Bonds · Bond basics
Bonds vs. CDs: rate, safety, taxes and getting out early
Compare Treasury bonds and bank CDs on yield, insurance, state tax and early exit, with late-2026 rates and $10,000 cashed out after one year of two.
On this page
A certificate of deposit and a Treasury note look alike from a distance. Both pay a fixed rate for a fixed term, both are about as safe as money gets in the United States, and both are used for the same jobs: a house deposit in two years, cash a retiree will spend in three. Up close they differ in four ways that change the result: what they pay, who stands behind them, how they are taxed, and what happens if you need the money before the term ends.
This page compares the two. "Bonds" here means mostly US Treasury notes and bills, the bonds a CD buyer is most likely to weigh, with a note on corporate and municipal bonds. The numbers are real: Treasury yields of October 28, 2026, the FDIC's national CD rate for November 2026, and an actual 2-year Treasury note auctioned on October 26, 2026.
What each one is
A certificate of deposit (Certificate of deposit (CD)) is a time deposit at a bank or credit union. You agree to leave money for a term, from a few months to five years or more, and the bank pays a fixed rate, quoted as an APY. The deposit is insured by the FDIC (or, at credit unions, the NCUA) up to the standard $250,000 limit per depositor, per insured bank, for each ownership category. If you withdraw before the term ends, the bank keeps a penalty that it sets and must disclose when you open the account. Federal Regulation D sets only a floor: at least seven days' simple interest on money withdrawn within six days of the deposit.
A Treasury note is a bond the US government sells at auction, with a term of 2, 3, 5, 7 or 10 years and interest paid every six months. Bills run up to a year and pay no coupon; bonds run 20 or 30 years. You can buy them at auction through TreasuryDirect or a broker, or later on the secondary market through a broker. There is no early-withdrawal penalty because there is no withdrawal: to get your money before maturity you sell the note to another investor at the market price. Bond basics: par value, coupon and maturity on a real Treasury note explains how coupons, par and maturity fit together.
The rates on offer in late 2026
On October 28, 2026 Treasury yields were 4.47% for one year, 4.67% for two and 4.85% for five. The FDIC's national rate for a 12-month CD was 1.81%, and for savings 0.39%. On $10,000, that is $447 a year from the 1-year Treasury against $181 from the average 12-month CD.
That gap overstates the real choice. The FDIC national rate is a deposit-weighted average, so it leans toward large banks that pay little on CDs held by customers who never shop. Online banks and credit unions routinely offer CDs near Treasury yields, and occasionally above them for a few months when a bank wants deposits. The honest comparison is between the best CD you can actually open and the Treasury of the same term on the same day.
Taxes: the hidden quarter point
Interest from both is taxed as ordinary income by the federal government. The difference is at the state level. Under 31 U.S.C. 3124, interest on US government obligations is exempt from state and local income tax. CD interest is taxed by your state like wages.
For someone in a state with no income tax, the exemption is worth nothing. In a state with a top rate near 10%, it can be worth nearly half a point. (Federal deductions for state tax change the exact figure slightly; the formula above ignores them.) How bonds are taxed in the US: interest, discounts, gains and funds covers the federal rules, including the treatment of a note bought below par.
Worked example: needing the money after one year
The difference that matters most is what happens when plans change. Take $10,000 and two choices:
- The note. The 2-year Treasury note auctioned on October 26, 2026 (CUSIP 91282CRU7) pays a 4.625% coupon and sold at a price of $99.843155 per $100, a yield of 4.708%. $10,000 buys $10,015.71 of face value, which pays $463.23 of interest in the first year.
- The CD. A 2-year CD paying 4.708%, the same rate, with a penalty of six months' interest for early withdrawal. Six months is a common penalty for a term of this length; your bank's disclosure states its own.
