Bonds · Treasuries, municipals and corporates
Corporate bonds vs. Treasuries: the extra yield and what it buys
What the spread over Treasuries pays for, how state tax, default and calls eat into it, and how corporate and Treasury funds behaved in 2008, 2020 and 2022.
On this page
A Treasury note and a corporate bond of the same maturity can look like the same thing at two prices. Both pay a fixed coupon, both return their face value at maturity, and both lose value when interest rates rise. The corporate bond pays more. The question this page answers is what that extra yield, the credit spread, actually pays you for, and what you give up to get it.
The short answer: the spread pays for the chance that the company defaults, for a market that is harder to trade in, for the right some companies keep to repay early, and for state income tax that Treasury interest escapes. Most years those costs are small and the spread is profit. In a crisis they arrive together, and corporate bonds fall at exactly the moment Treasuries rise.
Where the extra yield comes from
The Treasury part is the price of time: what the market demands for lending money for that many years to a borrower that cannot run out of dollars. The spread is everything else. Four things sit inside it:
- Expected default losses. Some companies will fail to pay. Investors want to be paid for the average loss, after what they recover in bankruptcy.
- A risk premium for when defaults happen. Defaults cluster in recessions, when everything else in a portfolio is falling too. Investors demand more than the average loss for bearing that.
- Liquidity. A Treasury note can be sold in seconds in the world's deepest bond market. A corporate bond trades over the counter through dealers, often a few times a day or less, and a small lot pays a wider markup. How bonds trade: dealers, mark-ups and checking a price before you buy shows the cost.
- Embedded options. Many corporate bonds can be called, repaid early at the company's choice, usually when rates have fallen. The US Treasury has not sold callable bonds since the mid-1980s. See Callable bonds: call schedules, price compression and yield to worst.
Yield spread measures: nominal, G-spread, I-spread, Z-spread and OAS explains the different ways the spread is measured (G-spread, Z-spread, option-adjusted spread). For a comparison like this one, the plain difference in yields is enough.
Default risk in numbers
S&P Global Ratings tracks every company it has rated since 1981 and publishes how many defaulted within each number of years. The averages across all those years:
| Rating | Defaulted within 1 year | Within 10 years |
|---|---|---|
| A | 0.05% | 1.03% |
| BBB | 0.14% | 2.86% |
| All investment grade (BBB− up) | 0.08% | 1.69% |
| All speculative grade | 3.54% | 19.15% |
| US Treasury | No default on record |
Investment-grade defaults are rare, and a default does not mean losing everything: bondholders usually recover part of their money. Bond default and recovery: what bondholders get back, and how often covers recovery rates. For high yield the numbers are a different order of magnitude, which is why it gets its own comparison, Investment grade vs. high yield bonds: default odds by rating.
Worked example: $10,000 for ten years
The 10-year Treasury note auctioned on November 10, 2026 sold at a yield of 5.020%. Suppose an A-rated company's 10-year bond yields 5.92% that day, a spread of 0.90 points. (The spread is illustrative; investment-grade spreads move with the market, and you can read the current one from any corporate bond quote.)
- Headline gap. $10,000 earns about $502 a year in the Treasury and $592 in the corporate bond: $90 more.
- State tax. At a 5% state income tax rate, the Treasury's interest is exempt and the corporate bond's is not. 5% of $592 is $29.60, leaving about $562. The gap is now roughly $60, or 0.60 points.
- Expected default loss. A-rated issuers defaulted within 10 years 1.03% of the time. Spread over ten years that is about 0.10% a year; if bondholders recover 40% (an assumption), the expected loss is about 0.06% a year, $6. For a BBB issuer the same arithmetic gives about $17.
- What is left. Roughly $54 a year, or 0.54 points, is the reward for taking the risk that the bond will fall in a crisis, be hard to sell, or be called away.
The expected default loss is small. The larger cost is the timing of losses, which the next section shows on real fund prices.
What happened in three bad years
The two funds hold bonds of broadly similar length, so the difference between them is mostly credit:
- 2008. From the end of August to the end of October 2008, LQD's price fell 13.3% and IEF's 1.7%. LQD's deepest month-end fall that year was 18.5%. Investors sold corporate debt and bought Treasuries, so spreads widened as Treasury yields fell. Over the whole stretch from mid-2007 to mid-2009, IEF's price rose 11.8% and LQD's fell 4.1%.
- March 2020. In the month the pandemic closed economies, LQD fell 6.6% and IEF rose 3.6%. The Federal Reserve's announcement that it would buy corporate bonds, made that month, ended the slide.
- 2021 to 2023. When inflation pushed the Federal Reserve to raise rates quickly, every fixed-rate bond fell. LQD fell 27.1% from its July 2021 high to October 2023, IEF 24.5% from its high to the same month. Credit spreads barely mattered: this was interest-rate risk, which the two share.
That pattern is the core of the comparison. Treasuries tend to rise when stocks crash, because investors flee to them. Corporate bonds tend to fall with stocks in the same episodes, by less. In a portfolio, a Treasury is the thing that helps when everything else hurts; a corporate bond helps less exactly then.
Corporate bonds vs. Treasuries at a glance
| Feature | Investment-grade corporate | Treasury |
|---|---|---|
| Who owes you | A company | The US government |
| Default risk | Low, not zero (1.69% in 10 years) | None on record |
| Yield | Treasury + spread | The benchmark |
| State income tax | Taxed | Exempt |
| Trading | Dealers, wider markups | Deepest market in the world |
| Calls | Common | Not on new issues |
| In a stock crash | Usually falls | Usually rises |
| In a rate shock | Falls | Falls |
| Typical minimum | $1,000 face | $100 face |
Which to use when
- Protection against a stock-market crash: Treasuries. Their record in 2008 and 2020 is the reason they anchor most balanced portfolios.
