Fundamentals · Ratios
Tangible book value: formula, ROTCE and negative tangible equity
How to calculate tangible book value per share, why Bank of America’s is $28.62 against $38.44 of book value, and what negative tangible equity means.
On this page
Tangible book value is a company's common shareholders' equity with goodwill and other intangible assets taken out. It is the part of book value that is backed by assets which could, at least in principle, be sold on their own: cash, loans, securities, buildings, equipment.
Investors use it when they want a harder floor than ordinary book value. Goodwill is an accounting entry left behind by past acquisitions. It cannot be sold, it earns nothing by itself, and it can be written off. For banks, where book value is the main yardstick of price, analysts and the banks themselves report the tangible version every quarter. For consumer companies built by acquisition, the same subtraction often gives a negative number, and understanding why is the second half of this page.
The page calculates Bank of America's tangible book value per share from its latest annual report, compares three banks with two consumer companies, and explains return on tangible common equity and negative tangible book value.
The idea
When one company buys another, it nearly always pays more than the value of the target's identifiable assets. The balance sheet still has to balance, so the excess is recorded as an asset of its own. Ordinary book value counts that asset at full value. Tangible book value asks what the owners' stake would be if it were worth nothing.
Goodwill is that excess: the purchase price of an acquired business minus the fair value of the identifiable assets, net of liabilities, that came with it. It stands for things like an assembled workforce, customer relationships that could not be valued one by one, and the cost savings the buyer expected. Under US GAAP public companies have not amortized goodwill since 2002. It stays on the balance sheet at its original amount and is tested for impairment at least once a year. If the acquired business is judged to be worth less than its carrying amount, goodwill is written down and the loss goes through the income statement.
Other intangible assets are the identifiable non-physical assets that were bought: brand names and trademarks, patents, licences, customer lists, and at banks the value of acquired deposit and card relationships. Those with a limited life are amortized over it. Some, such as long-established trademarks, are treated as having an indefinite life and are tested for impairment like goodwill. The same kinds of intangible asset built inside a company, by advertising or research, are mostly expensed as the money is spent and never reach the balance sheet.
That last point is the oddity at the centre of this measure. Tangible book value removes purchased brands from the count. Home-grown brands were never in it. So the subtraction does not make companies comparable on the value of their intangibles. It only makes them comparable on what remains without them.
The formula
A bank's own filings may show a slightly different figure. Banks commonly add back the deferred tax liabilities related to goodwill and intangibles, and some treat mortgage servicing rights differently. The plain formula above is the conservative version and is the one used for every company on this page.
Return on tangible common equity
Banks report return on tangible common equity, usually shortened to ROTCE, beside return on equity. The logic is the same as for tangible book: measure profit against the equity that is actually at work in loans and securities, leaving out the accounting residue of old deals.
Bank of America's net income for 2025 was $30,509 million. Against year-end tangible common equity of $206,430 million that is 14.8%. Against year-end common equity of $277,251 million the same profit is 11.0%. Nothing about the bank differs between the two figures. The denominator is smaller, so the return is higher.
Two simplifications are built into the 14.8%. Banks compute ROTCE on net income after preferred dividends and on average tangible equity over the period, not on the year-end balance. Their published figures will differ somewhat. The simple version is used here so that the three banks are measured the same way.
Five companies, one date
Balance sheets are from each company's latest Form 10-K. Prices are the close of November 17, 2026.
| Company | BVPS | Tangible BVPS | Price ÷ tangible book | Goodwill and intangibles, share of assets |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| JPMorgan Chase | $126.99 | $106.95 | 3.09× | 1.2% |
| Wells Fargo | $53.19 | $45.12 | 1.83× | 1.2% |
| Bank of America | $38.44 | $28.62 | 1.73× | 2.1% |
| Procter & Gamble | $22.94 | −$4.04 | not meaningful | 49.6% |
| Kraft Heinz | $35.19 | −$15.24 | not meaningful | 73.0% |
Balance sheet dates: December 31, 2025 for the banks, December 27, 2025 for Kraft Heinz and June 30, 2026 for Procter & Gamble.
The banks. Goodwill and intangibles are only 1% to 2% of a large bank's total assets, because the balance sheet is dominated by loans and securities. Against equity they are much larger, since a bank's equity is itself a thin slice of its assets. JPMorgan Chase carries $52,731 million of goodwill and $1,300 million of other intangibles, which takes its book value of $126.99 a share down to $106.95. Wells Fargo's balance sheet shows goodwill of $24,967 million. Other intangibles are not tagged as a separate line on its balance sheet in the data used here, so the $45.12 deducts goodwill only. If Wells Fargo carries other intangibles inside another line, its true tangible book value is slightly lower.
