Social Security and pensions Lesson 3 of 8
Retirement · Social Security and pensions
When to claim Social Security: 62, 67 or 70, with break-even ages
Claiming at 62, 67 or 70 with a full retirement age of 67: the 70%, 100% and 124% benefits, break-even ages with and without discounting, and survival odds.
On this page
- The three benchmark ages
- Break-even ages, step by step
- How many people get there?
- Expected value: weighting each check by survival
- Why the table understates waiting
- What decides it in practice
- Pitfalls
- Comparison of the three benchmark claims
- How Finabase does it
- Frequently asked questions
- Summary
- Check your understanding
- Exercise
Every worker eligible for Social Security retirement benefits chooses a start month somewhere between 62 and 70. The choice is permanent in one direction: an earlier start locks in a smaller check for life, and a later start buys a larger one. For anyone born in 1960 or later, full retirement age is 67, and the same primary insurance amount (PIA) pays 70% of itself at 62, 100% at 67 and 124% at 70. The difference between the earliest and latest claim is a 77% larger monthly benefit, adjusted for inflation every year for the rest of the worker's life.
Whether that larger check is worth the years of waiting depends on how long the person lives, what money they would live on meanwhile, whether a spouse will depend on the benefit after their death, and how they value a dollar now against a dollar later. This lesson works through the arithmetic everyone quotes, the break-even age, then goes one step further by weighting each future payment by the chance of being alive to collect it, using the Social Security Administration's (SSA) own mortality table. The numbers explain the trade-off; they do not decide it, and the honest answer for any one person depends on facts this page cannot know.
The three benchmark ages
The monthly amount at each claiming age is a fixed percentage of the PIA. Claiming before full retirement age cuts the benefit by 5/9 of 1% for each of the first 36 months early and 5/12 of 1% for each month beyond that. Waiting past full retirement age adds 2/3 of 1% a month, 8% a year, until 70. For a PIA of $2,000 and full retirement age 67:
| Claim at | Share of PIA | Monthly benefit | Yearly benefit |
|---|---|---|---|
| 62 | 70.0% | $1,400 | $16,800 |
| 63 | 75.0% | $1,500 | $18,000 |
| 64 | 80.0% | $1,600 | $19,200 |
| 65 | 86.7% | $1,733 | $20,796 |
| 66 | 93.3% | $1,866 | $22,392 |
| 67 | 100.0% | $2,000 | $24,000 |
| 68 | 108.0% | $2,160 | $25,920 |
| 69 | 116.0% | $2,320 | $27,840 |
| 70 | 124.0% | $2,480 | $29,760 |
SSA rounds a monthly benefit down to the whole dollar, which is why 86.7% of $2,000 is shown as $1,733. Each figure then grows with every cost-of-living adjustment, so the comparison below is in today's dollars throughout: we assume the COLAs keep pace with prices, which is what they are designed to do.
Break-even ages, step by step
A break-even age is the age by which the later claimant has collected as much in total as the earlier one. Before it, the early claimant is ahead; after it, the late claimant is.
62 against 67. By 67 the early claimant has received 60 checks of $1,400, a head start of $84,000. From 67 the late claimant receives $600 a month more ($2,000 − $1,400). Closing an $84,000 gap at $600 a month takes 140 months, 11 years and 8 months, so the totals are equal at 78.7. The same answer falls out of setting the totals equal: 1,400 × (A − 62) = 2,000 × (A − 67), so 600 × A = 47,200 and A = 78.67.
67 against 70. The 67 claimant collects 36 checks of $2,000 before the other starts, a $72,000 lead. The 70 claimant then gets $480 a month more. 72,000 ÷ 480 = 150 months, 12.5 years, so the break-even is 82.5.
62 against 70. The lead is 96 × $1,400 = $134,400 and the monthly difference is $1,080. That takes 124.4 months, so the break-even is 80.4.
Adding a discount rate
The simple break-even treats a dollar at 63 the same as a dollar at 83. Most people would not, if only because money received early can be invested. Discounting future payments at a real (after-inflation) rate pushes every break-even later. At an illustrative 2% a year (the Treasury page shows what inflation-protected Treasuries actually pay today), the 62-versus-67 break-even moves from 78.7 to 81.1, the 67-versus-70 one from 82.5 to 84.9, and the 62-versus-70 one from 80.4 to 82.7. A higher discount rate pushes them later still; a lower one pulls them earlier. The rate is a choice, and it is honest to try more than one.
How many people get there?
A break-even age is only interesting next to the odds of reaching it. SSA's Office of the Chief Actuary publishes a period life table, the death rates observed at each age in one calendar year. The 2023 table, used in the 2026 Trustees Report, gives a 62-year-old man a remaining life expectancy of 20.29 years and a 62-year-old woman 23.08 years. From that table Finabase computed how long people alive at 62 live:
| Alive at 62 | 25% have died by | Half have died by | 75% have died by |
|---|---|---|---|
| Man | 75.4 | 83.2 | 89.5 |
| Woman | 78.9 | 86.3 | 92.1 |
And the chance of living past each break-even age:
| Break-even | Man, undiscounted | Man, 2% real | Woman, undiscounted | Woman, 2% real |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 62 vs 67 | 65.8% | 57.9% | 75.6% | 68.8% |
| 67 vs 70 | 52.6% | 43.5% | 64.1% | 55.6% |
| 62 vs 70 | 60.2% | 51.8% | 70.9% | 63.4% |
For a man the 67-versus-70 decision is close to a coin flip once money is discounted at 2%: about 44% live past 84.9. For a woman the odds favour waiting at every pair.
