Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Bonds · Treasuries, municipals and corporates

TIPS vs I bonds: which inflation protection fits which job

Compare TIPS and I bonds on real yield, limits, liquidity, price risk and tax, with $10,000 worked over 5 and 10 years at 2%, 3% and 5% inflation.

On this page
  1. How each one follows inflation
  2. The number to compare
  3. $10,000 for 5 or 10 years
  4. When plans change: a rise in real yields
  5. The rules side by side
  6. Choosing between them
  7. Pitfalls
  8. How Finabase does it
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. Summary
  11. Check your understanding

TIPS and I bonds are the two ways the US Treasury lets savers protect money against inflation. Both follow the same price index, CPI-U, and both carry the full credit of the United States. They do the job in different ways, and that makes them fit different needs. TIPS lock in a real yield but have a market price that moves. I bonds never lose value but come in small amounts and lock your money up for a year.

TIPS and breakeven inflation: how inflation-protected bonds work explains how TIPS work and I bonds: how the rate is set, the rules, and what $10,000 earned how the I bond rate is built. This page puts them side by side, prices both with the rates on offer in late 2026, and runs $10,000 through each for 5 and 10 years at three inflation rates and through a rise in real yields.

How each one follows inflation

TIPS. The bond has a fixed real coupon, set at auction and never below 0.125%. Its principal is multiplied by an index ratio, the reference CPI-U on a given day divided by the reference CPI-U when the bond was first dated. Each six-month coupon is the fixed rate times the adjusted principal. At maturity you get the adjusted principal or the original par, whichever is greater. That deflation floor applies only at maturity: in between, the principal can fall below par if prices fall.

The auction data shows the index ratio at work. The 10-year TIPS first sold on July 23, 2026 (CUSIP 91282CRE3) had an index ratio of 1.00325 at issue. When the same bond was reopened in September the ratio was 0.99985, slightly below 1, because CPI-U had dipped over the summer. The 30-year TIPS reopened in August carried a ratio of 1.03055: buyers paid for 3.1% of inflation already added to its principal.

I bonds. The principal is not indexed. The interest rate is. Every six months the inflation rate, the change in CPI-U over the prior six months, is combined with the bond's fixed rate into a composite rate, which TreasuryDirect never lets fall below zero. So the I bond's value can stall in deflation but never shrink.

The number to compare

Comparing the I bond's composite rate (5.51% for November 2026 purchases) with a TIPS yield mixes two things. The composite includes current inflation; a TIPS yield does not. The like-for-like comparison is the I bond fixed rate against the TIPS real yield: what each pays above inflation for as long as you hold it.

Real yields on offer, May–October 2026: TIPS auctions against the I bond fixed rate TIPS 10-yr, May 21 2.169% TIPS 5-yr, Jun 18 1.955% TIPS 10-yr, Jul 23 2.438% TIPS 30-yr, Aug 20 2.973% TIPS 10-yr, Sep 17 2.653% TIPS 5-yr, Oct 22 2.367% 10-yr TIPS market, Oct 28 2.67% I bond fixed rate, Nov 1 1.40% TIPS: auction high yield (TreasuryDirect). Market: FRED DFII10. I bond: TreasuryDirect.
Real yields. TIPS: high yield at each auction, TreasuryDirect. Market: FRED DFII10, October 28, 2026. I bond: TreasuryDirect fixed rate from November 1, 2026.
Security Date Coupon Real yield
TIPS 91282CPU9 (10-yr reopening) May 21, 2026 1.875% 2.169%
TIPS 91282CQP9 (5-yr reopening) June 18, 2026 1.250% 1.955%
TIPS 91282CRE3 (new 10-yr) July 23, 2026 2.375% 2.438%
TIPS 912810US5 (30-yr reopening) Aug 20, 2026 2.375% 2.973%
TIPS 91282CRE3 (10-yr reopening) Sept 17, 2026 2.375% 2.653%
TIPS 91282CRR4 (new 5-yr) Oct 22, 2026 2.250% 2.367%
10-year TIPS in the market Oct 28, 2026 n/a 2.67%
I bond fixed rate from Nov 1, 2026 n/a 1.40%

From May to October 2026, TIPS auctions paid between 0.555 and 1.573 points more above inflation than a new I bond, and the market 10-year 1.27 points more. The four earlier 2026 auctions, January to April, sold at 1.367% to 2.473%, so the margin moves even within one year. And TIPS have not always paid more. In 2020 and 2021 the 10-year TIPS yield was below zero on 95.2% of trading days, reaching −1.19% (FRED DFII10), while I bonds issued from May 2020 on carried a 0% fixed rate. Then the I bond was the better real return, and the purchase limit was what held savers back. Real interest rates: nominal rates minus inflation, explained shows that history.

