Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Retirement · Social Security and pensions

Pension vs. 401(k): who carries the risk and what each pays at 65

How a defined-benefit pension and a 401(k) differ on who bears investment and longevity risk, vesting, portability and insurance, with one worker’s pay run through both.

On this page
  1. How each is built
  2. The same worker in both plans
  3. Where the risks sit
  4. Vesting, job changes and back-loading
  5. Side by side
  6. Which to use when
  7. How Finabase does it
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. Summary
  10. Check your understanding

Two kinds of workplace plan pay for most American retirements outside Social Security. A defined-benefit pension promises an income for life, set by a formula of salary and years of service; the employer invests the money and makes up any shortfall. A 401(k) is a defined-contribution plan: the worker and employer put in set amounts, the worker picks the investments, and what is there at retirement is whatever the deposits and markets produced. One promises an outcome; the other promises only the inputs.

Most private-sector workers now have a 401(k) and no pension; many public-sector workers have a pension and a 457(b) or 403(b) beside it. Comparing them helps in three practical moments: judging a job offer that comes with one or the other, deciding whether to stay long enough for a pension to grow, and working out how much a 401(k) must hold to replace the income a pension would have paid. This lesson runs one worker's pay through both, using a real mortality table to put them on one scale.

How each is built

A traditional pension formula multiplies three numbers: a percentage (the multiplier, often 1% to 2%), years of service, and a measure of pay, usually the average of the highest or last three to five years. The employer funds a trust, hires managers and must contribute more when the trust falls short under federal funding rules. The worker usually contributes nothing in private plans; many public plans require employee contributions. At retirement the benefit is paid as a monthly annuity, often with a survivor option, and some plans offer a lump sum instead, a choice covered in Pension lump sum or annuity: how defined-benefit choices work.

A 401(k) holds an account in the worker's name. Each year the worker defers part of pay, up to $24,500 in 2026 ($25,500 in 2027), the employer may match, and the worker chooses funds from the plan menu. At retirement the balance is the worker's to draw down, roll to an IRA or use to buy an annuity. The plan's rules are in 401(k) plans: deferrals, limits, the match and auto-enrollment.

The same worker in both plans

Take a worker who starts at 30 and retires at 65 after 35 years, with pay rising 3% a year from $29,284 to $80,000 in the final year.

  • Pension: 1.5% × 35 years × $80,000 = $42,000 a year, $3,500 a month, for life.
  • 401(k): 10% of pay goes in every year, 6% from the worker and 4% from the employer, $177,055 in all. What it becomes depends on returns. At 4% a year it reaches $331,557, at 6% $475,587 and at 8% $701,136.

To put a balance and a lifetime income on one scale, divide the balance by the cost of $1 a year for life. Using the Social Security period life table for a man of 65 and a 5% interest rate, $1 a year for life costs $11.72 with no insurer's margin. So each 401(k) balance converts to:

Yearly income at 65: a 1.5% pension vs a 401(k) saving 10% of the same pay Pension, 35 years × 1.5% $42,000 401(k) earning 4% a year $28,284 (balance $331,557) 401(k) earning 6% a year $40,571 (balance $475,587) 401(k) earning 8% a year $59,812 (balance $701,136) 401(k) income: balance ÷ the cost of $1 a year for life for a man of 65 at 5% (SSA 2023 life table). Illustrative.
One worker, 35 years, final pay $80,000. Pension at 1.5% a year of service. 401(k) at 10% of pay, converted to lifetime income at the cost of $1 a year for life for a man of 65 at 5% (SSA period life table 2023). Illustrative; no fees, taxes or insurer costs.

At a 6% return the 401(k) roughly matches the pension, $40,571 a year against $42,000. At 4% it falls a third short; at 8% it beats the pension by about 42%. Reading the same balances with the The 4% rule: what Bengen found, what it assumes and where it breaks instead, a withdrawal that keeps the money and leaves room for inflation adjustments, gives far less: $13,262, $19,023 and $28,045. The gap is the price of keeping control of the money and of not pooling longevity risk with others.

