Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Save for retirement Lesson 4 of 11

Retirement · Planning for retirement

Investing your 401(k): the fund menu, fee disclosures and defaults

How to read a 401(k) investment menu and the DOL fee disclosure, what the default fund rule requires, brokerage windows, company stock limits and 30 years of fee drag.

On this page
  1. The menu: what a plan usually offers
  2. The fee disclosure: what the plan must tell you
  3. The default: when a worker picks nothing
  4. Funds without a ticker: collective investment trusts
  5. Beyond the menu: brokerage windows and managed accounts
  6. Rebalancing inside the plan
  7. Employer stock: the concentration problem
  8. Worked example: 0.05% versus 0.60% for 30 years
  9. Pitfalls and limits
  10. The ways to invest a 401(k), compared
  11. How Finabase does it
  12. Frequently asked questions
  13. Summary
  14. Check your understanding
  15. Exercise

A 401(k) is an account, not an investment. What the money earns depends on what it is put into, and inside a workplace plan that choice is narrower and more structured than in an IRA or a brokerage account. The employer, acting as a fiduciary under federal law, picks a list of funds. The worker chooses among them, or makes no choice and lands in a default. Either way, federal rules decide what the worker is told about each fund, what the plan charges, and where money goes when nobody picks.

This lesson is about that choice. It explains how a plan menu is usually laid out, what the Department of Labor's participant fee disclosure must contain and how to read it, how the default investment works, and three features that sit beside the ordinary funds: brokerage windows, managed accounts and the employer's own stock. It ends with a worked example of what a fee difference of 0.55 percentage points a year does over 30 years. How a 401(k) works as an account, with its limits and match, is covered in 401(k) plans: deferrals, limits, the match and auto-enrollment; this page assumes that.

The menu: what a plan usually offers

The regulation calls each fund on the list a designated investment alternative: an investment the plan's fiduciaries have chosen for participants to direct money into. The list differs from plan to plan, but most menus have the same few layers.

  • An asset-allocation tier. A series of Target-date funds: structure, fees and the 2021 tax surprise, one for each retirement year, and sometimes a few fixed-mix funds. Each is meant to be the whole portfolio on its own.
  • A core tier. Single-asset funds the worker combines: a US stock index fund, perhaps a small-company and an international fund, a bond fund. Many plans offer both an index version and an actively managed version of the main asset classes.
  • A capital-preservation option. A money market fund or a stable-value fund. Stable-value funds hold bonds with insurance-company contracts that smooth the value, and they appear almost only in workplace plans.
  • Sometimes employer stock, in a public company that offers it.
  • Sometimes a brokerage window, which opens a far wider set of investments.

Reading the menu starts with a structural question: is the worker going to use one allocation fund, or build a mix from the core tier? Mixing the two undoes the allocation fund, which is designed to be held alone. A worker who holds a 2055 target-date fund and adds a stock index fund beside it ends up with more in shares than the glide path intended (Glide paths: how a portfolio’s stock share changes with age).

The fee disclosure: what the plan must tell you

Since plan years beginning on or after November 1, 2011, the Department of Labor (DOL) has required plans in which participants direct their own investments to give them a standard set of facts. The rule is 29 CFR 2550.404a-5. It applies to 401(k)s and similar individual-account plans covered by ERISA, the federal law on private-sector plans; governmental plans are outside ERISA.

When it arrives

The disclosure must be given on or before the first day a worker can direct their investments, and "at least annually thereafter", which the rule defines as at least once in any 14-month period. Plans often send it as a single "participant fee disclosure" or "annual notice" document, sometimes posted to the plan website with a paper notice. A change to the plan-level fees must be announced between 30 and 90 days before it takes effect.

What it covers about the plan

  • General information: how and when investment instructions can be given, any limits on them (for example, how often money can be moved), voting rights, the list of designated investment alternatives and investment managers, and a description of any brokerage window.
  • Administrative expenses: fees for plan-wide services such as recordkeeping, legal and accounting that may be charged to accounts and are not already inside a fund's expense ratio, and how they are split, for example pro rata to balances or a flat amount per person.
  • Individual expenses: charges that fall on one participant because of what they did, such as a loan processing fee, a fee for a qualified domestic relations order, investment advice, or a brokerage window.

