Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Bonds · Building a bond portfolio

Immunization: matching duration to a future bill

Fund a known sum on a known date by matching a bond holding’s duration to it: why it works for parallel moves, where twists break it, and why it needs rebalancing.

On this page
  1. The setup
  2. The result
  3. Why it works
  4. The match decays
  5. Twists break it
  6. Where it is used
  7. Pitfalls
  8. How Finabase does it
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. Summary
  11. Check your understanding

Suppose you need $100,000 in eight years: tuition, a balloon payment, a pension cheque. You can buy bonds today, but you do not know where interest rates will go. If they rise, bond prices fall. If they fall, coupons are reinvested at less. Is there a holding that delivers the $100,000 either way?

There is, approximately, and it is called immunization. The idea, set out by the actuary Frank Redington in 1952, is to hold bonds whose duration equals the time until the money is needed. This lesson builds three candidate holdings for an eight-year goal at a 5% yield, moves rates, and shows which one arrives on target, why, and what can still go wrong.

The setup

  • Goal: $100,000 in 8 years.
  • Yield today: 5% on every maturity, compounded twice a year.
  • Cost today: $100,000 ÷ 1.025^16 = $67,362.49.

Three ways to invest $67,362.49:

  1. A 3-year bond, reinvested in new bonds when it matures. Duration 2.82 years.
  2. A 30-year bond, sold after eight years. Duration 15.84 years.
  3. A 10-year bond, sold after eight years. Duration 7.99 years: matched.

All three are 5% coupon bonds at par. Right after purchase all yields move to a new level and stay there. Coupons are reinvested at the new level. What is each worth after eight years?

The result

Value in year 8 of three ways to fund a $100,000 goal, by where yields go $60k $80k $100k $120k $140k $160k 2% 3% 4% 5% 6% 7% 8% Goal 30-year bond, sold in year 8 3-year bond, then reinvested 10-year bond, duration 8 years Yield on all maturities after the move (started at 5%) Thousands of dollars
$67,362 invested at 5%; all yields move once, right after purchase, and stay there. Coupons reinvested at the new yield. Computed by Finabase.
Yields move to 8-year zero 10-year bond 3-year, rolled 30-year, sold
3% $100,000 $100,158 $90,352 $119,145
4% $100,000 $100,035 $95,064 $108,547
5% (unchanged) $100,000 $100,000 $100,000 $100,000
6% $100,000 $100,056 $105,169 $93,139
7% $100,000 $100,205 $110,582 $87,669

The short bond has too little duration. Its price barely reacts, but almost all of the money is reinvested at the new rate. Falling rates leave it $9,648 short.

The long bond has too much. Most of its value at year 8 is the sale price of a 22-year bond, which swings widely. Rising rates leave it $12,331 short.

The matched bond lands on the target every time. At 3%, its sale price is higher and its reinvested coupons earn less; at 7%, the reverse. With a duration equal to the horizon, the two effects cancel. The small gains on both sides, $35 to $205, come from convexity.

The 8-year zero-coupon bond is the perfect hedge: one payment of exactly $100,000 on the right date, no coupons to reinvest, no sale. This is called cash-flow matching or dedication, and for a single date it beats immunization. Treasury STRIPS make it possible (Zero-coupon bonds: pricing, STRIPS, rate risk and phantom income). Immunization matters when the liabilities are many, or when suitable zeros are not available or cost more.

Why it works

Reinvestment risk: why a bond rarely earns its yield to maturity showed the same bond from the other side: for a 10-year 5% bond, the wealth after eight years was almost the same whether yields went to 3%, 5% or 7%.

Condition 1 makes the holding big enough. Condition 2 makes small parallel shifts change both sides by the same amount. Condition 3 makes larger shifts leave the assets slightly ahead, which is the small surplus in the table.

Duration here is Macaulay duration, measured in years: the present-value-weighted average time of a bond's payments. Bond duration and convexity: measuring interest-rate risk explains it and its relation to the modified duration used for price sensitivity.

The match decays

Duration does not fall one year per year. As a coupon bond ages, its duration shortens, but more slowly than the calendar.

Why a matched bond does not stay matched: duration falls more slowly than time Years left to the goal Duration of the original 10-year bond 8.0 8.0 Today 6.0 6.7 After 2y 4.0 5.3 After 4y 2.0 3.7 After 6y 0.0 1.9 After 8y Macaulay duration in years of a 5% bond at a 5% yield. The gap is closed by rebalancing.
Macaulay duration in years of a 5% coupon bond at a 5% yield as it ages. Computed by Finabase.
Years passed Years left Duration of the original 10-year bond
0 8 7.99
2 6 6.69
4 4 5.26
6 2 3.67
8 0 1.93

After four years the holding is long by more than a year. Leave it alone and it is no longer immunized; it has become, in the language above, partly a "30-year bond sold early". The fix is to rebalance: after four years, swap into bonds with a duration of four years (for example, a 5-year 5% bond has a duration of 4.49 and a 4-year bond 3.67, so a mix of the two would do). Each rebalance costs trading spreads, and a changing yield also changes duration, so in practice the holding is reviewed periodically and the match is kept within a band.

Twists break it

Everything above assumed one flat yield that moved in parallel. Real curves twist. Take a fourth holding with the same 8-year duration built differently: 60.2% in the 3-year bond and 39.8% in the 30-year bond, a barbell (Barbell vs bullet: two ways to hold the same duration).

