Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Taxes · Tax-aware investing

Asset location: which account holds bonds, stocks and REITs

How placing assets across taxable, tax-deferred and Roth accounts changes after-tax wealth, a 30-year two-account model, and when the usual answer flips.

On this page
  1. Tax drag by asset in a taxable account
  2. The model: two accounts, two funds, 30 years
  3. When the answer flips
  4. What asset location cannot do
  5. Placement compared by account type
  6. How Finabase does it
  7. Frequently asked questions
  8. Summary
  9. Check your understanding

Asset allocation decides how much of your money is in stocks, bonds and everything else. Asset location decides which account each of them sits in: a taxable brokerage account, a tax-deferred account such as a traditional IRA or 401(k), or a Roth account. Two investors with the same allocation can end up with different after-tax wealth because one keeps the heavily taxed assets where tax cannot reach them each year and the other does not.

The idea is simple to state and harder to apply. Each asset has a tax drag, the share of its return lost to tax each year it sits in a taxable account, and each account type treats returns differently. This page measures the drag of the common assets under US federal law for tax year 2026, builds a 30-year model with two accounts of $100,000 each, computes both placements after every tax, and then shows the conditions under which the familiar answer reverses.

Account rules themselves (who may contribute, how much, when money can come out, required minimum distributions) belong to the retirement accounts lessons: Retirement accounts explained: 401(k), IRA, Roth and 2026 limits and Roth vs traditional IRA: how to compare tax now and tax later. This page takes the accounts as given. Which placement suits you depends on your accounts, rates, holdings and plans, and is a question for a tax professional or adviser who knows them; the model here is an illustration, not a recommendation.

Tax drag by asset in a taxable account

The table shows how each kind of return is taxed in 2026 when the asset sits in a taxable account, for an investor in the 24% ordinary bracket and the 15% long-term rate. The rates and brackets are in Tax brackets for investors: how gains and dividends stack in 2026.

Return When taxed Federal rate (example) Detail
Bond and cash interest Each year 24% (ordinary) How interest income is taxed: savings, CDs, T-bills and money funds
Treasury interest Each year 24%, no state tax How bonds are taxed in the US: interest, discounts, gains and funds
Municipal bond interest Generally not taxed 0% federal Municipal bonds: GO vs revenue bonds and tax-free yield math
Qualified dividends Each year 15% Qualified vs ordinary dividends: the 61-day test, REITs and funds
REIT ordinary dividends Each year 24%, less the 199A 20% REIT and MLP taxes: 199A deduction, K-1s, basis and recapture
Fund capital gain distributions Each year, if paid 15% How fund investors are taxed: distributions, retained gains and sales
Unrealized price gain Only when sold 15% if held > 1 year Capital gains tax on stocks: 2026 rates, holding periods and basis

Inside a traditional IRA or 401(k) none of these is taxed as it is earned. Everything that comes out is taxed as ordinary income, whatever it was inside: a stock's long-term gain becomes 24% income on withdrawal. Inside a Roth, qualified withdrawals are not taxed at all. Publication 590-B sets out both rules; the conditions for a qualified Roth withdrawal are in Roth vs traditional IRA: how to compare tax now and tax later.

That gives two forces that pull in opposite directions:

  1. Shelter the asset that is taxed most each year. Bond interest at 24% every year is the heaviest drag in the table; a broad stock index fund, whose return is mostly deferred gain, is among the lightest.
  2. Do not turn a 15% gain into 24% income. A stock fund in a traditional IRA gives up the long-term rate on its growth. In a Roth that cost disappears, so the Roth is the place where the fastest-growing asset gains the most.

The model: two accounts, two funds, 30 years

Finabase computed the numbers, and every assumption is listed here:

  • Accounts. $100,000 in a taxable account and $100,000 in a traditional IRA. Nothing is added or withdrawn for 30 years. At the end, the taxable account is sold and the IRA is withdrawn in full, both taxed.
  • Bond fund. 4.5% a year, all interest, no change in price. In the taxable account the interest is taxed at 24% each year and the rest reinvested.
  • Stock index fund. 7% a year total: a 1.5% qualified dividend and 5.5% price growth. In the taxable account the dividend is taxed at 15% each year, the rest reinvested and added to basis; no capital gain distributions. The accumulated gain is taxed at 15% when sold in year 30.
  • IRA. Grows untaxed; the whole balance is taxed at 24% on withdrawal, the same rate as today.
  • Left out. State tax, the 3.8% NIIT, inflation, fees, rebalancing, and any change in tax law.

