Bonds · Credit risk
Bond seniority and covenants: who gets paid first in a default
Rank a company’s debt from secured to common stock, compute recoveries down the stack in a bankruptcy, and learn which indenture covenants protect bondholders.
On this page
Two bonds from the same company can have very different risks. If the company fails, its lenders are not paid in the order they lent, or in proportion to what they are owed. They are paid in the order set by their contracts and by bankruptcy law. A secured lender may be repaid in full while a subordinated bondholder of the same company gets nothing.
Where a bond stands in that line is its seniority. The promises the company makes to its bondholders while the bond is outstanding are its covenants. This lesson lays out the order of claims, computes who recovers what in an illustrative bankruptcy at three company values, shows why a holding company's bonds can rank behind an operating company's, and explains the covenants you will find in an indenture and where to read them.
The order of claims
From first paid to last:
| Rank | Claim | What backs it |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Secured debt | A lien on specific assets (collateral) |
| 2 | Senior unsecured debt | The company's general credit |
| 3 | Subordinated debt | General credit, contractually behind senior debt |
| 4 | Preferred stock | Equity with a preference over common |
| 5 | Common stock | Whatever is left |
Secured debt has a lien on collateral: plant, receivables, sometimes nearly everything the company owns. Under 11 U.S.C. § 506(a), a secured claim is secured only up to the value of the collateral. Any shortfall becomes an unsecured claim and joins the next class.
Senior unsecured bonds have no collateral but rank ahead of anything that agrees to be junior to them. Many investment-grade corporate bonds are senior unsecured.
Subordinated bonds, see subordinated debt, agree in their indenture to be paid after senior debt. Section 510(a) of the Bankruptcy Code enforces such agreements in bankruptcy to the same extent as outside it.
Ahead of all of these, the law gives priority to certain claims, such as the administrative expenses of the bankruptcy case itself (11 U.S.C. § 507). The example below leaves them out to keep the arithmetic clear.
The absolute priority rule
In a Chapter 11 reorganization, a plan can be confirmed over the objection of a class of creditors only if it is "fair and equitable" to that class. Section 1129(b)(2) of the Bankruptcy Code defines that, for unsecured creditors, as either full payment of their claims or no recovery at all for any class junior to them. That is the absolute priority rule: value flows down the stack, filling each class before the next gets anything.
In practice, classes negotiate. Junior classes sometimes receive something to win their votes, which they can do only if the seniors agree. The rule sets each class's bargaining position.
A recovery waterfall
Take an illustrative company that files for bankruptcy with this capital structure, in millions of dollars: a $400 million secured loan, $500 million of senior notes, $200 million of subordinated notes and $100 million of preferred stock. That is $1,200 million of claims ahead of the common stock. Its value as a going concern, to be shared out, could be $700 million, $1,000 million or $1,300 million.
| Class | Claim | At $700m | At $1,000m | At $1,300m |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Secured loan | $400m | $400m (100%) | $400m (100%) | $400m (100%) |
| Senior notes | $500m | $300m (60%) | $500m (100%) | $500m (100%) |
| Subordinated notes | $200m | $0 (0%) | $100m (50%) | $200m (100%) |
| Preferred stock | $100m | $0 (0%) | $0 (0%) | $100m (100%) |
| Common stock | — | $0 | $0 | $100m |
Three lessons from the table:
- The fulcrum class. At each value, one class is partly paid: the senior notes at $700 million, the subordinated notes at $1,000 million. In a reorganization that class often receives much of the new company's equity in exchange for its claims.
- Junior claims swing the most. A $300 million change in value moves the senior notes from 60% to 100%, but the subordinated notes from 0% to 50%. That is why subordinated bonds pay higher yields than senior bonds of the same issuer.
- Equity is last. Shareholders get something only after $1,200 million of claims are paid.
The recovery rate a bond market uses for pricing is this percentage, estimated before the fact. Credit ratings and credit spreads: how bond risk is priced covers how the expected loss, default probability times one minus recovery, drives the spread.
Structural subordination
Seniority is set within one legal entity. Many companies are groups: a holding company (holdco) that owns the shares of an operating company (opco), which owns the assets and earns the cash. If the holdco borrows, its creditors' only claim is on the holdco's assets, which are the opco's shares. The opco's own creditors are paid out of the opco's assets first.