The quarterly statement

At least once every three months the worker must receive a statement of the dollar amount of administrative and individual fees actually charged to their account in the previous quarter, with a description of the services they paid for. This usually appears on the quarterly account statement. It is the one place where plan costs show as dollars rather than percentages. It does not include the fund expense ratios, which are taken inside each fund's price and never appear as a deduction.

The comparative chart of investments

For each designated investment alternative whose return is not fixed, the disclosure must show, in a format designed to make comparison easy:

Required item What the rule asks for
Type of investment The category, such as money market, balanced, large-cap stock fund or employer stock
Performance Average annual total return over 1, 5 and 10 calendar years (or since inception)
Benchmark Returns of a broad-based market index over the same periods
Total annual operating expenses As a percentage (the expense ratio) and in dollars a year per $1,000 invested
Shareholder-type fees Charges taken directly from the investment, such as redemption or purchase fees, and trading restrictions
Website A specific address with the issuer, objectives, strategies, risks, holdings and turnover
Glossary Terms explained, or a link to a glossary

The chart must also say that fees are only one factor to consider and that their cumulative effect can substantially reduce the growth of an account. The per-$1,000 column makes small percentages concrete: a fund with a 0.05% expense ratio costs $0.50 a year per $1,000, and one at 0.60% costs $6.00. Those look trivial on paper. The worked example below shows what they become over a career.

Reading the chart well means comparing like with like. A stock fund's 10-year return against a bond fund's tells nothing about either. The benchmark column answers the useful question: did this fund, after its costs, keep up with the market it invests in? The cost of a fund and its gap to the benchmark often turn out to be related. Expense ratios and fund costs: what you pay and how it compounds explains how expense ratios are charged.

The default: when a worker picks nothing

Under automatic enrollment, which SECURE 2.0 makes compulsory for most new plans, many workers never make a choice. A second DOL rule, 29 CFR 2550.404c-5, protects plan fiduciaries from liability for the investment results of money they place in a qualified default investment alternative (QDIA) on behalf of a worker who did not choose. A target-date fund is the usual default; Target-date funds: structure, fees and the 2021 tax surprise explains the rule's three kinds of QDIA and how those funds are built.

Three protections for the worker come with it. A notice explaining the default must reach the worker at least 30 days before eligibility or the first default investment (or on that date, if the plan lets new automatic enrollees take their money back), and again before each plan year. The worker can move defaulted money to any other option at least once in any three-month period, as often as people who chose that fund themselves. And in the first 90 days after the first default contribution, moving out or withdrawing it carries no restrictions, fees or surrender charges.

The default is chosen for the plan's workers as a group. It does not know a worker's other savings, a spouse's pension or their tolerance for losses, so being placed in it says nothing about whether it fits that worker.

Funds without a ticker: collective investment trusts

Many large plans offer their target-date and index options as collective investment trusts rather than mutual funds. They are pooled funds run by a bank or trust company for retirement plans only, usually cheaper, and they have no ticker or public price. The fee disclosure still has to show their returns, benchmark and expenses, and the required website address leads to their fact sheet. Target-date funds: structure, fees and the 2021 tax surprise compares the two structures in detail.

Beyond the menu: brokerage windows and managed accounts

Brokerage windows

A brokerage window, or self-directed brokerage account, lets a participant move part of the balance into an account where they can buy a much wider range of funds, ETFs and sometimes individual stocks. The fee rule names it explicitly: the general information must describe any brokerage window, and fees for using one appear among the individual expenses. Investments bought inside a window are not designated investment alternatives, so they do not appear in the comparative chart. The worker has to research their costs and records alone. A window can also carry its own account fee and trading commissions on top of the plan's.

