Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Fundamentals · Ratios

Piotroski F-score: the nine tests, worked through on Nike

Score a company from 0 to 9 with Piotroski’s nine pass-or-fail tests, follow each one on Nike’s fiscal 2026 numbers, and learn where the score misleads.

On this page
  1. The idea
  2. The formula
  3. Six companies
  4. Where it misleads
  5. Compared with its neighbours
  6. Where to find it in Finabase
  7. Frequently asked questions
  8. Summary
  9. Check your understanding

The Piotroski F-score is a count, from 0 to 9, of how many of nine simple tests a company's latest financial statements pass. Each test asks a yes-or-no question about profitability, the balance sheet or efficiency, and most of them compare this year with last year.

Joseph Piotroski, an accounting professor, published it in 2000. He was studying stocks that trade at low prices against their book value, a group that mixes real bargains with companies in trouble, and he wanted a mechanical way to tell which were getting financially stronger. The score needs nothing but two years of statements, which is why it now appears on data pages for every kind of stock, including many it was not designed for.

This page lists the nine tests, runs each of them on Nike's fiscal 2026 numbers, compares six companies and sets out what a score can and cannot say.

The idea

A single ratio gives one view of a company. A checklist gives several, and if each item is scored 1 or 0 the answers can be added. That is all the F-score is: nine signals that a careful reader of the statements would look at anyway, reduced to passes and fails.

The nine fall into three groups, and each group answers a plain question.

Is the company making money, and is it real? A profit, positive cash from operations, a better return on assets than last year, and cash flow larger than reported profit. The last test is about earnings quality: profit that arrives as cash is more dependable than profit that sits in receivables and inventory.

Is the balance sheet getting safer? Less long-term debt against assets, more short-term assets against short-term bills, and no new shares sold. A company that has to borrow or issue shares is, in this reading, one that cannot fund itself.

Is the business running better? A higher gross margin and more sales per dollar of assets than a year ago.

The word that matters is "than a year ago". Six of the nine tests are comparisons with the prior year, so the F-score is mainly a measure of improvement, not of level. A weak company that got slightly less weak can outscore an excellent one that slipped a little.

The formula

Following the paper, return on assets and asset turnover here divide by total assets at the start of the year, and long-term debt is divided by average assets. The pieces are explained on their own pages: Return on assets (ROA): how to calculate and compare it, Current ratio and quick ratio: measuring short-term liquidity, Gross margin: formula, what a point is worth and how it differs and Asset turnover ratio: how much revenue each dollar of assets makes.

Nike FY2026: 7 of 9 Piotroski tests passed Net income positive (ROA > 0) pass: 1 point Operating cash flow positive pass: 1 point ROA higher than the year before pass: 1 point Cash flow exceeds net income fail: 0 points Long-term debt ratio fell pass: 1 point Current ratio rose fail: 0 points No new shares issued pass: 1 point Gross margin rose pass: 1 point Asset turnover rose pass: 1 point FY2026 against FY2025, from Nike’s Form 10-K for 2026-05-31. Each test scores 1 or 0.
Nike, fiscal 2026 against fiscal 2025: 7 of 9 tests passed. Each test scores 1 or 0. Source: Form 10-K for the year ended May 31, 2026 (SEC EDGAR); computed by Finabase.

Look at how the points were won. Test 3 passed because return on assets moved from 8.45% to 8.50%, a gain of 0.05 of a point. Test 8 passed on a gross margin 0.18 of a point higher. Either could have gone the other way on a rounding of the accounts, and the score would have been 6 or 5 with the same business underneath.

The two fails are also worth reading for what they are. The current ratio fell from 2.21 to 1.96 in the same year that long-term debt fell by about $2,019 million. Debt that is repaid, or that moves into current liabilities as it comes due, lowers the current ratio. One act can pass test 5 and fail test 6. A current ratio of 1.96 still means short-term assets are nearly twice short-term liabilities. The test only records that it went down.

Six companies

The same nine tests on five more companies, each on its latest fiscal year against the one before. Fiscal years: Walmart to January 31, 2026; Nike to May 31, 2026; Procter & Gamble to June 30, 2026; Caterpillar to December 31, 2025; Intel and Kraft Heinz to December 27, 2025.

Company Profitability (of 4) Balance sheet (of 3) Efficiency (of 2) F-score
Walmart 4 2 2 8 / 9
Nike 3 2 2 7 / 9
Procter & Gamble 3 2 1 6 / 9
Caterpillar 3 2 1 6 / 9
Intel 3 2 1 6 / 9
Kraft Heinz 2 2 0 4 / 9
Piotroski F-score, six companies, latest fiscal year Nike FY2026 7 / 9 Walmart FY2026 8 / 9 Procter & Gamble FY2026 6 / 9 Caterpillar FY2025 6 / 9 Intel FY2025 6 / 9 Kraft Heinz FY2025 4 / 9 Nine pass-or-fail tests on two years of statements. Computed by Finabase from each company’s latest Form 10-K.
Piotroski F-score for six companies, latest fiscal year against the one before. Nine pass-or-fail tests on two years of statements, computed by Finabase from each company’s latest Form 10-K (SEC EDGAR).