Each placement puts one fund in each account. Because nothing is rebalanced, the two placements end with different mixes of stocks and bonds; the comparison is of after-tax dollars only.

Placement A: stocks taxable, bonds in the IRA

  • The taxable stock fund grows to $714,640 with a basis of $215,670 (the $100,000 plus 30 years of reinvested after-tax dividends). The tax on the sale is $74,845, leaving $639,795.
  • The IRA's bonds grow untaxed to $374,532. After 24% on withdrawal: $284,644.
  • Total after all taxes: $924,439.

Placement B: bonds taxable, stocks in the IRA

  • The taxable bond fund earns 4.5% × (1 − 24%) = 3.42% after tax a year and grows to $274,243. Nothing more is owed at the end.
  • The IRA's stocks grow untaxed to $761,226. After 24% on withdrawal: $578,531.
  • Total after all taxes: $852,775.

Placement A ends $71,664 ahead. Two things produce the gap: the bond interest that escaped a 24% tax every year inside the IRA, and the stock gain that kept its 15% rate instead of becoming 24% income.

The same model with a Roth

Replace the traditional IRA with a $100,000 Roth IRA, everything else unchanged:

  • Stocks taxable, bonds in the Roth: $639,795 + $374,532 = $1,014,326.
  • Bonds taxable, stocks in the Roth: $274,243 + $761,226 = $1,035,469.

Now the reverse placement wins, by $21,142. In a Roth there is no ordinary-income tax on the way out to avoid, so the only question left is which asset's growth is worth more to shelter, and at 7% against 4.5% the stock fund's is. (The Roth totals are larger than the IRA totals because a $100,000 Roth belongs entirely to the owner, while about a quarter of a traditional IRA is future tax. The two pairs answer the same question for different accounts; they do not compare a Roth with a traditional IRA.)

After all taxes in 30 years: $100,000 in each account, two placements IRA: stocks taxable, bonds in IRA $924,439 IRA: bonds taxable, stocks in IRA $852,775 Roth: stocks taxable, bonds in Roth $1,014,326 Roth: bonds taxable, stocks in Roth $1,035,469 Bonds 4.5% interest; stocks 7% (1.5% qualified dividends). 24% ordinary, 15% gains, IRA taxed at 24% on withdrawal.
Two accounts of $100,000, one bond fund and one stock fund, 30 years, 2026 federal rates held constant. Chart: Finabase.

When the answer flips

The grid below reruns the model across bond yields from 2% to 6% and stock returns from 5% to 9%, each time showing stocks taxable and bonds sheltered, minus the reverse. A plus sign means bonds belong in the sheltered account in that cell.

Stocks taxable and bonds sheltered, minus the reverse (after tax, 30 years) Stock return Bonds 2.0% Bonds 3.0% Bonds 4.5% Bonds 6.0% 5%, IRA pair +$24k +$31k +$54k +$99k 7%, IRA pair +$42k +$49k +$72k +$117k 9%, IRA pair +$72k +$79k +$102k +$147k 5%, Roth pair −$37k −$14k +$40k +$133k 7%, Roth pair −$98k −$75k −$21k +$72k 9%, Roth pair −$203k −$181k −$127k −$33k
After-tax difference in dollars after 30 years; same assumptions as the bar chart, one input changed at a time.

Low bond yields. At 2% interest, the yearly tax on bonds is small, so sheltering them is worth less. With a traditional IRA the usual placement still wins in the model, but by $41,692 at 7% stocks instead of $71,664. With a Roth, low yields make stocks in the Roth the better placement by $97,529.

High expected stock returns. The faster stocks grow, the more a Roth's tax-free growth is worth on them. At 9% stocks and 4.5% bonds, stocks in the Roth lead by $126,515. Expected returns are guesses, which means the "right" placement depends on a forecast.