Self-directed choice versus a managed account

Within the menu, a worker can direct their own mix or, where the plan offers it, hand the decision to a managed account service. The provider builds and rebalances an allocation from the plan's own funds, often using the worker's age, balance, salary and, if supplied, outside assets. A managed account is one of the three kinds of QDIA, and some plans use it as their default. It charges an advice fee, usually a percentage of the balance, on top of the funds' expense ratios; under the disclosure rule that fee is an individual expense. The question it raises is whether a personalised allocation is worth its extra yearly cost compared with an allocation fund that costs only its expense ratio, and the answer depends on how much personal information the service actually uses.

Rebalancing inside the plan

Markets move the mix. A portfolio set at 70% shares and 30% bonds drifts toward shares in a rising market and toward bonds in a falling one. Inside a 401(k), selling one fund and buying another is not a taxable event, so rebalancing costs nothing in tax, which is not true of a taxable account. Many recordkeepers offer automatic rebalancing on a schedule the participant picks.

Two limits apply. Some funds have trading restrictions, such as a ban on buying back into a fund within a set number of days after selling, which the disclosure must describe. And rebalancing is unnecessary for money in a target-date or other allocation fund, which rebalances itself. Rebalancing methods: calendar, threshold and what each one costs compares calendar and threshold approaches on real data.

Employer stock: the concentration problem

Some public companies offer their own stock in the plan, and some pay the match in it. Holding the employer's stock ties two risks together: if the company does badly, both the job and the savings can suffer at once. Concentration risk: when one holding dominates a portfolio shows on market data how a single holding can come to dominate a portfolio.

Federal tax law limits how far a plan can lock workers into that position. Section 401(a)(35) of the Internal Revenue Code, added by the Pension Protection Act of 2006, applies to defined contribution plans holding publicly traded employer securities:

  • money from a worker's own deferrals and contributions invested in employer stock must be free to be sold and reinvested elsewhere at any time the rule allows;
  • stock bought with employer contributions must become free to sell once the worker has three years of service;
  • the plan must offer at least three other investment options, each diversified and with materially different risk and return;
  • the plan may limit the timing of such switches to periodic opportunities, but no less often than quarterly, and cannot impose restrictions on employer stock that it does not impose on other assets.

Stand-alone employee stock ownership plans (ESOPs) without 401(k) money, and one-participant plans, are outside the rule.

The Supreme Court addressed the fiduciaries' side in Fifth Third Bancorp v. Dudenhoeffer (decided June 25, 2014). The Court held that fiduciaries of an ESOP enjoy no special "presumption of prudence" when they keep buying or holding company stock; they owe the same duty of prudence as other ERISA fiduciaries, except that they need not diversify the fund's assets. The case concerned Fifth Third's plan, in which participants could put contributions into an ESOP fund invested primarily in the company's stock. The decision changed how such lawsuits are judged; it does not stop a participant from holding as much employer stock as they choose. That choice remains the worker's.

Worked example: 0.05% versus 0.60% for 30 years

Fees are taken from the fund's assets every day, so their cost compounds just as returns do. To see the size, take one contribution path and run it through two funds that differ only in cost.

401(k) balance over 30 years at 0.05% vs 0.60% a year in fees (6% gross return) $0k $200k $400k $600k $800k $1000k $1200k Year 0 Year 5 Year 10 Year 15 Year 20 Year 25 Year 30 Fund costing 0.05% a year Fund costing 0.60% a year Difference $1013k $924k $90k Contributions $9,000 in year 1, rising 3% a year; $428,179 in all Balance, thousands of dollars
Balance of the same contributions in a fund costing 0.05% and one costing 0.60% a year, 6% gross return, 30 years. Computed by Finabase; illustrative.

The gap is small for a long time and large at the end: $3,854 after 10 years, $24,783 after 20 and $89,715 after 30. That is because the fee is a percentage of a balance that keeps growing, and the biggest balances come last.

Gross return Balance at 0.05% Balance at 0.60% Difference Share of the balance
4% $742,057 $681,623 $60,434 8.1%
6% $1,013,254 $923,539 $89,715 8.9%
8% $1,411,034 $1,276,742 $134,291 9.5%

The same contributions put through SPY's actual monthly total returns from November 1996 to October 2026 end at $2,424,136 in the cheaper version and $2,196,377 in the dearer one, a difference of $227,759, or 9.4%. Higher returns make the gap larger in dollars and slightly larger as a share, because the fee compounds on more money.

