Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Save for retirement Lesson 7 of 11

Retirement · Retirement accounts

Roth IRA rules: income limits, ordering and the five-year clocks

The Roth IRA worked in detail for 2027: the reduced-contribution worksheet, how withdrawals are ordered across accounts, both five-year clocks and qualified payouts.

On this page
  1. Who can contribute, and how much
  2. How withdrawals are ordered
  3. The two five-year clocks
  4. Qualified distributions
  5. No required minimum distributions
  6. Pitfalls and limits
  7. Roth IRA compared with its neighbours
  8. How Finabase does it
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. Summary
  11. Check your understanding
  12. Exercise

A Roth IRA takes money that has already been taxed and, if its rules are kept, never taxes it or its growth again. It has no required withdrawals during the owner's life. In exchange, the law limits who may contribute directly, by income, and attaches conditions to tax-free withdrawal.

The case for and against a Roth, the 2026 tables and the backdoor route are covered in Roth vs traditional IRA: how to compare tax now and tax later. This lesson works the rules at the level of the IRS worksheets, for 2027: how the reduced contribution is calculated to the dollar, which income counts, how a withdrawal is assigned to contributions, conversions and earnings when someone has several Roth IRAs and several conversions, and how the two five-year clocks run.

Who can contribute, and how much

The contribution limit is the same as for a traditional IRA and shared with it: $7,500 for 2026 and 2027, plus $1,100 at 50 or older, never more than taxable compensation. There is no age limit. What a Roth adds is an income test on the direct contribution.

Filing status 2026 phase-out 2027 phase-out
Single, head of household, MFS living apart $153,000–$168,000 $158,000–$173,000
Married filing jointly, qualifying surviving spouse $242,000–$252,000 $250,000–$260,000
Married filing separately, lived with spouse $0–$10,000 $0–$10,000

Source: IRS Notices 2025-67 and 2026-66.

Which income counts

The test uses modified AGI for Roth purposes, built on worksheet 2-1 of Publication 590-A. It starts from AGI, adds back a few exclusions and deductions, and subtracts any income from converting a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA or rolling a pre-tax plan balance into one. The IRS is explicit that the subtraction applies only to this test: a conversion does not lower AGI for anything else on the return. The practical result is that a conversion in a year does not, by itself, block a direct Roth contribution for the same year.

The reduced-contribution worksheet

Inside the range, worksheet 2-2 of Publication 590-A reduces the limit step by step:

Roth IRA contribution allowed by MAGI, tax year 2027 (under 50) $0 $2,000 $4,000 $6,000 $8,000 $10,000 $140k $170k $200k $230k $270k Single or head of household ($158,000–$173,000) Married filing jointly ($250,000–$260,000) MAGI $165,000 → $4,000 Modified adjusted gross income for Roth purposes (IRS Notice 2026-66; Pub 590-A worksheet 2-2 rounding)
Roth IRA contribution allowed by MAGI, tax year 2027, under 50. Ranges from IRS Notice 2026-66; worksheet 2-2 rounding from Publication 590-A. Computed by Finabase.

For a married couple filing jointly the range is $10,000 wide: at $256,000 of 2027 MAGI the share is 0.600 and each spouse may contribute $3,000. The room is per person, so the couple together may put $6,000 into Roth IRAs, and each may add up to $4,500 in a traditional IRA.

When a contribution turns out to be too much

Income is not final until the year ends, and many people contribute in January. If MAGI ends up above the range, the contribution is an excess. Publication 590-B describes the cleanest fix: withdraw it, with the earnings it made, by the due date of the return including extensions. It is then treated as if it had never been made, and only the earnings are taxed. A contribution can also be recharacterized as a traditional IRA contribution by the same deadline. Left in place, the excess owes a 6% excise tax for every year it stays. Conversions, by contrast, have not been reversible since 2018.

How withdrawals are ordered

A Roth IRA does not track each deposit separately. For withdrawals the law treats all of a person's Roth IRAs as one account, and it treats money as leaving in a fixed order. Publication 590-B sets out both the order and the aggregation rules.