After one year you need the money. The CD balance has grown to $10,470.80; breaking it costs $232.69, so you leave with $10,238.11. The note pays its two coupons and is sold with one year left. What you get depends on where one-year yields are on the day you sell.
| Yield when the note is sold | Note: coupons + sale | CD: balance − penalty |
|---|---|---|
| 1 point lower (3.71%) | $10,568 | $10,238 |
| Unchanged (4.71%) | $10,471 | $10,238 |
| 1 point higher (5.71%) | $10,375 | $10,238 |
| 2 points higher (6.71%) | $10,280 | $10,238 |
In this example the note came out ahead in every case, because the one year of price risk left in a 2-year note is small: a 2-point jump costs about 1.9% of value. The CD's cost is fixed and known in advance. With a longer term the balance changes. A 5- or 10-year note sold early after a large rise in yields can lose several times a CD's penalty; a penalty of a year's interest on a 5-year CD can, in turn, cost more than a small move in yields. And in a CD you can never gain from falling rates, while the note can.
Brokered CDs: a third option
Brokerage accounts sell brokered CDs: deposits issued by banks and distributed through a broker. They are FDIC-insured on the same terms as a CD from the bank itself, as long as the broker keeps the required records. But most cannot be broken at the bank. To get out early you sell the CD on the secondary market, which works like selling a bond: the price falls when rates rise, and the market for small lots can be thin, so the dealer's markdown can be large. Some are callable, meaning the bank can repay them early, usually after rates fall, which is when you would least want it. The SEC's investor bulletin on brokered CDs warns that a broker may charge a fee to sell one before maturity, and FINRA has noted that brokers are not required to keep a secondary market at all.
Bonds vs. CDs at a glance
| Feature | Bank CD | Treasury note or bill |
|---|---|---|
| Who owes you | A bank or credit union | The US government |
| Protection | FDIC/NCUA, $250,000 limit | Full faith and credit, no limit |
| Getting out early | Penalty set by the bank | Sell at the market price |
| Can value fall? | No (except brokered CDs) | Yes, if yields rise |
| State income tax | Taxed | Exempt |
| Minimum | Often $0 to $1,000 | $100 face at auction |
| Terms | Months to about 10 years | 4 weeks to 30 years |
| Where to buy | The bank, or a broker (brokered) | TreasuryDirect or a broker |
Corporate and municipal bonds add credit risk: the issuer can default, and no insurance stands behind them. They pay more for that, and municipal interest is usually exempt from federal tax. They are a different decision from a CD; Corporate bonds vs. Treasuries: the extra yield and what it buys covers that one.
Which to use when
- Money you may need early, with no tolerance for a loss: a bank CD with a small penalty, or a short Treasury bill that matures before you need it. A bill held to maturity has no price risk.
- You live in a high-tax state: Treasuries usually win at equal headline rates. Run the formula above with your own state rate.
- More than $250,000 at one bank: Treasuries have no limit. With CDs you spread money across banks or ownership categories to stay insured.
- A promotional CD above Treasury yields: take the CD if its penalty is one you could live with; banks sometimes pay up for deposits in a way the bond market never does.
- Building a ladder: both work. Treasuries are easier to buy in matching amounts each year and to sell; CDs are easier for someone who wants no brokerage account. See Bond ladders: how to build one and what it does when rates change.
Pitfalls
- Comparing an APY with a bond yield as if they were the same thing. A CD APY compounds; a Treasury yield is quoted on a semiannual basis. At these rates the difference is a few hundredths of a point, but it exists. APR vs. APY: how US rates are quoted and how to compare them explains the conventions.
- Automatic renewal. Many CDs roll into a new CD at the bank's current rate unless you act during a short grace period.
- Reinvestment. A 1-year CD or bill locks a rate for one year only. If rates fall, the renewal pays less. A longer term locks the rate for longer and carries more exit cost.
- Brokered CD lock-in. Selling a brokered CD before maturity can cost more than a bank penalty.
How Finabase does it
Finabase is not a bank and does not list CD rates. It shows the bond side of the comparison. The Treasury page lists today's yields at every benchmark maturity from 1 month to 30 years, with daily changes and 52-week ranges, so you can check the Treasury of the same term as any CD you are offered. Each maturity has its own chart, such as the 2-year yield. The figures here are ours: the note prices come from the Treasury's own auction results and our pricing code, and the deposit rates from frozen FDIC series.
Frequently asked questions
Are CDs safer than Treasury bonds?
Both are about as safe as US investments get. A CD is backed by the FDIC up to $250,000 per depositor, per bank, per ownership category; a Treasury is backed by the US government with no limit. The real difference is price: a bank CD's value never falls, while a Treasury sold before maturity can be worth less than you paid.