Yields move to Barbell with duration 8
3% everywhere $101,803
7% everywhere $101,469
Short to 4%, long to 6% $94,298
Short to 6%, long to 4% $106,512

In parallel moves the barbell does even better than the matched bullet, because its convexity is about twice as large (145.6 against 73.6). But when short yields fall and long yields rise, it reinvests its short bond at 4% and sells its long bond at a 6% yield: both legs lose, and it ends $5,702 short.

The lesson: immunization with a bullet, a holding concentrated near the horizon, is far less exposed to twists than an equal-duration barbell. The closer the cash flows sit to the liability date, the less the shape of the curve matters. In the limit, a zero maturing on the date is exposed to nothing.

Where it is used

  • Pension funds and insurers match the duration of bond holdings to the duration of promised payments. This is the core of what is called liability-driven investing.
  • Defined-maturity bond funds and target-maturity ETFs hold bonds maturing in a single year and wind up then, which approximates a bullet for an individual.
  • Individuals saving for a dated goal often get the same effect with a ladder or a single Treasury maturing on the date. Bond ladders: how to build one and what it does when rates change covers that route.

Pitfalls

  • Matching maturity instead of duration. An 8-year coupon bond has a duration of about 6.7 years; matching its maturity leaves it short of the horizon in duration terms.
  • Setting and forgetting. Duration drifts as bonds age and yields change.
  • Assuming parallel shifts. Twists and changes in credit spreads can still open a gap.
  • Ignoring default risk. Immunization handles rate risk. A corporate bond that defaults breaks any match. Treasuries avoid this.
  • Ignoring calls and prepayments. Callable bonds and mortgage securities change duration exactly when rates move, which defeats the purpose.

How Finabase does it

All figures were computed by Finabase: 5% coupon bonds bought at par at a flat 5% yield, semiannual coupons and compounding, one immediate move in yields held until year 8, coupons and matured principal reinvested at the new yield, bonds sold in year 8 priced at the new yield, no taxes or trading costs.

Frequently asked questions

What is bond immunization?

Holding bonds whose present value and duration match those of a future payment, so that a parallel change in interest rates leaves the holding able to make that payment.

Why does matching duration protect against rate changes?

At a horizon equal to the duration, a fall in bond prices from higher rates is offset by higher reinvestment income, and the reverse when rates fall.

Is a zero-coupon bond the same as immunization?

It is the exact version for a single date: one payment of the right size on the right day. Immunization approximates that with coupon bonds and must be rebalanced.

How often does an immunized portfolio need rebalancing?

Whenever its duration drifts too far from the time remaining, which happens with the passage of time and with changes in yields. Institutions review it regularly; the right frequency weighs drift against trading costs.

What risks does immunization not cover?

Non-parallel changes in the yield curve, default, calls and prepayments, and liabilities whose size is itself uncertain.

Summary

To meet a known payment on a known date despite unknown rates, hold bonds worth the payment's present value with a duration equal to the time remaining. A 10-year 5% bond, with an eight-year duration, delivered an eight-year $100,000 goal to within $205 across yields from 3% to 7%, where a shorter or longer bond missed by $9,000 to $12,000. The match decays as bonds age and must be reset, and it protects against parallel moves, not twists: a barbell of the same duration fell $5,700 short in a twist. A zero-coupon bond maturing on the date is the exact solution for a single payment.

Check your understanding

5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. You need a fixed sum in 8 years. Which bond holding protects that sum best against a parallel change in yields right after you buy?

    1. A bond with an 8-year maturity
    2. A bond with an 8-year Macaulay duration
    3. A 3-year bond, rolled over
    Show the answer

    B. A bond with an 8-year Macaulay duration Immunization matches duration, not maturity. An 8-year coupon bond has a duration of only about 6.7 years.

  2. Why does the matched holding arrive on target whether rates rise or fall?

    1. Its price never changes
    2. At the horizon, the price effect and the reinvestment effect of a rate change cancel
    3. It pays no coupons
    Show the answer

    B. At the horizon, the price effect and the reinvestment effect of a rate change cancel Higher rates lower the sale price but raise reinvestment income; lower rates do the reverse. At a horizon equal to the duration they offset.

  3. Four years after buying a 10-year bond to fund an 8-year goal, the bond’s duration is 5.26 and four years remain. What should happen?

    1. Nothing: it is still matched
    2. Rebalance toward bonds with about a 4-year duration
    3. Buy longer bonds
    Show the answer

    B. Rebalance toward bonds with about a 4-year duration Duration falls more slowly than time passes, so the holding has become too long. Rebalancing restores the match.

  4. A barbell with the same 8-year duration is hit by short yields falling to 4% and long yields rising to 6%. What happens?

    1. It still meets the goal exactly
    2. It falls short, because both legs lose
    3. It does better than the goal
    Show the answer

    B. It falls short, because both legs lose The short leg is reinvested at a lower rate and the long leg is sold at a higher yield. In the example it ended $5,702 short. Immunization covers parallel moves only.

  5. Which holding meets a single dated payment exactly, with no rebalancing?

    1. A 30-year bond
    2. A zero-coupon bond maturing on that date
    3. A bond fund
    Show the answer

    B. A zero-coupon bond maturing on that date A zero pays one known amount on one date. There is nothing to reinvest and nothing to sell.

Sources and further reading

  1. F. M. Redington, “Review of the Principles of Life-Office Valuations,” Journal of the Institute of Actuaries, vol. 78 (1952) — immunization
  2. Frederick R. Macaulay, Some Theoretical Problems Suggested by the Movements of Interest Rates, Bond Yields and Stock Prices in the United States since 1856 (National Bureau of Economic Research, 1938) — duration
  3. TreasuryDirect — STRIPS
  4. FINRA — Bonds: interest rate risk and reinvestment risk