The example compares cost alone. A fund that charges more can still be worth holding if it buys something the cheaper fund lacks, such as a different asset class. Two funds tracking the same index, however, differ in result by little more than their cost.

Pitfalls and limits

  • The expense ratio is not the whole cost. Plan administrative fees, advice fees and brokerage-window fees are separate. The quarterly statement shows the plan-level ones in dollars; adding them to the fund costs gives the full picture.
  • Past returns in the chart are history. The 1-, 5- and 10-year figures describe what happened, and the disclosure itself must say past performance does not guarantee future results.
  • Doubling up. Holding a target-date fund beside other funds changes its risk. Holding several target-date funds of different years does the same.
  • Defaults stay put. Automatic enrollment puts money in the default and leaves it there. Being defaulted is a fact about the plan's design, not a judgement about the individual.
  • Concentration creeps. A match paid in company stock adds to the position every paycheck, even if the worker never buys any.
  • No advice here. This page explains how the menu and rules work; which funds fit a given worker depends on their whole situation.

The ways to invest a 401(k), compared

Approach Who decides the mix Rebalancing Extra cost beyond fund fees Information source
Default (QDIA), usually target-date The fund's glide path Inside the fund None Fee disclosure, fund fact sheet
Chosen allocation fund The fund manager Inside the fund None Fee disclosure
Own mix from the core tier The worker The worker, or automatic None Fee disclosure
Managed account The provider The provider Advice fee Provider reports
Brokerage window The worker The worker Window fee, commissions The worker's own research

How Finabase does it

Finabase is a research app. It does not hold 401(k) accounts, see a plan's menu or know a reader's fees, and it cannot show collective investment trusts, which have no ticker. What it can show is the mutual funds and ETFs that many menus include or resemble. Each has a symbol page with a chart, distributions on the Dividends tab, and, when the fund-data feed has it, the expense ratio on the Holders tab; the comparison tab puts two funds on one chart. Portfolio can track holdings from a plan beside other accounts, with their dividends.

Frequently asked questions

How should I invest my 401(k)?

That depends on the worker's age, other savings, plans and tolerance for losses, which is why no general page can answer it. What a page can do is show the structure: choose either a single allocation fund or a mix from the core funds, compare costs and benchmarks in the plan's fee disclosure, and keep an eye on concentration in any one holding.

Where do I find my 401(k) fees?

In two documents the Department of Labor requires. The annual participant fee disclosure lists every fund's expense ratio and cost per $1,000 and describes plan-level fees. The quarterly statement shows the dollar amount of administrative and individual fees actually taken from the account in the previous quarter.

What happens if I don't choose investments in my 401(k)?

The money goes into the plan's qualified default investment alternative, usually a target-date fund. The worker gets a notice in advance and can move the money to any other option at least once every three months, and without fees in the first 90 days.

What is a 401(k) brokerage window?

An optional account inside the plan that lets a participant invest beyond the menu, in a wide range of funds and sometimes individual stocks. Its fees must be disclosed, but its investments are not in the plan's comparison chart, so the participant researches them alone.

Can my employer make me keep company stock in my 401(k)?

Not indefinitely, in a plan holding publicly traded employer stock. Under section 401(a)(35), stock bought with the worker's own contributions must be free to sell, and stock from employer contributions must be free to sell after three years of service, with switching allowed at least quarterly.

Summary

Investing a 401(k) means choosing from a list the employer's fiduciaries assembled, or accepting its default. Federal rules make that choice readable: a comparison chart of every option with its 1-, 5- and 10-year returns, a benchmark and its cost per $1,000, a quarterly statement of fees in dollars, a default fund that a worker can leave at least once a quarter, and a right to sell employer stock. Beyond the menu, brokerage windows widen the choice and managed accounts delegate it, each for an extra fee. Cost is the one input known in advance, and on a career's contributions a difference of 0.55 percentage points a year ends about 9% of the final balance apart.

