Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Personal finance · Saving for goals

Saving for a house down payment: targets, time and where to hold it

What 3%, 3.5%, 10% and 20% down cost on the $393,300 median US house, how mortgage insurance ends, how long each target takes to save, and where the money can wait.

On this page
  1. The four common targets
  2. Why 20% keeps coming up: mortgage insurance
  3. How long each target takes
  4. Where the money can wait
  5. Retirement accounts as a source
  6. Pitfalls
  7. How Finabase does it
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. Summary
  10. Check your understanding

A down payment is the part of a home's price paid in cash at purchase. The rest is borrowed. It is usually the largest sum a household saves for outside retirement, and it is saved on a deadline: the money has to be there, in full, when a seller accepts an offer.

That deadline is what makes it an investing question. Money needed in two to five years cannot ride out a bad stock market the way retirement savings can. A portfolio that falls a third the year before a purchase delays the purchase, or shrinks it.

This lesson works out what the common down payment sizes cost on the median US house, how private mortgage insurance ties into the 20% figure, how long each target takes at several monthly amounts, and what history says about holding the money in cash or in shares for three and five years. Mortgages themselves, their rates and how to shop for one, are outside its scope.

The four common targets

A down payment is stated as a share of the price. The share sets the loan size, and the loan size sets the monthly payment and whether mortgage insurance is needed. Four shares come up most often in the US:

  • 3%. Fannie Mae announced in December 2014 an option allowing qualified first-time homebuyers to borrow 97% of the value, a down payment as low as 3%. Lenders set their own further conditions.
  • 3.5%. The smallest down payment on an FHA-insured loan. HUD set the rule in 2010: a minimum FICO score of 580 qualifies for 3.5% down; a borrower below 580 must put down at least 10%. FHA loans carry their own mortgage insurance, with different rules from the private kind below.
  • 10%. A common middle figure, and the FHA minimum for scores under 580.
  • 20%. The point at which a conventional loan normally needs no private mortgage insurance.

Applied to the median sales price of houses sold in the US, $393,300 in the third quarter of 2026 (Census Bureau and HUD), the targets are:

Down payment on the median US house sold, $393,300 (Q3 2026) 3% down $11,799 3.5% down (FHA) $13,766 10% down $39,330 20% down $78,660 Census/HUD median sales price of houses sold (MSPUS), Q3 2026. Closing costs not included.
Down payment at four common shares of the Q3 2026 median sales price of houses sold in the US (MSPUS). Closing costs are not included.
Down payment Cash at closing Loan Mortgage insurance
3% $11,799 $381,501 Private, until it ends
3.5% (FHA) $13,766 $379,535 FHA's own premium
10% $39,330 $353,970 Private, until it ends
20% $78,660 $314,640 Usually none

The median is a national figure for houses sold, new and existing, and local prices differ widely. The arithmetic scales: a $250,000 home needs half these amounts again plus a little. Closing costs, the fees and prepaid items paid at settlement, are itemized on the lender's Loan Estimate and vary by state, lender and loan, so this lesson leaves them as a separate line the saver adds to the target.

Why 20% keeps coming up: mortgage insurance

Private mortgage insurance (PMI) protects the lender, not the borrower, against a loss if the borrower defaults. Lenders generally require it on conventional loans with less than 20% down. It is a monthly cost on top of the loan payment, and it is not permanent.

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau sets out the federal rules for single-family principal residences with loans closed on or after July 29, 1999:

  1. On request at 80%. The borrower can ask, in writing, to cancel PMI once the principal balance reaches 80% of the home's original value, or earlier through extra payments. The borrower must be current with a good payment history, show there are no junior liens, and may have to show, for example with an appraisal, that the home's value has not fallen below its original value.
  2. Automatically at 78%. The servicer must end PMI on the date the balance is scheduled to reach 78% of the original value, if the borrower is current.
  3. At the midpoint. PMI must also end the month after the loan reaches the midpoint of its amortization schedule (15 years into a 30-year loan), if the borrower is current.

On a $393,300 home, 80% of the original value is a balance of $314,640 and 78% is $306,774. A buyer who puts 20% down starts at the first of those numbers. A buyer who puts 5% down reaches it only after years of payments. FHA and VA loans have different requirements, which the CFPB points readers to their servicer for.