The municipal bond alternative. An investor who keeps bonds in a taxable account can hold municipal bonds, whose interest is generally exempt from federal tax under §103. At an assumed 3.2% muni yield, $100,000 grows to $257,271 in 30 years, less than the $274,243 of the 4.5% taxable fund after 24% tax, whose after-tax yield is 3.42%. At a higher bracket or a narrower yield gap the muni would win. Tax-equivalent yield: brackets, the 3.8% NIIT and state tax shows the comparison; munis are rarely held in an IRA because their exemption is wasted there.

Foreign tax on international funds. A fund holding foreign stocks has foreign taxes withheld from its dividends. In a taxable account, the investor can usually claim a foreign tax credit for them (Publication 514). Inside an IRA there is no US tax on the income to credit it against, so the withheld tax is simply lost. That is a reason some investors keep international funds in taxable accounts.

REITs. REIT dividends are mostly not qualified dividends. They are taxed at ordinary rates, with a 20% deduction under section 199A that the 2025 law made permanent, so their drag in a taxable account is close to a bond's. REIT and MLP taxes: 199A deduction, K-1s, basis and recapture works the numbers. MLPs are the opposite case: their income can be taxable even inside an IRA.

Higher or lower rates at withdrawal. The model taxes the IRA at 24% both when the money went in and when it comes out. A lower rate in retirement makes everything in the traditional IRA worth more, a higher one less, and either changes the size of the gap between the placements; the model does not test it.

What asset location cannot do

  • It cannot fix an allocation. Location works only within the mix you have chosen. Holding more bonds than you want, to fill an IRA, is an allocation decision dressed up as a tax one.
  • It needs more than one kind of account. An investor with only a 401(k), or only a taxable account, has nothing to locate.
  • It makes accounts drift apart. With stocks in one account and bonds in another, rebalancing means trading inside the sheltered account, and a sale in the taxable account to rebalance can realize a gain. Over 30 years the two placements in the model end with different stock-bond mixes.
  • It complicates the after-tax picture. A dollar in a traditional IRA is not worth a dollar to spend; part of it is future tax. Two portfolios that look 50/50 on statements are not 50/50 after tax.
  • It rests on today's law. Rates, the treatment of dividends and the rules for Roth withdrawals can change over 30 years.

Placement compared by account type

Asset (2026 law) Taxable account Traditional IRA / 401(k) Roth IRA / Roth 401(k)
Taxable bond fund Interest taxed yearly at ordinary rate Untaxed until withdrawal, then ordinary Untaxed if withdrawals qualify
Broad stock index fund Dividends yearly, gain at sale at 15% Gain becomes ordinary income Untaxed if withdrawals qualify
Municipal bond fund Interest generally federal tax-free Exemption wasted Exemption wasted
International stock fund Foreign tax credit usually available Foreign tax withheld, no credit Foreign tax withheld, no credit
REIT fund Mostly ordinary dividends, 199A 20% Untaxed until withdrawal Untaxed if withdrawals qualify

How Finabase does it

Finabase does not model accounts or taxes, and it does not suggest a placement. What it can show are the inputs to a model like this one. A fund's dividends tab lists every distribution with its amount, for example a bond fund such as AGG against an S&P 500 fund such as IVV, which shows how much of each fund's return arrives as yearly income. The Treasury page shows current yields across maturities. A portfolio can be kept per account, so the holdings of a taxable account and an IRA sit side by side; its gains are matched first in, first out, without tax lots or after-tax values.

Frequently asked questions

Should bonds go in an IRA or a taxable account?

In the model on this page, with a traditional IRA, bonds in the IRA ended $71,664 ahead over 30 years, and that held across every bond yield and stock return tested. With a Roth the answer reversed in most cells. The result depends on your rates, yields, accounts and plans, so it is a question for an adviser who knows them.

What is tax drag?

Tax drag is the part of an investment's return lost to tax each year while it is held in a taxable account. A 4.5% bond fund taxed at 24% loses 1.08 points a year; a stock index fund with a 1.5% qualified dividend taxed at 15% loses about 0.23 points a year until it is sold.

Why put stocks in a Roth?

