Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Before you invest Lesson 4 of 9

Personal finance · Before you invest

APR vs. APY: how US rates are quoted and how to compare them

Why a card’s APR understates what a balance costs, why a savings APY already counts compounding, and how to put card, savings and Treasury bill rates on one scale.

On this page
  1. Two rules, two numbers
  2. Worked example: a credit card balance
  3. Worked example: three ways to quote cash
  4. All five on one scale
  5. Pitfalls and limits
  6. How the main quotes compare
  7. How Finabase does it
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. Summary
  10. Check your understanding
  11. Exercise

Two numbers describe almost every interest rate a US household sees. A credit card or a loan quotes an APR, the annual percentage rate. A savings account or a certificate of deposit quotes an APY, the annual percentage yield. They sound alike and are often confused, but they are built differently, by two different federal rules, and they answer different questions.

The short version: an APY counts compounding and an APR on a credit card does not. That makes a savings APY a fair measure of what a year earns, and a card APR a slight understatement of what a year of carried balance costs. A third convention, the discount rate used for Treasury bills, understates the yield of a bill too.

This lesson shows how each number is defined, works the arithmetic on real rates from late 2026, and puts a card balance, a savings account and a Treasury bill on one scale.

Two rules, two numbers

APR: a rate times a number of periods

For credit cards and other revolving credit, Regulation Z (12 CFR 1026.14) says the annual percentage rate is the periodic rate multiplied by the number of periods in a year. An example in the rule's official interpretation (comment 14(c)-4) uses a monthly rate of 1.5%, which becomes an APR of 18%. Nothing in that multiplication allows for interest being charged on interest.

For installment loans such as car loans and mortgages, the APR under 12 CFR 1026.22 is a broader measure: it folds certain fees, the finance charges, into the yearly rate, so two loans with the same note rate but different fees show different APRs. That is useful when comparing loans, and it is why a loan's APR is usually a little above its stated interest rate. Loan shopping is outside this section; what matters here is that an APR is a quoting convention, not the amount a year will actually cost.

APY: what a year actually earns

For deposit accounts, Regulation DD, the Truth in Savings rule, requires banks and savings institutions to state an annual percentage yield, and Appendix A to Part 1030 gives the formula.

Because the interest in the formula is the interest actually credited, with compounding, the APY already contains the effect of compounding. An account paying a 4.00% interest rate compounded daily has an APY of 4.08%. The same 4.00% paid once a year has an APY of 4.00%. Two banks can quote the same interest rate and different APYs, and the APY is the one that tells which pays more. Regulation DD (12 CFR 1030.4) requires both the interest rate and the APY in account disclosures, using those names.

Converting one to the other

When a rate is compounded n times a year, the yearly result is:

This yearly figure is sometimes called the effective annual rate. For savings it is the APY. For a card, US rules do not require it to be shown at all.

Rate quoted at 4.00% Yearly yield $10,000 after 10 years
Compounded yearly 4.000% $14,802
Compounded quarterly 4.060% $14,889
Compounded monthly 4.074% $14,908
Compounded daily 4.081% $14,918

The table shows how small the effect is at savings-account rates: going from yearly to daily compounding adds $116 on $10,000 over a decade. At card rates it is larger, as the next section shows. The growth of money over long periods is covered in Compound interest: how growth on growth builds wealth.

Worked example: a credit card balance

The Federal Reserve's G.19 consumer credit release reports the average interest rate on credit card plans at commercial banks. For August 2026, the average for accounts that were charged interest was 22.36%. Card issuers in the US generally charge interest daily, using a daily periodic rate: the APR divided by 365 (some issuers use 360, which is disclosed in the card agreement).

  • Daily periodic rate: 22.36% ÷ 365 = 0.06126% a day.
  • Interest on a $1,000 balance for one day: about $0.61.
  • If the balance were left for a whole year with no payments and no other charges, daily compounding would turn the 22.36% APR into 25.05%: $250 of interest instead of the $224 the APR alone suggests.

In practice a card requires a minimum payment every month, so nobody carries a balance for a year without paying. The example isolates the arithmetic: each day's interest joins the balance and earns interest the next day. The longer a balance runs, the wider the gap between the APR and what it costs.

$1,000 left unpaid at 22.36% APR: interest owed $0 $500 $1,000 $1,500 $2,000 $2,500 0 yr 1 yr 2 yr 3 yr 4 yr 5 yr Compounded daily (how cards charge) Simple interest at the APR $2,058 $1,118 Interest owed on $1,000
Interest on $1,000 at the August 2026 average card rate for accounts paying interest, compounded daily as cards charge it, against simple interest at the APR. An illustration of compounding: real cards require monthly payments and add fees.

Over five years the compounded interest, $2,058, is almost double the simple figure of $1,118. A balance that is never paid down more than doubles in about three years and one month at this rate. How a card's statement turns the daily rate into a monthly charge, with the grace period and the average daily balance, is a separate subject from the quoting convention covered here.