Expected value: weighting each check by survival
Break-even ages compare two lifetimes, one short and one long. A fuller picture weights every future monthly payment by the probability of being alive to receive it and discounts it to age 62. The sum is the expected present value of the benefit stream, the price a fair insurer with no costs would charge for it.
At a 2% real discount rate:
| Claim at | Man | Woman |
|---|---|---|
| 62 | $271,276 | $302,264 |
| 67 | $277,117 | $319,919 |
| 68 | $277,939 | $323,454 |
| 69 | $276,481 | $324,466 |
| 70 | $272,921 | $323,108 |
For the average man the curve is nearly flat: the best claiming age, 68, is worth 2.5% more than 62, and 70 only 0.6% more. For the average woman it rises 6.9% from 62 to 70 and peaks at 69. Without discounting (a 0% real rate), both curves rise all the way to 70: from $341,442 to $380,924 for a man and from $388,282 to $458,667 for a woman.
What the averages leave out matters as much as what they show. Delaying is a way of buying more inflation-indexed lifetime income from the government at a price set by law rather than by an insurer's pricing, and its value is largest in exactly the scenario a household should worry about most: a long life, in which savings could run out. A flat expected value with a much higher payout in long lives is, in insurance terms, cheap longevity protection. The same calculation run on a person in poor health, with a much higher chance of dying in their 60s or 70s, tilts strongly toward claiming early.
Why the table understates waiting
A period life table freezes 2023 death rates. Someone who is 62 today will be 80 in 2044 and will face the death rates of 2044, which on past trends will be lower. Projections that build in future improvement (cohort tables) give longer lives than period tables, so every survival probability above is, if mortality keeps improving, a little too low for today's 62-year-olds. That makes waiting somewhat more valuable than the figures show. The table is also a national average: people with more education and higher lifetime earnings, who tend to have the larger PIAs, have lived longer on average than the population as a whole.
What decides it in practice
The arithmetic above is the same for everyone with a given PIA and sex. The real decision rests on facts that differ from household to household:
- Health and family history. Expected value depends on survival odds. Someone with a serious illness faces a very different curve from the national table.
- Marriage. When the higher earner dies, the surviving spouse keeps the larger of the two benefits (Social Security survivor benefits: amounts, limits and switching), and a spouse's own benefit has its own rules (Social Security spousal benefits: the 50% rule and deemed filing). Delaying the higher earner's claim raises the survivor's income for what may be the longest-lived of two lives, which often matters more than the worker's own break-even.
- Need for income now. A household without savings or work income may have no practical choice but to claim. Waiting requires something else to live on.
- Where the bridge money comes from. Funding the years before a later claim from a portfolio exposes those withdrawals to market falls early in retirement; see Sequence of returns risk: why the order of returns matters and Safe withdrawal rates: how much can a portfolio pay out?.
- Working before full retirement age. Claiming early while still earning more than $24,480 (2026) or $25,560 (2027) triggers the earnings test, which withholds benefits for a while.
- Taxes. Part of the benefit can become taxable once other income is large enough, which changes the after-tax comparison between drawing savings and drawing Social Security.
- Trust fund doubts. The 2026 Trustees Report projects that the Old-Age and Survivors Insurance fund can pay full benefits until the fourth quarter of 2032 and 78% of scheduled benefits after that unless Congress acts (Social Security trust fund outlook: the 2026 Trustees Report). The Trustees state the shortfall as a share of all scheduled benefits payable at that time, not as a cut that depends on when someone claimed.
Pitfalls
- Comparing nominal dollars. COLAs raise every claiming age's check by the same percentage, so comparisons should be in today's dollars, as here.
- Using life expectancy as a forecast. Half of 62-year-old men live past 83.2 under the period table; planning to the average means a coin-flip chance of outliving the plan.
- Ignoring the spouse. A worker's break-even is the wrong test when the benefit will become a survivor benefit.
- Treating the decision as all or nothing. Any month from 62 to 70 is allowed; 64 or 68 can be reasonable answers.
- Assuming the break-even is the answer. It is only the age at which totals cross; it says nothing about how much each path is worth or how risky it is.