On the simple year-end measure, return on tangible common equity was 19.8% at JPMorgan, 15.3% at Wells Fargo and 14.8% at Bank of America. The order of those returns matches the order of the price-to-tangible-book multiples: 3.09, 1.83 and 1.73 times. That is the usual pattern for banks. The more a bank earns on each dollar of tangible equity, the more investors pay for that dollar.
The consumer companies. Kraft Heinz has shareholders' equity of $41,664 million. Its goodwill is $22,179 million and its other intangibles $37,529 million, together 73.0% of total assets. Subtract them and tangible common equity is −$18,044 million, or −$15.24 a share. Procter & Gamble has equity of $54,081 million, which includes $756 million of convertible Class A preferred stock, goodwill of $41,276 million and other intangibles of $21,444 million: tangible common equity of −$9,395 million, or −$4.04 a share. Both companies own brands that came with acquisitions and were recorded at the prices paid.
Why negative tangible book is not insolvency
A company is insolvent when it cannot pay what it owes as it falls due. Tangible book value does not test that. It tests whether the physical and financial assets, at their book amounts, exceed all the liabilities. For a company whose business is brands, they need not.
Procter & Gamble earned net income of $16,046 million in fiscal 2026 (year ended June 30, 2026) with tangible equity below zero. Its lenders are repaid out of the cash that its brands generate, not out of the sale of factories. The brands are real assets that produce that cash, and tangible book value simply refuses to count them. At $171.72 on November 17, 2026, the market valued the shares at 7.49 times ordinary book value.
Kraft Heinz shows the other side. It reported a net loss of $5,846 million for 2025, and at $25.11 its shares traded at 0.71 times a book value of $35.19. A price below book for a company whose assets are mostly goodwill and brands says investors value those intangibles at less than their carrying amounts. Here the negative tangible book is not the warning. The discount to stated book value is.
So negative tangible book value means only that the company's value rests on intangibles and on future earnings. Whether that is safe depends on how dependable the earnings are and how much debt sits against them, which are questions for the income statement and for interest coverage.
Where it misleads
- It treats all intangibles as worthless. A dominant brand and an overpriced acquisition both go to zero. The measure is a floor, not an estimate.
- It penalizes buyers, not builders. A company that built its brands shows no intangibles to deduct. One that bought identical brands deducts billions. Their tangible book values differ for reasons of history.
- "Tangible" is not "liquid". What remains includes loans that may default and plants that may sell for less than book. Tangible book value is not what shareholders would receive in a wind-up.
- Definitions vary. Some versions add back deferred taxes or keep certain intangibles such as servicing rights. Compare figures from one source only.
- Preferred stock. Forgetting to subtract it overstates the result, most of all at banks. Bank of America's preferred stock is $25,992 million.
- ROTCE flatters acquirers. A bank that paid a large premium for an acquisition did spend that capital. Removing the goodwill from the denominator makes the return on the deal look better than it was for the shareholders who funded it.
- Ratios break below zero. Price to tangible book and ROTCE have no meaning when tangible equity is negative or very small.
Compared with its neighbours
| Measure | What is subtracted from equity | Bank of America |
|---|---|---|
| Book value per share | Preferred stock | $38.44 |
| Tangible book value per share | Preferred, goodwill, other intangibles | $28.62 |
| Price to book | (uses book value per share) | 1.29× |
| Price to tangible book | (uses tangible book value per share) | 1.73× |
Bank of America's price is the November 17, 2026 close. The price-to-book ratio is the right starting point for most companies. The tangible version earns its place for banks and insurers, and as a stress test for any balance sheet where goodwill is a large share of equity.
Where to find it in Finabase
Finabase does not show tangible book value, tangible book value per share or ROTCE. It shows the ingredients.
On the balance sheet page, goodwill and intangible assets appear as one combined row, Goodwill and Intangible Assets. Subtract it from Shareholders Equity, subtract any preferred stock (from the 10-K, since the page has no preferred row), and divide by the share count to get tangible book value per share. The combined row is all the formula needs, because both parts are deducted. To see goodwill and other intangibles separately you need the 10-K.
On the Valuation tab, the Financial position card shows the balance sheet as shares of total assets, and one of the slices is Goodwill and intangibles. It is a quick read of how much of a company is acquired intangibles: a couple of percent for a large bank, around half or more for a consumer company built by acquisition, as the table above shows. The P/B tile in the Valuation group charts ten fiscal years of price to ordinary book value, which is the nearest ratio the tab offers.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between book value and tangible book value?
Tangible book value is book value minus goodwill and other intangible assets. For Bank of America at December 31, 2025 the two were $38.44 and $28.62 a share. For a company with no acquisitions they are nearly the same.
Why do banks report tangible book value?
Because a bank's capacity to absorb losses depends on capital that actually exists in loans, securities and cash. Goodwill cannot absorb a loan loss, and bank regulators deduct it when they measure capital. Investors therefore price banks on tangible book and judge them on return on tangible common equity.