Worked example: three ways to quote cash

Cash earns money in several forms, and each form quotes its rate its own way:

  • Savings accounts, money market deposit accounts and CDs quote an APY under Regulation DD. The FDIC publishes a national average each month. For November 2026 it was 0.39% for savings, 0.64% for money market deposit accounts and 1.81% for 12-month CDs. Individual banks pay anywhere from near zero to several times these averages; the averages are weighted by deposits, so they lean toward the large banks.
  • Treasury bills are sold below face value and repaid at face value. The Federal Reserve's H.15 table shows their rates on a discount basis: the discount as a share of the face value, on a 360-day year. That understates the yield on the money actually paid.
  • Money market funds and bill ETFs report a yield on their own basis, such as the SEC 7-day yield for money market funds. They are covered in Money market funds and cash: T-bills, savings and real returns.

To turn a bill's discount rate into a yield comparable with an APY, divide by the price paid rather than the face value, and use a 365-day year:

TreasuryDirect calls this figure the investment rate and shows it next to the discount rate in auction results. Treasury bill rates: discount rate vs investment rate, with the math explains the conventions in more depth, including why the gap grows for longer bills.

All five on one scale

Once each number is turned into what a year earns or costs, they can be compared directly.

Five US rates on one scale: what a year costs or earns (late 2026) Card balance, daily compounding 25.05% (APR 22.36%) 3-month Treasury bill 4.15% (discount 4.05%) 12-month CD, national rate 1.81% APY Money market deposit, national 0.64% APY Savings account, national 0.39% APY Card: G.19 accounts assessed interest, Aug 2026. Bill: H.15, Oct 2026. Deposits: FDIC national rates, Nov 2026.
What a year costs or earns on a card balance, a Treasury bill and three FDIC national deposit rates, late 2026. Card: Federal Reserve G.19, August 2026. Bill: H.15, October 2026. Deposits: FDIC national rates, November 2026.

Three things stand out:

  1. A carried card balance costs about six times what a Treasury bill earned. Each dollar of card debt paid off "earns" the card's rate with certainty. No cash product came close in 2026, which is the arithmetic behind paying high-interest debt before investing.
  2. The national average savings rate was about a tenth of the bill yield. The average is dragged down by large banks paying little. The spread between what an average account pays and what a bill pays is the reason so many savers compare accounts and consider bills for cash they will not need for a few months.
  3. The quoting convention changes the numbers by less than the choice of product does. The difference between an APR and its compounded yield, or between a bill's discount rate and its yield, is tenths of a point at cash rates. The difference between a 0.39% account and a 4.15% bill is nearly four points.

Pitfalls and limits

  • Comparing an APR with an APY. A card's 22.36% APR and a savings account's 4.08% APY are on different footings. Convert one before comparing, or the card looks cheaper than it is.
  • Promotional and variable rates. Many card APRs are variable: they track an index such as the prime rate and move when the Federal Reserve moves its target. Savings APYs change whenever the bank decides. A deposit APY is accurate only as of the date the bank states.
  • Fees are outside the APY. A savings account with a monthly fee can earn less than its APY says. A card's annual fee, late fees and cash-advance fees are outside its purchase APR.
  • Taxes. Interest from deposits is taxed as ordinary income at federal and state level. Interest on Treasury bills is taxed federally but is exempt from state and local income tax, which raises the after-tax yield of a bill for anyone paying state income tax. How interest is taxed is covered in How dividends and interest are taxed: qualified, ordinary, muni.
  • Averages hide the spread. The FDIC national rate is a deposit-weighted average, not a typical offer. The G.19 card rate is an average across many accounts and credit scores; a given card can be well above or below it.

How the main quotes compare

Quote Rule or source Includes compounding? Used for
APR (revolving) Regulation Z, 1026.14 No Credit cards, lines
APR (instalment) Regulation Z, 1026.22 No, but includes fees Car loans, mortgages
APY Regulation DD, App. A Yes Savings, CDs
Discount rate H.15, TreasuryDirect No, and on face value Treasury bills
Investment rate TreasuryDirect Yield on the price paid Comparing bills with APY

How Finabase does it

Finabase is an investing app, not a bank, so it shows no deposit APYs or card rates. Where it helps is the cash side of the comparison. The Treasury page shows current Treasury yields across maturities, from bills to 30-year bonds, so the bill side of the chart above can be checked on any day. Bill ETFs such as BIL show the monthly income they pass on, which reflects the bills they hold. The numbers in this lesson come from frozen copies of the Federal Reserve and FDIC series named in the sources, and the arithmetic is in the lesson's figure script.

Frequently asked questions

Is APR or APY better?

Neither is better; they describe different things. For money you owe, a lower APR is cheaper, and its compounded yearly cost is a little higher than the APR itself. For money you deposit, a higher APY earns more, and the APY already includes compounding.

Why is my card's interest higher than the APR suggests?

Because cards charge interest daily on a balance that includes yesterday's interest. At 22.36%, that turns into about 25.05% over a year on an unchanged balance. The monthly statement also uses the average daily balance for the cycle, so new purchases and the timing of payments change the charge.

How is APY calculated?

Regulation DD's formula takes the interest a deposit would earn over its term, divides by the deposit, and annualizes it: APY = 100 × [(1 + Interest/Principal)^(365/Days in term) − 1]. For an account with no maturity, it is the interest a year would earn, as a percentage of the deposit.

