Bonds · Building a bond portfolio
Reinvestment risk: why a bond rarely earns its yield to maturity
See how the rate at which coupons are reinvested changes what a bond actually earns, how much of a long bond’s return is interest on interest, and when rising rates help.
On this page
A bond bought at a 5% yield to maturity does not necessarily earn 5%. It earns 5% only if every coupon, as it arrives, can be put back to work at 5% as well. If rates have fallen, those coupons earn less and the investor ends up with less than the yield promised. That shortfall is reinvestment risk.
It is the mirror image of the risk most bond investors worry about. When rates rise, prices fall but coupons can be reinvested at better rates. When rates fall, prices rise but reinvestment gets worse. Which effect wins depends on how long you hold. This lesson measures both on a ten-year bond, shows how large interest on interest becomes over long periods, and finds the holding period at which the two effects cancel.
Where the assumption hides
Yield to maturity vs current yield vs yield to call: which to use defines yield to maturity as the single rate that discounts all of a bond's payments to its price. The same statement run forward says: invest the price at that rate, compounding every half-year, and you end with exactly what the bond's payments would grow to, if each payment were reinvested at that rate until maturity.
A bond does not reinvest anything. It hands you cash. What you do with the cash, and at what rate, is outside the bond's terms. So a bond's yield to maturity is fully earned only in a world where rates never change.
What a 5% bond actually earns
Take $10,000 of a ten-year bond with a 5% coupon, bought at par. It pays $250 every six months, twenty times, and $10,000 at the end. Suppose every coupon is reinvested at one rate until maturity. The ending amount, and the compound return it represents, depend on that rate.
| Coupons reinvested at | Ending value of $10,000 | Realized yield |
|---|---|---|
| 0% (spent or left idle) | $15,000 | 4.10% |
| 2% | $15,505 | 4.43% |
| 3% | $15,781 | 4.61% |
| 4% | $16,074 | 4.80% |
| 5% | $16,386 | 5.00% |
| 6% | $16,718 | 5.21% |
| 7% | $17,070 | 5.42% |
| 8% | $17,445 | 5.64% |
The first row is the case of someone who spends the coupons. The bond did everything it promised, and yet the money invested grew at 4.10% a year, not 5%. There is nothing wrong with spending coupons. It only means that "5% yield to maturity" overstated how fast that person's wealth would compound.
The spread across the table is about one and a half points, from 4.10% to 5.64%. That is the size of reinvestment risk for a ten-year par bond.
Interest on interest
The effect grows quickly with time, because early coupons have longer to compound.
| Bond | Coupons received | Interest on reinvested coupons | Share of all interest |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5-year | $2,500 | $301 | 10.7% |
| 10-year | $5,000 | $1,386 | 21.7% |
| 30-year | $15,000 | $18,998 | 55.9% |
On a thirty-year bond, more than half of the eventual interest is not paid by the issuer at all. It is earned by the investor, on coupons, at rates nobody knows when the bond is bought. If those coupons earn 3% in place of 5%, the thirty-year bond's realized yield is 4.13%; at 7% it is 6.01%. The "5%" on the label covers a range of nearly two points.
This observation, made famous by Sidney Homer and Martin Leibowitz in Inside the Yield Book in 1972, changed how professionals read yields: a long bond's yield to maturity is mostly a statement about future reinvestment rates.
Two risks that offset
So far the bond was held to maturity, so its price did not matter. Now let the holder sell early, and let rates change.
Suppose yields move once, right after purchase, and stay at the new level. Two things happen to the holder of a ten-year 5% bond.
- Price effect. If yields rise to 7% the bond's price falls at once. If they fall to 3% it rises.
- Reinvestment effect. At 7%, each coupon earns more from then on. At 3%, less.
The total, coupons plus interest on them plus the sale price of the bond, depends on when you stop the clock.
| Yields move to | Wealth at year 2 | Year 5 | Year 8 | Year 10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3% | $12,436 | $13,598 | $14,869 | $15,781 |
| 5% (no change) | $11,038 | $12,801 | $14,845 | $16,386 |
| 7% | $9,844 | $12,101 | $14,875 | $17,070 |
Read down each column.