So the choice is not 20% or nothing. A smaller down payment buys the home sooner and pays mortgage insurance for a while. A larger one costs more years of saving. Which costs more depends on the premium, the loan rate, how house prices move in the meantime, and rent paid while saving, none of which this lesson can know for a given reader.

How long each target takes

The months needed depend mostly on the monthly amount and very little on the interest rate, over periods this short. The figure uses the October 2026 average 3-month Treasury bill rate, 4.05%, as the rate on the savings, compounded monthly and held constant.

Months to save each down payment at 4.05% a year $500 a month $1,000 a month $2,000 a month 27 mo 14 mo 7 mo 3.5% down: $13,766 70 mo 37 mo 20 mo 10% down: $39,330 127 mo 70 mo 37 mo 20% down: $78,660 Interest at the Oct 2026 3-month bill average (4.05%), compounded monthly, rate held constant.
Months to save each down payment on the Q3 2026 median house at three monthly amounts, earning 4.05% a year (October 2026 3-month bill average), compounded monthly.
Target (Q3 2026 median) $500 a month $1,000 a month $2,000 a month
3.5%: $13,766 27 months 14 months 7 months
10%: $39,330 70 months 37 months 20 months
20%: $78,660 127 months 70 months 37 months

Two points stand out. First, the rate matters less than it seems: three extra months on a three-year goal, against the difference between $1,000 and $2,000 a month, which halves the time. Second, the rate still pays for something. On a $39,000 balance, the gap between 0.39% and 4.05% is several hundred dollars a year, which is why the place the money waits is worth a look (next section). How a rate is quoted, and why an APY is the number to compare, is in APR vs. APY: how US rates are quoted and how to compare them.

A down payment fund also is not an emergency fund. If both live in one account, a car repair quietly delays the house. Many savers keep them separate so the target stays visible.

Where the money can wait

For a two-to-five-year goal, the options are mostly the ones described for emergency money in Where to keep an emergency fund: savings, MMDAs, funds, bills, CDs, with one difference: access on the same day matters less, and the purchase date is roughly known.

  • Insured savings and money market deposit accounts. No price risk, FDIC insurance up to the limits, rates set by the bank.
  • Treasury bills, held directly or through a fund. Values barely move before maturity, interest is free of state and local income tax, and maturities can be lined up with an expected closing date (Treasury bill rates: discount rate vs investment rate, with the math).
  • Certificates of deposit. A fixed rate for a fixed term, with an early withdrawal penalty set by the bank. A CD that matures after the closing date is a poor match.
  • I bonds. TreasuryDirect's rules: no redemption at all for 12 months, three months of interest lost if cashed before five years, and $10,000 of electronic bonds per person per calendar year. They can hold part of a goal several years out; the 12-month lock and the purchase limit make them awkward for all of one (I bonds: how the rate is set, the rules, and what $10,000 earned).

What shares did over three and five years

Shares have earned more than cash over long periods, so it is natural to ask whether a down payment could be invested. History gives the range of outcomes. Finabase took SPY's monthly total return (dividends reinvested) from February 1993 to October 2026 and the 3-month bill rate for the same months, then measured every window of 36 and 60 consecutive months, one starting in each month: 369 windows of three years and 345 of five.

Cumulative return over every 3- and 5-year window, 1993–2026 −50% 0% +50% +100% +150% +200% +250% 3 years S&P 500 (SPY) 3-month bills 5 years S&P 500 (SPY) 3-month bills Bar: worst to best window · tick: 10th percentile · dot: median SPY total return and 3-month bills, monthly, Mar 1993 to Oct 2026; overlapping windows.
Cumulative total return of SPY and of 3-month bills over every 36- and 60-month window, February 1993 to October 2026. Bar: worst to best window; tick: 10th percentile; dot: median.
Cumulative return, 1993–2026 Worst 10th percentile Median Windows with a loss
S&P 500, 3 years −41.3% −16.2% +40.7% 16.3%
Bills, 3 years +0.1% +0.2% +5.5% 0%
S&P 500, 5 years −29.2% −5.4% +71.9% 14.2%
Bills, 5 years +0.3% +0.5% +11.5% 0%

The median share result was far better than cash. The worst was a different kind of outcome: $50,000 invested in April 2000 was worth $29,348 three years later, and $50,000 invested in March 2004 was worth $35,411 in February 2009, after five years. A saver whose closing date fell at the end of either window would have had a much smaller down payment, or no purchase. Bills never ended a window below where they started, though in the years of near-zero rates after 2008 they earned almost nothing.