Comparison of the three benchmark claims
| Measure ($2,000 PIA, FRA 67) | Claim at 62 | Claim at 67 | Claim at 70 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly benefit | $1,400 | $2,000 | $2,480 |
| Total received by 80 (no discount) | $302,400 | $312,000 | $297,600 |
| Total received by 90 (no discount) | $470,400 | $552,000 | $595,200 |
| Expected value at 62, man, 2% real | $271,276 | $277,117 | $272,921 |
| Expected value at 62, woman, 2% real | $302,264 | $319,919 | $323,108 |
How Finabase does it
Finabase does not know your PIA, health or family, and it does not advise on claiming. It is a research app: the Treasury page shows the real yields on inflation-protected Treasury securities, a market reference for the discount rate used above, and Portfolio tracks the holdings that would have to cover any years between leaving work and a later claim. The figures on this page come from Finabase's Learn scripts, which apply SSA's reduction and credit rules and SSA's 2023 period life table; your own estimate belongs on your my Social Security account.
Frequently asked questions
What is the break-even age for waiting from 62 to 70?
With a full retirement age of 67 and no discounting it is about 80 years and 4 months, the age at which 96 months of a 124% benefit catch up with 8 extra years of a 70% benefit. Discounting at 2% real moves it to about 82.7.
Does it matter how large my PIA is?
Not for the break-even age. Every claiming age is a fixed percentage of the same PIA, so the ages are the same for a $1,000 PIA and a $4,000 PIA; only the dollar totals scale.
Is it better to claim early and invest the money?
Only if the investments earn more, after tax and inflation, than the implied return from waiting, and only if you are comfortable with the risk. The 2% discount case above shows how much the answer moves with that assumption.
Can I change my mind after claiming?
SSA allows a worker to withdraw an application within 12 months and repay what was received, and benefits can be voluntarily suspended at full retirement age to earn delayed credits. Both have conditions; check them with SSA before relying on either.
Summary
With a full retirement age of 67, a PIA pays 70% at 62, 100% at 67 and 124% at 70. Undiscounted, waiting from 62 to 67 breaks even at 78.7 and from 67 to 70 at 82.5; at a 2% real discount rate the break-evens are about 81.1 and 84.9. Under SSA's 2023 period life table, most 62-year-olds live past the first and a little under half of men live past the second. Weighted by survival, the expected value of claiming at 70 is about the same as at 62 for the average man and about 7% higher for the average woman, before allowing for longer future lifespans or the value of insurance against a long life. Health, marriage, other income and the need for money now decide the question for any one household.
Check your understanding
4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
With a full retirement age of 67, one person claims at 62 and another at 67 on the same $2,000 PIA. Ignoring discounting, when have they received the same total?
- At 72
- At about 78 and 8 months
- Never, because the early claimant is always ahead
Show the answer
B. At about 78 and 8 months The early claimant builds an $84,000 lead (60 checks of $1,400). The later claimant gets $600 a month more and closes the gap in 140 months, at about 78.7.
What does discounting future payments at a 2% real rate do to break-even ages?
- Moves them later, because later dollars count for less
- Moves them earlier
- Leaves them unchanged, because benefits are inflation-adjusted
Show the answer
A. Moves them later, because later dollars count for less A positive discount rate gives less weight to the larger checks that arrive later, so it takes longer for them to catch up. At 2% the 62-versus-67 break-even moves from 78.7 to about 81.1.
Why might a married higher earner delay even if their own break-even age looks unattractive?
- Delayed credits also raise the spouse’s benefit while both are alive
- The larger benefit can continue as the survivor benefit after the higher earner dies
- Married couples receive a bonus for claiming at 70
Show the answer
B. The larger benefit can continue as the survivor benefit after the higher earner dies A surviving spouse keeps the larger of the two benefits. Delaying the higher earner’s claim raises the income of whichever spouse lives longer, which a single-life break-even ignores.
Why do figures based on SSA’s 2023 period life table probably understate the value of waiting for today’s 62-year-olds?
- Because the table is for the whole world, not the United States
- Because it uses 2023 death rates, while death rates at older ages have tended to fall over time
- Because it ignores women
Show the answer
B. Because it uses 2023 death rates, while death rates at older ages have tended to fall over time A period table freezes one year’s death rates. If mortality keeps improving, people who are 62 now will live longer than the table implies, which makes a larger lifetime benefit worth more.
Exercise
One task to do in Finabase. Nothing is graded or saved.
With a $2,400 PIA and a full retirement age of 67, a claim at 62 pays $1,680 a month and at 70 pays $2,976. Work out the undiscounted break-even: waiting gives up 96 months of $1,680, and the gain is $1,296 a month from 70. Then open the Economy page and take the 10-year Treasury yield minus the latest year-over-year CPI inflation as a rough real yield, a market reference for the lesson’s discount rate. Is it above or below the lesson’s 2%?
Open the Economy pageWhat you should find
96 × $1,680 = $161,280, and $161,280 ÷ $1,296 is about 124 months, so the later claim catches up a little after 80. Discounting pushes break-evens later: at 2% real the lesson’s 62-to-67 break-even moves from 78.7 to 81.1. A real yield above 2% moves them later still; one below 2% brings them closer.
Sources and further reading
- Social Security Administration — Starting your retirement benefits early (reduction by year of birth)
- Social Security Administration — Delayed retirement credits
- Social Security Administration, Office of the Chief Actuary — Period life table, 2023, as used in the 2026 Trustees Report
- Social Security Administration — A summary of the 2026 annual Social Security and Medicare trust fund reports