Is negative tangible book value bad?
Not by itself. It means goodwill and acquired intangibles exceed common equity, which is common among consumer companies that grew by buying brands. Procter & Gamble has negative tangible book value and earned $16,046 million in fiscal 2026. It matters more when earnings are weak or debt is heavy.
What is a good price to tangible book value?
There is no fixed level. For banks the multiple tends to rise with return on tangible common equity, as the three banks above show. A bank at well under 1 times tangible book is one whose assets or earnings the market distrusts.
Is tangible book value the same as liquidation value?
No. Tangible assets are carried at accounting amounts, mostly cost less depreciation or reserves, not at what they would fetch in a forced sale. Liquidation value is usually lower and has to be estimated asset by asset.
Summary
Tangible book value strips goodwill and other intangible assets, along with preferred stock, out of shareholders' equity to leave the common equity backed by assets that could be sold separately. Bank of America's $206,430 million of tangible common equity at December 31, 2025 is $28.62 a share against $38.44 of book value, and at $49.44 on November 17, 2026 the shares traded at 1.73 times it, with a simple return on tangible common equity of 14.8%. For banks the measure and its return are central. For companies such as Procter & Gamble and Kraft Heinz, where acquired brands exceed equity, tangible book is negative, which describes where their value sits and says nothing about whether they can pay their debts. Treat it as a deliberately harsh floor and read it with earnings and debt.
Check your understanding
5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
A bank has shareholders’ equity of $1,000 million, preferred stock of $100 million, goodwill of $250 million, other intangibles of $50 million and 60 million common shares. What is its tangible book value per share?
- $15.00
- $10.00
- $11.67
Show the answer
B. $10.00 Tangible common equity is 1,000 − 100 − 250 − 50 = $600 million, and 600 ÷ 60 = $10.00. Book value per share, before removing goodwill and intangibles, is $15.00.
A bank earns $90 million. Its common equity is $900 million and its tangible common equity is $600 million. What are its return on equity and return on tangible common equity?
- ROE 10% and ROTCE 15%
- ROE 15% and ROTCE 10%
- Both are 10%, because the profit is the same
Show the answer
A. ROE 10% and ROTCE 15% 90 ÷ 900 = 10% and 90 ÷ 600 = 15%. The profit is identical; ROTCE is higher only because goodwill and intangibles are removed from the denominator.
A consumer company that bought many brands has negative tangible book value but steady profits. What does the negative figure mean?
- The company cannot pay its debts
- The shares are worthless
- Goodwill and acquired intangibles exceed its common equity, so its value rests on brands and future earnings and not on physical assets
Show the answer
C. Goodwill and acquired intangibles exceed its common equity, so its value rests on brands and future earnings and not on physical assets Tangible book value counts acquired brands as zero. A company can be profitable and pay its lenders from the cash those brands produce while showing negative tangible equity. Solvency is judged from earnings, cash flow and debt.
Company A built its brands itself over decades. Company B bought identical brands last year. Otherwise they are the same. How do their tangible book values compare?
- B’s is higher, because it paid for its brands
- They are the same, because the brands are identical
- A’s is likely higher: it has no acquired intangibles to subtract, while B deducts the goodwill and intangibles it recorded
Show the answer
C. A’s is likely higher: it has no acquired intangibles to subtract, while B deducts the goodwill and intangibles it recorded Internally built brands are expensed as the money is spent and never appear as assets, so there is nothing to deduct. Purchased brands are recorded and then removed by the tangible calculation, along with the capital used to buy them.
Two banks have the same tangible book value per share. Bank X earns a 20% return on tangible common equity and bank Y 8%. Which would you expect to trade at the higher multiple of tangible book?
- Y, because it has more room to improve
- X, because investors usually pay more for each dollar of equity that earns a higher return
- They must trade at the same multiple
Show the answer
B. X, because investors usually pay more for each dollar of equity that earns a higher return Price to tangible book tends to rise with ROTCE. A dollar of equity that earns 20% a year is worth more than one that earns 8%, other things equal.
Sources and further reading
- Bank of America Corporation — Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2025, filed February 25, 2026 (SEC EDGAR)
- JPMorgan Chase & Co. — Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2025, filed February 13, 2026 (SEC EDGAR)
- Wells Fargo & Company — Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2025, filed February 24, 2026 (SEC EDGAR)
- The Kraft Heinz Company — Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 27, 2025, filed February 12, 2026 (SEC EDGAR)
- The Procter & Gamble Company — Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended June 30, 2026, filed August 4, 2026 (SEC EDGAR)
- SEC EDGAR — XBRL company facts (StockholdersEquity, PreferredStockValue, Goodwill, intangible assets, NetIncomeLoss) for Bank of America, read November 18, 2026
- Finabase chart data — closing prices of November 17, 2026; ratios computed by Finabase