Three companies share a score of 6 and have little else in common, which is the most useful thing in the table:

  • Procter & Gamble earned a 12.81% return on assets, the highest of the six. It fails test 3 because the year before was 13.05%, and test 8 because gross margin went from 51.16% to 50.18%. Both levels are high. Both moved down.
  • Caterpillar fails three tests for a year in which return on assets fell from 12.34% to 10.12%, gross margin fell from 37.97% to 33.79% and long-term debt rose from 27,351 to 30,696 ($ millions). Makers of heavy equipment have profits that rise and fall with the business cycle, so their scores swing with it.
  • Intel lost $267 million and still scores 6. It fails test 1, but its return on assets "improved" from −9.79% to −0.14%, its cash from operations of $9,697 million was far above its net loss, and its current ratio rose from 1.33 to 2.02. It fails test 7: shares outstanding went from 4,330 million to 4,994 million. A smaller loss collects the same point as a larger profit.

Walmart scores 8, and two of its passes are thin: gross margin of 24.93% against 24.85%, and a long-term debt ratio of 12.69% against 13.02% even though long-term debt in dollars rose from 33,401 to 34,624. Assets grew faster than the debt. Kraft Heinz scores 4 on a net loss of $5,846 million, with return on assets, gross margin and asset turnover all lower, while its cash from operations stayed positive at $4,462 million.

Where it misleads

  • It was designed for cheap stocks. The paper studied companies with high book-to-market ratios (a low price to book), often small and little followed, and that is where it found the signal. Nothing in the paper says the score separates good from bad among large, closely watched companies.
  • Binary tests ignore size. A gross margin up 0.01 point scores the same as one up 5 points; a return on assets down 0.24 of a point (Procter & Gamble) fails the same as one down from 3.04% to −6.62% (Kraft Heinz).
  • Direction, not level. A company with a 50% gross margin that slips fails where a company with a 20% margin that inches up passes. The score cannot rank two companies on quality.
  • Test 7 punishes any share issuance. Read strictly, a company that issues shares for employee stock plans fails it, even if it buys back more than it issues. Many providers instead compare share counts, as this page does, which lets a net buyer pass. The two readings give different scores for most large US companies.
  • Test 4 has innocent failures. A growing company that builds inventory before a strong season can report cash flow below net income for a year without anything being wrong with its accounts.
  • Paying down debt can lower the current ratio, as in the Nike example, so tests 5 and 6 can contradict each other.
  • Providers differ. Which debt counts as long-term, which share count, opening or average assets, fiscal year or trailing twelve months: each choice can flip a close test. Expect scores for one company to differ by a point or two between sources.
  • Not suited to banks. Gross margin and the current ratio have no clear meaning for a bank or an insurer.

Compared with its neighbours

Measure Inputs What it tells you
Piotroski F-score Nine yes-or-no tests, two years Whether fundamentals are improving
Altman Z-score: formula, zones and what it cannot tell you Five weighted ratios and the price A zone of financial distress risk
Return on assets (ROA): how to calculate and compare it Net income ÷ total assets The level of profitability, as a rate
Quality of earnings: accruals, cash conversion and red flags Cash flow against reported profit Whether profit is backed by cash

The Z-score asks whether a company looks like past failures. The F-score asks whether this year looks better than last year. A company can score well on one and badly on the other.

Where to find it in Finabase

Open the Valuation tab for Nike and scroll to the Financial health block. It shows Piotroski F-Score as "n / 9" with the caption "Nine pass/fail tests of profitability, leverage and efficiency", beside the Altman Z-Score.

The figure comes from the data provider and follows the provider's definitions. On staging on November 18, 2026 the tab showed 6 / 9 for Walmart, where this page's fiscal-year method gives 8. That two-point gap is the provider-difference point above in practice, not an error in either number.

To rebuild a score yourself, the rows are on the three statement pages. The income statement has Net Income, Total Revenue, Gross Profit and Weighted Average Shares. The balance sheet has Total Assets, Current Assets, Current Liabilities and Debt Non-Current. The cash flow statement has Net Cash Flow from Operations. You need three fiscal year ends of total assets, because last year's return on assets uses the assets of the year before it.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good Piotroski F-score?

Piotroski's paper treated 8 or 9 as the high group and 0 or 1 as the low group; many screens today call 8 or 9 strong and 0 to 2 weak, with everything between treated as neutral. Those labels come from how the score has been used on cheap stocks, and they carry less meaning for large, stable companies.