$10,000 for 5 or 10 years

Here is what $10,000 grows to under each, held to the end.

Method. Inflation is constant each year. The I bond earns the composite rate from a 1.40% fixed rate and a six-month inflation rate matching the annual one, using the Treasury's formula, rounded to four decimals, compounded every six months; at 5 years there is no penalty. The TIPS is bought at the real yield of the latest auction of that maturity, 2.367% for 5 years (October 22) and 2.653% for 10 years (September 17); its principal grows with inflation and its coupons are reinvested in TIPS at the same real yield. No taxes, no costs, and no allowance for the timing details of how the index ratio follows CPI.

$10,000 held to the end: I bond against TIPS bought at 2026 auction yields I bond (1.40% fixed) TIPS (2.367% / 2.653% real) $11.8k $12.4k 5 yr, 2% $12.4k $13.0k 5 yr, 3% $13.7k $14.4k 5 yr, 5% $14.0k $15.9k 10 yr, 2% $15.5k $17.5k 10 yr, 3% $18.7k $21.2k 10 yr, 5% Constant inflation. TIPS coupons reinvested at the same real yield; no CPI lag, taxes or costs.
I bond: 1.40% fixed rate and the Treasury composite formula. TIPS: 2.367% (5-year) and 2.653% (10-year) real yields from the October and September 2026 auctions. Computed by Finabase.
Years Inflation I bond composite I bond value TIPS value TIPS ahead by
5 2% 3.40% $11,836 $12,419 $583
5 3% 4.40% $12,431 $13,040 $609
5 5% 6.37% $13,683 $14,356 $674
10 2% 3.40% $14,009 $15,866 $1,856
10 3% 4.40% $15,453 $17,492 $2,039
10 5% 6.37% $18,721 $21,201 $2,480

Two lessons from the table.

Inflation does not pick the winner; the real yield does. Both instruments pass inflation through. Higher inflation lifts both columns and widens the dollar gap only because there is more money compounding. The gap itself comes from the extra real yield the TIPS locked in: 0.967 point over 5 years and 1.253 points over 10.

Held to maturity, TIPS have no price risk either. The results above are certain in real terms for the TIPS holder, as long as the bond is held to maturity and coupons can be reinvested at the same real yield. The I bond's advantage shows up only when plans change.

When plans change: a rise in real yields

Suppose real yields rise one point, from 2.653% to 3.653%, the day after you buy a 10-year TIPS at par.

  • The TIPS price falls at once to 91.69 per 100 of adjusted principal, a loss of about $831 on $10,000, or 8.3%. Like any bond, a TIPS has duration: this one's modified duration is 8.73, so a one-point move in real yield costs roughly that percentage (How much a bond’s price falls when rates rise: worked examples).
  • If you then need the money after 2 years, with inflation at 3%, selling the TIPS returns about $10,457, including reinvested coupons.
  • An I bond bought the same day and cashed at 2 years returns about $10,791: 21 months of interest at 4.40%, after the three-month penalty. Its value never dipped.

The I bond has no duration, because you can always hand it back to the Treasury at its full accrued value. That redemption right is valuable, and it is part of why its fixed rate is lower.

Deflation. If CPI-U fell 1% a year for 5 years, the I bond composite would be 0.39% and $10,000 would grow to about $10,197. The TIPS principal would be adjusted down to $9,510 along the way, but at maturity the floor returns the full $10,000, plus coupons received on the lower principal along the way.

