Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Retirement · Retirement accounts

401(k) vs. 403(b): who offers each, costs and the 15-year catch-up

How a 403(b) differs from a 401(k): employers, the annuity and mutual-fund menu, ERISA, the 15-year catch-up and fees, with 2027 limits and a cost example.

On this page
  1. Who offers which
  2. Limits: shared, with one extra for long service
  3. What the money can be invested in
  4. ERISA and who watches the menu
  5. Worked example: what costs do over a career
  6. Side by side
  7. Which to use when
  8. How Finabase does it
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. Summary
  11. Check your understanding

A 401(k) and a 403(b) do the same job. Both let an employee defer part of each paycheck, pre-tax or Roth, into a retirement account; both share one deferral limit; both can carry an employer match. The difference is mainly who offers them. A 401(k) is the plan of for-profit companies. A 403(b) is the plan of public schools, colleges, hospitals, charities and churches. That history explains most of what still separates them: what the plan can invest in, whether federal pension law watches over it, an extra catch-up for long-serving employees, and, too often, cost.

For a worker the question is rarely "which one should I choose", since the employer decides. The useful questions are what a 403(b) offers that a 401(k) does not, what to check on its menu, and how to combine it with other plans. This lesson answers them with the 2027 limits and a cost example on real numbers.

Who offers which

Employer Plan it can offer
Private for-profit company 401(k)
501(c)(3) charity, private school or hospital 403(b), and a 401(k) too
Public school, college or university 403(b), often with a governmental 457(b)
Church 403(b), including retirement income accounts
State or local government (non-school) Governmental 457(b); 401(k) only if grandfathered

A teacher in a public school district therefore usually sees a 403(b), and often a 457(b) beside it. A nurse at a nonprofit hospital sees a 403(b) or a 401(k). An engineer at a listed company sees a 401(k). The full rules of the 403(b) are in 403(b) plans: annuities, custodial accounts and the 15-year catch-up, and of the 401(k) in 401(k) plans: deferrals, limits, the match and auto-enrollment.

Limits: shared, with one extra for long service

Both plans use the section 402(g) elective deferral limit, and it is per person: a nurse who works at a nonprofit hospital with a 403(b) and moonlights at a company with a 401(k) has one limit across both. The age-based catch-ups are identical.

Most an employee can defer in 2027: 401(k) vs 403(b) with 15 years of service 401(k), or 403(b) without the 15-year rule 403(b) with the 15-year catch-up $25,500 $28,500 Under 50 $34,000 $37,000 50 to 59 $37,250 $40,250 60 to 63 IRS Notice 2026-66 limits. The 15-year rule needs 15 years with a qualifying employer and a plan that offers it.
Maximum employee deferrals for 2027 by age, IRS Notice 2026-66. The 403(b) bars add the 15-year service catch-up of $3,000, which needs 15 years with a qualifying employer and a plan that offers it.

The 403(b) alone can add the 15-year catch-up. An employee with at least 15 years of service at a public school system, hospital, home health agency, health and welfare agency, church or church association may defer up to $3,000 more a year, with a lifetime cap of $15,000, if the plan allows it. The amount is the least of $3,000, $15,000 minus earlier use, and $5,000 times years of service minus all earlier deferrals, so people who deferred heavily in earlier years may have no room. When both catch-ups apply, the IRS counts the excess first as the 15-year catch-up. In 2027 that lifts a 61-year-old teacher with 15 years' service to $40,250, against $37,250 for a 401(k) worker of the same age; in 2026 the figures are $38,750 and $35,750.

The total limit on employee and employer money together is the same section 415(c) figure, $75,000 for 2027, but in a 403(b) it is measured against "includible compensation for the most recent year of service", which matters for someone who stops working mid-career.

What the money can be invested in

A 401(k) is a trust; its trustee may offer almost any investment: mutual funds, collective investment trusts, company stock, a brokerage window. A 403(b) is narrower by statute. Its assets must sit in:

  • annuity contracts issued by insurance companies, under section 403(b)(1), fixed or variable;
  • custodial accounts invested only in mutual funds, under section 403(b)(7); or
  • retirement income accounts of church plans.