What are the nine tests?

Positive net income, positive operating cash flow, higher return on assets, cash flow above net income, a lower long-term debt ratio, a higher current ratio, no new shares issued, a higher gross margin and higher asset turnover. Each scores one point.

Can a company that loses money have a high F-score?

Yes. A loss fails only test 1. Intel lost $267 million in fiscal 2025 and passes six tests, because its loss shrank, its operating cash flow was positive and its current ratio rose.

Why do different sites show different F-scores for the same company?

Because the paper leaves details open and providers fill them in differently: the share count, the definition of long-term debt, opening or average assets, and annual or trailing-twelve-month data. A test that passes by a few hundredths of a point flips easily.

Is the F-score a measure of value?

No. It says nothing about price. Piotroski applied it to stocks already chosen for being cheap on book value; the score was the second step, used to sort that group by financial strength.

Summary

The Piotroski F-score counts how many of nine pass-or-fail tests a company's statements meet: four on profitability, three on debt, liquidity and share issuance, two on efficiency. Nike's fiscal 2026 statements pass seven, failing on cash flow below net income and a lower current ratio, and two of its passes rest on changes of less than 0.2 of a point. Walmart scores 8, Kraft Heinz 4, and Procter & Gamble, Caterpillar and Intel all score 6 for unrelated reasons, one of them while reporting a loss. The score measures direction, ignores size, was built for cheap stocks and varies between providers, so read which tests passed and by how much before reading the total.

Check your understanding

5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. An invented company passes all four profitability tests, one of the three balance-sheet tests and neither efficiency test. What is its F-score?

    1. 5
    2. 7
    3. 4
    Show the answer

    A. 5 Each pass is one point: 4 + 1 + 0 = 5. The score is a simple count with no weights.

  2. Company A’s gross margin rose from 30.00% to 30.01%. Company B’s rose from 30% to 35%. How do they score on test 8?

    1. B scores more because its margin rose more
    2. A fails because the change is too small to count
    3. Both score one point, because the test only asks whether the margin rose
    Show the answer

    C. Both score one point, because the test only asks whether the margin rose The tests are binary. They record direction and ignore size, which is why a pass should be read with the numbers behind it.

  3. A company reports net income of $500 million and cash flow from operations of $400 million, both positive. Which tests does it pass among tests 1, 2 and 4?

    1. All three
    2. Tests 1 and 2, but not test 4
    3. Only test 1
    Show the answer

    B. Tests 1 and 2, but not test 4 Net income is positive (test 1) and operating cash flow is positive (test 2), but cash flow of 400 does not exceed net income of 500, so test 4 fails.

  4. Intel reported a net loss for fiscal 2025 and still scored 6 of 9. What does that show about the F-score?

    1. It mostly measures year-to-year improvement, so a shrinking loss and stronger liquidity earn points
    2. It ignores net income
    3. A score of 6 means the company is profitable
    Show the answer

    A. It mostly measures year-to-year improvement, so a shrinking loss and stronger liquidity earn points Only test 1 requires a profit. Six of the nine tests compare this year with last year, so a company that is less weak than before can score well.

  5. One data site shows an F-score of 6 for a company and another shows 8. What is the most likely explanation?

    1. One of the sites has made an arithmetic mistake
    2. The company restated its accounts between the two readings
    3. The sites use different definitions or periods (share count, long-term debt, opening or average assets), and close tests flipped
    Show the answer

    C. The sites use different definitions or periods (share count, long-term debt, opening or average assets), and close tests flipped The paper leaves details open. Tests that pass or fail by a few hundredths of a point change with the definition used, so a gap of a point or two between providers is normal.

Sources and further reading

  1. Joseph D. Piotroski, “Value Investing: The Use of Historical Financial Statement Information to Separate Winners from Losers,” Journal of Accounting Research, vol. 38, Supplement (2000), pp. 1–41
  2. NIKE, Inc. — Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended May 31, 2026, filed July 15, 2026 (SEC EDGAR)
  3. Walmart Inc. — Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended January 31, 2026, filed March 13, 2026 (SEC EDGAR)
  4. The Procter & Gamble Company — Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended June 30, 2026, filed August 4, 2026 (SEC EDGAR)
  5. Caterpillar Inc. — Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2025, filed February 13, 2026 (SEC EDGAR)
  6. Intel Corporation — Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 27, 2025, filed January 23, 2026 (SEC EDGAR)
  7. The Kraft Heinz Company — Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 27, 2025, filed February 12, 2026 (SEC EDGAR)
  8. SEC EDGAR — XBRL company facts (net income, operating cash flow, assets, long-term debt, current ratio inputs, shares, gross profit, revenue) for Nike and the five other companies, read November 18, 2026
  9. Chicago Booth Review — Separating winners from losers (on Piotroski’s high and low F-score groups)