Turned around, the pension itself is worth a lot of money. At the same 5% rate and mortality, buying $42,000 a year for life for a man of 65 costs about $492,340, and about $536,579 for a woman, who on average lives longer. That is the 401(k) balance the worker would need to match it, before an insurer's costs and profit, which make a real annuity dearer.

Where the risks sit

Investment risk. In a pension, poor markets raise the employer's required contributions; the benefit does not change. In a 401(k), a bad decade before retirement shrinks the balance directly.

Longevity risk. A pension pays until death, however long. A 401(k) can run out if withdrawals are too high or life is long, unless part of it buys an annuity.

Employer risk. A pension depends on the plan staying funded. Private single-employer plans are insured by the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation up to a legal maximum, $7,789.77 a month at 65 for plans ending in 2026 and $8,113.64 for 2027. Government plans are not covered by PBGC; they depend on the state or city. 401(k) assets are held in trust in the worker's name, separate from the employer, so an employer's bankruptcy does not touch them, but no one insures their investment results.

Inflation risk. Most private pensions pay a fixed dollar amount with no cost-of-living raise, so $42,000 buys less each year. Many public pensions include a partial adjustment. A 401(k) left invested can grow with prices, or not.

Vesting, job changes and back-loading

Federal rules let a defined-benefit plan vest on a five-year cliff or a graded schedule from three to seven years; a 401(k) match can vest on a three-year cliff or graded from two to six years. The worker's own 401(k) deferrals are always fully vested.

Portability is where the two diverge most. A pension formula based on final pay is back-loaded: a worker who leaves at 45 keeps a benefit based on pay frozen at 45 and paid from 65, which in real terms is worth little. The same years in the formula above are worth much more when earned near the end. A 401(k) balance goes along whole once vested and keeps compounding. Someone who expects to change jobs every few years usually gets more from a 401(k); someone who stays 30 years at one employer usually gets more from a pension.

Side by side

Feature Defined-benefit pension 401(k)
What is promised An income, by formula Only the contributions
Who invests The employer's trust The worker, from the plan menu
Investment risk Employer Worker
Longevity risk Pooled; paid for life Worker, unless an annuity is bought
Insurance PBGC for private plans, up to a cap None on results; assets held in trust
Portability Weak; back-loaded Strong once vested
Inflation Often none in private plans Depends on investments
Limit, 2026 (2027) Benefit up to $290,000 ($300,000) a year $24,500 ($25,500) deferral, $72,000 ($75,000) total

Which to use when

Workers rarely choose the plan type; employers do. The comparison is useful in these cases:

  • Weighing two job offers. A pension's value can be estimated as the lifetime income it will pay, priced as above; a 401(k) match is a known yearly amount. Compare like with like.
  • Deciding when to leave a pension job. Because pensions are back-loaded, the last years of service often add the most; checking the projected benefit before leaving is worth the effort.
  • Holding both (a public pension plus a 457(b) or 403(b)): the pension covers a base income and longevity; the account adds flexibility and can be invested more boldly.
  • Only a 401(k): the worker carries both risks, and planning has to replace what a pension would have done, through saving rates, diversification, and possibly buying an annuity with part of the balance at retirement (Annuities explained: SPIAs, deferred income, QLACs and their costs).
  • Offered a pension lump sum: that is a conversion from pension to account, with the same trade-offs in reverse.

How Finabase does it

Finabase does not run pension or 401(k) plans. Two of its pages bear on this comparison. The Treasury page shows the yields that drive annuity prices and pension lump-sum calculations: when rates rise, a lifetime income costs less to buy and lump-sum offers shrink. And a 401(k)'s holdings can be tracked in Portfolio, with each fund's history on its symbol page. The pension and 401(k) numbers above come from the lesson's figure script, using the SSA period life table.

Frequently asked questions

Is a pension better than a 401(k)?

A pension removes investment and longevity risk from the worker and, after a long career at one employer, often pays more than a typical 401(k). A 401(k) is portable, can be left to heirs in full and benefits from good markets. For short careers at many employers, the 401(k) usually comes out ahead.

How much 401(k) money equals a pension?

