Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Taxes · How investment income is taxed

Marginal vs. effective tax rate: which one to use for which decision

How the rate on the next dollar differs from the average rate on all income, worked on 2026 brackets for four incomes, plus the hidden marginal rates of phase-outs.

On this page
  1. How the brackets stack
  2. Worked example: $85,000 of wages
  3. Four incomes, both rates
  4. Which rate answers which question
  5. Where the true marginal rate is higher than the bracket
  6. Married couples and two incomes
  7. Pitfalls
  8. Side by side
  9. Which to use when
  10. How Finabase does it
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. Summary
  13. Check your understanding

Every US tax return has two rates hiding in it. The marginal rate is the rate on the next dollar of income: the bracket the last dollar falls in. The effective rate (also called the average rate) is the total tax divided by income: what the return costs as a share of the whole. For almost everyone the marginal rate is much higher than the effective rate, because the brackets tax the first dollars lightly and only the top slice at the top rate.

Mixing the two causes real mistakes. People turn down raises fearing a higher bracket will shrink their pay, which it cannot. Others value a deduction or a Roth contribution at the wrong rate. This lesson computes both rates on the 2026 federal brackets for four incomes, shows which rate answers which question, and points out the places where the true marginal rate is higher than the bracket says.

How the brackets stack

Federal income tax is progressive. For a single filer in 2026, taxable income is taxed at:

Taxable income, single, 2026 Rate
$0 to $12,400 10%
$12,400 to $50,400 12%
$50,400 to $105,700 22%
$105,700 to $201,775 24%
$201,775 to $256,225 32%
$256,225 to $640,600 35%
Above $640,600 37%

Each rate applies only to the slice of income inside its band. Taxable income is income after deductions; for a wage earner taking the 2026 standard deduction, it is wages minus $16,100. For 2027 the single edges move to $12,800, $52,025, $109,125, $208,325, $264,550 and $661,375, and the standard deduction to $16,600 (Rev. Proc. 2026-35); the examples here stay in 2026. The full schedules for every filing status, and how gains and dividends sit on top of wages, are in Tax brackets for investors: how gains and dividends stack in 2026.

Worked example: $85,000 of wages

Both effective figures are used; the one on gross income is the better measure of the burden, the one on taxable income isolates the rate schedule. The marginal rate is nearly double either.

Single filer, 2026: marginal rate vs average federal income tax on wages 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% $0k $50k $100k $150k $200k $250k $300k $350k $400k Marginal rate on the next dollar Effective rate: tax ÷ wages Wages (standard deduction of $16,100 taken first; no other income)
Federal income tax only, single filer with wages and the 2026 standard deduction, no other income or credits (Rev. Proc. 2025-32). Effective rate = tax ÷ wages. Computed by Finabase.

The staircase is the marginal rate; the curve is the effective rate. The curve always lies below the staircase and never jumps, because crossing a bracket edge changes the rate only on the dollars past it.

Four incomes, both rates

Wages, 2026 Federal income tax Effective (of wages) Marginal
$40,000 $2,620 6.6% 12%
$85,000 $9,870 11.6% 22%
$150,000 $24,734 16.5% 24%
$300,000 $68,134 22.7% 35%

Single filer, standard deduction, no other income or credits. Computed by Finabase.

Even at $300,000, where the marginal rate is 35%, federal income tax takes less than a quarter of wages.

Which rate answers which question

Use the marginal rate for anything that adds or removes income at the edge:

Use the effective rate to describe the overall burden: comparing one year with another, budgeting, or comparing households. It says nothing about what the next dollar costs.

Where the true marginal rate is higher than the bracket

The bracket rate is the statutory marginal rate. Several rules make an extra dollar cost more:

  • Payroll tax. Wages also carry 6.2% Social Security tax (up to the $184,500 wage base in 2026, $192,300 in 2027) and 1.45% Medicare tax, 7.65% in all, paid by the worker; the employer pays the same again. At $85,000 that is $6,503, and the combined marginal rate on a dollar of pay is 29.65% before state tax. Payroll tax does not apply to investment income.
  • Phase-outs. When a credit or deduction shrinks as income rises, each extra dollar costs the bracket rate plus the phase-out. The child tax credit falls by $50 for each $1,000 of income above its threshold, adding 5 points.
  • Social Security taxation. For retirees, each extra dollar of other income can make 50 or 85 cents of benefits taxable, lifting the true marginal rate well above the bracket.
  • The net investment income tax. Above $200,000 of modified AGI for single filers ($250,000 joint), investment income carries an extra 3.8%; see Net investment income tax (NIIT): the 3.8% surtax in depth.
  • Capital gain stacking. Extra ordinary income can push long-term gains from the 0% band into the 15% band, so a dollar of wages also raises the tax on gains.
  • State and local tax. Most states add their own rate on top; see State taxes on investments: gains, dividends, interest and moving.

Married couples and two incomes

Joint filers get brackets twice as wide as single filers through the 32% band ($100,800 tops the 12% bracket for 2026 against $50,400 single), so a second earner's first dollar is taxed at the household's marginal rate, not from zero. A spouse returning to work at $40,000 in a household already at 22% sees that pay taxed at 22% plus payroll tax from the first dollar, even though the couple's effective rate barely moves. Both numbers are correct; they describe different things.

