Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Personal finance · Before you invest

CDs vs. Treasury bills: yield, state tax, early exit and safety

How bank CDs and Treasury bills compare on yield, taxes, early exit and safety, with FDIC and Federal Reserve rates for 2021 to 2026 and $10,000 worked through.

On this page
  1. How each works
  2. What they paid, 2021 to 2026
  3. Worked example: $10,000 for one year
  4. Getting the money out early
  5. Safety
  6. Taxes
  7. Side by side
  8. Which to use when
  9. How Finabase does it
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. Summary
  12. Check your understanding

A certificate of deposit (CD) is a bank deposit locked for a set term at a set rate. A Treasury bill is a short-term loan to the US government, bought at a discount and repaid at face value in four to 52 weeks. Both are among the safest places in the US to put cash for a known period, and both pay a rate fixed at the start. They differ in who stands behind them, how they are taxed, what happens if the money is needed early, and, over the past few years, in how much they paid.

This lesson compares the two on real rates: the FDIC's national 12-month CD rate against the Federal Reserve's three-month bill rate from 2021 to 2026, then a worked example of $10,000 for a year, before and after federal and state tax. It ends with the cases where each fits better.

How each works

A bank CD is opened at a bank or credit union for a term from a few months to several years. The rate is fixed for the term; interest may compound and is credited monthly or at maturity. The bank must disclose the APY and any penalty for early withdrawal before the account is opened (Regulation DD). At maturity many CDs renew automatically for another term unless the saver acts within a short grace window.

A brokered CD is a CD issued by a bank but bought through a brokerage. It is still FDIC-insured up to the limit at the issuing bank, but it usually cannot be cashed with the bank early; instead it is sold to another investor on the secondary market at whatever price that investor will pay.

A Treasury bill is sold at auction in terms from 4 to 52 weeks (weekly for terms up to 26 weeks, every four weeks for the 52-week bill), with a $100 minimum at TreasuryDirect, or bought through a broker at auction or on the secondary market. It pays no coupon: the buyer pays less than face value and receives face value at maturity; the difference is the interest. Quotes in the Federal Reserve's tables use a discount rate, which understates the yield on money paid; Treasury bill rates: discount rate vs investment rate, with the math and APR vs. APY: how US rates are quoted and how to compare them explain the conversion.

What they paid, 2021 to 2026

12-month CD national rate vs the 3-month Treasury bill, April 2021 to November 2026, % 0% 1% 2% 3% 4% 5% 6% 3-month bill (investment yield, H.15) 12-month CD (FDIC national rate) 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
Monthly. 3-month bill: Federal Reserve H.15 secondary-market rate, converted from the discount basis to an investment yield. 12-month CD: FDIC national rate (deposit-weighted average). FRED copies downloaded November 18, 2026.

When the Federal Reserve raised rates in 2022 and 2023, bill yields followed within weeks. The national CD rate moved slowly and topped out under 1.9%. In October 2023 the bill yielded about 5.49% while the national 12-month CD averaged 1.79%. In late 2026 the gap was still 2.34 points.

The national rate is a deposit-weighted average, so the largest banks, which pay little, dominate it. It is not what a saver who shops can get: online banks, credit unions and brokered CDs have often paid within a few tenths of bill yields. The chart is the clearest picture of what not shopping costs, not a quote of the best CD.

Worked example: $10,000 for one year

Take the late-2026 rates and a saver in the 22% federal bracket living in a state with a 5% income tax.

The rolled bills carry a risk the CD does not: if rates fall during the year, each new bill pays less. A 12-month CD, or a 52-week bill, locks the rate for the whole year.

Getting the money out early

  • Bank CD: the bank sets the early-withdrawal penalty and discloses it; common penalties are a number of months of interest, larger for longer terms. Ninety days' interest on a 4.00% CD of $10,000 is about $99. Regulation D sets only a floor: at least seven days' simple interest on money withdrawn within six days of deposit. A penalty can exceed the interest earned and eat into principal.
  • Brokered CD: usually no early redemption with the bank; it must be sold on the secondary market. If rates have risen, the price will be below what was paid.
  • Treasury bill: can be sold through a broker any business day. Because a bill matures within a year, its price moves little when rates change; a three-month bill's price changes by roughly a quarter of a percent for a one-point move in rates. Bills held at TreasuryDirect must first be transferred to a broker, after a 45-day hold, to be sold.

Safety

A bank CD is insured by the FDIC (or the NCUA at credit unions) up to $250,000 per depositor, per insured bank, per ownership category, covering principal and accrued interest. A Treasury bill is a direct obligation of the US government, backed by its full faith and credit, with no dollar cap. For balances under the insurance limit, the practical credit risk of either is negligible. Above it, bills avoid spreading money across several banks.

Taxes

Both pay interest taxed as ordinary federal income. The difference is state tax: federal law (31 U.S.C. § 3124) exempts interest on US government obligations from state and local income tax, and bill interest qualifies. CD interest is taxable by the state. Timing differs too: a bill's interest is taxed in the year it matures or is sold, so a bill bought in November and maturing in February moves the interest into the next tax year; CD interest is taxable as credited, even if it stays in the account. More detail is in How interest income is taxed: savings, CDs, T-bills and money funds.