At two years, the price effect dominates. Falling rates are good news ($12,436) and rising rates are bad ($9,844, less than was invested).
At ten years, the reinvestment effect is all that is left. The bond matures at par in every case, so the only difference is what the coupons earned. Now rising rates are the good news ($17,070) and falling rates the bad ($15,781).
At eight years, the three results are almost identical: $14,869, $14,845 and $14,875. The loss in price from higher rates has been made back by better reinvestment, and the gain in price from lower rates has been used up by worse reinvestment.
That crossover is not a coincidence. This bond's Macaulay duration is 7.99 years. Duration, usually presented as a measure of price sensitivity, is also the holding period at which price risk and reinvestment risk cancel. An investor who needs a known sum on a known date can come close to locking it in by holding bonds whose duration equals the time remaining, a technique called immunization, first set out by the actuary Frank Redington in 1952. Bond duration and convexity: measuring interest-rate risk covers duration itself.
The practical reading:
- If your horizon is shorter than the bond's duration, you are mainly exposed to price risk. Rising rates hurt you.
- If your horizon is longer than its duration, you are mainly exposed to reinvestment risk. Falling rates hurt you.
A retiree living on bond income for thirty years and a trader holding the same bond for a month have opposite interests in the direction of rates.
Where reinvestment risk is highest
| Holding | Why |
|---|---|
| Treasury bills, money market funds, short CDs | The whole principal is reinvested within months |
| Callable bonds | Called when rates fall, returning principal at the worst moment |
| Mortgage-backed securities | Homeowners refinance when rates fall, so principal comes back early |
| High-coupon and premium bonds | More of the return arrives early as coupons |
| Floating-rate notes | The coupon itself resets to the lower rate |
And where it is lowest:
| Holding | Why |
|---|---|
| Zero-coupon bonds held to maturity | No coupons to reinvest: the realized yield equals the purchase yield |
| Long, low-coupon, non-callable bonds | Little cash arrives early |
| A ladder | Only one rung is reinvested at a time (Bond ladders: how to build one and what it does when rates change) |
The short-term trap. Cash feels safe because its price never falls. Its income is the most exposed of all. The 26-week bill auctioned on November 16, 2026 locked in a 4.467% investment rate for half a year and for not one day longer. Someone who needs steady income for a decade and holds only bills has swapped price risk for a larger income risk. Bond ladders: how to build one and what it does when rates change shows the same $100,000 losing 45% of its income in one year in bills and 7% in a five-year ladder after the same fall in rates.
Calls make it worse. A bond with a 6.5% coupon called after three years stops paying 6.5% exactly when new bonds pay much less. The investor gets their money back and no way to earn the old rate on it. This is why callable bonds must offer a higher yield than non-callable ones, and why yield to worst is the figure to read.
Managing it
- Match maturities to needs. Money required on a known date is best held in something that matures then, or whose duration matches the date.
- Ladder. Spreading maturities spreads reinvestment dates.
- Prefer non-callable bonds where income certainty matters, or demand enough extra yield to accept the call.
- Use zero-coupon bonds for a single distant goal: the return is fixed on day one (Zero-coupon bonds: pricing, STRIPS, rate risk and phantom income). The price for that certainty is the highest price volatility of any bond along the way, and yearly tax on interest not yet received in a taxable account.
- Know what a fund does with interest. A bond fund pays its income out as distributions. Reinvesting them buys shares at the current yield, so a fund holder faces the same reinvestment rates as everyone else.
Pitfalls
- Reading yield to maturity as the growth rate of your money. It is, only with reinvestment at the same rate.
- Thinking short maturities remove interest-rate risk. They move it from price to income.
- Cheering falling rates when your horizon is long and you are still adding money.
- Ignoring calls. A callable bond's coupon stream is the issuer's to cut short.
- Assuming one shift in rates. The examples move rates once. Real rates wander, and the matching of duration to horizon has to be redone as time passes.
How Finabase does it
- The Treasury page shows the rates at which coupons and maturing bills can be reinvested today. The short end, such as the 2-year yield, is the relevant comparison for reinvesting over the next few years.
- A bond fund's income history shows reinvestment rates at work. The AGG dividends tab lists its monthly distributions, which follow, with a lag of years, the yields at which the fund has been able to replace maturing bonds.