These are overlapping windows from one 34-year history, so they are not independent tries, and the next decade can produce a worse case than any here. The general relation between how soon money is needed and how much loss it can absorb is in Time horizon and risk tolerance: matching investments to goals, and the holding-period history for cash, bonds and shares side by side is in Where to keep money for short-term goals: cash, bonds or stocks.

Retirement accounts as a source

Two federal tax rules let retirement money help with a first home. Both are covered fully in the retirement lessons (Retirement accounts explained: 401(k), IRA, Roth and 2026 limits, Roth vs traditional IRA: how to compare tax now and tax later); briefly, for 2026:

  • The IRA first-home exception. IRS Publication 590-B: up to $10,000 in a lifetime of IRA distributions escapes the 10% additional tax on early distributions if used within 120 days to buy, build or rebuild a first home. A first-time homebuyer is someone with no present interest in a main home during the two years before the purchase date; a spouse must meet the test too. Income tax still applies to traditional IRA money. The exception is for IRAs, not 401(k) plans.
  • Roth IRA contributions. Under the ordering rules in the same publication, regular contributions come out of a Roth IRA first, and they come out tax-free and without the additional tax. Earnings follow; they can be withdrawn tax-free for a first home (up to the same $10,000 lifetime limit) once the account has met the five-year rule.

The cost is retirement savings that stop compounding, and IRA contribution room that cannot be refilled for past years.

Pitfalls

  • Forgetting closing costs and moving costs. A target that covers only the down payment leaves the buyer short at the table.
  • Draining the emergency fund for the down payment. A new house tends to produce repair bills early.
  • Assuming today's rate holds. Bill rates fell from 5.34% in October 2023 to 4.05% in October 2026; a plan built on one rate should be checked as rates move.
  • Treating the national median as a local price. It is a starting point for arithmetic.
  • Counting on the stock market for a fixed date. The history above shows how far a three-year result can fall short.

How Finabase does it

Finabase is an investing app and has no savings-goal tracker. The Treasury page shows today's bill yields, the rate a down payment fund held in bills earns, and T-bill ETFs such as BIL have symbol pages whose Dividends & splits tab lists their monthly payouts. Every figure in this lesson was computed by Finabase from the frozen Census/HUD, Federal Reserve and FDIC series and SPY's price and dividend history.

Frequently asked questions

How much do I need for a down payment on a house?

It depends on the price and the loan. On the Q3 2026 national median of $393,300, 3.5% is $13,766, 10% is $39,330 and 20% is $78,660, plus closing costs. Lenders and loan programs set the minimum a given buyer can use.

Is 20% down required?

No. FHA loans allow 3.5% with a 580 credit score, and some conventional programs allow 3%. Below 20%, conventional loans usually carry private mortgage insurance, which can be cancelled on request at 80% of the original value and ends automatically at 78%.

Should a down payment be invested in stocks?

That depends on the reader's timeline and how much delay they could accept. History shows the range: from 1993 to 2026, 16% of 3-year windows for the S&P 500 ended with a loss, the worst at −41.3%, while bills never lost money over the same windows.

Can I use my IRA for a down payment?

Up to $10,000 in a lifetime of IRA distributions avoids the 10% early-distribution tax for a first home, under IRS rules. Traditional IRA money is still taxed as income. Roth IRA contributions can be withdrawn at any time without tax.

Summary

A down payment is a large sum with a date attached. On the median US house in Q3 2026 it ranged from $13,766 at 3.5% to $78,660 at 20%, and below 20% a conventional loan usually adds private mortgage insurance until the balance reaches 80% of the original value on request or 78% automatically. How long the money takes depends mainly on the monthly amount: at $1,000 a month and 4.05%, 37 months for 10% and 70 for 20%. Insured accounts, bills and CDs keep the balance intact; in the 1993–2026 history, shares beat bills in most 3- and 5-year windows but lost as much as 41% in one. IRA and Roth rules can help a first purchase, at the cost of retirement savings.