Divide the pension by the price of $1 a year for life. At 5% and the SSA life table, a man of 65 needs about $11.72 per $1 a year, so a $42,000 pension corresponds to about $492,000 before insurer costs.

What happens to my pension if my employer goes bankrupt?

For a private single-employer plan, PBGC takes over and pays benefits up to its maximum, $7,789.77 a month at 65 for plans ending in 2026 and $8,113.64 for 2027. Benefits above the cap can be lost. Government pensions are not PBGC-insured.

Can I have a pension and a 401(k)?

Yes. Many employers offer both, and public employees often have a pension plus a 403(b) or 457(b). The 401(k) deferral limit is not reduced by pension coverage.

Summary

A pension promises an income by formula and leaves investment and longevity risk with the employer and PBGC; a 401(k) promises only contributions and leaves both risks with the worker. Run through the same 35-year career, a 1.5% pension paid $42,000 a year at 65, while a 401(k) saving 10% of pay delivered $28,284, $40,571 or $59,812 a year of lifetime income at 4%, 6% or 8% returns. Pensions reward long service and fall short on portability and, in the private sector, inflation; 401(k)s are portable and flexible but make the outcome depend on markets and on the saver's own choices.

Check your understanding

4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. In a defined-benefit pension, who bears the cost if the plan’s investments do badly?

    1. The retiree, through a lower benefit
    2. The employer, through larger contributions; the formula benefit does not change
    3. Nobody; pensions hold only Treasury bonds
    Show the answer

    B. The employer, through larger contributions; the formula benefit does not change A pension promises an outcome. Funding rules require the employer to make up shortfalls. In a 401(k) the same bad markets shrink the worker’s balance.

  2. A worker’s pension will pay $42,000 a year from 65. At 5% and the SSA life table, $1 a year for life for a man of 65 costs $11.72. Roughly what 401(k) balance would buy the same income, before insurer costs?

    1. $42,000
    2. About $492,000
    3. About $1,050,000, using the 4% rule
    Show the answer

    B. About $492,000 $42,000 × 11.72 ≈ $492,000. The 4% rule answers a different question: a withdrawal designed to keep the capital and allow for inflation, which costs much more.

  3. Why does leaving a final-pay pension job at 45 often cost more than the years of service suggest?

    1. Pension benefits are forfeited after leaving
    2. The formula freezes pay at the level of 45, while the benefit is paid from 65, so inflation and missed raises shrink it
    3. Vesting restarts at each employer
    Show the answer

    B. The formula freezes pay at the level of 45, while the benefit is paid from 65, so inflation and missed raises shrink it Final-pay formulas are back-loaded: the same year of service is worth more when earned near the end, at a higher salary.

  4. What does PBGC insure?

    1. The investment returns of 401(k) accounts
    2. Private-sector defined-benefit pensions, up to a yearly maximum
    3. All pensions, including state and city plans
    Show the answer

    B. Private-sector defined-benefit pensions, up to a yearly maximum PBGC covers private single-employer and multiemployer DB plans up to its limits ($7,789.77 a month at 65 for single-employer plans ending in 2026). Government plans and 401(k) results are not covered.

Sources and further reading

  1. U.S. Department of Labor — Types of retirement plans (defined benefit and defined contribution)
  2. Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation — Maximum monthly guarantee tables (single-employer plans ending in 2026: $7,789.77 a month at 65; 2027: $8,113.64)
  3. Internal Revenue Service — Retirement topics: vesting (defined-benefit and defined-contribution schedules)
  4. U.S. Code — 26 U.S.C. 411(a)(2): minimum vesting (defined benefit 5-year cliff or 3-to-7-year graded; defined contribution 3-year cliff or 2-to-6-year graded)
  5. Internal Revenue Service — Notice 2025-67, 2026 limits: 415(b) defined-benefit limit $290,000, 415(c) $72,000
  6. Internal Revenue Service — Notice 2026-66, 2027 limits: 402(g) $25,500, 415(b) $300,000, 415(c) $75,000
  7. Social Security Administration — Period life table 2023, as used in the 2026 Trustees Report
  8. Finabase calculations (pension formula, 401(k) balances, annuity factor at 5%) in the lesson figure script