Take an opco with $400 million of its own notes, owned by a holdco with $300 million of notes.
| Opco value | Opco notes recover | Holdco notes recover |
|---|---|---|
| $300m | 75% | 0% |
| $500m | 100% | 33.3% |
| $700m | 100% | 100% |
Both sets of notes may be called "senior unsecured". The holdco notes are still behind every creditor of the opco, including its trade suppliers. Guarantees from the opco to the holdco's lenders, where they exist, are the usual fix. Reading which entity issued a bond, and which subsidiaries guarantee it, is part of reading its seniority.
Indentures and trustees
A bond's terms are set in its indenture, the contract between the issuer and a trustee acting for the bondholders. The SEC explains that the Trust Indenture Act of 1939 applies to debt securities offered for public sale, and that such debt may not be offered to the public unless the indenture meets the Act's standards.
Among those standards:
- After a default, the trustee must use the care and skill of a prudent person in the conduct of their own affairs (15 U.S.C. § 77ooo, section 315 of the Act).
- A holder's right to receive principal and interest when due, and to sue for it, cannot be impaired without that holder's consent (15 U.S.C. § 77ppp, section 316(b)).
Section 316(a) also lets holders of a majority of the bonds direct the trustee and waive past defaults. Bondholders therefore act mostly as a group, through the trustee.
Covenants
Covenants come in two families.
- Affirmative covenants: things the issuer must do. Pay interest and principal, file reports, maintain its corporate existence, keep insurance.
- Negative covenants: things the issuer may not do, or may do only within limits.
Negative covenants are where the protection lies. Common ones:
| Covenant | What it limits |
|---|---|
| Limitation on liens | Pledging assets to other lenders (a negative pledge) |
| Limitation on debt | New borrowing, often unless a ratio test is met |
| Restricted payments | Dividends, share buybacks and junior debt repayments |
| Asset sales | Selling assets without using the cash to repay debt or reinvest |
| Mergers | Combining or selling substantially all assets unless the buyer assumes the bonds |
| Change of control | Gives holders a right to sell back, often at 101% of principal |
Covenants are also incurrence or maintenance tests. An incurrence test applies only when the company takes an action, such as borrowing more: it may add debt only if, say, its leverage ratio after the new debt stays under a limit. A maintenance test must be met every quarter whatever the company does. Bonds generally use incurrence tests; bank loans more often use maintenance tests, which give lenders an earlier warning.
A real example. The indenture for Citizens Communications' 7.125% senior notes due 2019, filed with the SEC in March 2007, has a typical investment-grade set: reports to holders and the SEC (section 4.06), a limit on subsidiary debt (4.08), a limit on liens (4.09), a repurchase offer upon a change of control triggering event at 101% of principal plus accrued interest (4.10), and a limit on mergers and asset sales (5.01). It has no restricted-payments covenant, which is common in investment-grade bonds and rare in high-yield ones.
What a 101% put is worth depends on the price. If a takeover is announced and the bonds fall to 92 because the buyer will add debt, a holder who can put the bonds back at 101 gains 9.8% on that price. If the bonds trade above 101, the put is worth nothing.
Where to find them
The indenture, and supplemental indentures for each series of notes, are filed on the SEC's EDGAR system, usually as exhibit 4 to a registration statement or a current report. Search EDGAR by company name, then look for "indenture" in the exhibit index. The prospectus supplement for a bond summarizes its covenants under "Description of the notes".
Pitfalls
- Assuming "senior" means safe. Senior to what, and at which entity? A senior holdco note can rank behind all opco debt.
- Ignoring the secured debt above you. Every dollar of secured debt reduces what senior unsecured holders can recover.
- Reading ratings without the indenture. Ratings reflect seniority, but covenants can be loosened by holder votes or removed when a bond is upgraded.
- Treating the 101% put as protection against all leveraged buyouts. It applies only when the indenture's definition of a change of control is met.
- Expecting strict priority every time. Negotiated plans can give junior classes some value if seniors agree.
How Finabase does it
Finabase does not show indentures or recovery estimates for individual bonds.
- HYG, a high-yield bond fund, holds the bonds where seniority and covenants matter most. The comparison tab sets the investment-grade fund LQD beside it, so you can see how differently the two moved in past credit scares.
- A company's financials tab, shown here for Apple, has its balance sheet, the starting point for sizing the debt ahead of any bond.
The recoveries in this lesson are for an illustrative company and were computed by Finabase: strict absolute priority, the secured claim fully covered by its collateral, no administrative claims, costs or negotiated deviations.
Frequently asked questions
Who gets paid first when a company goes bankrupt?
Secured creditors, up to the value of their collateral, after certain priority claims such as the costs of the case. Then senior unsecured creditors, then subordinated creditors, then preferred and finally common shareholders.
