Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Fundamentals · Ratios

Effective tax rate: formula, the 21% benchmark and what moves it

How to calculate a company’s effective tax rate, compare it with the 21% US federal rate and with cash taxes paid, worked on Walmart’s 24.4%.

On this page
  1. The idea
  2. The formula
  3. The statutory rate, and why companies differ from it
  4. Cash taxes against the provision
  5. What a point of tax rate is worth
  6. Where it misleads
  7. Compared with its neighbours
  8. Where to find it in Finabase
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. Summary
  11. Check your understanding

A company's effective tax rate is the income tax expense on its income statement divided by its profit before tax. It is the share of pretax profit that the accounts set aside for income taxes in that period.

The rate matters for two reasons. It sits between pretax profit and net income, so a move of a few points changes earnings per share with no change in the business. And it is rarely equal to the headline rate in the tax code, so comparing the two tells you how much of a company's profit depends on where it earns its money, on credits and deductions, and on items that will not repeat.

This page computes Walmart's effective tax rate from its latest annual report, compares it with the US federal rate and with the tax Walmart paid in cash, and sets it beside five other large companies.

The idea

A person who earns $80,000 and pays $14,000 of income tax has paid 17.5% of their income, whatever the brackets say. That 17.5% is their effective rate. The top bracket they reached, the marginal rate, may be higher. The effective rate is what the whole bill came to as a share of the whole income.

A company's effective rate is the same idea with one twist. The numerator is not the tax paid. It is the tax expense recognized under accounting rules, which tries to match tax to the profit of the same period, whenever the cash moves. A company can expense tax this year and pay it in three years, or pay it this year for profit it reported earlier. So there are really three rates to keep apart:

  • the statutory rate: what the law says, 21% for US federal corporate income tax;
  • the effective rate: tax expense over pretax profit, from the income statement;
  • the cash tax rate: income taxes actually paid over pretax profit, from the cash flow statement or its supplemental disclosures.

The formula

Both inputs to the first line are on the income statement, one above the other. The provision for income taxes (also called income tax expense) has two parts. Current tax is what the company expects to owe for the year on its tax returns. Deferred tax is tax on profit that the accounts recognize now and the tax return recognizes in another year, for example because tax rules allow faster depreciation than the accounts use. Under US GAAP the rules are in FASB ASC Topic 740, Income Taxes.

Walmart FY2026: effective tax rate 24.4% ($ billions) Income before income taxes $29.5B Provision for income taxes $7.2B (24.4%) Tax at the 21% federal rate $6.2B Income taxes paid in cash $5.4B Source: Walmart Form 10-K for 2026-01-31, income statement and cash flow statement.
Walmart Inc., fiscal year ended January 31, 2026: the provision for income taxes was $7.2 billion on pretax income of $29.5 billion, an effective rate of 24.4%. Tax at the 21% federal rate alone would be $6.2 billion, and $5.4 billion was paid in cash. Source: Walmart Form 10-K.

Three numbers describe one year's tax. The first gap, $1,011 million, is everything that is not the federal rate: other taxes and adjustments. The second gap, between the charge and the payment, is mostly timing. Of the $7,199 million provision, $2,277 million was deferred, which leaves a current portion of $4,922 million, close to the cash figure. Payments also follow installment dates, so cash paid in a fiscal year never matches the current expense exactly.

The statutory rate, and why companies differ from it

The US federal corporate income tax rate is a flat 21% of taxable income. It has applied to tax years beginning after December 31, 2017, under Public Law 115-97, which amended 26 U.S.C. §11(b). Before that the top federal rate was 35%, which is why ten-year charts of effective rates for US companies step down around 2018.

