Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Bonds · Credit risk

Investment grade vs. high yield bonds: default odds by rating

How often BBB, BB, B and CCC companies have defaulted since 1981, what a default costs per year after recovery, and when the extra yield of junk bonds pays for it.

On this page
  1. The rating scale and the line
  2. How often each rating defaulted
  3. How bad the bad years were
  4. Worked example: what defaults cost per year
  5. Investment grade vs. high yield at a glance
  6. Which to use when
  7. Pitfalls
  8. How Finabase does it
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. Summary
  11. Check your understanding

Every rated corporate bond falls on one side of a single line. Bonds rated BBB− or higher by S&P Global Ratings and Fitch (Baa3 or higher by Moody's) are investment grade. Everything below is high yield, also called speculative grade or, less politely, junk. The line was drawn by convention, but rules have made it real: many pension funds, insurers and bond funds may hold only investment grade, so crossing the line changes who can own a bond.

This page compares the two sides with the most useful data there is: S&P's record of what happened to every company it has rated since 1981. It shows how often each rating defaulted, how bad the worst years were, and what the defaults cost per year once you account for what bondholders got back.

The rating scale and the line

S&P / Fitch Moody's Side of the line In plain words
AAA, AA Aaa, Aa Investment grade Very strong capacity to pay
A A Investment grade Strong, somewhat sensitive to bad times
BBB Baa Investment grade Adequate; the lowest rung above the line
BB Ba High yield Pays now, exposed to setbacks
B B High yield More vulnerable; depends on good times
CCC and below Caa and below High yield Default a real possibility

Ratings come from firms registered with the SEC as nationally recognized statistical rating organizations. A rating is an opinion of the chance of default, not a price or a recommendation, and ratings change. Credit ratings and credit spreads: how bond risk is priced explains how they are set; this page uses them as the agencies' own record lets us test them.

How often each rating defaulted

Share of rated companies that defaulted within 5 and 10 years, by rating (1981–2024) Within 5 years Within 10 years 0.34% 0.67% AAA 0.28% 0.65% AA 0.39% 1.0% A 1.4% 2.9% BBB 5.8% 10.4% BB 15.6% 22.0% B 46.5% 50.4% CCC/C Global corporate average cumulative default rates. S&P Global Ratings 2024 default study, Table 24.
Share of companies with each rating at the start that defaulted within 5 and 10 years, averaged over every yearly group from 1981 to 2024. Global, issuer-weighted. S&P Global Ratings 2024 default study, Table 24.

S&P takes every company with a given rating at the start of each year, follows it, and averages the results across all the years since 1981. The chart shows the result at 5 and 10 years. Three things stand out:

  1. The ratings rank risk well. Each step down the scale defaults more often than the one above, with one small exception at the very top, where the numbers are too small to separate AAA from AA.
  2. The line is a cliff. BBB companies defaulted within 10 years 2.86% of the time; BB, one notch group lower, 10.44%. Crossing the line multiplies the risk by about 3.7.
  3. CCC is different in kind. Half of CCC/C companies defaulted within ten years, most of them in the first few. At that level a bond is a bet on whether the company survives.

How bad the bad years were

Default rate in selected years: investment grade vs speculative grade (global, S&P) Investment grade Speculative grade (high yield) 0.23% 9.7% 2001 0.41% 9.3% 2002 0.42% 3.7% 2008 0.33% 9.9% 2009 0.00% 5.5% 2020 0.00% 1.7% 2021 0.00% 1.9% 2022 0.06% 3.7% 2023 0.03% 3.9% 2024 Issuer-weighted share of rated companies that defaulted in the year. S&P Global Ratings, Table 1.
Share of rated companies that defaulted during the year, global. S&P Global Ratings 2024 default study, Table 1.