Do Treasuries pay more than CDs?
Usually more than the average CD, often about the same as the best CDs. In November 2026 the FDIC national 12-month CD rate was 1.81%, against a 1-year Treasury at 4.47%. After state tax, a Treasury can come out ahead even when a CD quotes the same rate.
Can I lose money in a CD?
Not in an insured bank CD held to maturity. Breaking it early can cost more than the interest earned if you withdraw very soon. Brokered CDs sold before maturity can lose value, like bonds.
What happens to a Treasury if I hold it to maturity?
You receive every coupon and the full face value at maturity, whatever happened to its market price in between. Price changes matter only if you sell early.
Summary
CDs and Treasuries do the same job with different trade-offs. A CD is an insured deposit whose value never falls but which costs a penalty to break; a Treasury is a government bond with no insurance limit, no state income tax on its interest and a market price that moves until it matures. In late 2026 the 1-year Treasury paid 4.47% against a 1.81% national CD average, though the best CDs came close. In our worked example, a 2-year note sold after one year beat a CD broken with a six-month penalty even if yields rose 2 points, because a short note carries little price risk. For longer terms, higher state taxes or more than $250,000, the comparison shifts, and the right choice depends on how likely you are to need the money early.
Check your understanding
4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
You live in a state with a 5% income tax. A 1-year Treasury yields 4.47%. Roughly what must a 1-year CD pay to leave you the same after state tax?
- 4.47%, because both are taxed the same
- About 4.71%
- About 4.25%
Show the answer
B. About 4.71% Treasury interest is exempt from state and local income tax; CD interest is not. 4.47% ÷ (1 − 0.05) ≈ 4.71%.
Why can a 2-year Treasury note be worth less than you paid if you sell it after one year, while a bank CD cannot?
- Because the government can skip a coupon
- Because the note is sold at the market price, which falls when yields rise; a bank CD is redeemed at its balance minus a fixed penalty
- Because the FDIC does not cover CDs held for less than two years
Show the answer
B. Because the note is sold at the market price, which falls when yields rise; a bank CD is redeemed at its balance minus a fixed penalty A Treasury has no early withdrawal, only a sale to another investor. Its price moves with yields. A bank CD returns the balance less a penalty set in advance.
Which is true of a brokered CD?
- It is not FDIC-insured because a broker sold it
- It is FDIC-insured, but getting out early usually means selling it at a market price that can be below what you paid
- It can always be broken at the issuing bank for a seven-day interest penalty
Show the answer
B. It is FDIC-insured, but getting out early usually means selling it at a market price that can be below what you paid Brokered CDs keep FDIC coverage on the usual terms but most trade on a secondary market instead of being broken, so they carry price risk like a bond.
Someone wants to hold $600,000 in safe fixed-rate instruments at one institution. What limits a CD here that does not limit a Treasury?
- The $250,000 FDIC limit per depositor, per bank, per ownership category
- Treasuries cannot be bought in amounts above $10,000
- CDs cannot be opened above $100,000
Show the answer
A. The $250,000 FDIC limit per depositor, per bank, per ownership category FDIC insurance covers $250,000 per depositor, per insured bank, for each ownership category. Treasuries are backed by the US government with no limit.
Sources and further reading
- FDIC — Deposit insurance: $250,000 per depositor, per insured bank, for each account ownership category
- FDIC — National rates and rate caps (12-month CD and savings national rates, November 2026)
- Federal Reserve Board — Regulation D, 12 CFR 204.2(c): time deposits and the minimum early-withdrawal penalty
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau — Regulation DD, 12 CFR 1030.4: account disclosures, including early-withdrawal penalties
- U.S. Code — 31 U.S.C. 3124: exemption of US government obligations from state and local taxation
- TreasuryDirect — Auction results, 2-year note 91282CRU7 (auctioned October 26, 2026)
- SEC Investor.gov — Investor bulletin: brokered CDs (secondary-market sales, fees, callable CDs)
- FINRA — Notice to Members 02-69: brokered CDs (deposit brokers need not maintain a secondary market)
- Federal Reserve Board — Treasury constant-maturity yields (FRED DGS1, DGS2, DGS5), October 28, 2026