Every Form 10-K contains a rate reconciliation in the income tax note: a table that starts at the statutory rate and lists each item that moves the company to its effective rate. The usual lines, in general terms:

  • State and local income taxes add to the federal rate. A company that earns nearly all its profit in the United States tends to land a few points above 21% for this reason.
  • Foreign earnings are taxed where they are earned, at rates that can be higher or lower than the US rate. A company with large profits in low-tax countries reports a lower effective rate.
  • Tax credits, such as credits for research spending, reduce tax directly.
  • Stock-based compensation. When shares given to employees are worth more at vesting than the expense that was recorded, the extra tax deduction lowers the provision. The effect is larger after a share price has risen.
  • One-off items: settlements with tax authorities, changes in tax law that revalue deferred tax balances, write-downs that are not deductible, and changes in the valuation allowance against deferred tax assets.

Six companies, each from its latest Form 10-K, in $ millions:

Company Pretax income Tax provision Effective rate Cash tax rate
Walmart 29,469 7,199 24.4% 18.2%
Home Depot 18,602 4,446 23.9% 26.1%
Microsoft 165,934 32,185 19.4% 12.8%
Johnson & Johnson 32,581 5,777 17.7% 20.1%
Nvidia 141,450 21,383 15.1% 14.3%
Pfizer 7,520 −266 −3.5% 62.3%

Fiscal years: Walmart ended January 31, 2026; Home Depot February 1, 2026; Microsoft June 30, 2026; Nvidia January 25, 2026; Johnson & Johnson December 28, 2025; Pfizer December 31, 2025.

Effective tax rate, latest fiscal year, against the 21% US federal rate Walmart FY2026 24.4% Home Depot FY2025 23.9% Johnson & Johnson FY2025 17.7% Microsoft FY2026 19.4% Nvidia FY2026 15.1% Pfizer FY2025 -3.5% US federal statutory rate 21.0% Income tax expense ÷ income before income taxes, from each company’s latest Form 10-K.
Effective tax rate, latest fiscal year: income tax expense divided by income before income taxes, against the 21% US federal statutory rate. Source: each company’s latest Form 10-K (SEC EDGAR).

The table sorts into three groups.

Above 21%. Walmart (24.4%) and Home Depot (23.9%) sit a few points over the federal rate, the pattern described above for state taxes and other additions. Their rates were also stable: 23.4% and 23.7% the year before.

Below 21%. Microsoft (19.4%), Johnson & Johnson (17.7%) and Nvidia (15.1%) report rates under the federal rate. The general causes are the ones in the list: foreign earnings taxed at lower rates, credits and deductions. Each company's own reconciliation gives the split. All three rates rose from the prior year, by about two points each: from 17.6%, 15.7% and 13.3%.

Negative. Pfizer recorded a tax benefit of $266 million on pretax income of $7,520 million, so its net income was higher than its pretax income. A negative rate does not mean the company paid no tax. Pfizer paid $4,688 million of income taxes in cash that year, 62.3% of its pretax income, while its deferred tax expense was −$2,133 million. Accounting expense and cash moved in opposite directions. A rate like this describes the items of one year and is useless for forecasting.

Cash taxes against the provision

The last column of the table is the check on the one before it. A cash tax rate far below the effective rate means the company is expensing tax it has not yet paid. Microsoft's provision was $32,185 million and its cash payments $21,188 million; the deferred tax expense of $14,424 million accounts for the difference in direction. Deferred tax is still a cost. It becomes a liability on the balance sheet and is paid when the timing difference reverses, though a growing company can keep the balance rising for many years.

A cash rate above the effective rate, as at Home Depot (26.1% against 23.9%) and Johnson & Johnson (20.1% against 17.7%), usually means payments for earlier periods or installments running ahead of the expense. Over several years the two rates should converge. If they do not, the tax note explains why. The Quality of earnings: accruals, cash conversion and red flags page shows a case where a tax charge was expensed in one year and paid in the next.

One more disclosure belongs here. Companies report a balance of unrecognized tax benefits: tax positions taken on returns that the company has not counted in its accounts because a tax authority might not accept them. Walmart's was $2,440 million and Microsoft's $25,831 million. It measures how much of the reported tax position is still open to dispute.

