether the tax comes off first or last.
A 40-year-old has put $63,000 of contributions into a Roth IRA that is now worth $141,019. How much can she withdraw with no tax and no 10% additional tax?
- Nothing before 59½
- $63,000, her contributions
- The whole $141,019
Show the answer
B. $63,000, her contributions Roth IRA withdrawals come out of contributions first, and contributions are always tax- and penalty-free. The $78,019 of earnings is not, until a qualified distribution.
A single filer has modified AGI of $175,000 in 2026. Which statement is right?
- She cannot contribute to a Roth IRA directly, but she can still defer to her 401(k)
- She cannot contribute to either
- She can contribute the full $7,500 to a Roth IRA
Show the answer
A. She cannot contribute to a Roth IRA directly, but she can still defer to her 401(k) The 2026 single phase-out is $153,000 to $168,000, so a direct Roth IRA contribution is not allowed. The 401(k) has no income test.
Sources and further reading
- Internal Revenue Service — Notice 2025-67, 2026 limits: 402(g), catch-ups, IRA limit, Roth IRA phase-outs
- Internal Revenue Service — Notice 2026-66, 2027 limits
- Internal Revenue Service — Publication 590-B (2025), Distributions from IRAs: ordering rules for Roth IRA distributions, qualified distributions
- Internal Revenue Service — Publication 590-A (2025), Contributions to IRAs: Roth IRA modified AGI limits
- Internal Revenue Service — Retirement topics: exceptions to tax on early distributions
- Internal Revenue Service — COLA increases for dollar limitations (IRA limits 2017–2025)
- Finabase chart data — SPY monthly closes and cash dividends, January 2017 to October 2026 (frozen snapshot)