Because nothing that comes out of a qualified Roth withdrawal is taxed, the account is worth most when it holds whatever grows fastest. In the model, at 7% stocks and 4.5% bonds, stocks in the Roth ended $21,142 ahead of bonds in the Roth.

Is asset location the same as asset allocation?

No. Allocation is the mix of assets; location is which account holds each one. Location is applied after the allocation is chosen and should not change it.

Summary

Asset location places each holding in the account where tax costs it least. In a taxable account, bond interest is taxed every year at ordinary rates while a stock index fund's return is mostly deferred gain taxed at long-term rates, and a traditional IRA turns everything into ordinary income on the way out while a Roth taxes nothing. In a 30-year model with $100,000 in each of two accounts, bonds at 4.5% and stocks at 7%, keeping stocks taxable and bonds in a traditional IRA ended $71,664 ahead after all taxes, but with a Roth the reverse placement won by $21,142, and low bond yields or high stock returns push further that way. Municipal bonds, foreign tax credits and REITs change the answer again. Location cannot improve an allocation or help an investor with one kind of account, and the right placement for any one investor depends on facts this model leaves out.

Check your understanding

4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. Why does a broad stock index fund usually carry less tax drag in a taxable account than a bond fund?

    1. Stock funds are exempt from federal tax
    2. Most of its return is unrealized gain, taxed only on sale and at long-term rates, while bond interest is taxed every year at ordinary rates
    3. Stock dividends are taxed at 0% for everyone
    Show the answer

    B. Most of its return is unrealized gain, taxed only on sale and at long-term rates, while bond interest is taxed every year at ordinary rates In the model, the bond fund loses 1.08 points a year to tax (4.5% × 24%), the stock fund about 0.23 points a year (1.5% × 15%) until it is sold.

  2. In the model, keeping bonds in a traditional IRA beat keeping stocks there, but with a Roth the result reversed. What explains the difference?

    1. A traditional IRA turns a stock gain that would have been taxed at 15% into ordinary income; a Roth taxes neither, so it favors the faster-growing asset
    2. Roth accounts cannot hold bonds
    3. Traditional IRAs are taxed every year
    Show the answer

    A. A traditional IRA turns a stock gain that would have been taxed at 15% into ordinary income; a Roth taxes neither, so it favors the faster-growing asset Withdrawals from a traditional IRA are ordinary income whatever was earned inside. A qualified Roth withdrawal is untaxed, so the asset with the most growth gains the most from it.

  3. An investor in the 24% bracket compares a 4.5% taxable bond fund with a 3.2% municipal bond fund for a taxable account. Which earns more after federal tax, on these numbers?

    1. The municipal fund, because its interest is tax-free
    2. The taxable fund: 4.5% × (1 − 0.24) = 3.42%, above 3.2%
    3. They are exactly equal
    Show the answer

    B. The taxable fund: 4.5% × (1 − 0.24) = 3.42%, above 3.2% The after-tax yield of the taxable fund is 3.42%. Over 30 years $100,000 grows to $274,243 against $257,271 for the muni. A higher bracket or a narrower yield gap would reverse it.

  4. What can asset location not do?

    1. Reduce yearly tax on bond interest
    2. Keep a foreign tax credit available on an international fund
    3. Help an investor whose money is all in one 401(k)
    Show the answer

    C. Help an investor whose money is all in one 401(k) Location needs at least two kinds of account. With one account, there is no choice of where to hold each asset.

Sources and further reading

  1. IRS — Rev. Proc. 2025-32, §4.01 and §4.03 (tax year 2026 rate tables and capital gain thresholds)
  2. IRS — Publication 550 (2025), Investment Income and Expenses: interest income, qualified dividends, capital gain distributions
  3. IRS — Publication 590-B (2025), Distributions from Individual Retirement Arrangements: taxation of traditional and Roth IRA distributions
  4. IRS — Publication 514 (2025), Foreign Tax Credit for Individuals
  5. 26 U.S. Code §199A, Qualified business income: qualified REIT dividends (as amended by P.L. 119-21, July 4, 2025) (Cornell LII)
  6. 26 U.S. Code §103, Interest on state and local bonds (Cornell LII)