The rules side by side

TIPS I bonds
Inflation link Principal × index ratio (CPI-U, not seasonally adjusted) Composite rate reset every 6 months from CPI-U
Real return Real yield set by the market at purchase Fixed rate set by the Treasury, 1.40% from Nov 2026
Floor Par at maturity; coupon rate at least 0.125% Composite rate never below zero
Terms 5, 10 or 30 years Earns for 30 years
Minimum $100, in $100 steps $25, to the penny
Limit $10 million per auction for non-competitive bids $10,000 per Social Security number per calendar year
Getting out Sell any day at the market price Locked 12 months; 3 months of interest lost before 5 years
Price risk Yes, about 8.3% for one point of real yield on a 10-year None
Where bought TreasuryDirect at auction, or a bank, broker or dealer TreasuryDirect only
Federal tax Coupons and each year's principal increase, every year Deferrable until cashed
State/local tax None None

Securities bought in TreasuryDirect must be held 45 days before they can be transferred or sold. A TIPS fund such as TIP gives daily liquidity but never matures, so it gives up the deflation floor and the certainty of the held-to-maturity result.

The tax drag on TIPS

TreasuryDirect states that inflation adjustments to TIPS principal are taxable in the year they occur, though they are not paid until maturity. Take $10,000 of the 2.375% 10-year TIPS in a year with 3% inflation and a 24% federal tax rate. The holder receives about $242.83 in coupons but is taxed on those coupons plus the $300 principal increase: about $130.28 of tax, leaving $112.55 of cash. In a high-inflation year the tax can exceed the cash paid. That "phantom income" is a reason to hold TIPS in a tax-deferred account. An I bond defers everything until you cash it.

Choosing between them

  • For a modest emergency or near-term reserve that must never show a loss, the I bond's redemption right is the point. The 12-month lock-up is the catch.
  • For larger sums or a known future date, TIPS bought to mature on that date lock in a higher real yield and have no size limit; a ladder of TIPS can match a string of dates.
  • For retirement accounts, TIPS can be held there and I bonds cannot.
  • In a taxable account, the I bond's deferral is worth more the higher inflation runs.
  • When real yields are low or negative, the I bond fixed rate (never below 0%) can be the better real return outright.

None of this is a recommendation. The point is to compare the right numbers.

Pitfalls

  • Comparing the I bond composite with the TIPS real yield. One includes inflation, the other does not. Compare fixed rate with real yield, or composite with nominal Treasury yields.
  • Forgetting that the TIPS floor works only at maturity. Sold early, a TIPS can return less than you paid, and a fund never matures at all.
  • Ignoring phantom income on TIPS held in a taxable account.
  • Planning on more I bonds than the limit allows. The cap is $10,000 per Social Security number per calendar year.
  • Needing I bond money in the first year. There is no exit before 12 months.

How Finabase does it

  • TIP, a fund of TIPS, shows the price risk that held-to-maturity TIPS and I bonds avoid: its chart moves with real yields every day.
  • The Treasury page shows nominal Treasury yields, the other half of the breakeven inflation rate, and the Economy page tracks the CPI that both instruments follow.

Finabase computed every value on this page from the TreasuryDirect auction results for the six 2026 TIPS auctions in its snapshot, the FRED DFII10 series and the TreasuryDirect I bond rates, with the method stated above.

Frequently asked questions

Which pays more, TIPS or I bonds?

In late 2026, TIPS. New I bonds lock in 1.40% above inflation; TIPS auctioned from May to October 2026 sold at real yields between 1.955% and 2.973%. Held to maturity, $10,000 in a 10-year TIPS ends about $1,860 to $2,480 ahead.

Can TIPS lose money?

Yes, if sold before maturity after real yields rise. A one-point rise cuts a new 10-year TIPS price by about 8.3%. Held to maturity, you get at least the original par back.

Can I bonds lose money?

No. The composite rate cannot go below zero and the redemption value never falls. Cashing in before five years costs the last three months of interest.

Why is the I bond fixed rate lower than TIPS yields?

The I bond includes a free option to cash in at full value at any time after a year, no price risk and tax deferral. TIPS holders are paid for bearing price risk and immediate tax.

Can I hold both?

Yes. Many savers use I bonds up to the yearly limit and TIPS for anything above it, or for money in retirement accounts.

