Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Turn savings into retirement income Lesson 5 of 9

Retirement · Turning savings into income

Annuities explained: SPIAs, deferred income, QLACs and their costs

How immediate, deferred-income, fixed, indexed and variable annuities work, what a fair payout per $100,000 looks like at 65, and what protects the buyer.

On this page
  1. What an annuity is buying
  2. Income annuities: SPIAs and deferred income annuities
  3. QLACs: deferred income inside an IRA or plan
  4. Deferred annuities sold for accumulation
  5. What protects the buyer if the insurer fails
  6. Pitfalls
  7. The main types compared
  8. How Finabase does it
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. Summary
  11. Check your understanding
  12. Exercise

An annuity is a contract with an insurance company. The buyer pays a premium, in one sum or in instalments, and the insurer promises payments back: for a fixed number of years, for life, or for two lives. The word covers products that have almost nothing in common. A single premium immediate annuity is the simplest retirement income product there is, a pension bought with cash. A variable annuity with optional riders is one of the most complicated retail investments sold in the United States, with a prospectus that can run to hundreds of pages.

What the useful ones share is one thing no portfolio can do on its own: they pool longevity risk. A retiree who spends from savings has to plan for living to 95 or 100, because nobody knows which of their possible lifetimes they will get. An insurer that pays a thousand people for life only has to plan for the average. That difference is worth real money, and this lesson puts a number on it with the Social Security Administration's (SSA) own mortality table. It then walks through the products, what each charges, how the federal tax rules treat a qualifying longevity annuity contract (QLAC) in 2026 and 2027, and what protects a buyer if the insurer fails.

What an annuity is buying

Every annuity has two phases, though some skip the first. In the accumulation phase money is paid in and grows inside the contract, untaxed until it comes out. In the payout phase, also called annuitization, the contract is turned into a stream of payments. Investor.gov, the SEC's investor site, groups the contracts people actually buy into four families by how the accumulation phase is credited: fixed, fixed indexed, registered index-linked (RILA) and variable. Income annuities sit outside that grid because they have no accumulation phase to speak of: the premium goes straight into a promise of payments.

The distinction matters more than the brand names. An income annuity is a purchase of insurance against a long life. A deferred annuity sold as an investment is a savings vehicle with tax deferral, insurance features bolted on, and a surrender schedule that ties the money up for years. The two are judged by different tests.

Income annuities: SPIAs and deferred income annuities

A single premium immediate annuity (SPIA) takes one premium and starts paying within a year, usually monthly, for as long as the buyer lives. Options change the price: a joint-and-survivor version keeps paying while either of two people is alive; a period-certain or cash-refund feature returns something to heirs if the buyer dies early; a cost-of-living rider raises the payment each year by a fixed percentage. Each option buys protection against one outcome and pays for it with a lower starting income.

A deferred income annuity (DIA) is the same contract with a gap. The premium is paid today and the income starts years later, say at 80 or 85. Because the insurer keeps the money longer and because some buyers will not live to the start date, the income per dollar of premium is much larger. A DIA is longevity insurance in its purest form: it pays only in the scenario that strains a retirement plan most, a very long life.

Both are usually irrevocable. Once the premium is paid there is no account balance to withdraw. That is the price of the guarantee and the reason most of the pitfalls below are about buying the wrong amount, not the wrong product.

What a fair payout looks like

The benchmark is a payout an insurer could offer if it had no costs, no profit margin and priced with the national mortality table. Finabase computed it from SSA's 2023 period life table, the one used in the 2026 Trustees Report: each future yearly payment is weighted by the chance the buyer is alive to receive it and discounted at an interest rate. The payments here are level, paid at the start of each year, with no inflation adjustment.

Bought at 65 with $100,000 3% rate 4% rate 5% rate
Man, per year $7,218 $7,868 $8,531
Woman, per year $6,527 $7,170 $7,827
Couple, both 65, 100% to the survivor $5,684 $6,297 $6,929

Three patterns stand out. A woman's payment is lower than a man's because, on SSA's table, she can expect to collect for about two and a half more years. A joint contract pays less again, because it runs until the second death. And the interest rate matters a great deal: a one-point change moves the payment by about 8% to 10%.