Averages hide when defaults happen. They come in waves after recessions and credit booms. In 2001 and 2002, after the dot-com bust, more than 9% of speculative-grade companies defaulted each year. In 2009 it was 9.89%. Even in those years, investment-grade default rates stayed below half a percent. In 2020 not one investment-grade company rated by S&P defaulted, while 5.54% of speculative-grade ones did. In 2024 the speculative-grade rate was 3.94% globally and 5.1% in the United States, and 59.3% of all defaults were distressed exchanges: deals in which bondholders accept less than they were promised to keep the company out of bankruptcy.

Worked example: what defaults cost per year

A default does not wipe out a bond. Holders usually recover part of their money in a restructuring or bankruptcy, depending on where the bond sits in line (Bond seniority and covenants: who gets paid first in a default). Assume a 40% recovery, a round figure often used for senior unsecured bonds (actual recoveries vary widely; see Bond default and recovery: what bondholders get back, and how often).

Rating Defaulted within 10 years Per year Yearly loss at 40% recovery
BBB 2.86% 0.29% 0.17%
BB 10.44% 1.10% 0.66%
B 22.02% 2.46% 1.47%

Now put a portfolio behind it. $100,000 split equally across 50 B-rated bonds, $2,000 each. If the group behaves like S&P's average B-rated company, about 11 of the 50 issuers default within ten years. At 40% recovery each default loses $1,200, about $13,200 in all, roughly 1.3% a year of the starting $100,000 (the 1.47% in the table is measured on the bonds still standing each year). A BBB portfolio of the same size would expect one or two defaults and about $1,700 of losses.

Compare that with the yield. The 10-year Treasury auctioned on November 10, 2026 yielded 5.02%. Suppose a B-rated bond yields 4 points more, 9.02% (an illustrative spread; actual ones move a lot). After 1.47% of expected default losses it nets about 7.5%, still 2.5 points over the Treasury. That surplus is what the market pays for bearing defaults in waves, for bonds that are harder to sell in a panic, and for the chance that this decade is worse than the average. In a year like 2009, losses for one year alone can wipe out several years of surplus.

Investment grade vs. high yield at a glance

Feature Investment grade (BBB− and up) High yield (BB+ and below)
10-year default rate 1.69% (1981–2024 average) 19.15%
Worst year in the table 0.42% (2008) 9.89% (2009)
What moves the price Mostly interest rates Mostly defaults and the economy
Typical behavior in a crash Falls a little or holds Falls with stocks
Covenants Few More, to protect lenders
Who may own it Almost every bond investor Investors and funds allowed to hold junk

Which to use when

  • The bond is there to steady a portfolio: investment grade, or Treasuries. High yield falls in the same months as stocks and does little to offset them.
  • The goal is income and you can hold through a bad cycle: high yield can pay its expected losses and more, but only in a diversified fund or a large spread of issuers. With a handful of B-rated bonds, a single default can erase years of extra income.
  • You need the money on a fixed date: investment grade held to maturity, so defaults are unlikely to break the plan.
  • Taxes matter: high-yield income is mostly ordinary interest, taxed at your full rate, which takes a larger bite out of the extra yield than the rate on qualified dividends would. Holding it in a tax-advantaged account changes that.
  • The yield looks too good: it usually is. A yield far above other B-rated bonds often means the market thinks the rating is out of date.

Pitfalls

  • Treating the rating as permanent. Companies are upgraded and downgraded. A BBB company cut to BB, a "fallen angel", may be sold by investment-grade funds at the same moment, pushing its price below what the change in risk justifies.
  • Using averages as a forecast. The 1981–2024 averages blend booms and busts. A portfolio bought just before a recession will see more defaults than average.
  • Ignoring calls. Most high-yield bonds can be called, so the upside is capped when the company does well while the downside stays open. See Callable bonds: call schedules, price compression and yield to worst.
  • Confusing a fund's price with its return. High-yield fund prices tend to drift down over time because some holdings default; the monthly income is most of the return.

How Finabase does it

Finabase does not list individual bonds or ratings. It covers both sides through funds. The symbol pages of HYG (high yield) and LQD (investment grade) chart each fund's price, and their Dividends & splits tab, for example HYG's, lists the monthly income that the price chart leaves out. The comparison view draws the two on one chart from any start date. The two figures on this page are ours, drawn from S&P's published default study.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between investment-grade and high-yield bonds?

