Fundamentals · The financial statements
Inventory accounting (FIFO, LIFO and average cost): how they differ
See how FIFO, LIFO and average cost turn the same purchases into three profits, and use Caterpillar’s LIFO reserve to put LIFO and FIFO companies on one basis.
On this page
Inventory accounting is the set of rules that decides which purchase costs a company charges against this year's sales and which it leaves on the balance sheet as unsold stock. A company that buys the same goods at different prices through the year has to pick an order in which those costs leave inventory. The three common choices are first-in, first-out (FIFO), last-in, first-out (LIFO) and average cost.
The choice matters because it moves profit, taxes and the inventory balance without moving a single box in the warehouse. Two companies with identical purchases and identical sales can report different gross profits only because one uses LIFO and the other FIFO.
This page works through an invented example with all three methods, then uses Caterpillar's 2025 annual report to show how one disclosed number, the LIFO reserve, lets you put a LIFO company and a FIFO company on the same basis.
The idea
Take an invented shop. It buys 100 units at $10, then another 100 at $12, and sells 100 units for $20 each. Revenue is $2,000 and the shop spent $2,200 on stock. The only open question is which 100 units it is deemed to have sold.
- FIFO assumes the oldest units go first. Cost of sales is the 100 units bought at $10: $1,000. Gross profit is $1,000. The 100 units left are carried at $12 each: $1,200.
- LIFO assumes the newest units go first. Cost of sales is the 100 units at $12: $1,200. Gross profit is $800. The units left are carried at $10: $1,000.
- Weighted average blends the two. The 200 units cost $2,200, or $11 each. Cost of sales is $1,100, gross profit $900 and ending inventory $1,100.
Three things follow from this small example. First, cost of sales plus ending inventory is $2,200 under every method. The method only decides the split. Second, the methods are about the flow of costs, not the physical flow of goods. A grocer sells its oldest milk first whatever method its accountants use. Third, the difference is one of timing. Once the shop sells its last unit, total profit over its life is the same under all three.
The example had rising prices. When prices fall, the ranking reverses: LIFO reports the highest profit and FIFO the lowest. When prices are flat, the methods agree.
The reason companies choose LIFO is tax. In the example, LIFO profit is $200 lower than FIFO profit, and at the 21% federal rate that is $42 less tax this year. The tax is postponed, not cancelled: it comes due if the old, cheap units are ever sold. US tax law attaches a condition, the LIFO conformity rule in 26 U.S.C. §472(c). A company that uses LIFO for tax must use it in its financial reports too. It cannot show the tax collector the low profit and shareholders the high one.
Where the line sits
Inventory is a current asset on the balance sheet, usually below receivables. The cost that leaves inventory appears on the income statement as cost of sales (also called cost of goods sold), the first deduction from revenue. See Balance sheet: assets, liabilities and equity explained with Apple and Income statement: how to read one line by line, with Apple for the surrounding lines.
The method itself is not on the face of either statement. In a 10-K it is in two places: the summary of significant accounting policies, which says which method applies to which inventories, and the inventory note, which breaks the balance into raw materials, work in process and finished goods. A company on LIFO also discloses there how far its LIFO carrying value sits below current or replacement cost. Many companies use more than one method, for example LIFO for US inventories and FIFO or average cost abroad, because IFRS (IAS 2) does not permit LIFO.
The formula
The LIFO reserve is not a pile of cash or a provision. It is a measurement difference: how much higher inventory would be if it were carried at current cost. The reserve grows in a year when purchase prices rise, and the growth is exactly the extra cost that LIFO pushed through the income statement that year. A reserve that shrinks means the opposite: LIFO cost of sales was lower than FIFO cost of sales, and reported profit was higher.
The balance sheet effect is much larger than the income effect. Caterpillar's reported inventory understates current cost by almost a quarter, because the reserve has built up over many years. The 2025 income statement differs from a FIFO one by only $441 million, because only one year's price change passes through it.
The reserve also changes ratios. Cost of sales divided by year-end inventory is 44,752 ÷ 18,135 = 2.47 times as reported, and 44,311 ÷ 22,440 = 1.97 times at current cost. A LIFO company's inventory turnover looks faster than a FIFO competitor's for that reason alone.
Four LIFO users
The same disclosure for four US companies that use LIFO for at least part of their inventories, from each company's latest Form 10-K. Exxon Mobil, Chevron and Caterpillar report calendar 2025; Kroger reports its fiscal 2025 (year ended January 31, 2026). Amounts are in $ millions.
| Company | LIFO reserve | Year before | Change | Reserve ÷ reported inventory |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Exxon Mobil | 7,000 | 10,000 | −3,000 | not tagged |
| Chevron | 4,808 | 5,997 | −1,189 | 49.5% |
| Caterpillar | 4,305 | 3,864 | +441 | 23.7% |
| Kroger | 2,553 | 2,404 | +149 | 37.0% |
"Not tagged" means the filing's data does not break out a single inventory figure to divide by; the reserve itself comes from the inventory note. Exxon Mobil states its reserve only approximately, as about $7 billion and $10 billion. Kroger's balance sheet shows FIFO inventory of $9,445 million less the $2,553 million reserve, so reported inventory was $6,892 million.
