Turn savings into retirement income Lesson 8 of 9
Retirement · Turning savings into income
Retirement withdrawal order: taxable, tax-deferred or Roth first?
The conventional withdrawal order against proportional and bracket-based ones, with a 30-year example on 2026 brackets, RMDs and the Social Security tax thresholds.
On this page
Most retirees hold money in three kinds of account: taxable brokerage accounts, tax-deferred accounts such as traditional IRAs and 401(k)s, and Roth accounts. Each is taxed differently on the way out. Selling from a taxable account taxes only the gain, at capital gains rates; every dollar from a tax-deferred account is ordinary income; qualified Roth withdrawals are not taxed at all. The order in which a retiree draws on them does not change how much they can spend in a year, but it can change how much federal income tax they pay over a lifetime, how large their required minimum distributions (RMDs) become, and how much of their Social Security is taxed.
The textbook answer is to spend the taxable account first, then the tax-deferred accounts, and the Roth last, so that the tax-advantaged money keeps compounding longest. This lesson tests that rule against two alternatives on one invented couple over 30 years, using the 2026 federal brackets. The point is not the answer for that couple; it is to show where the conventional order leaves low tax brackets unused, and why. The tax mechanics behind each piece, such as how gains and Social Security are taxed, belong to the taxes section and are touched on here only as far as the example needs.
Three ways to order withdrawals
Conventional: taxable first, tax-deferred next, Roth last. The reasoning is that a taxable account pays tax every year on dividends and interest, so it is the least efficient place to keep money, and the Roth, which is never taxed again, is the most efficient. Spending in that order keeps the most money in the best shelters for the longest. The weakness is that during the taxable phase the retiree's taxable income can be close to zero, so the low brackets go unused, while the tax-deferred balance grows untouched until RMDs force it out in larger amounts.
Proportional. Each year's withdrawal comes from all accounts in proportion to their balances. A household with 55% of its money in an IRA takes about 55% of each withdrawal from the IRA. This spreads ordinary income evenly over the years and avoids both the empty early years and the bunched late ones.
Bracket-based. Each year the retiree withdraws from the tax-deferred account up to a chosen point, usually the top of a low bracket, whether the money is needed that year or not. The rest of the spending comes from the taxable account, and Roth money is kept for years that would otherwise push income into a higher bracket. Any IRA money withdrawn but not spent is reinvested in the taxable account. A Roth conversion is a variant of the same idea: instead of withdrawing up to the bracket top, the extra is moved into a Roth (Roth conversions in early retirement: filling low tax brackets).
What forces the order
Whatever the plan, three rules shape it.
- RMDs. From 73 for people born from 1951 to 1958 (and, under 2024 proposed regulations, 1959), and from 75 for those born in 1960 or later, a share of every tax-deferred balance must come out each year, the prior year-end balance divided by the IRS Uniform Lifetime Table divisor (26.5 at 73, 24.6 at 75). RMDs override any order. A plan that leaves the IRA untouched until then is committing to large, rising, fully taxable withdrawals later; see Required minimum distributions: ages, tables, deadlines and QCDs.
- The Social Security thresholds. Under §86 of the Internal Revenue Code, up to 50% of benefits become taxable once "combined income" (adjusted gross income, plus tax-exempt interest, plus half the benefits) exceeds $25,000 for a single filer or $32,000 for a joint return, and up to 85% above $34,000 or $44,000. These amounts are written into the statute and are not indexed for inflation, so each year more retirees cross them. In the range where benefits are being phased into income, an extra dollar of IRA withdrawal can add up to $1.85 of taxable income.
- Deductions for older taxpayers. For 2026 a married couple both 65 or over gets the $32,200 standard deduction plus $1,650 each (Rev. Proc. 2025-32), and, for 2025 through 2028, an extra $6,000 each that the IRS says phases out above $75,000 of modified adjusted gross income ($150,000 joint). In 2027 the standard deduction is $33,200 and the additional amount $1,700 (Rev. Proc. 2026-35).
A worked example over 30 years
The couple is invented. Both are 65 in 2026, born in 1961, so their RMDs start at 75. They file jointly and receive $50,000 a year of Social Security between them. They hold $500,000 in a taxable account (of which $300,000 is cost basis), $900,000 in traditional IRAs and $200,000 in Roth IRAs. They spend $100,000 a year after federal income tax, from 65 to 94.