Side by side

Feature Bank CD Treasury bill
Issuer A bank or credit union US Treasury
Terms Months to years 4 to 52 weeks
Protection FDIC/NCUA, $250,000 per depositor per bank Full faith and credit, no cap
Rate quote APY Discount rate (convert to investment yield)
State income tax Yes Exempt
Early exit Bank penalty (brokered: sell at market) Sell at market price, small moves
Late 2026 benchmark 1.81% national 12-month average 4.15% three-month investment yield

Which to use when

  • Highest after-tax yield in a state with income tax: bills start with a built-in advantage; compare a CD's rate after state tax with the bill yield.
  • A term over a year, or a rate locked for the full term: CDs come in longer terms; bills top out at 52 weeks (Treasury notes cover two to ten years).
  • Simplicity at an existing bank: a CD at the saver's own bank is a few clicks; check the rate against the national average and bill yields first, and check the renewal setting.
  • Possible early need: a bill can be sold for close to its value; a bank CD's penalty is fixed in advance and can be large; a no-penalty CD is another option, usually at a lower rate.
  • More than $250,000: bills avoid the insurance cap; CDs need several banks or ownership categories.
  • A ladder: both work. Splitting money across maturities a few months apart keeps part of it reachable and averages rates over time.

How Finabase does it

Finabase does not sell CDs or bills. The Treasury page shows current Treasury yields, from one-month bills to 30-year bonds, for comparing against a CD offer on any day. Bill ETFs such as SGOV have symbol pages listing the monthly income they pay, which tracks bill yields with a short lag. The rates on this page come from frozen FRED copies of the FDIC and H.15 series named in the sources, computed in the lesson's figure script.

Frequently asked questions

Are Treasury bills better than CDs?

Neither is better in general. In late 2026 bills yielded more than the national CD average, and their interest is free of state tax, but many CDs paid close to bill yields, offered longer terms and were simpler to buy at a bank. Compare the after-tax yield for your state.

Are T-bills safer than CDs?

Both are very safe. CDs are FDIC-insured up to $250,000 per depositor, per bank, per ownership category; bills are backed by the US government without a cap. Above $250,000 at one bank, bills avoid the insurance limit.

Can I lose money on a CD or a T-bill?

A bank CD held to maturity returns principal and interest; cashing it early can cost a penalty larger than the interest earned. A bill held to maturity pays face value; sold early, its price may be slightly lower or higher than paid.

Do I pay state tax on T-bill interest?

No. Interest on Treasury bills is exempt from state and local income tax under 31 U.S.C. § 3124. It is taxed federally as ordinary income.

Summary

CDs and Treasury bills both lock a rate for a set term and are about as safe as US cash gets. Bills are government debt with no insurance cap and state-tax-free interest, quoted on a discount basis, and can be sold before maturity at a market price that barely moves. CDs are bank deposits, insured to $250,000, offered in longer terms, with penalties for early withdrawal and interest taxed by the state. In late 2026 the national 12-month CD averaged 1.81% against a 4.15% bill yield, but the best CDs paid far more than the average, so the comparison that matters is a specific CD's after-tax rate against the bill yield on the same day.

Check your understanding

4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. A saver in a state with a 5% income tax and the 22% federal bracket is offered a 4.00% CD. Roughly what bill yield leaves the same after tax?

    1. 4.00%
    2. About 3.74%, because bill interest escapes the state tax
    3. About 4.26%
    Show the answer

    B. About 3.74%, because bill interest escapes the state tax The CD keeps 73% of its interest (1 − 0.22 − 0.05); the bill keeps 78%. 4.00% × 0.73 ÷ 0.78 ≈ 3.74%.

  2. Why did the FDIC national 12-month CD rate stay under 1.9% while bill yields passed 5% in 2023?

    1. CDs are riskier than bills
    2. The national rate is a deposit-weighted average dominated by large banks that pay little; many other banks paid far more
    3. Federal law caps CD rates
    Show the answer

    B. The national rate is a deposit-weighted average dominated by large banks that pay little; many other banks paid far more The average reflects where deposits sit, not the best offers. Shopping among banks and brokered CDs narrowed the gap considerably.

  3. A saver needs her money four months into a 12-month bank CD. What usually happens?

    1. She sells it at market price
    2. The bank charges the early-withdrawal penalty disclosed when the CD was opened, often months of interest
    3. She must wait until maturity
    Show the answer

    B. The bank charges the early-withdrawal penalty disclosed when the CD was opened, often months of interest Bank CDs carry a penalty set and disclosed by the bank. A brokered CD, by contrast, is sold on the secondary market; a bill is sold at its market price.

  4. Someone wants to hold $600,000 in cash-like assets with no exposure to a single bank. Which fits more simply?

    1. One bank CD
    2. Treasury bills, which have no insurance cap
    3. Either; FDIC insurance has no limit on CDs
    Show the answer

    B. Treasury bills, which have no insurance cap FDIC insurance covers $250,000 per depositor, per bank, per ownership category. Bills are backed by the US government without a cap.

Sources and further reading

  1. FDIC — National rates and rate caps (12-month CD national rate 1.81%, November 2026; method)
  2. Federal Reserve Board — H.15 Selected Interest Rates (3-month Treasury bill, secondary market, discount basis)
  3. TreasuryDirect — Treasury bills (terms from 4 to 52 weeks, $100 minimum, federal tax only)
  4. TreasuryDirect — Understanding pricing and interest rates (price from the discount rate, investment rate)
  5. FDIC — Understanding deposit insurance ($250,000 per depositor, per insured bank, per ownership category)
  6. CFPB — Regulation DD, 12 CFR 1030.4(b)(6): time account disclosures, early withdrawal penalties
  7. Federal Reserve — Regulation D, 12 CFR 204.2(c): time deposits (at least seven days’ simple interest if withdrawn within six days)
  8. 31 U.S.C. § 3124 — exemption of US government obligations from state and local taxation
  9. FINRA — Notice to Members 02-69, brokered certificates of deposit (pre-maturity sale price may be below the purchase price)
  10. TreasuryDirect — Selling marketable securities (transfer to a broker first; 45-day holding period)
  11. Finabase calculations from FRED copies of FDIC NDR12MCD and H.15 TB3MS (downloaded November 18, 2026)