- Extra income over many years, with defaults spread across many issuers: a diversified investment-grade fund, accepting that it falls in crises. One bond from one company is a concentrated bet on that company.
- High state income tax: Treasuries look better than the headline spread suggests. Compare after state tax, as in the worked example.
- Money needed on a fixed date: either, held to maturity. A Treasury removes the default question entirely; a high-quality corporate bond adds a small one for the extra yield.
- You might need to sell before maturity: Treasuries, whose market stays open and deep when the corporate market thins out.
Pitfalls
- Reading yield as return. A higher yield is a promise, not a forecast. Defaults, calls and forced sales at bad prices are what the spread pays for.
- Ignoring what's inside a fund. Corporate bond funds differ in maturity and credit quality. Compare a fund's duration as well as its yield (Duration vs. maturity: when you get paid vs. how much you risk).
- Assuming a downgrade can't hurt investment grade. A BBB company cut to BB becomes a "fallen angel", and funds limited to investment grade may have to sell.
- Forgetting state tax. A spread of half a point can vanish for a buyer in a high-tax state.
How Finabase does it
Finabase does not list individual corporate bonds or their ratings. It covers the comparison through benchmarks and funds. The Treasury page shows the Treasury yield at each maturity, the starting point of every corporate yield. The symbol pages of LQD and IEF chart the two funds used above, and the comparison view draws them on one chart as percent changes from a common start, so you can pick a crisis and see how they parted. The chart on this page is ours, built from the same month-end prices.
Frequently asked questions
Are corporate bonds riskier than Treasuries?
Yes. They carry default risk, call risk and weaker liquidity, which Treasuries do not. For investment-grade bonds the default risk is small (1.69% of rated companies within ten years, on S&P's 1981–2024 averages), but they fall when markets panic, as in 2008 and March 2020.
Why do corporate bonds pay more than Treasuries?
To pay for expected defaults, for the fact that defaults come in recessions, for harder trading and for call features, and to make up for state income tax that Treasury interest avoids.
Do corporate bonds and Treasuries move together?
When interest rates move, yes: both fell sharply in 2022. When credit fears rise, no: corporate bond prices fall as spreads widen while Treasuries often rise.
Is the interest on corporate bonds taxed by my state?
Generally yes. Interest on US Treasury securities is exempt from state and local income tax under federal law; interest on corporate bonds is not.
Summary
A corporate bond yields its Treasury twin plus a spread, and the spread is payment for default risk, weaker trading, call features and state income tax. For investment-grade companies the expected default loss is small: in our example of an A-rated bond 0.90 points over the November 2026 10-year Treasury, state tax took about 0.30 points and expected defaults about 0.06, leaving about half a point. The real cost shows up in a crisis: in late 2008 and March 2020, corporate bond prices fell while Treasuries held or rose. In a pure rate shock, as in 2022, they fell together. Treasuries are the better crash protection; investment-grade corporates are the better income if you can ride out the years when spreads widen.
Check your understanding
4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
A 10-year corporate bond yields 5.92% and the 10-year Treasury yields 5.02%. What is the 0.90-point difference called, and what does it pay for?
- The coupon; it pays for inflation
- The credit spread; it pays for default risk, weaker liquidity, call features and the state tax Treasury interest avoids
- The term premium; it pays for the longer maturity
Show the answer
B. The credit spread; it pays for default risk, weaker liquidity, call features and the state tax Treasury interest avoids Both bonds have the same maturity, so the gap is not a term premium. It compensates for everything the corporate bond carries that the Treasury does not.
From the end of August to the end of October 2008, LQD fell 13.3% while IEF fell 1.7%. What explains most of the gap?
- LQD holds much longer bonds than IEF
- Credit spreads widened as investors sold corporate debt and bought Treasuries
- IEF paid a special dividend
Show the answer
B. Credit spreads widened as investors sold corporate debt and bought Treasuries The two funds hold bonds of broadly similar length, so the difference was credit: spreads widened while Treasury yields fell.
Why did LQD and IEF both fall about a quarter between 2021 and October 2023?
- Corporate defaults spread to the Treasury market
- Interest rates rose sharply, and every fixed-rate bond loses value when yields rise
- Both funds changed their index
Show the answer
B. Interest rates rose sharply, and every fixed-rate bond loses value when yields rise That was a rate shock. Interest-rate risk is shared by Treasuries and corporates, so they fell together.
You pay 5% state income tax. Which part of a corporate bond's extra yield does that eat into?
- None: all bond interest is taxed the same way
- Some of it, because corporate interest is taxed by your state and Treasury interest is exempt
- All of it, because corporate interest is taxed twice federally
Show the answer
B. Some of it, because corporate interest is taxed by your state and Treasury interest is exempt Federal law exempts Treasury interest from state and local income tax. On a 5.92% corporate yield, 5% state tax takes about 0.30 points.
Sources and further reading
- S&P Global Ratings — 2024 Annual Global Corporate Default and Rating Transition Study (March 27, 2025), Table 24: average cumulative default rates 1981–2024
- TreasuryDirect — Auction results, 10-year note 91282CRX1 (auctioned November 10, 2026)
- U.S. Code — 31 U.S.C. 3124: exemption of US government obligations from state and local taxation
- TreasuryDirect — Treasury calls the 11-3/4% bonds of 2009-14, issued November 15, 1984 (July 15, 2009); only Treasury bonds issued before 1985 are callable
- FINRA — Corporate bonds and TRACE price reporting
- SEC Investor.gov — Corporate bonds (investor bulletin)
- Finabase price history of LQD (iShares iBoxx $ Investment Grade Corporate Bond ETF) and IEF (iShares 7–10 Year Treasury Bond ETF), month-end closes, frozen October 2026