Assumptions, kept deliberately simple: every account earns 4% a year after inflation and everything is in 2026 dollars; the 2026 brackets, standard deduction and additional deductions are held at their 2026 values in real terms, and the $6,000 senior deduction applies only in 2026 to 2028, as the law now stands. A sale from the taxable account realises gains in proportion to the account's unrealised share, taxed at 0% while taxable income is under $98,900 and at 15% above it (the 2026 thresholds). Taxable Social Security follows the IRS Publication 915 worksheet. There is no state tax, no net investment income tax and no Medicare premium surcharge in the model, and the taxable account pays no tax on its own dividends. The modified AGI stays under $150,000 in every year from 2026 to 2028 in all three plans, so the senior deduction is never reduced.
| Order | Lifetime federal income tax | Tax at 65 | Tax at 75 | Tax at 90 | Left at 95 | Left at 95, IRA at 78% |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Conventional | $178,352 | $0 | $6,171 | $10,289 | $2,006,529 | $1,840,598 |
| Proportional | $129,608 | $0 | $3,415 | $7,477 | $2,071,676 | $1,950,356 |
| Fill the 12% bracket | $127,600 | $11,600 | $11,600 | $0 | $1,930,236 | $1,930,236 |
What happened in each plan
Conventional. For ten years the couple lived on Social Security and $50,000 a year from the taxable account. Their adjusted gross income was $26,850 at 65 and $41,797 at 73, almost all of it gains taxed at 0% and a small taxable slice of their benefits, and they paid no federal income tax at all. The 12% bracket, which could have held about $100,000 of taxable income a year, sat empty. At 75 the first RMD of $54,155 arrived, and taxable withdrawals all but stopped. With it, taxable Social Security jumped from $14,434 at 74 to $36,901, and from then on they paid $6,000 to more than $10,000 a year as RMDs grew. They never needed the Roth, which grew untouched to $648,680, and at 95 they still held $754,233 in IRAs.
Proportional. Taking about 56% of each withdrawal from the IRA from the start put roughly $28,000 to $29,000 of ordinary income on the return every year before RMDs. They paid no tax in the first two years and a little over $1,400 a year by 68, and because the IRA was being drawn down early, their first RMD at 75 was $39,595 instead of $54,155. Lifetime tax fell by $48,744 against the conventional order.
Fill the 12% bracket. Each year they withdrew from the IRA up to the top of the 12% bracket: $105,800 a year while the senior deduction lasted and $93,800 after it, paying $11,600 a year in federal tax from the very first year. The surplus went into the taxable account. The IRA was empty at 76, after which their only taxable income was gains and part of their benefits, and their tax fell to zero. Lifetime tax was the lowest of the three, $127,600.
Why lowest tax is not automatically best
The bracket plan paid the least tax but ended with slightly less money than the proportional plan, $1,930,236 against $1,950,356 when the IRAs left to heirs are counted at 78 cents on the dollar. Tax paid at 65 is money that no longer compounds for 30 years. The comparison also turns on assumptions the model fixes: heirs who inherit an IRA must generally empty it within ten years and pay ordinary income tax at their own rates, so a heir in a high bracket makes the IRA worth less and the bracket plan look better; and assets in a taxable account generally receive a step-up in basis at death, which erases the unrealised gain and favours leaving the taxable account to heirs. Neither effect is in the totals above beyond the 78% assumption.
Pitfalls and limits
- Optimising one year at a time. The lowest tax this year is often the conventional order. The lowest tax over a retirement is rarely the same thing.
- Ignoring the survivor. The example keeps both spouses alive to 94. A widow or widower files as single, with brackets about half as wide, and an IRA left to them is taxed at those rates.
- Forgetting Medicare. Withdrawals that lift modified AGI above $218,000 (joint; the 2026 threshold, $224,000 for 2027) raise Medicare premiums two years later; none of the plans above came close.
- Selling at a loss or a gain. Which lots are sold from the taxable account changes the gain; the model assumes an average.
- Assuming the law stays still. The 2026 brackets and deductions are set by Rev. Proc. 2025-32; the senior deduction ends after 2028 unless Congress extends it; the §86 thresholds are fixed only until Congress changes them.
- State taxes. Some states exempt Social Security or retirement income, which can change the ranking.
The orders compared
| Order | Early-retirement tax | Late-retirement tax | RMD size | Roth left for heirs | Main risk |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Conventional | Very low | Highest | Largest | Largest | Wasted low brackets; RMDs push benefits into tax |
| Proportional | Low and steady | Moderate | Smaller | Moderate | Uses the Roth before it is needed |
| Bracket-based | Highest | Lowest | Smallest, or none | Large | Paying tax early on money that might have been taxed less |
| Roth conversions in gap years | Higher | Lower | Smaller | Larger | Same as bracket-based, plus Medicare look-back |
How Finabase does it
Finabase is a research app. It does not hold retirement accounts, run withdrawals or know a reader's tax return, and the example on this page is an illustration, not advice for any household. The Portfolio page can track the holdings in a taxable account, an IRA and a Roth side by side, which shows how much of the total sits in each tax treatment, and each fund's symbol page lists its dividends, the income a taxable account is taxed on each year. The calculation above was made by Finabase from the IRS rate tables for 2026 and the Publication 915 worksheet.
Frequently asked questions
Which retirement account should I withdraw from first?
There is no single answer. The conventional order, taxable first and Roth last, keeps tax-advantaged money growing longest, but it can waste low tax brackets early and create large RMDs later. Proportional and bracket-based orders often pay less lifetime tax; which is best depends on balances, Social Security, spending, heirs and future tax law.
At what income does Social Security become taxable?