The Roth IRA ordering rules: which dollars leave first 1. Regular contributions All years, all Roth IRAs added together. Never taxed, never the 10% additional tax. 2. Conversions and rollovers, oldest year first Within each: the part that was taxed on conversion first, then any nontaxable part. No income tax; 10% tax if taxed part is under 5 years and under 59½. 3. Earnings Taxed and 10% tax unless the distribution is qualified or an exception applies. A withdrawal that is not qualified is treated as coming out in this order, top to bottom, whichever Roth IRA it is taken from. A qualified distribution (5 years and 59½, disability, death or first home) is tax-free whatever the layer. Source: IRS Publication 590-B (2025), “Ordering Rules for Distributions” and “Aggregation rules”.
The Roth IRA ordering rules for a distribution that is not qualified, from IRS Publication 590-B (2025).
  1. Regular contributions. Every contribution ever made, across all Roth IRAs, minus any earlier withdrawals of contributions. Never taxed, and never subject to the 10% additional tax.
  2. Conversions and rollovers from pre-tax plans, oldest year first. Within each year's conversions, the part that was taxed on conversion comes out before any part that was not (a conversion of nondeductible basis is the nontaxable part). No income tax, because it was paid at conversion, but a taxed part withdrawn within five years and before 59½ owes the 10% additional tax unless an exception applies.
  3. Earnings. Taxable, and subject to the 10% additional tax, unless the distribution is qualified or an exception applies.

The aggregation rules fill in the bookkeeping. All Roth IRA distributions in a year are added together. All regular contributions for the year are added, including those made after year-end but before the return's due date, then added to earlier undistributed contributions. Conversions are grouped by year. Rollovers from one Roth IRA to another are ignored, because they move money without changing the layers.

The two five-year clocks

Publication 590-B is direct about it: the five-year period for each conversion is figured separately and is not necessarily the same as the five-year period for qualified distributions.

Clock Starts Decides
Qualified-distribution clock (one only) January 1 of the first tax year for which any Roth IRA contribution was made Whether earnings can come out tax-free
Conversion clock (one per conversion) January 1 of the year of each conversion or rollover Whether the taxed part of that conversion owes the 10% tax before 59½

The first clock starts once and never restarts, even if every Roth IRA is later emptied. A contribution made in April 2027 for tax year 2026 starts it on January 1, 2026. Publication 590-B gives the contrast: a conversion and a prior-year regular contribution made on the same day in February 2025 started two clocks, the conversion's on January 1, 2025 and the contribution's on January 1, 2024.

Qualified distributions

A distribution is qualified when it is made after the first five-year period and is also one of:

  • made on or after the date the owner reaches 59½;
  • made because the owner is disabled;
  • paid to a beneficiary or the estate after the owner's death;
  • used for a first home, up to $10,000 over a lifetime.

A qualified distribution is entirely tax-free and the ordering rules no longer matter. Someone over 59½ with a Roth IRA first funded more than five years ago can take any amount, from any layer, without tax.

No required minimum distributions

The owner of a Roth IRA never has to take money out. Required minimum distributions apply only to beneficiaries after the owner's death, under the inherited-account rules. Since 2024 the same is true of designated Roth accounts in 401(k) and 403(b) plans, covered in Roth 401(k): designated Roth accounts, rules and the break-even.

Pitfalls and limits

  • Contributing early in a year of uncertain income. An excess has to be withdrawn or recharacterized by the return's due date, including extensions, or it owes 6% a year.
  • Forgetting the traditional IRA in the worksheet. Contributions to traditional IRAs for the year reduce the Roth room.
  • Confusing the two clocks. A Roth IRA that is ten years old does not exempt a two-year-old conversion from the 10% additional tax before 59½.
  • Treating each Roth IRA separately. Ordering looks across all of them, so taking money from the "conversion IRA" does not change which layer is used.
  • Losing the records. The ordering rules only help a saver who can show how much was contributed and converted; Form 8606 and custodian statements are the evidence.

Roth IRA compared with its neighbours

Feature (2027) Roth IRA Roth 401(k) Traditional IRA
Direct contribution income limit $158,000–$173,000 single None None (deduction may phase out)
Limit $7,500 (+$1,100), shared with trad. IRA $25,500 (+ catch-ups) $7,500 (+$1,100), shared
Early withdrawals Contributions first, tax-free Pro rata contributions and earnings All taxable except basis
Five-year clock One for all Roth IRAs, plus one per conversion One per plan None
Lifetime RMDs None None since 2024 From 73 (75 if born 1960+)

How Finabase does it

Finabase does not hold IRAs and cannot see a reader's MAGI, contributions or conversions, so it cannot work out anyone's Roth room or the tax on a withdrawal. The worksheets above are short enough to do by hand. Finabase covers what a Roth IRA holds: symbol pages for funds and stocks with prices, dividends and distributions, and Portfolio for following holdings and the income they pay inside the account.

Frequently asked questions

Can I contribute to a Roth IRA if my income is above the limit?