These are not quotes. Real prices are lower for three reasons. Insurers carry sales, administration and capital costs and need a profit. People who buy annuities live longer on average than the population as a whole, so insurers price with annuitant mortality tables that assume longer lives than SSA's national period table. And the rate an insurer credits depends on what it earns on its own bond portfolio, after its spread. The fair figures are a yardstick for judging a quote, not a substitute for one. The natural comparison is the yield on Treasury notes and on Treasury inflation-protected securities (TIPS) of similar length, which the Treasury page shows each day.

Mortality credits, in numbers

A fair annuity pays more than interest alone because of mortality credits. Picture a pool of 65-year-old men who each put in money earning 4%. Each year about 1.65% of them die (SSA's death rate at 65 is 0.0165). If their balances are shared among the survivors, each survivor's money grows not by 4% but by 1.04 ÷ (1 − 0.0165) − 1, or about 5.7%. The extra 1.7 points is the credit.

The credit grows with age because death rates do:

Age Man: death rate Return to a survivor at 4% Woman: death rate Return to a survivor
65 1.65% 5.7% 1.02% 5.1%
75 3.38% 7.6% 2.38% 6.5%
85 9.27% 14.6% 7.18% 12.0%
90 15.95% 23.7% 12.92% 19.4%

No bond and no stock offers a guaranteed 14.6% a year. That is why annuity payout rates climb steeply with the age at purchase, and why the case for an income annuity is strongest late in life.

Fair life-annuity payout rate by age at purchase, 4% discount rate (SSA 2023 table) 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 60 65 70 75 80 85 4% interest alone Man Woman Couple, same age, 100% to the survivor 65: 7.9% 80: 13.6% Age at purchase Yearly income as % of the premium (no costs)
Yearly income per dollar of premium for a fair life annuity with no costs, by age at purchase, at a 4% discount rate. Mortality: SSA period life table 2023 (2026 Trustees Report). Computed by Finabase.

The same credits are what a retiree gives up by spending from a portfolio instead. A 4% rate spread evenly over 30 years, with no mortality at all, supports $5,561 a year per $100,000. A man of 65 can get a fair $7,868 for life because the pool pays the late years of those who live long with the balances of those who do not. Against that, the portfolio keeps the money available, can grow with stocks and leaves whatever is left to heirs. An annuity gives up all three.

A deferred start multiplies the income

The same $100,000 at 65, with income starting later, at 4%:

Income starts at Man, per year Chance a man is alive then Woman, per year Chance a woman is alive
65 (immediate) $7,868 100% $7,170 100%
80 $38,157 64.2% $29,600 73.9%
85 $86,658 44.9% $61,028 56.6%

Deferring from 65 to 85 turns $7,868 a year into $86,658, more than eleven times as much, because twenty years of interest and twenty years of mortality credits are folded in. The other side of that number is in the next column: under the period table, more than half of 65-year-old men never collect a payment. That is not a flaw. A deferred income annuity is insurance, and most insurance is never claimed.

QLACs: deferred income inside an IRA or plan

Retirement accounts face required minimum distributions (RMDs), which make a deferred annuity awkward to hold: the RMD is calculated on a balance that includes the annuity's value even though it pays nothing yet. A qualifying longevity annuity contract fixes that. Under the RMD regulations (Treasury Regulation § 1.401(a)(9)-6(q)), premiums paid for a QLAC are left out of the account balance used for RMDs, and the contract must start paying no later than the first day of the month after the owner's 85th birthday.

Section 202 of the SECURE 2.0 Act changed the rules, as the Treasury's final RMD regulations of July 19, 2024 summarise: it removed the old cap of 25% of the account balance, raised the dollar limit from $125,000 to $200,000 indexed for inflation, protected joint-and-survivor benefits after a divorce that meets set conditions, and allowed a free-look rescission of up to 90 days. The indexed limit is $210,000 for 2026 (IRS Notice 2025-67, unchanged from 2025) and $220,000 for 2027 (IRS Notice 2026-66). It applies per person across all of their QLACs.