So a 403(b) cannot hold individual stocks, and in practice it does not hold the collective investment trusts that many large 401(k) plans use to cut costs. A well-run 403(b) with low-cost index mutual funds is still a cheap place to save; the constraint is about the menu's shape, not its quality.

ERISA and who watches the menu

Most private-sector 401(k) plans are covered by ERISA, the federal pension law. That gives participants a fiduciary, someone legally bound to choose and monitor the investments and fees in their interest, plus reporting on Form 5500 and fee disclosures.

Many 403(b) plans are outside ERISA. Governmental plans (public schools) and church plans are exempt by statute. A nonprofit's plan can also fall outside if it meets a Department of Labor safe harbor (29 CFR 2510.3-2(f)): employee money only, voluntary participation and a hands-off employer. In those plans the employer may simply let several vendors sell to its staff. No one is obliged to remove a high-cost product, and sales agents may be paid by commission.

A 403(b) is also not tested the way a 401(k) is. A 401(k)'s deferrals must pass a nondiscrimination test comparing highly and non-highly paid employees. A 403(b) instead follows the universal availability rule: if any employee can defer, essentially all must be offered the chance.

Worked example: what costs do over a career

Annuity-based 403(b) products can stack a mortality-and-expense charge, administrative fees and sub-account fund expenses, often 1% to 2% a year in total, and some carry surrender charges for leaving early. An index mutual fund in a custodial account can cost a few hundredths of a percent.

The same arithmetic applies to a 401(k) with expensive funds. The point is not that 403(b)s are always dearer, but that the structure lets dear products in more easily, so the menu is worth reading. A variable annuity's fee table is in its prospectus; a mutual fund's expense ratio is on its fact sheet.

Side by side

Feature (2027) 401(k) 403(b)
Employers For-profit companies (and nonprofits) 501(c)(3)s, public schools, churches
Deferral limit $25,500, shared with 403(b) $25,500, shared with 401(k)
Catch-ups $8,500 at 50; $11,750 at 60–63 Same, plus 15-year rule up to $3,000
Investments Any the trustee chooses Annuities or mutual funds only
ERISA Usually yes Often no
Deferral testing ADP nondiscrimination test Universal availability
Loans, hardship, Roth If the plan allows If the plan allows

Rollovers flow freely between them: a 403(b) can be rolled into a 401(k) or an IRA after leaving the job, and the other way round.

Which to use when

The employer picks the plan type, so "which to use" is about what to do inside the one offered.

  • A 403(b) with several vendors: check whether a custodial account with low-cost index funds is among them; it often is, beside the annuity products.
  • 15 or more years at a school, hospital or church: ask whether the plan offers the 15-year catch-up; it adds $3,000 a year for up to five years.
  • A public school or government job with a 457(b) too: the 457(b) limit is separate from the 403(b) limit, so both can be filled; see 457(b) plans: government and nonprofit deferred compensation.
  • Two jobs, one with each plan: the deferral limit is shared. Each employer's 415(c) limit is separate, so employer money in both plans is fine.
  • Leaving the employer: a rollover to an IRA or a new 401(k) can move money out of a high-cost annuity, but check surrender charges first.

How Finabase does it

Finabase does not administer plans. It shows the funds. Most mutual funds available in 403(b) custodial accounts and 401(k) menus have symbol pages with price history, distributions and, where the data feed carries it, the expense ratio, and the comparison tool charts two funds side by side. Variable annuity sub-accounts and collective trusts have no ticker and are not covered. Plan holdings can be mirrored in Portfolio. The limits and the cost example come from the IRS notices in the sources and the lesson's figure script.

Frequently asked questions

Is a 403(b) the same as a 401(k)?

They share the deferral limit, catch-ups, Roth option and tax treatment. They differ in who offers them, what they can invest in (a 403(b) only annuities and mutual funds), ERISA coverage, and the 403(b)'s extra 15-year catch-up.