Why does the Treasury bill rate on a news site differ from TreasuryDirect's?

Many tables, including the Federal Reserve's, show the discount rate, which is computed on the face value and a 360-day year. TreasuryDirect also shows the investment rate, the yield on the price paid over 365 days. For a three-month bill at a 4.05% discount rate, the investment rate is about 4.15%.

Does compounding frequency matter much for savings?

Very little at typical savings rates. At 4.00%, daily compounding adds 0.08 percentage points a year over yearly compounding: $116 on $10,000 over ten years. The rate itself matters far more.

Summary

APR and APY are quoting conventions set by two federal rules. A card's APR, under Regulation Z, is a periodic rate multiplied up to a year and leaves compounding out, so a balance carried at the August 2026 average of 22.36% costs about 25.05% a year. A deposit's APY, under Regulation DD, includes compounding and is the fair way to compare accounts. Treasury bill rates are usually shown as discount rates, which understate the yield: October 2026's 4.05% three-month rate was about 4.15% on the money paid. Put on one scale, a carried card balance cost about six times what a bill earned and more than sixty times the national average savings rate, which is the arithmetic that sits under the order in which many people pay off debt, build cash and begin to invest.

Check your understanding

4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. A card has an APR of 18%. Under Regulation Z, what periodic rate does that APR stand for if interest is charged monthly?

    1. 1.5% a month
    2. 18% a month
    3. About 1.39% a month, because compounding is taken out
    Show the answer

    A. 1.5% a month For revolving credit the APR is the periodic rate times the number of periods in a year. 1.5% × 12 = 18%. Compounding is not part of the APR, which is why the yearly cost of a carried balance is a little higher.

  2. Two savings accounts both pay a 4.00% interest rate. One compounds daily, the other yearly. Which number tells you which earns more?

    1. The APR
    2. The APY, because it includes compounding
    3. Neither: they earn the same
    Show the answer

    B. The APY, because it includes compounding Regulation DD defines the APY from the interest actually earned, so it captures compounding: 4.08% for daily, 4.00% for yearly. Deposit accounts must disclose both the interest rate and the APY.

  3. The Federal Reserve’s table shows a three-month Treasury bill at 4.05%. Why is the yield on the money you pay higher than that?

    1. Because bill interest is exempt from federal tax
    2. Because the 4.05% is a discount rate, computed on the face value and a 360-day year, not on the lower price paid over 365 days
    3. Because bills compound daily
    Show the answer

    B. Because the 4.05% is a discount rate, computed on the face value and a 360-day year, not on the lower price paid over 365 days H.15 bill rates are on a discount basis. Converting to an investment yield (365 × d ÷ (360 − d × days)) gives about 4.15% for 91 days.

  4. Someone has $2,000 in a savings account earning the November 2026 national rate and a $2,000 card balance at the August 2026 average rate. What does the arithmetic of the two rates say?

    1. The two roughly cancel out
    2. The balance costs far more a year (about $500) than the savings earn (about $8)
    3. The savings earn more because the APY includes compounding
    Show the answer

    B. The balance costs far more a year (about $500) than the savings earn (about $8) About 25% a year on $2,000 is roughly $500; 0.39% on $2,000 is under $8. Whether to use savings to pay a card also depends on keeping cash for emergencies, which is a personal decision.

Exercise

One task to do in Finabase. Nothing is graded or saved.

Open the Treasury page and note the 1-month and 3-month yields. Using the lesson’s numbers, put three rates side by side: the 3-month yield, the 0.39% national savings rate and the 25.05% a year a card balance at 22.36% APR costs with daily compounding. How many times the bill yield does the card cost?

Open Treasury yields
What you should find

With bill yields near 4%, a carried card balance costs about six times what a bill earns and far more than a savings account at the national rate pays. The quoting conventions move these numbers by tenths of a point; the choice of product moves them by whole points.

Sources and further reading

  1. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau — Regulation DD (Truth in Savings), Appendix A to Part 1030: annual percentage yield calculation
  2. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau — Regulation DD, 12 CFR 1030.4: account disclosures (annual percentage yield and interest rate)
  3. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau — Regulation Z, 12 CFR 1026.14: determination of annual percentage rate (open-end credit)
  4. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau — Regulation Z, 12 CFR 1026.22: determination of annual percentage rate (closed-end credit)
  5. Federal Reserve Board — G.19 Consumer Credit release (interest rate on credit card plans)
  6. Federal Reserve Board — H.15 Selected Interest Rates (Treasury bill rates are on a discount basis)
  7. FDIC — National rates and rate caps (savings, money market and CD national rates)
  8. TreasuryDirect — Understanding pricing and interest rates (bill price from the discount rate)
  9. U.S. Code — 31 U.S.C. 3124: exemption of US government obligations from state and local taxation
  10. Finabase calculations from FRED copies of the Federal Reserve series TERMCBCCINTNS (August 2026) and TB3MS (October 2026) and the FDIC series SNDR, MMNDR and NDR12MCD (November 2026)