Bonds · Bond basics
How bonds trade: dealers, mark-ups and checking a price before you buy
See how bonds trade between dealers, what a mark-up costs in yield on short and long bonds, what your confirmation must show, and how to check a price on TRACE or EMMA.
On this page
Stocks trade on exchanges, where every buyer and seller meets in one order book and the last price is on every screen. Most bonds do not. They trade over the counter, between dealers, one negotiated trade at a time. A single company may have dozens of bond issues outstanding, and many of them change hands only occasionally, so there is often no live quote until you ask a dealer for one.
That structure decides what a bond costs to buy. This lesson explains who is on the other side of a bond trade, how dealers are paid, what a mark-up costs in yield (much more on a short bond than a long one), what US rules require your confirmation to show, and how to check a price yourself before trading.
Dealers, not an order book
A bond trade usually involves a broker-dealer, a firm that can act in two ways.
- As principal. The firm buys the bond for its own account and sells it to you, or buys yours. Its pay is the difference between its price and the market: a mark-up when you buy, a mark-down when you sell. This is how most bond trades are done.
- As agent. The firm finds the other side for you and charges a stated commission, as a stock broker does.
A common middle case is the riskless principal trade. The dealer buys a bond from another dealer only once you have ordered it, and sells it to you at once. It takes no inventory risk and earns the mark-up.
Dealers also trade with each other, by phone and on electronic platforms. FINRA's investor guidance notes that most corporate bonds trade over the counter, and municipal bonds trade the same way. Treasury securities trade the same way in the secondary market, and individuals can also buy them at auction without a dealer (How to buy Treasury bonds: TreasuryDirect vs a broker, step by step).
Prices are quoted in percent of par, as How to read a bond quote: price, 32nds, yield and bid-ask explains. A price of 101.25 on a $25,000 bond means $25,312.50 plus accrued interest.
What a mark-up costs in yield
A mark-up is a price, but a bond buyer earns a yield. The same price premium spread over a longer life costs less a year. To measure it, take bonds priced at par on the Treasury par yield curve of October 28, 2026 (coupon equal to yield), add 1 point to the price, and solve for the yield the buyer then earns.
| Maturity | Yield at 100 | Yield at 101 | Yield given up |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 year | 4.470% | 3.444% | 1.03 |
| 2 years | 4.670% | 4.144% | 0.53 |
| 5 years | 4.850% | 4.624% | 0.23 |
| 10 years | 5.050% | 4.922% | 0.13 |
| 30 years | 5.370% | 5.303% | 0.07 |
Read the 2-year and 10-year rows together. One point of mark-up takes 0.53 percentage point a year off the 2-year bond, more than a tenth of its yield. On the 10-year bond the same point takes 0.13. A mark-up that looks small in price terms can be large in yield terms on a short bond.
The cost doubles if you sell before maturity, since you pay a mark-down on the way out too. On a 5-year bond bought at a fair 100, held one year and sold with the curve unchanged, the return before costs is 4.94%. Pay 1 point on the way in and give up 1 point on the way out, and it falls to 2.91%. Method: the bond is resold as a 4-year bond at the curve's 4.825% 4-year yield, coupons spent, no taxes.
What your confirmation must show
Since May 14, 2018, two parallel rules require mark-up disclosure on retail confirmations: FINRA Rule 2232 for corporate and agency bonds and MSRB Rule G-15 for municipal bonds. The disclosure applies when:
- the firm sold to (or bought from) a non-institutional customer as principal, and
- the firm made offsetting principal trades in the same bond, of at least the same size, on the same trading day.
When both hold, the confirmation must show the mark-up or mark-down in total dollars and as a percent of the prevailing market price. Every retail confirmation in these bonds, whether or not a mark-up is shown, must also give:
- the time of execution; and
- a reference, and a link if the confirmation is electronic, to the bond's page on FINRA's TRACE data (corporates and agencies) or the MSRB's EMMA site (municipals).