For a joint return, up to half of benefits become taxable when combined income (AGI plus tax-exempt interest plus half the benefits) exceeds $32,000, and up to 85% above $44,000. For single filers the amounts are $25,000 and $34,000. They are fixed in IRC §86 and not adjusted for inflation.
Do RMDs change the withdrawal order?
Yes. From 73 or 75, depending on birth year, each tax-deferred account must pay out at least its RMD every year, whatever order the retiree prefers. Spending more from the IRA before then reduces later RMDs.
Should I leave my Roth IRA for last?
Often, because it has no lifetime RMDs and qualified withdrawals are tax-free, and heirs inherit it without income tax on qualified withdrawals. But dipping into it in a year that would otherwise cross into a higher bracket or a Medicare threshold can be cheaper than taking more from an IRA.
Summary
The order of retirement withdrawals changes lifetime taxes more than most people expect. In an invented example on 2026 federal law, a couple who spent their taxable account first paid no federal income tax for ten years and then $6,000 to $10,600 a year once RMDs began and pushed their Social Security into tax, $178,352 over 30 years. Drawing proportionally from every account cost $129,608, and filling the 12% bracket from the IRA each year cost $127,600 but left slightly less behind because tax was paid earlier. RMDs, the unindexed §86 thresholds of $25,000 and $32,000, Medicare's surcharges and what heirs will pay all shape the answer, which is why it differs from one household to the next.
Check your understanding
4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
In the lesson’s example, why did the conventional order pay the most federal tax over 30 years?
- Because capital gains are taxed more than IRA withdrawals
- Because the low brackets went unused for ten years, then RMDs and more taxable Social Security arrived together
- Because it spent the Roth first
Show the answer
B. Because the low brackets went unused for ten years, then RMDs and more taxable Social Security arrived together Living on the taxable account kept taxable income near zero until 75. The untouched IRA then produced larger RMDs, which also pulled more of the couple’s benefits into tax.
A married couple’s combined income for Social Security purposes is $40,000. Roughly what share of their benefits can be taxable?
- None, because the threshold is indexed above $40,000
- Up to 50%, because combined income is between $32,000 and $44,000
- Up to 85%
Show the answer
B. Up to 50%, because combined income is between $32,000 and $44,000 Under IRC §86, for a joint return up to half of benefits are taxable between $32,000 and $44,000 of combined income, and up to 85% above $44,000. The thresholds are not indexed.
The bracket-based plan paid the least lifetime tax but left slightly less money at 95 than the proportional plan. Why?
- It earned a lower return
- It paid tax earlier, so less money compounded over the following decades
- It took RMDs late
Show the answer
B. It paid tax earlier, so less money compounded over the following decades Tax paid at 65 removes money that would otherwise have grown for 30 years. Lowest lifetime tax and largest final wealth are different goals.
Why might leaving a taxable account to heirs be better than the conventional order suggests?
- Assets in a taxable account generally get a step-up in basis at death, erasing the unrealised gain
- Taxable accounts have no estate tax
- Heirs can roll a taxable account into an IRA
Show the answer
A. Assets in a taxable account generally get a step-up in basis at death, erasing the unrealised gain Heirs who inherit an IRA pay ordinary income tax as they withdraw it, generally within ten years; inherited taxable assets usually take a new basis at their value on the date of death.
Exercise
One task to do in Finabase. Nothing is graded or saved.
Open VTI’s Dividends tab and add up the last four payments per share. Divide by the current price to get a yearly yield. Imagine a $250,000 taxable account held in that fund: how much dividend income would appear on the tax return each year, whatever order the household takes its withdrawals in? Compare it with the 0% bracket for qualified dividends the lesson’s couple stays in while spending taxable money first.
Open VTI’s dividendsWhat you should find
A total-market fund has yielded somewhere around 1% to 2%, so $250,000 throws off a few thousand dollars a year, taxed whether or not it is spent. For a couple with low other income those qualified dividends fall in the 0% bracket, which is part of why spending the taxable account first cost no federal tax for ten years in the lesson.
Sources and further reading
- IRS Rev. Proc. 2025-32 — 2026 tax rate tables, standard deduction, additional deduction for the aged, 0% capital gains threshold
- IRS Rev. Proc. 2026-35 — 2027 tax rate tables and standard deduction
- CMS — 2027 Medicare Parts B premiums and deductibles fact sheet (November 17, 2026): income-related monthly adjustment above $224,000 of joint 2025 MAGI
- IRS Publication 915 (2025) — Social Security and Equivalent Railroad Retirement Benefits (worksheet with the $25,000/$32,000 base amounts)
- 26 U.S.C. § 86 — Social security and tier 1 railroad retirement benefits
- IRS — Working Families Tax Cuts: tax deductions for working Americans and seniors ($6,000 deduction for 65 and older, 2025–2028)
- Treasury and IRS — Required Minimum Distributions, proposed regulations REG-103529-23, Federal Register, July 19, 2024 (applicable age 73 for those born in 1959)
- IRS Publication 590-B (2025) — required minimum distributions and the Uniform Lifetime Table