The two oil companies moved the opposite way from Caterpillar and Kroger. Their reserves fell, Exxon Mobil's by $3,000 million and Chevron's by $1,189 million. A falling reserve means LIFO cost of sales was lower than it would have been under FIFO, so reported profit was higher. Exxon Mobil reported pretax income of $41,268 million; on a FIFO basis it would have been roughly $38.3 billion. Chevron reported $19,743 million against about $18,554 million.
A reserve can fall for two reasons, and the number alone does not say which. The current cost of the inventory may have dropped, which is common for crude oil and refined products whose prices swing widely from one year end to the next. Or the company may have sold more than it bought, reaching back into old, cheap cost layers. The second case is called a LIFO liquidation, and companies describe its profit effect in the inventory note when it is material.
Chevron's ratio shows how old LIFO layers can be. Its reported inventory was $9,711 million and its reserve $4,808 million, so inventory at current cost was $14,519 million, half as much again as the balance sheet shows. Caterpillar and Kroger sit on the other side: their costs rose during the year, the reserve grew, and LIFO took $441 million and about $149 million off pretax income. Grocers often call that yearly amount the LIFO charge; Kroger's own figure for its 2025 LIFO charge is $157 million, a little more than the change in the reserve.
Where it misleads
- Comparing margins across methods. A FIFO company and a LIFO company in the same industry report different gross margins on identical trading when prices move. Adjust the LIFO company with the change in its reserve before comparing.
- FIFO profit in inflation. When costs rise quickly, FIFO matches old, low costs against today's selling prices. Part of the reported profit is a holding gain that must be spent again to restock at the new price. It is real under the accounting rules and still not available to shareholders.
- LIFO balance sheets. LIFO leaves the oldest costs in inventory. Working capital, the current ratio and book value are all understated by the reserve, less the tax that would be due on it.
- LIFO liquidations. Running inventory down releases old costs into the income statement and lifts profit for a year. It can happen for good operating reasons, and it can also flatter a weak year. The inventory note is the place to check.
- The reserve is not all yours. Converting to current cost brings a tax bill with it. Caterpillar's $4,305 million reserve carries about $904 million of postponed tax at 21%, and state taxes would add to that.
- Mixed methods. Most large companies use LIFO for only part of their inventory. The policy note says how much, and a small LIFO share limits how far the method can explain a margin difference.
- Write-downs. Under every method, US GAAP (FASB ASC 330) requires inventory to be written down when it can no longer be sold for what it cost. A write-down is a separate event from the cost method and can swamp it in a bad year.
Compared with its neighbours
| Method | Cost of sales uses | Inventory shows | When prices rise |
|---|---|---|---|
| FIFO | Oldest costs | Recent costs | Highest profit, highest inventory |
| Weighted average | Blended cost | Blended cost | In between |
| LIFO | Newest costs | Oldest costs | Lowest profit, lowest tax |
| Specific identification | Each item's cost | Each item's cost | Depends on which items were sold |
Specific identification tracks the actual cost of each item and suits businesses that sell few, distinct, high-value things. The other three are assumptions for goods that are interchangeable. For what happens after the method is chosen, see Inventory turnover: how fast stock sells, and days of inventory for the speed at which stock sells and Cash conversion cycle: days of cash tied up, and when it is negative for how inventory ties up cash.
Where to find it in Finabase
Finabase shows the results of inventory accounting, not the method. Open Caterpillar's balance sheet and find the Inventory row: it is the reported figure, on whatever method the company uses. On the income statement, Cost of Revenue and Gross Profit are the lines the method moves. The Valuation tab charts ten fiscal years of Gross Margin with a five-year median, which is where a LIFO effect would show up over time.
The LIFO reserve is not a row on any Finabase tab, and neither is inventory turnover. To adjust a company, open its 10-K, search the inventory note for "LIFO" and take the stated excess of current cost over LIFO value for this year and last. Add this year's figure to the Inventory row, and subtract the year's increase from Cost of Revenue. The glossary entry LIFO and FIFO has the short definitions.
Frequently asked questions
Which is better, FIFO or LIFO?
Neither is better; each gets one statement right. FIFO gives a balance sheet close to current cost and an income statement built on older costs. LIFO gives an income statement close to current cost and a balance sheet built on old costs. The LIFO reserve lets a reader convert one to the other.