At the 2026 limit, a fair QLAC bought at 65 that starts at 85 would pay about $181,981 a year to a man or $128,158 to a woman at 4%, under the same no-cost assumptions as above. Real contracts pay less, and payments are fully taxable when they come out of a traditional account. The RMD rules themselves are in Required minimum distributions: ages, tables, deadlines and QCDs.

Deferred annuities sold for accumulation

Many deferred annuities are bought to grow, with income as an option rather than the point. Earnings inside them are tax-deferred, and the gain is taxed as ordinary income when it is withdrawn. Withdrawals of gains before 59½ generally also face a 10% additional tax, and the taxes section covers those mechanics.

Fixed annuities credit a declared interest rate for a guarantee period, often three to ten years. The multi-year guaranteed versions resemble a certificate of deposit issued by an insurer rather than a bank. Investor.gov notes that their main risk of loss is a surrender charge for withdrawals taken during the surrender period.

Fixed indexed annuities credit interest linked to an index such as the S&P 500, with a floor of zero. The SEC's investor bulletin on indexed annuities lists the brakes on the upside: the index's change is usually measured without dividends; a participation rate credits only part of the gain (75% of a 10% index gain is 7.5%); a cap limits the credited return (a 7% cap on a 12% index gain credits 7%); and a spread or margin may be subtracted first. The insurer can usually reset caps and participation rates periodically. FINRA's investor guidance adds that surrender charges commonly apply for six to ten years after purchase and that some contracts forfeit credited interest if money is withdrawn early.

Registered index-linked annuities (RILAs) work the same way but can lose money: a buffer absorbs the first part of a loss (with a 10% buffer, a 12% index fall costs 2%), or a floor limits the loss (with a 10% floor, the same fall costs 10%). Because the owner bears market risk, RILAs are registered with the SEC as securities as well as being insurance products.

Variable annuities invest premiums in subaccounts that are, in effect, mutual funds. There is no floor and no cap: the value follows the funds. Investor.gov lists the layers of cost: a mortality and expense risk charge, which the SEC's investor bulletin puts at around 1.25% a year, administration fees, the underlying funds' expenses, surrender charges that usually decline over several years, and fees for optional benefits such as enhanced death benefits or guaranteed lifetime withdrawal riders. Bonus credits of 1% to 5% of premium are sometimes offered, and the SEC warns that the extra fees may outweigh them. A variable annuity has a free-look period, usually 10 to 30 days according to Investor.gov, during which it can be cancelled without a surrender charge.

What protects the buyer if the insurer fails

An annuity is a promise from one company, backed by its general account. It is not a bank deposit and has no FDIC insurance. The backstop is the state life and health insurance guaranty association: insurers licensed to sell annuities in a state must generally belong to it, and if a member fails, the association continues coverage up to a limit. NOLHGA, the national organisation of the associations, publishes each state's limits. For annuities they apply to the present value of annuity benefits, and as of November 2026 they are $250,000 in 40 jurisdictions, $300,000 in six, $410,000 in one (Minnesota, for annuitized contracts and structured settlements) and $500,000 in four. California covers 80% of a contract's value up to its $250,000 limit, and a few states set a higher limit only for annuities already paying out. Coverage excludes the parts of a contract whose risk is borne by the owner, such as variable annuity subaccounts, which are held separately from the insurer's own assets. A buyer who wants more than one state limit of protection can split purchases between insurers.

Pitfalls

  • Comparing a payout rate with a yield. A 7.9% payout is mostly the buyer's own premium coming back. Compared with a 4% bond yield it looks generous; compared with what the same money could pay for the same expected lifetime, it is fair at best.
  • Forgetting inflation. A level $7,868 a year loses about a quarter of its buying power in ten years of 3% inflation. A cost-of-living rider starts lower, and a payment tied to the consumer price index, where an insurer offers one, starts lower still. Social Security is the main inflation-indexed annuity most households have, which is why delaying it is often compared with buying one.
  • Buying with money needed later. Income annuities cannot be undone, and deferred contracts carry surrender charges. Liquidity for emergencies and health costs has to sit elsewhere.
  • Judging an indexed annuity by the index. Without dividends, and with caps and participation rates that the insurer can reset, the credited return is structurally below the index's total return in good years. That is the price of the zero floor.
  • Concentrating in one insurer. Guaranty limits are per person, per insurer, per state.
  • Exchanging old contracts for new. A Section 1035 exchange moves money between annuities without tax, but a new contract can restart the surrender clock.