What is the absolute priority rule?
The Chapter 11 standard, in 11 U.S.C. § 1129(b), that a plan forced on an objecting class of unsecured creditors must either pay them in full or give nothing to anyone junior to them.
What is structural subordination?
The position of a holding company's creditors behind its subsidiaries' creditors. They are paid only from what is left in the subsidiaries after the subsidiaries' own creditors.
What is a bond covenant?
A promise in the indenture: to do something, such as file reports, or not to do something, such as pledge assets to other lenders or pay dividends beyond a limit.
What is a change-of-control put?
A right for bondholders to sell their bonds back to the issuer, usually at 101% of principal plus accrued interest, if the company is taken over in the way the indenture defines.
Summary
Seniority decides who is paid first. Secured debt is paid from its collateral, then senior unsecured, subordinated, preferred and common, each in full before the next under the absolute priority rule of 11 U.S.C. § 1129(b). In the example, a company worth $700 million pays senior notes 60% and subordinated notes nothing; at $1,000 million, subordinated notes recover 50%. Holding-company bonds sit behind all operating-company creditors. Covenants, written in the indenture that the Trust Indenture Act governs and filed on EDGAR, limit liens, debt, payouts and mergers and often give holders a 101% put on a change of control.
Check your understanding
5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
Which order of claims applies in a US bankruptcy under the absolute priority rule, from first paid to last?
- Common stock, preferred stock, subordinated debt, senior unsecured debt, secured debt
- Secured debt, senior unsecured debt, subordinated debt, preferred stock, common stock
- All creditors share in proportion to what they are owed
Show the answer
B. Secured debt, senior unsecured debt, subordinated debt, preferred stock, common stock Secured lenders are paid from their collateral first. Each later class gets value only after the classes ahead of it are paid in full, unless they agree otherwise.
A company worth $700 million has a $400 million secured loan, $500 million of senior notes and $200 million of subordinated notes. What do the senior notes recover?
- 100%
- 60%
- 0%
Show the answer
B. 60% The secured loan takes $400 million, leaving $300 million for $500 million of senior notes: 60%. The subordinated notes get nothing.
A holding company’s only asset is the stock of its operating company. Why do the holdco’s senior notes rank behind the opco’s creditors?
- Because holdco notes always have lower coupons
- Because the holdco is paid only from what is left in the opco after the opco’s own creditors are paid
- Because the law ranks holdco notes as preferred stock
Show the answer
B. Because the holdco is paid only from what is left in the opco after the opco’s own creditors are paid That is structural subordination. With $400 million of opco notes and an opco worth $500 million, $300 million of holdco notes recover only 33%.
What is the difference between an incurrence covenant and a maintenance covenant?
- An incurrence test applies only when the company takes an action such as borrowing more; a maintenance test must be met every period
- Incurrence covenants apply only to secured debt
- There is no difference
Show the answer
A. An incurrence test applies only when the company takes an action such as borrowing more; a maintenance test must be met every period An incurrence test is checked when the company acts. A maintenance test is checked regularly, so it can be breached just because results worsen.
Takeover news pushes a bond to 92. Its indenture has a change-of-control put at 101% of principal and the deal meets the indenture’s definition. What can a holder do?
- Nothing until maturity
- Require the issuer to buy the bond back at 101 plus accrued interest, a 9.8% gain on 92
- Convert the bond into shares
Show the answer
B. Require the issuer to buy the bond back at 101 plus accrued interest, a 9.8% gain on 92 The change-of-control put lets holders sell back at 101. It protects holders when a buyer loads the company with debt.
Sources and further reading
- 11 U.S.C. § 1129 — Confirmation of plan (§ 1129(b), fair and equitable; absolute priority), Cornell LII
- 11 U.S.C. § 506 — Determination of secured status, Cornell LII
- 11 U.S.C. § 507 — Priorities, Cornell LII
- 11 U.S.C. § 510 — Subordination, Cornell LII
- SEC — The laws that govern the securities industry: Trust Indenture Act of 1939
- 15 U.S.C. § 77ooo — Duties and responsibility of the trustee (Trust Indenture Act § 315), Cornell LII
- 15 U.S.C. § 77ppp — Directions and waivers by bondholders; prohibition of impairment of holder’s right to payment (Trust Indenture Act § 316), Cornell LII
- Citizens Communications Company — Indenture for 7.125% Senior Notes due 2019, March 23, 2007 (SEC EDGAR, exhibit 4.2)
- SEC — EDGAR full-text search