Pitfalls

  • Quoting the bracket as "my tax rate". It overstates what most people pay on average, often by half.
  • Using the effective rate to value a deduction. It understates the saving.
  • Forgetting the other layers. Payroll tax, state tax and phase-outs all add to the true cost of the next dollar.

Side by side

Question Marginal rate Effective rate
Definition Tax on the next dollar Total tax ÷ income
$85,000 wages, 2026 22% (29.65% with payroll tax) 11.6% of wages
Changes at a bracket edge? Jumps Rises smoothly
Use it for Raises, deductions, Roth vs pre-tax, munis Overall burden, year-to-year comparisons

Which to use when

  • Deciding about extra income or a deduction: the marginal rate, including payroll tax and any phase-out in play.
  • Comparing a taxable and a tax-free investment: the marginal rate, federal and state.
  • Describing how much of your income goes to tax: the effective rate, on gross income.
  • Planning retirement withdrawals: both. The marginal rate tells what the next dollar of withdrawal costs; the effective rate tells what a year of withdrawals costs on average.

How Finabase does it

Finabase does not compute anyone's taxes. Its portfolios show realized and unrealized gains for each position and the dividends received, the amounts to which the rates on this page apply, and the Dividends tab on a symbol page lists each payment. The bracket arithmetic on this page is done in the lesson's figure script from the 2026 rate schedules in Rev. Proc. 2025-32.

Frequently asked questions

Will a raise put me in a higher tax bracket and lower my take-home pay?

No. Only the dollars above the bracket edge are taxed at the higher rate. A $1,000 raise at $85,000 of wages in 2026 costs $220 of federal income tax, so take-home pay rises by about $703 after payroll tax.

What is the difference between marginal and effective tax rate?

The marginal rate is the rate on your last dollar of taxable income (22% for a single filer with $68,900 of taxable income in 2026). The effective rate is total tax divided by income (14.3% of taxable income, 11.6% of wages, in that example).

How do I find my effective tax rate?

Divide total federal income tax on your return by your income. Using total income gives a broader measure; using taxable income isolates the brackets. Adding payroll and state taxes gives a fuller picture.

Which rate should I use for tax-loss harvesting?

The marginal rate on the gains the loss offsets: ordinary rates for short-term gains, the 0%, 15% or 20% rate for long-term gains, plus the 3.8% NIIT if it applies.

Summary

The marginal rate is what the next dollar costs; the effective rate is what all income costs on average. A single filer with $85,000 of wages in 2026 pays $9,870 of federal income tax: 22% at the margin, 11.6% of wages overall. Decisions about raises, deductions, Roth contributions and tax-exempt bonds turn on the marginal rate, which payroll tax, phase-outs, Social Security taxation and the NIIT can push above the bracket rate. The effective rate is the right summary of the burden but the wrong tool for any decision at the margin.

Check your understanding

4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. A single filer’s taxable income rises from $105,000 to $106,500 in 2026, crossing the 24% bracket edge at $105,700. What happens to the tax?

    1. All income becomes taxed at 24%
    2. Only the $800 above $105,700 is taxed at 24%; the $700 below it at 22%
    3. Take-home pay falls because of the higher bracket
    Show the answer

    B. Only the $800 above $105,700 is taxed at 24%; the $700 below it at 22% Each rate applies only to the slice inside its band. Crossing an edge changes the rate on the dollars past it, nothing else.

  2. A single filer with $85,000 of wages owes $9,870 of federal income tax in 2026. Which rate tells her what a $2,000 deductible IRA contribution saves?

    1. The effective rate, 11.6%
    2. The marginal rate, 22%: about $440
    3. The payroll tax rate, 7.65%
    Show the answer

    B. The marginal rate, 22%: about $440 A deduction removes income from the top of the stack, so it saves the marginal rate. IRA contributions do not reduce payroll tax.

  3. Why can a retiree’s true marginal rate exceed the bracket rate?

    1. Because retirees pay payroll tax on withdrawals
    2. Because each extra dollar of income can make 50 or 85 cents more of Social Security benefits taxable
    3. Because the standard deduction does not apply after 65
    Show the answer

    B. Because each extra dollar of income can make 50 or 85 cents more of Social Security benefits taxable Provisional income above $25,000 and $34,000 (single) pulls benefits into taxable income, so one dollar of withdrawal can add up to $1.85 of taxable income.

  4. Which question is the effective rate the right tool for?

    1. Whether to accept a bonus
    2. How much of the household’s income went to federal income tax this year
    3. Whether a municipal bond beats a taxable bond
    Show the answer

    B. How much of the household’s income went to federal income tax this year The effective rate summarizes the overall burden. Decisions at the margin use the marginal rate.

Sources and further reading

  1. Internal Revenue Service — Revenue Procedure 2025-32: 2026 tax rate schedules and standard deduction
  2. Internal Revenue Service — Revenue Procedure 2026-35: 2027 tax rate schedules and standard deduction
  3. Internal Revenue Service — Federal income tax rates and brackets
  4. Social Security Administration — 2027 cost-of-living adjustment fact sheet (taxable maximum $184,500 in 2026, $192,300 in 2027)
  5. Internal Revenue Service — Topic no. 751, Social Security and Medicare withholding rates (6.2% and 1.45%)
  6. U.S. Code — 26 U.S.C. 1411: net investment income tax (3.8%)
  7. U.S. Code — 26 U.S.C. 24(b): child tax credit phase-out ($50 per $1,000 above the threshold)
  8. Finabase calculations (tax by income, layer by layer) in the lesson figure script