The main types compared

Type Money grows by Can lose value? Income for life? Typical exit cost Regulated as
Immediate (SPIA) Nothing to grow: pays at once No balance to lose; the premium is spent Yes Cannot be surrendered Insurance (state)
Deferred income (DIA, QLAC) Interest and mortality credits until the start date Not in value; may pay nothing if the buyer dies first Yes, from the start date Usually cannot be surrendered Insurance (state)
Fixed Declared rate Only through surrender charges Optional Surrender charge Insurance (state)
Fixed indexed Index-linked credit, floor of zero, caps Only through surrender charges Optional Surrender charge, often 6–10 years Insurance (state)
RILA Index-linked, with a buffer or floor Yes, beyond the buffer Optional Surrender charge Insurance and SEC security
Variable Subaccount (fund) returns Yes Optional, often through riders Surrender charge plus ongoing fees Insurance and SEC security

How Finabase does it

Finabase is a research app. It does not sell annuities, hold accounts or quote insurers' rates, and it does not know a reader's health, tax position or other income. What it can do is supply the market side of the comparison: the Treasury page shows today's yields on Treasury bills, notes, bonds and TIPS, which are the risk-free returns an annuity's payout should be judged against, and a TIPS yield is the closest market price for inflation-protected income. The Portfolio page tracks the savings that sit beside any annuity, with their dividends, so the share of income that is guaranteed and the share that depends on markets can be seen together. The figures on this page were computed by Finabase from SSA's published life table.

Frequently asked questions

How much does a $100,000 annuity pay at 65?

A fair life annuity with no costs would pay about $7,870 a year to a 65-year-old man and $7,170 to a woman at a 4% interest rate, using SSA's 2023 period life table. Commercial quotes are lower because of costs, insurer mortality tables and the rates insurers credit, and they change with interest rates.

What is the difference between an immediate and a deferred annuity?

An immediate annuity starts paying within a year of purchase. A deferred annuity either delays income to a chosen date (a deferred income annuity) or grows a balance that may later be turned into income or withdrawn (fixed, indexed and variable deferred annuities).

What is the QLAC limit for 2026 and 2027?

The QLAC premium limit is $210,000 for 2026 and $220,000 for 2027, per person, under IRS Notices 2025-67 and 2026-66. Since SECURE 2.0 there is no longer a limit of 25% of the account balance.

What happens to my annuity if the insurance company goes bankrupt?

The state guaranty association where the owner lives continues coverage up to its limit, which is at least $250,000 of annuity benefits per person in every state, and more in some, according to NOLHGA; California covers 80% of the contract's value up to that limit. Amounts above the limit depend on what the failed insurer's estate recovers.

Why do annuities pay more than bonds?

They return the buyer's own principal over time and add mortality credits, the balances of buyers who die early shared among those who live. The payout rate is not an investment return; the return on a life annuity depends on how long the buyer lives.

Summary

An annuity converts a sum of money into payments from an insurer. Income annuities, immediate or deferred, buy protection against a long life by pooling it: a fair contract at 65 pays about $7,870 a year per $100,000 to a man and $7,170 to a woman at 4%, and the advantage over spending from savings, the mortality credit, grows from under two points a year at 65 to more than ten at 85. Fixed, indexed and variable deferred annuities are mostly savings products whose caps, fees and surrender charges need reading line by line, with the SEC's and FINRA's bulletins as a guide. A QLAC shelters up to $210,000 (2026) or $220,000 (2027) of retirement-account money from RMDs until income starts by 85, and state guaranty associations protect annuity benefits up to limits of at least $250,000 per person if an insurer fails.

Check your understanding

5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. A fair life annuity bought at 65 pays a man about 7.9% of the premium a year at a 4% interest rate. Where does the part above 4% come from?