The prevailing market price is the benchmark the mark-up is measured from. For municipal bonds, MSRB Rule G-30 starts from the dealer's own contemporaneous cost, and the dealer may move off it only for stated reasons, such as a change in interest rates. It also requires the total price, mark-up included, to be fair and reasonable.
A worked example, with illustrative numbers:
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Par bought | $25,000 |
| Price paid | 101.25 |
| Prevailing market price | 100.40 |
| Mark-up in dollars | $212.50 |
| Mark-up as % of PMP | 0.847% |
Bonds the dealer held from an earlier day do not fall under the same-day condition, so some trades show no mark-up figure. The cost is still there; it just has to be estimated.
The life of a trade
Reporting. FINRA requires member firms to report over-the-counter trades in eligible fixed-income securities to TRACE. For corporate bonds the deadline is 15 minutes after execution. Municipal trades are reported to the MSRB and shown on EMMA.
Best execution. FINRA Rule 5310 requires a firm handling a customer order to use reasonable diligence to find the best market and trade there so the price is as favorable as possible under prevailing conditions. The rule covers debt securities. MSRB Rule G-18 applies the same duty to municipal bonds.
Settlement. SEC Rule 15c6-1 requires settlement no later than the first business day after the trade (T+1) for most securities, including corporate bonds. The SEC set the compliance date for the move from T+2 at May 28, 2024. Government and municipal securities are outside that rule; MSRB Rule G-15 sets regular-way settlement for municipal trades with customers at the first business day after the trade date as well.
How to check a price before you trade
- Get the CUSIP. Every bond has one. Use it to look up the bond, not the issuer's name.
- Look up recent trades. FINRA's Fixed Income Data (TRACE) for corporates and agencies; EMMA for municipals. Note the size of each trade: prices for $25,000 can differ from prices for $5 million, and the larger trades are closer to the dealer market.
- Compare buys and sells by customers. Customer buys sit above dealer-to-dealer trades by roughly the mark-up; customer sells sit below by the mark-down.
- Check the yield, not just the price. Ask for the yield to worst at your price and compare it with a Treasury of similar maturity on the Treasury page.
- Ask whether the firm is acting as principal or agent, and what it is charging.
- Read the confirmation for the mark-up in dollars and percent.
A price far above recent prints, without a move in rates to explain it, is a question to ask before trading.
Pitfalls
- Judging cost in price points alone. On a 1-year bond, 1 point is more than a full point of yield.
- Assuming "no commission" means free. In a principal trade the cost is in the price.
- Comparing with odd trades. A single small trade on EMMA or TRACE can be an outlier.
- Ignoring the exit. Selling an individual bond early costs a mark-down.
- Forgetting accrued interest. It is added to the price you pay, not a cost.
How Finabase does it
Finabase quotes yields and exchange-traded funds, not individual bonds.
- The Treasury page gives the risk-free yield at each maturity, the yardstick for a bond's yield after the mark-up.
- Bond ETFs such as LQD for corporates and MUB for municipals trade on exchanges with a visible bid and ask, an alternative way to hold bonds that Bond ETFs vs individual bonds: maturity, risk and cost compared compares.
The yield costs in this lesson were computed by Finabase from the Treasury par curve of October 28, 2026: semiannual coupons, bonds priced on a coupon date, no taxes. The confirmation example uses illustrative numbers.
Frequently asked questions
What is a bond mark-up?
The amount a dealer adds to the prevailing market price when it sells you a bond from its own account. It is the dealer's pay on a principal trade, in place of a commission.
Do I have to be told the mark-up on a bond?
For many retail trades, yes. Since May 14, 2018, FINRA Rule 2232 and MSRB Rule G-15 require the confirmation to show it in dollars and percent when the firm bought or sold the same bond on the same day to offset your trade.
Where can I see what a bond last traded at?
FINRA's TRACE data for corporate and agency bonds, and the MSRB's EMMA website for municipal bonds. Both are free to the public.