Can I contribute to both a 401(k) and a 403(b)?

Yes, if you work for employers offering each, but your own deferrals across both share one limit, $25,500 in 2027. Employer contributions are limited per plan.

Why are some 403(b) plans expensive?

Many sell annuity contracts through agents, and plans outside ERISA have no fiduciary required to screen costs. Annuity fees can total 1% to 2% a year. Most plans also offer cheaper mutual-fund custodial accounts.

Can I roll my 403(b) into a 401(k)?

Yes, when you leave the job (and sometimes at 59½ while still employed), if the receiving plan accepts rollovers. An IRA is the other common destination.

Summary

A 401(k) and a 403(b) share the same employee limit ($25,500 in 2027), catch-ups, Roth option and tax rules. A 403(b) is the plan of schools, nonprofits and churches; it can hold only annuities or mutual funds, is often outside ERISA, and can add a 15-year catch-up worth up to $3,000 a year. Costs deserve the most attention: on $10,000 a year for 25 years at 6% before costs, the difference between 0.05% and 1.50% a year is $99,145. Inside whichever plan the employer offers, the menu is the part a worker can act on.

Check your understanding

4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. A nurse defers $15,000 to her hospital’s 403(b) in 2027 and also works part-time at a company with a 401(k). How much more can she defer to the 401(k), if she is under 50?

    1. $25,500, because each plan has its own limit
    2. $10,500, because the deferral limit is shared
    3. Nothing; one person can join only one plan
    Show the answer

    B. $10,500, because the deferral limit is shared The 402(g) limit, $25,500 in 2027, is per person across 401(k), 403(b) and SIMPLE plans. A 457(b) plan is the one workplace plan whose limit is separate.

  2. What can a 403(b) invest in?

    1. Anything a 401(k) can, including individual stocks
    2. Annuity contracts and mutual-fund custodial accounts (and church retirement income accounts)
    3. Only fixed annuities
    Show the answer

    B. Annuity contracts and mutual-fund custodial accounts (and church retirement income accounts) Section 403(b) limits the funding vehicles to annuities under 403(b)(1) and mutual-fund custodial accounts under 403(b)(7), plus church accounts.

  3. Why does it matter that many 403(b) plans are outside ERISA?

    1. Their contributions are not tax-deferred
    2. No fiduciary is required to choose and monitor the investments and fees in participants’ interest
    3. They cannot offer a Roth option
    Show the answer

    B. No fiduciary is required to choose and monitor the investments and fees in participants’ interest ERISA imposes fiduciary duties and disclosures. Governmental, church and safe-harbor nonprofit plans are exempt, so high-cost products can stay on the menu.

  4. On $10,000 a year for 25 years at 6% before costs, how much less does an account charging 1.50% a year end with than one charging 0.05%?

    1. About $3,600, the fees paid
    2. $99,145, about 18% of the low-cost result
    3. Nothing, if the markets are the same
    Show the answer

    B. $99,145, about 18% of the low-cost result Costs compound: they reduce every year’s growth and the growth on that growth. $544,797 against $445,652.

Sources and further reading

  1. Internal Revenue Service — Notice 2026-66, 2027 limits (402(g), catch-ups, 415(c))
  2. Internal Revenue Service — Notice 2025-67, 2026 limits
  3. Internal Revenue Service — Retirement topics: 403(b) contribution limits (15-year rule, ordering of catch-ups)
  4. Internal Revenue Service — 403(b) plan fix-it guide (universal availability of elective deferrals)
  5. Internal Revenue Service — Publication 571 (Tax-Sheltered Annuity Plans, 403(b) plans for employees of public schools and certain tax-exempt organizations)
  6. U.S. Department of Labor — 29 CFR 2510.3-2(f): tax-sheltered annuity programs outside ERISA
  7. U.S. Department of Labor — A look at 401(k) plan fees
  8. Finabase calculations (limits by age, cost example) in the lesson figure script