Check your understanding

5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. Where does a 401(k) participant see the plan’s administrative fees as a dollar amount?

    1. In each fund’s expense ratio
    2. In the statement required at least quarterly, which shows the fees actually charged to the account in the previous quarter
    3. Nowhere; plans only disclose percentages
    Show the answer

    B. In the statement required at least quarterly, which shows the fees actually charged to the account in the previous quarter 29 CFR 2550.404a-5 requires a statement at least every three months with the dollar amount of administrative and individual fees charged and the services they paid for. Fund expense ratios are taken inside the funds and do not appear there.

  2. A fund on the comparison chart shows total annual operating expenses of 0.60%. What does the required per-$1,000 column show?

    1. $0.60
    2. $6.00 a year for each $1,000 invested
    3. $60 a year for each $1,000 invested
    Show the answer

    B. $6.00 a year for each $1,000 invested 0.60% of $1,000 is $6.00. The rule requires the cost as a percentage and as dollars per $1,000 so small percentages can be compared concretely.

  3. Why does the gap between the 0.05% and 0.60% funds grow from $3,854 after 10 years to $89,715 after 30?

    1. Because fees rise with age
    2. Because the fee is a percentage of a growing balance, and the money lost to fees also loses its future growth
    3. Because contributions to the dearer fund stop
    Show the answer

    B. Because the fee is a percentage of a growing balance, and the money lost to fees also loses its future growth Both funds get identical contributions. The dearer fund takes 0.55 percentage points more of a balance that keeps growing, and each dollar taken would have compounded too, so most of the gap appears in the last decade.

  4. Investments bought through a 401(k) brokerage window differ from the plan’s menu funds because:

    1. They are not designated investment alternatives, so they are not in the plan’s comparison chart
    2. They are not part of the 401(k) for tax purposes
    3. The employer guarantees them
    Show the answer

    A. They are not designated investment alternatives, so they are not in the plan’s comparison chart The DOL rule excludes brokerage windows from the definition of designated investment alternatives. The plan must describe the window and its fees, but the participant researches what is bought through it.

  5. Under section 401(a)(35), when must stock bought with employer contributions become free to sell in a plan holding publicly traded employer stock?

    1. Never; employer contributions can be locked in company stock
    2. Once the worker has three years of service
    3. Only at retirement
    Show the answer

    B. Once the worker has three years of service Employee deferrals in employer stock must be divestable, and employer-contribution stock must be divestable after three years of service, with at least three diversified alternatives and switching at least quarterly.

Exercise

One task to do in Finabase. Nothing is graded or saved.

Open the comparison of SPY with VOO, two funds that track the S&P 500. Over the longest period shown, how far apart do the two lines end? Each fund’s Overview lists its expense ratio (SPY about 0.09%, VOO 0.03%). Work out each one’s yearly cost on $100,000, then set that gap beside the lesson’s fund A at 0.05% and fund B at 0.60%.

Compare SPY with VOO
What you should find

The lines nearly overlap: funds on the same index differ by little more than cost. About $90 against $30 a year on $100,000 is a gap a ninth the size of $600 against $50, so over the lesson’s 30-year path it would cost roughly a tenth of the $89,715 the 0.55-point gap did.

Sources and further reading

  1. U.S. Department of Labor — 29 CFR 2550.404a-5, Fiduciary requirements for disclosure in participant-directed individual account plans (text via Cornell LII)
  2. U.S. Department of Labor — 29 CFR 2550.404c-5, Fiduciary relief for investments in qualified default investment alternatives (text via Cornell LII)
  3. 26 U.S.C. §401(a)(35), diversification requirements for defined contribution plans holding publicly traded employer securities, added by the Pension Protection Act of 2006, Pub. L. 109-280 §901 (via Cornell LII)
  4. Supreme Court of the United States — Fifth Third Bancorp v. Dudenhoeffer, 573 U.S. 409 (2014), decided June 25, 2014 (via Cornell LII)
  5. Finabase chart data — monthly SPY total returns, November 1996 to October 2026; fee scenarios computed by Finabase