Why do US companies still use LIFO?
Mainly because it postpones income tax when their costs rise. The conformity rule in 26 U.S.C. §472(c) then obliges them to use LIFO in their financial reports as well, which is why the method shows up in 10-Ks at all.
Is LIFO allowed under IFRS?
No. IAS 2 does not permit LIFO, so companies that report under IFRS use FIFO or weighted average cost. US GAAP (FASB ASC 330) allows all three.
What is the LIFO reserve?
It is the amount by which inventory at current or replacement cost exceeds inventory as reported under LIFO. Adding it to reported inventory gives an approximate FIFO figure, and its change over a year is the difference between LIFO and FIFO cost of sales.
Does the inventory method affect cash flow?
Only through tax. The method does not change what the company pays suppliers or collects from customers. It changes taxable profit, so a LIFO company pays less tax in years of rising costs and more when the reserve unwinds.
Summary
Inventory accounting decides which purchase costs are matched against sales. With rising prices FIFO reports the highest profit and inventory, LIFO the lowest, and average cost falls between; the invented shop on this page earned $1,000, $800 or $900 on the same trade. LIFO is a US practice, kept alive by its tax deferral and tied to financial reporting by the conformity rule, and banned under IFRS. A LIFO company's reserve converts its numbers: Caterpillar's $18,135 million of inventory was $22,440 million at current cost at the end of 2025, and the $441 million rise in its reserve is what LIFO took off pretax income. Before comparing margins, turnover or book value across companies, check the inventory note for the method and the reserve.
Check your understanding
5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
A shop buys 10 units at $5, then 10 units at $7, and sells 10 units. What is cost of sales under FIFO and under LIFO?
- FIFO $70, LIFO $50
- FIFO $60, LIFO $60
- FIFO $50, LIFO $70
Show the answer
C. FIFO $50, LIFO $70 FIFO charges the oldest costs first (10 × $5 = $50) and LIFO the newest (10 × $7 = $70). Total cost is $120 either way; only the split between cost of sales and ending inventory changes.
A company reports LIFO inventory of $400 and a LIFO reserve of $100. What is its inventory at current cost?
- $500
- $300
- $400
Show the answer
A. $500 The reserve is the excess of current cost over the LIFO carrying value, so reported inventory + reserve = 400 + 100 = $500.
A company’s LIFO reserve rose from $60 to $90 during the year. What does that say about its reported pretax income?
- It was $30 higher than it would have been under FIFO
- It was $30 lower than it would have been under FIFO
- Nothing: the reserve only affects the balance sheet
Show the answer
B. It was $30 lower than it would have been under FIFO A rising reserve means LIFO pushed $30 more cost through the income statement than FIFO would have. Add the increase back to compare with a FIFO company.
Why can a US company not use LIFO on its tax return and FIFO in its annual report?
- Because the SEC bans FIFO
- Because the LIFO conformity rule in the tax code requires a LIFO taxpayer to use LIFO in its financial reports
- Because IFRS requires LIFO
Show the answer
B. Because the LIFO conformity rule in the tax code requires a LIFO taxpayer to use LIFO in its financial reports Under 26 U.S.C. §472(c) a company that elects LIFO for tax must report on LIFO too. IFRS does the opposite of the third option: IAS 2 does not permit LIFO.
Caterpillar reported 2025 inventory of $18,135 million and a LIFO reserve of $4,305 million. What is the fairest reading?
- Caterpillar holds $4,305 million of cash set aside for inventory
- Its inventory would be $22,440 million at current cost, and about 21% of the difference is tax that has been postponed
- Its 2025 profit was understated by $4,305 million
Show the answer
B. Its inventory would be $22,440 million at current cost, and about 21% of the difference is tax that has been postponed The reserve is a measurement gap built up over many years, not cash. Only the year’s change in it ($441 million) affected 2025 profit, and converting the whole reserve would bring a tax bill with it.
Sources and further reading
- Caterpillar Inc. — Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2025, filed February 13, 2026 (SEC EDGAR)
- Exxon Mobil Corporation — Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2025, filed February 18, 2026 (SEC EDGAR)
- Chevron Corporation — Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2025, filed February 24, 2026 (SEC EDGAR)
- The Kroger Co. — Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended January 31, 2026, filed March 31, 2026 (SEC EDGAR)
- SEC EDGAR — XBRL company facts (InventoryLIFOReserve, inventory, cost of sales, pretax income) for Caterpillar, read November 18, 2026
- FASB Accounting Standards Codification Topic 330, Inventory (US GAAP)
- IFRS Foundation — IAS 2 Inventories
- Internal Revenue Code, 26 U.S.C. §472(c) (the LIFO conformity rule)