All tables in this lesson were computed by Finabase: semiannual coupons and compounding, one reinvestment rate applied to every coupon, no taxes or trading costs.
Frequently asked questions
What is reinvestment risk in simple terms?
It is the risk that the cash a bond pays you, coupons and returned principal, will have to be reinvested at lower rates than the bond itself was earning.
Which bonds have the most reinvestment risk?
Short-term securities, callable bonds, mortgage-backed securities and bonds with high coupons: all of them return a lot of cash early.
Do zero-coupon bonds have reinvestment risk?
Not if held to maturity. There are no coupons to reinvest, so the yield at purchase is the yield earned.
Is reinvestment risk the opposite of interest-rate risk?
It is the other half of it. Rising rates lower prices and improve reinvestment; falling rates do the reverse. The two cancel when the holding period equals the bond's duration.
Does it matter if I spend my coupons?
Your bond still pays everything it promised. Your invested money, though, compounds more slowly than the yield to maturity suggests: about 4.1% a year on a ten-year 5% bond.
Summary
Yield to maturity assumes coupons are reinvested at the same yield. When they are not, the realized return differs: a ten-year 5% bond earns between 4.1% and 5.6% depending on what its coupons earn, and on a thirty-year bond more than half the interest comes from reinvestment. Reinvestment risk and price risk offset each other and cancel at a holding period equal to the bond's duration, about eight years in the example. Short-term and callable holdings carry the most reinvestment risk, zero-coupon bonds none, and laddering or matching duration to your horizon are the standard ways to control it.
Check your understanding
5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
You buy a 10-year bond at par with a 5% yield to maturity and spend every coupon. At what rate does the money you invested compound over the ten years?
- Exactly 5%
- Less than 5%, about 4.1%
- More than 5%
Show the answer
B. Less than 5%, about 4.1% Yield to maturity assumes coupons are reinvested at the same yield. With coupons spent, $10,000 becomes $15,000 of total receipts, a compound rate of about 4.1%.
Rates rise two points just after you buy a 10-year bond whose duration is 8 years. If you will hold for the full 10 years, the rise is
- Bad, because the price fell
- Good, because the bond matures at par anyway and every coupon is reinvested at higher rates
- Irrelevant
Show the answer
B. Good, because the bond matures at par anyway and every coupon is reinvested at higher rates With a horizon longer than the bond’s duration, reinvestment outweighs price. Held to maturity, the price drop is never realized and the coupons earn more.
Which holding carries the most reinvestment risk for someone who needs steady income for 15 years?
- A 15-year zero-coupon Treasury
- A 15-year non-callable Treasury bond
- Six-month Treasury bills rolled over
Show the answer
C. Six-month Treasury bills rolled over With bills, the entire principal is reinvested twice a year at whatever rate then applies. The zero has no reinvestment at all, and the bond only reinvests its coupons.
On a 30-year 5% bond with coupons reinvested at 5%, roughly what share of the total interest is interest earned on reinvested coupons?
- About 10%
- About 25%
- More than half
Show the answer
C. More than half Coupons total $15,000 on $10,000 of par, and reinvesting them at 5% earns about $19,000 more: 56% of all the interest. Long-bond yields are mostly statements about reinvestment.
Why does a callable bond increase reinvestment risk?
- The issuer repays early when rates have fallen, so the holder must reinvest the principal at lower rates
- Callable bonds pay no coupons
- A call lowers the par amount repaid
Show the answer
A. The issuer repays early when rates have fallen, so the holder must reinvest the principal at lower rates Issuers call when they can refinance more cheaply. That is exactly when the holder’s alternatives pay less.
Sources and further reading
- FINRA — Bonds: reinvestment risk and call risk
- Sidney Homer and Martin L. Leibowitz, Inside the Yield Book (Prentice-Hall, 1972) — interest on interest and realized compound yield
- F. M. Redington, “Review of the Principles of Life-Office Valuations,” Journal of the Institute of Actuaries, vol. 78 (1952) — immunization
- TreasuryDirect — auction results, 26-week bill of November 16, 2026 (CUSIP 912797XD4)
