Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Bonds · Building a bond portfolio

Barbell vs bullet: two ways to hold the same duration

A barbell of short and long bonds against one intermediate bullet of the same duration: the yield given up, the convexity gained, and what curve shifts and twists do.

On this page
  1. The two structures
  2. Parallel moves: convexity pays
  3. Changes in shape: the barbell's real exposure
  4. Cash flows and reinvestment
  5. Where the two show up in practice
  6. Pitfalls
  7. How Finabase does it
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. Summary
  10. Check your understanding

Two bond holdings can have the same duration, the same headline sensitivity to interest rates, and still behave very differently. A bullet puts the money in one maturity, here the 7-year Treasury note. A barbell splits it between a short maturity and a long one, here the 2-year and the 30-year, in the proportions that give it the bullet's duration.

Duration says they move alike when every yield moves by the same small amount. This lesson prices both structures off the Treasury curve of October 28, 2026 and runs them through larger moves and through changes in the curve's shape, where they part company.

The two structures

Treasury par yields on October 28, 2026, and the risk numbers of a par bond at each:

Bond Yield Modified duration Convexity
2-year 4.67% 1.89 4.6
7-year 4.95% 5.86 40.6
30-year 5.37% 14.82 330.1

Modified duration is the approximate percentage price change for a one-point change in yield (How much a bond’s price falls when rates rise: worked examples). Convexity measures how much that sensitivity itself changes as yields move (Bond duration and convexity: measuring interest-rate risk).

To give the barbell the bullet's duration of 5.86, solve for the weight in the 30-year bond:

Where $100,000 sits along the curve in each structure Bullet: 7-year $100,000 Barbell: 2-year $69,331 Barbell: 30-year $30,669 Ladder: each of 10 rungs $10,000 Barbell weights chosen so its modified duration equals the bullet's 5.86.
Weights chosen so the barbell’s modified duration equals the bullet’s 5.86. Computed by Finabase from Treasury par yields of October 28, 2026.
Structure Yield Modified duration Convexity
Bullet: 7-year 4.95% 5.86 40.6
Barbell: 69% 2y, 31% 30y 4.88% 5.86 104.4

The barbell's yield is the weighted average of its two parts. It is lower than the bullet's because the 2-year note, which makes up most of it, yields well below the 7-year. That 0.07 of a point is the price of a convexity more than two and a half times larger.

Parallel moves: convexity pays

When every yield moves by the same amount at once, the barbell does better in both directions.

Same duration, different shape: price change of a bullet and a barbell Bullet: 7-year note Barbell: 2-year and 30-year 12.6 14.2 All −2 pt 6.1 6.4 All −1 pt −5.7 −5.4 All +1 pt −10.9 −9.9 All +2 pt −0.0 −1.5 Steeper −0.0 1.8 Flatter Immediate price change in percent. Steeper: 2-year −0.5 pt, 30-year +0.5 pt. Flatter: the reverse.
Immediate price change, repriced exactly from each bond’s cash flows. Steeper: 2-year yield −0.5 point, 30-year +0.5 point, 7-year unchanged. Flatter: the reverse. Computed by Finabase.
Scenario Bullet Barbell Barbell minus bullet on $100,000
All yields −2 points +12.57% +14.21% +$1,640
All yields −1 point +6.06% +6.42% +$361
All yields +1 point −5.66% −5.37% +$283
All yields +2 points −10.94% −9.93% +$1,009

This is convexity at work. With equal duration, the two start out equally sensitive. As yields fall the barbell's sensitivity grows faster, and as yields rise it shrinks faster. The advantage grows roughly with the square of the move: about $300 for one point and about $1,000 to $1,600 for two.

Against that, the barbell earns 0.07 of a point less each year, about $65 on $100,000. Over a year, yields have to move by roughly half a point in either direction (about 0.45 to 0.5 of a point) for the convexity gain to pay for the yield given up. That trade, yield now against protection in large moves, is the core of the choice when the curve keeps its shape.

Changes in shape: the barbell's real exposure

Yields rarely move in parallel. The 2-year yield follows expectations for the Federal Reserve's policy rate closely. The 30-year yield follows long-run inflation, the supply of long bonds and the term premium. They can move in opposite directions.

Steepening (short yields fall, long yields rise) hurts a barbell. In the scenario above the 2-year falls half a point and the 30-year rises half a point, with the 7-year unchanged. The bullet does not move. The barbell's small gain on the 2-year is swamped by the loss on the 30-year, whose duration is almost eight times larger: −1.49%.

Flattening helps it: +1.75% in the reverse scenario.

So a barbell is not simply "the same duration with extra convexity". It is a position on the curve: long the two ends, short the middle, relative to the bullet. A bullet is the opposite position. Neither is neutral to changes in shape.

You hold a You gain when You lose when
Bullet Yields stay put (higher yield); the middle of the curve falls most Yields make large parallel moves; the curve flattens
Barbell Yields make large parallel moves; the curve flattens Yields stay put (lower yield); the curve steepens

Cash flows and reinvestment

The structures also differ in when money comes back.