Not directly. Some people make a nondeductible traditional IRA contribution and convert it, which has no income limit; the pro-rata rule that can make it taxable is explained in Roth vs traditional IRA: how to compare tax now and tax later.

Can I take my contributions out of a Roth IRA at any time?

Yes. Under the ordering rules regular contributions come out first, with no income tax and no 10% additional tax, at any age.

Does each Roth IRA have its own five-year clock?

No. One clock covers all of a person's Roth IRAs for qualified distributions, started by the first contribution to any of them. Each conversion separately starts its own clock for the 10% additional tax.

Does a Roth conversion count toward the income limit for contributing?

No. Conversion income is subtracted when figuring modified AGI for the Roth contribution test, although it remains in AGI for every other purpose.

Summary

For 2027 the Roth IRA's direct contribution phases out between $158,000 and $173,000 of MAGI for single filers and between $250,000 and $260,000 for joint filers. Inside the range the $7,500 limit falls in proportion, rounded up to $10 with a $200 floor, and conversion income is left out of the test. For withdrawals all Roth IRAs are one account: contributions first, conversions oldest first with the taxed part leading, earnings last. One five-year clock, started by the first contribution, governs tax-free earnings; one clock per conversion governs the 10% tax before 59½. Once a distribution is qualified, none of that matters and every dollar is tax-free.

Check your understanding

4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. A single filer under 50 has 2027 MAGI of $165,000. What is her maximum Roth IRA contribution?

    1. $7,500
    2. $4,000
    3. $3,500
    Show the answer

    B. $4,000 She is $7,000 into the $15,000 range, a share of 0.467. $7,500 − $3,502.50 = $3,997.50, which the worksheet rounds up to $4,000.

  2. A saver has three Roth IRAs and takes money from the one that holds only her 2024 conversion. Which money is she treated as withdrawing first?

    1. The 2024 conversion, because that is the account it came from
    2. Her regular contributions across all three Roth IRAs
    3. Earnings
    Show the answer

    B. Her regular contributions across all three Roth IRAs For the ordering rules all Roth IRAs are aggregated. Regular contributions come out first, whichever account the cash is taken from.

  3. A 50-year-old whose first Roth IRA contribution was in 2012 withdraws, in 2027, money traced to the taxed part of a 2024 conversion. What applies?

    1. Nothing: the Roth IRA is more than five years old
    2. No income tax, but the 10% additional tax, because that conversion’s own five-year period is still running and she is under 59½
    3. Income tax and the 10% additional tax
    Show the answer

    B. No income tax, but the 10% additional tax, because that conversion’s own five-year period is still running and she is under 59½ Each conversion has its own five-year clock for the 10% additional tax. The 2024 conversion’s clock runs through 2028. The conversion was already taxed, so no income tax is due again.

  4. Why does a large Roth conversion in 2027 not by itself block a direct Roth IRA contribution for 2027?

    1. Conversions are not income
    2. Conversion income is subtracted when figuring modified AGI for the Roth contribution test
    3. The income limit does not apply in conversion years
    Show the answer

    B. Conversion income is subtracted when figuring modified AGI for the Roth contribution test Worksheet 2-1 of Publication 590-A removes conversion and pre-tax-to-Roth rollover income from MAGI for this test only. It stays in AGI for everything else.

Exercise

One task to do in Finabase. Nothing is graded or saved.

Open Portfolios. Signed out, the page shows an example portfolio named Retirement with a Market value; sign in to use your own. Treat it as the Roth IRAs of the lesson’s saver: $40,000 of regular contributions and a $30,000 conversion made in 2023. Using the ordering rules, how much could come out before any earnings are reached, and what share of the Market value is that?

Open Portfolios
What you should find

Contributions come out first, then conversions, then earnings. Here $70,000, about 28% of the example’s roughly $248,000, comes out before earnings. Contributions are free of tax at any age; conversion money owes the 10% additional tax only while its five-year period runs and the owner is under 59½.

Sources and further reading

  1. Internal Revenue Service — Notice 2026-66, 2027 Roth IRA phase-out ranges (November 2026)
  2. Internal Revenue Service — Notice 2025-67, 2026 Roth IRA phase-out ranges
  3. Internal Revenue Service — Publication 590-A (2025), worksheets 2-1 and 2-2 (modified AGI and reduced Roth contribution)
  4. Internal Revenue Service — Publication 590-B (2025), qualified distributions, ordering and aggregation rules, recapture
  5. Internal Revenue Service — Roth IRAs (accessed November 18, 2026)