Fundamentals · Ratios
ROE vs. ROIC: return on equity or return on all capital
How ROE and ROIC differ, why Home Depot’s ROE is 146% while its ROIC is 25%, and which return to use when debt and buybacks shrink equity.
On this page
Return on equity (ROE) measures the profit a company earns for each dollar of its shareholders' money. Return on invested capital (ROIC) measures the operating profit earned on every dollar put into the business, by shareholders and lenders together. Both are "returns on capital", both are quoted as percentages, and for companies with little debt they come out close. For companies with a lot of debt, or that have bought back much of their stock, they can be worlds apart.
Home Depot's ROE in its fiscal year 2025 (ended February 1, 2026) was 145.5%. Its ROIC was 24.7%. The business did not change between the two calculations; only the denominator did. Home Depot has $55.8 billion of debt and, after years of buybacks, only $12.8 billion of shareholders' equity, so a profit that is a solid return on all its capital is an enormous return on the thin slice that belongs to shareholders. This page explains the difference, works it on eight companies, and shows when each ratio is the right one.
The two ratios compared
| ROE | ROIC | |
|---|---|---|
| Numerator | Net income (after interest and tax) | NOPAT: operating income × (1 − tax rate) |
| Denominator | Shareholders’ equity | Equity + debt (often less excess cash) |
| Whose return? | Shareholders only | All providers of capital |
| Effect of more debt | Usually raises it | Neutral |
| Effect of buybacks | Raises it (smaller equity) | Small, unless funded by debt |
| Negative equity | Not meaningful | Still meaningful |
| Compare it with | Cost of equity | WACC, the weighted average cost of all capital |
| Full lesson | Return on equity (ROE): formula, DuPont analysis and pitfalls | Return on invested capital (ROIC): NOPAT, capital and WACC |
This page uses the "financing" definition of invested capital (equity plus borrowings, averaged over the year, operating leases left out) so every company is treated the same way. Subtracting cash, or adding leases, changes the level; the Return on invested capital (ROIC): NOPAT, capital and WACC lesson shows how much.
Eight companies, two returns
From each company's latest Form 10-K, read from SEC EDGAR:
| Company | ROE | ROIC | Debt ÷ equity |
|---|---|---|---|
| Home Depot (FY2025) | 145.5% | 24.7% | 4.35 |
| Microsoft (FY2026) | 34.0% | 28.8% | 0.09 |
| Costco (FY2026) | 28.4% | 22.9% | 0.17 |
| Procter & Gamble (FY2026) | 30.2% | 17.9% | 0.63 |
| Walmart (FY2026) | 23.0% | 16.4% | 0.45 |
| Cisco (FY2026) | 27.3% | 16.5% | 0.59 |
| Verizon (2025) | 16.9% | 9.0% | 1.51 |
| Kraft Heinz (2025) | −12.9% | −7.6% | 0.51 |
Ranked by ROE, Home Depot is the best business on the list by a mile. Ranked by ROIC, Microsoft is first and Home Depot second, close behind. The ROIC ranking is the one that reflects the businesses: Home Depot's lead on ROE comes from $4.35 of debt for each dollar of equity, not from selling more profitably than Microsoft.
The gap between the two returns grows with leverage. Microsoft, whose debt is 9% of its equity, shows only 5 points between ROE and ROIC. Verizon, at 1.51 times, shows ROE almost double ROIC. Kraft Heinz shows that both can go negative together: a large impairment charge took operating income below zero in 2025, and no choice of denominator rescues that year.
Why debt and buybacks inflate ROE
Suppose a business earns $10 million of after-tax operating profit on $100 million of capital, all equity: ROE and ROIC are both 10%. Now it borrows $60 million at 5% (about 4% after tax) and uses the money to buy back stock. Capital is still $100 million and ROIC is still 10%. But the after-tax interest of $2.4 million reduces net income to $7.6 million, and equity falls to $40 million, so ROE jumps to 19%.
Nothing about the stores, products or customers improved. The extra return is borrowed, and so is the extra risk: if operating profit falls, interest stays the same and the shareholders' return falls faster. This is the "financial leverage" term of the DuPont analysis, which splits ROE into margin, asset turnover and leverage.
Buybacks reduce equity even without debt, because the company hands cash to sellers of the stock. Companies that have bought back more stock than they have equity end up with negative equity: McDonald's (−$1.8 billion), Starbucks (−$7.7 billion) and Lowe's (−$9.9 billion) in their latest 10-K filings. Their ROE is meaningless, but ROIC still measures how well their capital works.
Home Depot's ROE taken apart
The DuPont identity splits ROE into three factors, which shows exactly where Home Depot's 145.5% comes from:
The first two factors describe the business: Home Depot earns 8.6 cents on each dollar of sales and turns its assets over 1.64 times a year, which together give a return on assets of about 14%. The third factor, more than ten dollars of assets for every dollar of equity, multiplies that 14% into 145%. Microsoft's leverage factor is under 2, so its ROE stays close to its return on assets and its ROIC. When one company's ROE towers over another's, the leverage factor is the first place to look.