Check your understanding

5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. A buyer saves for a $393,300 house. Which down payment avoids private mortgage insurance on a conventional loan from the start, in the usual case?

    1. 3.5%, or $13,766
    2. 10%, or $39,330
    3. 20%, or $78,660
    Show the answer

    C. 20%, or $78,660 Lenders generally require private mortgage insurance on conventional loans with less than 20% down. At 20% the loan starts at 80% of the home’s value, the level at which federal rules let a borrower ask to cancel PMI.

  2. Under the federal rules the CFPB describes, when must a servicer end private mortgage insurance automatically, if the borrower is current?

    1. When the balance is scheduled to reach 78% of the home’s original value
    2. When the home’s market value rises 20%
    3. After five years of payments
    Show the answer

    A. When the balance is scheduled to reach 78% of the home’s original value The borrower may request cancellation at 80% of the original value; the servicer must end it automatically when the balance is scheduled to reach 78%, or at the loan’s midpoint.

  3. Saving $1,000 a month toward a $39,330 goal, the time is 37 months at 4.05% and 40 months at 0.39%. What does that show?

    1. The interest rate is the main driver of how long a short goal takes
    2. Over a few years the monthly amount matters far more than the rate
    3. Higher rates always make a goal take longer
    Show the answer

    B. Over a few years the monthly amount matters far more than the rate A ten-fold difference in rate saved three months. Doubling the deposit to $2,000 a month cuts the same goal to about 20 months.

  4. From 1993 to 2026, what share of 3-year windows ended with a loss for the S&P 500 (SPY total return) and for 3-month bills?

    1. None for either
    2. About 16% for the S&P 500 and none for bills
    3. About half for both
    Show the answer

    B. About 16% for the S&P 500 and none for bills 16.3% of the 369 overlapping 3-year windows were losses for SPY, the worst −41.3%. Bills never ended a 3-year window below their start, though they sometimes earned almost nothing.

  5. What does the IRA first-home exception do, under IRS rules?

    1. Makes any IRA withdrawal for a house tax-free with no limit
    2. Removes the 10% early-distribution tax on up to $10,000 in a lifetime used for a first home; income tax on traditional IRA money still applies
    3. Applies to 401(k) plans as well as IRAs
    Show the answer

    B. Removes the 10% early-distribution tax on up to $10,000 in a lifetime used for a first home; income tax on traditional IRA money still applies Publication 590-B limits it to $10,000 in a lifetime, used within 120 days for a first-time homebuyer. It waives the additional tax, not the income tax, and it is an IRA exception, not a 401(k) one.

Sources and further reading

  1. U.S. Census Bureau and HUD — Median Sales Price of Houses Sold for the United States (MSPUS), quarterly, Q3 2026 (FRED copy)
  2. HUD — press release No. 10-150, July 15, 2010: minimum FICO score of 580 for FHA’s 3.5 percent down payment program; at least 10 percent down below 580
  3. Fannie Mae — news release, December 2014: 97 percent loan-to-value option (down payments as low as 3%) for qualified first-time homebuyers
  4. CFPB — When can I remove private mortgage insurance (PMI) from my loan? (request at 80%, automatic at 78%, midpoint; FHA and VA differ), reviewed August 28, 2026
  5. IRS — Publication 590-B (2025), Distributions from Individual Retirement Arrangements: first home exception ($10,000, 120 days, first-time homebuyer), Roth IRA ordering rules and qualified distributions
  6. IRS — Topic no. 557, Additional tax on early distributions from traditional and Roth IRAs
  7. TreasuryDirect — I bonds (12-month minimum, three months of interest lost before five years, $10,000 electronic limit per calendar year)
  8. FDIC — National Rates and Rate Caps (savings 0.39%, 12-month CD 1.81%, November 16, 2026)
  9. Federal Reserve Board — H.15 Selected Interest Rates (3-month Treasury bill, monthly average)
  10. Finabase calculations from the frozen series MSPUS, TB3MS and SNDR (FRED copies of Census/HUD, Federal Reserve H.15 and FDIC data, downloaded November 18, 2026) and SPY monthly total returns, February 1993 to October 2026