    1. From the insurer’s profits
    2. From the buyer’s own principal being paid back, plus mortality credits from buyers who die early
    3. From investing the premium in stocks
    Show the answer

    B. From the buyer’s own principal being paid back, plus mortality credits from buyers who die early A life annuity returns principal over the buyer’s lifetime and shares the balances of those who die early among those who live. That is why the payout rate is not a yield and why it rises with age.

  2. Why does a deferred income annuity bought at 65 that starts at 85 pay more than ten times as much per year as an immediate one?

    1. Twenty years of interest and mortality credits accrue before payments start, and many buyers never collect
    2. Deferred annuities invest in riskier assets
    3. The IRS adds a credit to deferred annuities
    Show the answer

    A. Twenty years of interest and mortality credits accrue before payments start, and many buyers never collect The insurer keeps the money for twenty years and, under SSA’s 2023 table, fewer than half of 65-year-old men live to 85. Those who do are paid from everyone’s premiums.

  3. What does a QLAC change about required minimum distributions?

    1. It ends RMDs for the whole account
    2. Its premium, up to $210,000 in 2026, is left out of the balance used to calculate RMDs until payments start, no later than 85
    3. It lets the owner skip RMDs until 85 on any annuity
    Show the answer

    B. Its premium, up to $210,000 in 2026, is left out of the balance used to calculate RMDs until payments start, no later than 85 The QLAC premium is excluded from the RMD balance; the rest of the account still has RMDs. Payments must begin by the first day of the month after the owner turns 85.

  4. An indexed annuity has a 7% cap and the index rises 12% in a year, of which 2% was dividends. What is credited, before any spread?

    1. 12%
    2. 10%
    3. 7%
    Show the answer

    C. 7% The index’s change is usually measured without dividends, 10% here, and the cap then limits the credit to 7%.

  5. What protects an annuity owner if the insurer fails?

    1. FDIC insurance
    2. The state life and health insurance guaranty association, up to its limit (at least $250,000 of annuity benefits per person)
    3. Nothing at all
    Show the answer

    B. The state life and health insurance guaranty association, up to its limit (at least $250,000 of annuity benefits per person) Annuities are insurance, not deposits. State guaranty associations continue coverage up to limits that NOLHGA lists by state; amounts above the limit depend on the failed insurer’s estate.

Exercise

One task to do in Finabase. Nothing is graded or saved.

The lesson works out that a fair income annuity at 65 pays a man about $7,870 a year per $100,000, priced at 4%. Open the Treasury page and read the 10-year yield. Work out a year’s interest on $100,000 at that yield. The difference between the two incomes is the part of each annuity payment that comes from spending principal and from the mortality credit.

Open Treasury yields
What you should find

At a 10-year yield near 4%, interest pays about $4,000 and leaves the $100,000 intact; the annuity pays nearly twice that because it spends the principal and pools longevity, and nothing is left at death. Insurers’ quotes include costs, so real offers sit below the fair figure, and they rise and fall with rates.

Sources and further reading

  1. Social Security Administration, Office of the Chief Actuary — Period life table, 2023, as used in the 2026 Trustees Report
  2. IRS Notice 2026-66 — 2027 limitations adjusted as provided in section 415(d), etc. (QLAC premium limit $220,000), November 2026
  3. IRS Notice 2025-67 — 2026 limitations (QLAC premium limit remains $210,000)
  4. Treasury and IRS — Required Minimum Distributions, final regulations, 89 Fed. Reg. 58886 (July 19, 2024): SECURE 2.0 section 202 changes to QLACs
  5. SEC, Investor.gov — Annuities (fixed, fixed indexed, registered index-linked and variable)
  6. SEC, Investor.gov — Variable annuities (fees, surrender charges, free look period, bonus credits)
  7. SEC — Investor Bulletin: Variable Annuities (mortality and expense risk charge around 1.25% a year)
  8. SEC, Investor.gov — Updated Investor Bulletin: Indexed Annuities
  9. FINRA — The Complicated Risks and Rewards of Indexed Annuities
  10. National Organization of Life and Health Insurance Guaranty Associations (NOLHGA) — How you’re protected (coverage limits by state)