Which to use when
| Question | Use | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Is this a high-quality business? | ROIC | Not distorted by financing choices |
| Does the business create value? | ROIC against WACC | A spread above the cost of capital creates value |
| What return are shareholders earning on book equity? | ROE | Their slice of the profit |
| Comparing banks or insurers | ROE | Debt and deposits are their raw material; ROIC does not fit |
| Company with negative or tiny equity | ROIC | ROE is meaningless |
| Screening many companies quickly | ROE, then check debt ÷ equity | ROE is widely published; leverage explains outliers |
A good habit is to read them together. ROE well above ROIC means leverage is doing part of the work; ROE close to ROIC means returns come from the business itself. A rising ROE with a flat ROIC usually means more debt or more buybacks, not a better business.
How Finabase does it
A stock's Financials tab shows return on equity by fiscal year together with total debt and shareholders' equity, so you can see at once whether a high ROE rests on leverage, for example Home Depot. The Valuation tab charts ten years of profitability and leverage ratios, and the Comparison tab lines up ROE for several stocks. ROIC definitions vary between data providers (cash and leases in or out), so the ROIC figures on this page were computed by Finabase from each company's 10-K data with the one definition stated above.
Frequently asked questions
Is ROIC better than ROE?
For judging the business, usually yes, because it is not inflated by debt or buybacks. For banks and insurers, and for knowing what shareholders earn on their book equity, ROE is the standard.
Why is ROE higher than ROIC?
Because the company uses debt. Borrowing at a rate below what the business earns lifts the return on the smaller equity base. ROE below ROIC happens when borrowing costs more after tax than the business returns.
What is a good ROIC?
One comfortably above the company's weighted average cost of capital, often 7% to 10% for large US companies. Many investors look for 15% or more sustained over years as a sign of a competitive advantage (see Economic moats: what protects a company’s profits, and how to test it).
Can ROE be negative while ROIC is positive?
Yes, if the business earns an operating profit but interest costs, a one-off loss below the operating line or negative equity turn the shareholders' figure negative.
Where do I find the numbers for ROIC?
All of them are in the 10-K: operating income and income tax on the income statement, shareholders' equity and borrowings on the balance sheet. Average the opening and closing balances, apply the effective tax rate to operating income, and divide. Decide once whether to subtract cash and add leases, and apply the same choice to every company you compare.
Summary
ROE divides net income by shareholders' equity; ROIC divides after-tax operating profit by equity plus debt. Debt and buybacks inflate ROE without improving the business, while ROIC stays neutral. In the latest 10-Ks Home Depot's ROE was 145.5% and its ROIC 24.7%, while Microsoft, with almost no debt, showed 34.0% and 28.8%. Use ROIC to judge the business and test it against the cost of capital, use ROE for what shareholders earn and for financial companies, and treat a large gap between them as a measure of leverage.
Check your understanding
4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
A company earns $10 million of after-tax operating profit on $100 million of capital, all equity. It then borrows $60 million at about 4% after tax and buys back $60 million of stock. What happens to ROIC and ROE?
- Both rise to 19%
- ROIC stays 10%; ROE rises to 19%
- ROIC falls to 7.6%; ROE stays 10%
Show the answer
B. ROIC stays 10%; ROE rises to 19% Capital and operating profit are unchanged, so ROIC stays 10%. Net income falls by $2.4 million of interest to $7.6 million while equity falls to $40 million, so ROE is 19%.
Home Depot’s ROE was 145.5% and its ROIC 24.7%. What explains most of the gap?
- Its tax rate
- A one-off gain
- Debt and years of buybacks that left only $12.8 billion of equity against $55.8 billion of debt
Show the answer
C. Debt and years of buybacks that left only $12.8 billion of equity against $55.8 billion of debt A small equity base makes the same profit look like a huge return to shareholders. ROIC, measured on equity plus debt, shows the return of the business itself.
McDonald’s reports negative shareholders’ equity. Which return still tells you how well its capital is used?
- ROIC
- ROE
- Neither
Show the answer
A. ROIC With negative equity, ROE has no meaningful sign or size. ROIC uses equity plus debt, which is still positive, so it measures the return on all capital in the business.
For which kind of company is ROE the standard measure rather than ROIC?
- A software company with no debt
- A bank, whose deposits and borrowings are its raw material
- A retailer with large operating leases
Show the answer
B. A bank, whose deposits and borrowings are its raw material For banks and insurers, borrowed money is the product, not a financing choice, so "invested capital" is not meaningful. Analysts judge them by ROE against the cost of equity.
Sources and further reading
- The Home Depot — Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended February 1, 2026 (SEC EDGAR)
- Microsoft Corporation — Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended June 30, 2026 (SEC EDGAR)
- Costco Wholesale — Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended August 30, 2026 (SEC EDGAR)
- Procter & Gamble — Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended June 30, 2026 (SEC EDGAR)
- Walmart Inc. — Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended January 31, 2026 (SEC EDGAR)
- Cisco Systems — Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended July 25, 2026 (SEC EDGAR)
- Verizon Communications — Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2025 (SEC EDGAR)
- The Kraft Heinz Company — Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 27, 2025 (SEC EDGAR)
- Finabase calculations from the SEC EDGAR XBRL company facts of each 10-K, read 2026-11-18