What a point of tax rate is worth

Because tax is taken off the top of pretax profit, every point of rate moves net income by 1% of pretax income. For Walmart that is 29,469 × 1% = about $295 million, or roughly $0.037 a share. The rise from 23.4% to 24.4% in fiscal 2026 therefore cost about that much in earnings per share compared with an unchanged rate.

This is why analysts separate tax from operations when they read earnings growth. Two companies can each report 10% growth in earnings per share, one because the business earned more and one because its tax rate fell three points. The first can repeat. The second cannot, unless the lower rate is permanent. Comparing growth in pretax income with growth in net income shows at once how much the tax line contributed.

Where it misleads

  • One year is noisy. Settlements, law changes and write-downs land in single years. Use an average of three to five years, or the rate management guides to, as the "normal" rate.
  • Low pretax income breaks the ratio. When pretax profit is near zero, a modest tax figure gives a rate of 200% or −50%. Rates for loss-making companies mean nothing.
  • It is not the cash rate. Valuation models that tax operating profit at the effective rate may overstate or understate the cash that leaves. Check income taxes paid.
  • A low rate can reverse. Rates that depend on where profit is booked or on particular credits depend on laws staying as they are. Treat an unusually low rate as a risk to future earnings as well as a benefit to current ones.
  • Noncontrolling interests muddy shortcuts. Tax is charged on all consolidated pretax income. Net income attributable to shareholders is after the share of profit belonging to minority owners, so "one minus net income over pretax income" overstates the tax rate.

Compared with its neighbours

Measure Formula What it tells you Walmart, FY2026
Statutory rate Set by law The federal starting point 21%
Effective tax rate Tax provision ÷ pretax income The accounting tax burden for the year 24.4%
Cash tax rate Income taxes paid ÷ pretax income What actually left the bank 18.2%
Tax burden Net income ÷ pretax income The share of pretax profit kept See DuPont analysis: splitting ROE into margin, turnover and leverage
Net margin Net income ÷ revenue Profit after tax per sales dollar See Profit margins: gross, operating and net margin explained

The tax burden used in five-step DuPont analysis is simply one minus the effective rate, before noncontrolling interests.

Where to find it in Finabase

Finabase does not show an effective tax rate, and the income statement there has no pretax income row. You can get close with two rows.

Open Walmart's income statement and read Income Tax Expense: this is the provision. For the denominator, add Income Tax Expense back to profit after tax. Where the statement shows a Consolidated Income row (net income before noncontrolling interests), use that: for Walmart, 29,469 − 7,199 gives consolidated income of 22,270, and adding the tax back returns the pretax figure exactly. If you use the Net Income row instead, the result is approximate. Walmart's net income of 21,893 plus 7,199 is 29,092, which gives a rate of 24.7% against the true 24.4%.

The Financials overview draws the same expense as the Income Tax block in the Revenue & Expenses flow, for the latest year or quarter, so you can see its size next to net income. The balance sheet has a Tax Liabilities row. Income taxes paid in cash is not a row on the site; read it in the 10-K's cash flow statement or the note on supplemental cash flow information.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between the effective and the statutory tax rate?

The statutory rate is the rate written in law, 21% for US federal corporate income tax. The effective rate is what a company's tax expense actually came to as a share of its pretax profit, after state and foreign taxes, credits, deductions and one-off items.

Why is a company's effective tax rate below 21%?

Usually because part of its profit is earned in countries with lower rates, or because credits and deductions reduce its tax. The rate reconciliation in the income tax note of the 10-K lists each item and its size.

Can an effective tax rate be negative?

Yes. A company that records a net tax benefit while reporting a pretax profit has a negative rate, as Pfizer did at −3.5%. It reflects accounting items of that year and does not mean no tax was paid.

Is the effective tax rate the tax a company actually paid?

No. It is based on the tax expense in the accounts, which includes deferred tax. Cash paid is a separate disclosure. Walmart's expense was $7,199 million and its cash payments $5,364 million.