How long does a bond trade take to settle?
One business day for corporate and municipal trades: SEC Rule 15c6-1 has required T+1 since May 28, 2024, and MSRB Rule G-15 sets the same regular-way date for municipal bonds.
Why does a mark-up hurt more on a short-term bond?
Because it is spread over fewer years. One point is about 0.53 percentage point a year on a 2-year bond and 0.13 on a 10-year bond.
Summary
Bonds trade over the counter with dealers, usually as principal, who are paid through a mark-up on sales and a mark-down on purchases. In yield terms a mark-up costs most on short bonds: one point takes 0.53 point a year off a 2-year bond and 0.13 off a 10-year bond. Since May 14, 2018, retail confirmations for same-day principal trades in corporate, agency and municipal bonds show the mark-up in dollars and as a percent of the prevailing market price, with a link to the bond's TRACE or EMMA page. Firms owe customers best execution, and trades settle T+1. Before buying, look up recent prints by CUSIP and compare the yield to worst with a Treasury of similar maturity.
Check your understanding
5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
A dealer sells you a corporate bond from its own account at a price above the prevailing market price. What is the difference called?
- A commission
- A mark-up
- Accrued interest
Show the answer
B. A mark-up In a principal trade the dealer is paid through the price. A commission is charged when the firm acts as agent. Accrued interest is the coupon earned since the last payment date.
You pay 101 for two par bonds, one maturing in 2 years and one in 10. On which does the extra point cost more yield each year?
- The 2-year bond: about 0.53 point against 0.13
- The 10-year bond, because it is longer
- The same on both
Show the answer
A. The 2-year bond: about 0.53 point against 0.13 The premium is spread over fewer years on the short bond. On the October 28, 2026 Treasury curve the 2-year gives up 0.53 point of yield, the 10-year 0.13.
Under FINRA Rule 2232 and MSRB Rule G-15, when must a retail confirmation show the mark-up?
- On every bond trade
- When the firm traded as principal with a non-institutional customer and made offsetting trades in the same bond, of at least the same size, on the same trading day
- Only on Treasury purchases
Show the answer
B. When the firm traded as principal with a non-institutional customer and made offsetting trades in the same bond, of at least the same size, on the same trading day Both conditions must hold. The mark-up is then shown in dollars and as a percent of the prevailing market price. The execution time and a link to the bond’s TRACE or EMMA page appear on every retail confirmation.
Where can you look up recent trade prices for a municipal bond?
- The MSRB’s EMMA website
- Only from the dealer selling it
- The NYSE order book
Show the answer
A. The MSRB’s EMMA website EMMA shows municipal trade prices to the public. FINRA’s TRACE data does the same for corporate and agency bonds.
How soon must a US corporate bond trade settle under SEC Rule 15c6-1?
- Three business days after the trade
- The first business day after the trade (T+1), since May 28, 2024
- The same day
Show the answer
B. The first business day after the trade (T+1), since May 28, 2024 The SEC shortened the standard cycle from T+2 to T+1 with a compliance date of May 28, 2024.
Sources and further reading
- FINRA Rule 2232 — Customer Confirmations (mark-up and mark-down disclosure, amended effective May 14, 2018)
- MSRB Rule G-15 — Confirmation, Clearance, Settlement and Other Uniform Practice Requirements (mark-up disclosure effective May 14, 2018; regular-way settlement)
- MSRB Rule G-30 — Prices and Commissions (fair and reasonable prices; prevailing market price)
- FINRA Rule 5310 — Best Execution and Interpositioning
- MSRB Rule G-18 — Best Execution
- FINRA — Trade Reporting and Compliance Engine (TRACE)
- FINRA — Bonds: how bonds trade, mark-ups and mark-downs
- 17 CFR 240.15c6-1 — Settlement cycle (eCFR)
- SEC — press release 2023-29, shortening the settlement cycle (compliance date May 28, 2024)
- MSRB — Electronic Municipal Market Access (EMMA)