A rating. Bonds rated BBB− or higher by S&P and Fitch, or Baa3 or higher by Moody's, are investment grade; anything lower is high yield. Behind the label is a large gap in risk: on S&P's 1981–2024 averages, 1.69% of investment-grade companies defaulted within 10 years against 19.15% of speculative-grade ones.

Are junk bonds a bad investment?

Not necessarily. Their higher yields have historically more than covered average default losses, but the losses come in waves, they fall with stocks, and the surplus depends on owning many issuers.

What does BBB mean for a bond?

It is the lowest investment-grade rating. BBB companies defaulted within 10 years 2.86% of the time on S&P's averages, more than A-rated companies (1.03%) but far fewer than BB (10.44%).

Why do investment-grade and high-yield bonds react differently to the economy?

Investment-grade prices mostly track interest rates, because defaults are rare. High-yield prices mostly track the chance of default, which rises in recessions, so they move more like stocks.

Summary

The line between investment grade and high yield sits between BBB− and BB+, and the default record shows why it matters. Since 1981, 1.69% of investment-grade companies defaulted within ten years against 19.15% of speculative-grade ones; within high yield the odds climb from 10.44% for BB to more than half for CCC. After an assumed 40% recovery, that costs about 0.17% a year on BBB debt and 1.47% on B. High-yield spreads have usually paid for those losses with something left over, but defaults arrive in waves, as in 2001–02 and 2009, and high yield falls when stocks do. Investment grade is a ballast asset; high yield is an income asset with equity-like risk, best held in numbers.

Check your understanding

4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. On S&P's 1981–2024 averages, roughly how many times more often did BB companies default within 10 years than BBB companies?

    1. About the same
    2. About 3.7 times (10.44% against 2.86%)
    3. About 50 times
    Show the answer

    B. About 3.7 times (10.44% against 2.86%) BBB is the lowest investment-grade rating and BB the highest speculative-grade one. One step across the line multiplies the 10-year default rate by about 3.7.

  2. A B-rated portfolio expects about 2.46% of issuers to default each year, with 40% recovery. What yearly loss should its extra yield cover first?

    1. About 2.46%
    2. About 1.47%
    3. About 0.98%
    Show the answer

    B. About 1.47% Expected loss = default rate × (1 − recovery) = 2.46% × 0.6 ≈ 1.47% a year. Only yield above that pays for the risk of defaults coming in waves.

  3. Why is a long-run average default rate a weak forecast for a high-yield fund bought today?

    1. Because defaults arrive in waves, such as 9.89% of speculative-grade companies in 2009 alone
    2. Because rating agencies stopped rating high-yield bonds
    3. Because high-yield bonds cannot default in their first year
    Show the answer

    A. Because defaults arrive in waves, such as 9.89% of speculative-grade companies in 2009 alone The averages blend good and bad years. A portfolio bought before a recession can see several years of average losses in one.

  4. A company is downgraded from BBB− to BB+. Why can its bond price fall more than the change in default risk alone suggests?

    1. Its coupon is cut automatically
    2. Funds limited to investment grade may have to sell it at the same time
    3. It stops paying interest until the rating is restored
    Show the answer

    B. Funds limited to investment grade may have to sell it at the same time A "fallen angel" leaves the investment-grade universe, and forced selling by funds and insurers can push the price below fair value for a while.

Sources and further reading

  1. S&P Global Ratings — 2024 Annual Global Corporate Default and Rating Transition Study (March 27, 2025), Table 1 (annual default rates) and Table 24 (average cumulative default rates, 1981–2024)
  2. SEC — Current nationally recognized statistical rating organizations (NRSROs)
  3. SEC Investor.gov — What are high-yield corporate bonds? (investor bulletin)
  4. FINRA — Corporate bonds: ratings, call risk and liquidity
  5. TreasuryDirect — Auction results, 10-year note 91282CRX1 (auctioned November 10, 2026)