Summary

The effective tax rate is the provision for income taxes divided by income before income taxes. Walmart's was 24.4% in fiscal 2026: $7,199 million on $29,469 million, against $6,188 million at the 21% federal rate and $5,364 million paid in cash. Rates differ from 21% because of state and foreign taxes, credits, stock-compensation deductions and one-off items, and they differ from cash taxes because of deferred tax and payment timing. Across six companies the rate ran from 24.4% down to −3.5% at Pfizer, which paid $4,688 million in cash that year. Each point of rate is worth about $295 million of Walmart's net income, so read the rate over several years, check it against cash taxes, and separate tax effects from operating ones before judging earnings growth.

Check your understanding

5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. A company reports income before income taxes of $400 and a provision for income taxes of $88. What is its effective tax rate?

    1. 28%
    2. 21%
    3. 22%
    Show the answer

    C. 22% 88 ÷ 400 = 22%. The 21% is the US federal statutory rate, which is a benchmark and not the result; 28% divides the tax by net income of 312 instead of pretax income.

  2. Walmart’s provision for income taxes was $7,199 million and it paid $5,364 million of income taxes in cash. What mainly explains the gap?

    1. Part of the provision is deferred tax, expensed now and payable in other periods, and payments follow their own timing
    2. The cash figure is wrong, because expense and payment must match each year
    3. Walmart received a refund of the difference
    Show the answer

    A. Part of the provision is deferred tax, expensed now and payable in other periods, and payments follow their own timing The provision is current plus deferred tax. Walmart’s deferred tax expense was $2,277 million, leaving a current portion of $4,922 million, close to the cash paid.

  3. A company’s earnings per share grew 9% while its pretax income grew 4%. Its share count did not change. What is the most likely reason?

    1. Revenue grew 9%
    2. Its effective tax rate fell, so more of each pretax dollar reached net income
    3. Its operating margin widened
    Show the answer

    B. Its effective tax rate fell, so more of each pretax dollar reached net income Revenue and margins act above the pretax line, so they are already inside the 4%. With the share count flat, the extra growth came from a lower tax rate, which may not repeat.

  4. A company has pretax income of $2,000 million and 500 million shares. Roughly what is one percentage point of tax rate worth per share?

    1. $4.00
    2. $0.40
    3. $0.04
    Show the answer

    C. $0.04 One point is 1% of pretax income: $20 million. Divided by 500 million shares that is $0.04 a share.

  5. Pfizer reported an effective tax rate of −3.5% and paid $4,688 million of income taxes in cash in the same year. What does this show?

    1. The accounts contain an error
    2. The effective rate is built on accounting expense, including deferred tax, and can move opposite to the cash paid
    3. A negative rate means the government paid the company
    Show the answer

    B. The effective rate is built on accounting expense, including deferred tax, and can move opposite to the cash paid Pfizer’s deferred tax expense was −$2,133 million, which pulled the total provision below zero while cash payments continued. A single year’s rate like this is not a guide to the future.

Sources and further reading

  1. Walmart Inc. — Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended January 31, 2026, filed March 13, 2026 (SEC EDGAR)
  2. The Home Depot, Inc. — Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended February 1, 2026, filed March 18, 2026 (SEC EDGAR)
  3. Johnson & Johnson — Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 28, 2025, filed February 11, 2026 (SEC EDGAR)
  4. Microsoft Corporation — Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended June 30, 2026, filed July 29, 2026 (SEC EDGAR)
  5. NVIDIA Corporation — Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended January 25, 2026, filed February 25, 2026 (SEC EDGAR)
  6. Pfizer Inc. — Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2025, filed February 26, 2026 (SEC EDGAR)
  7. SEC EDGAR — XBRL company facts (pretax income, IncomeTaxExpenseBenefit, NetIncomeLoss, income taxes paid) for Walmart Inc., read November 18, 2026
  8. United States Code, Title 26, Section 11(b) — corporate income tax rate of 21%, as amended by Public Law 115-97 for tax years beginning after December 31, 2017
  9. FASB Accounting Standards Codification, Topic 740 — Income Taxes