  • Bullet. Nearly everything matures on one date. Useful when a known sum is needed then. Until then, little cash returns apart from coupons, so there is little reinvestment risk and little flexibility.
  • Barbell. Most of the money returns within two years and must be reinvested, at whatever rates then apply. The rest is locked up for thirty years. It needs active management: as the short end matures and the long bond ages, the duration drifts and the weights must be reset.
  • Ladder. Equal amounts maturing every year. Reinvestment is spread out and the structure maintains itself. Bond ladders: how to build one and what it does when rates change works through one built on the same curve. A 1-to-10-year ladder on this curve has an average modified duration of 4.61.

Where the two show up in practice

  • Pension funds and insurers with a liability on a known date often hold bullets matched to it. Immunization: matching duration to a future bill covers that use.
  • Individuals build barbells, sometimes without meaning to: a large cash or bill holding plus a long bond fund is a barbell. The total duration may look moderate while the holding behaves very differently from an intermediate fund.
  • Bond funds often state their duration and their maturity distribution. Two funds with the same duration can have very different distributions; the distribution says which of them is the barbell.
  • When the yield curve is inverted, short yields are above intermediate ones and a barbell can have a higher yield than a bullet of the same duration. The yield cost described above then disappears, which is one reason barbells became popular in 2023.

Pitfalls

  • Treating equal duration as equal risk. Duration covers small parallel moves only.
  • Forgetting the yield cost. On an upward-sloping curve a barbell earns less every year; the convexity gain only shows up in large moves.
  • Ignoring curve risk. A barbell loses when the curve steepens even if the "average" yield does not change.
  • Letting it drift. A barbell's duration changes as its short end matures and its long end ages. Without rebalancing it stops being the structure you chose.
  • Building one by accident. Cash plus a long bond fund is a barbell, with all of its exposures.

How Finabase does it

  • The Treasury page shows the full curve. The yield cost of a barbell is the bullet's yield minus the weighted average of the two ends; read it straight from the table.
  • Chart the 2-year and 30-year yields together over any period to see how often the curve steepens and flattens, which is the barbell's main risk.

All figures in this lesson were computed by Finabase: par bonds at the October 28, 2026 Treasury par yields, semiannual coupons, prices recomputed exactly from cash flows after each move (not estimated from duration), no trading costs.

Frequently asked questions

What is a barbell strategy in bonds?

Holding short-term and long-term bonds and little in between, sized so the total has a chosen duration.

What is a bullet strategy?

Holding bonds that all mature around one date, usually an intermediate maturity.

Which is better, a barbell or a bullet?

Neither in general. At the same duration the barbell has more convexity and usually a lower yield, and it is exposed to changes in the curve's shape. Which suits depends on when the money is needed and on how the curve moves.

How is a barbell different from a ladder?

A ladder spreads money evenly across maturities. A barbell concentrates it at the two ends. A ladder reinvests a little every year; a barbell reinvests most of its short end often.

Does a barbell always yield less than a bullet?

On an upward-sloping curve, usually yes. On an inverted curve it can yield more.

Summary

A bullet and a barbell of the same duration move together for small parallel shifts in yields and differ in everything else. The barbell has more convexity, so it does better in large parallel moves, and it usually yields less: on the October 28, 2026 curve, 0.07 of a point less for 2.6 times the convexity. Its larger exposure is to the curve's shape, gaining when the curve flattens and losing when it steepens. A ladder sits between the two. The choice is about when money is needed and which changes in the curve you can live with.

Check your understanding

5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. A barbell and a bullet have the same modified duration. All yields rise two points at once. Which loses less?

    1. The bullet
    2. The barbell, because it has more convexity
    3. They lose exactly the same
    Show the answer

    B. The barbell, because it has more convexity Equal duration makes them equally sensitive to small moves only. In the example the barbell lost 9.93% and the bullet 10.94%, thanks to the barbell’s larger convexity.

  2. On an upward-sloping curve, what does a barbell usually give up compared with a bullet of the same duration?

    1. Some yield
    2. Convexity
    3. Liquidity
    Show the answer

    A. Some yield Most of a barbell sits in short bonds that yield less than the intermediate bullet. On the October 28, 2026 curve it yielded 4.88% against 4.95%.

  3. Short yields fall and long yields rise, with the middle of the curve unchanged. What happens to a barbell relative to the bullet?

    1. It gains
    2. It loses
    3. Nothing
    Show the answer

    B. It loses A steepening hurts the long bond far more than it helps the short one. In the example the barbell lost 1.49% while the bullet did not move.

  4. Which structure needs the most rebalancing to stay what it is?

    1. A bullet
    2. A barbell
    3. A ladder
    Show the answer

    B. A barbell The barbell’s short end matures quickly and its long end ages, so its duration drifts. A ladder renews itself one rung at a time.

  5. An investor holds a large cash balance and a long-term Treasury fund. What structure is that?

    1. A bullet
    2. A ladder
    3. A barbell
    Show the answer

    C. A barbell Money at the two ends of the curve and little in the middle is a barbell, with its sensitivity to changes in the curve’s shape.

Sources and further reading

  1. US Treasury — Daily Treasury Par Yield Curve Rates (October 28, 2026 values, read through FRED series DGS2, DGS7, DGS30)
  2. FINRA — Bonds: interest rate risk and duration
  3. Frank J. Fabozzi (ed.), The Handbook of Fixed Income Securities — yield curve strategies