Summary

TIPS and I bonds both follow CPI-U and both are backed by the Treasury. TIPS index the principal and lock in a market real yield, 1.955% to 2.973% at the May–October 2026 auctions; I bonds index the rate and lock in a fixed rate set by the Treasury, 1.40% from November 2026. Held to the end at those rates, $10,000 in TIPS beats I bonds by $580 to $670 over 5 years and $1,860 to $2,480 over 10, whatever the inflation rate. I bonds give that up for safety and flexibility: no price risk, a rate that never goes negative and tax deferral, within a $10,000 yearly limit and a one-year lock-up. TIPS suit large sums, fixed dates and retirement accounts; their cost is price risk if sold early and tax on inflation gains every year.

Check your understanding

5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. Which pair of numbers is the fair comparison between a new I bond and a TIPS?

    1. The I bond composite rate and the TIPS real yield
    2. The I bond fixed rate and the TIPS real yield
    3. The I bond composite rate and the TIPS coupon
    Show the answer

    B. The I bond fixed rate and the TIPS real yield Both the I bond fixed rate and the TIPS real yield are returns above inflation, locked in at purchase. The composite rate also includes current inflation, so comparing it with a real yield mixes two different things.

  2. How does a TIPS pass inflation on to its holder?

    1. By raising its coupon rate every six months
    2. By multiplying the principal by an index ratio based on CPI-U, with the fixed coupon paid on that adjusted principal
    3. By paying a separate inflation bonus at maturity only
    Show the answer

    B. By multiplying the principal by an index ratio based on CPI-U, with the fixed coupon paid on that adjusted principal The TIPS coupon rate stays fixed. The principal is adjusted with CPI-U through the index ratio, and each coupon is the fixed rate times the adjusted principal.

  3. Real yields rise one point right after you buy a 10-year TIPS at par. Roughly what happens to its price?

    1. Nothing, because TIPS are inflation-protected
    2. It falls about 8%
    3. It rises about 8%
    Show the answer

    B. It falls about 8% Inflation protection does not remove interest-rate risk on the real yield. With a modified duration of about 8.7, the price falls to about 91.7 per 100. An I bond has no such price risk because it can be redeemed at full value.

  4. Why can a TIPS in a taxable account create a tax bill larger than the cash it pays in a year?

    1. Because state income tax applies to TIPS
    2. Because each year’s increase in principal is federally taxable even though it is not paid until maturity
    3. Because TIPS coupons are taxed at a higher rate than other interest
    Show the answer

    B. Because each year’s increase in principal is federally taxable even though it is not paid until maturity TreasuryDirect states that principal adjustments are taxable in the year they occur. With 3% inflation and a 24% rate, $10,000 of a 2.375% TIPS paid about $243 in coupons and owed about $130 of tax.

  5. Which feature does an I bond have that a TIPS does not?

    1. No purchase limit
    2. A value that never falls, because the composite rate cannot go below zero and the bond can be redeemed at its accrued value
    3. It can be held in an IRA
    Show the answer

    B. A value that never falls, because the composite rate cannot go below zero and the bond can be redeemed at its accrued value I bonds cannot lose value; TIPS can fall in price before maturity. I bonds are limited to $10,000 a person a year and cannot be held in an IRA.

Sources and further reading

  1. TreasuryDirect — Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities (terms, minimum, fixed-rate floor, purchase limits, taxes), read November 18, 2026
  2. TreasuryDirect — Summary of marketable Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities (CPI-U, redemption at the greater of adjusted principal or par, taxation of adjustments)
  3. TreasuryDirect — Comparing EE and I bonds (rates for November 2026, never-below-zero rule, limits), read November 18, 2026
  4. TreasuryDirect — I bonds interest rates and composite-rate formula
  5. TreasuryDirect — Buying a marketable security (TreasuryDirect, bank, broker or dealer; 45-day hold)
  6. TreasuryDirect — TIPS auction results, May 21 to October 22, 2026 (TA_WS securities service, downloaded November 18, 2026)
  7. Federal Reserve Board — 10-year TIPS real yield (FRED DFII10), October 28, 2026