Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Crypto · Coins and tokens

Fiat-backed vs. crypto-backed stablecoins: how each holds $1

How reserve-backed coins like USDC and over-collateralized coins like DAI keep a $1 price, what broke each in 2020 and 2023, and how a crypto vault gets liquidated.

On this page
  1. How a fiat-backed stablecoin holds $1
  2. How a crypto-backed stablecoin holds $1
  3. Worked example: a vault at November 2026 prices
  4. How each one has failed
  5. The two designs at a glance
  6. Which to use when
  7. Pitfalls
  8. How Finabase does it
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. Summary
  11. Check your understanding

A stablecoin is a token meant to be worth exactly one dollar, and the interesting question is always the same: what stands behind the dollar? There are two serious answers. A fiat-backed stablecoin, such as USDT or USDC, is backed by dollars and Treasury bills held by a company, which promises to redeem each token for $1. A crypto-backed stablecoin, such as DAI, is backed by other crypto locked in smart contracts, worth more than the tokens issued against it, and sold automatically if its value falls too far.

The first design trusts an issuer and its banks. The second trusts code and the market for its collateral. Each has failed in its own way, and each failure teaches what the design depends on. This page compares the two, with the market's stablecoins as of November 18, 2026 and a worked liquidation at that day's ether price. (Stablecoins: how dollar tokens hold a $1 peg and how they fail introduces all three designs, including the algorithmic kind that collapsed with TerraUSD.)

How a fiat-backed stablecoin holds $1

An issuer takes in dollars and creates the same number of tokens. It invests the dollars in reserves: cash, bank deposits, short Treasury bills and repurchase agreements. Approved customers can redeem tokens with the issuer for $1 each, and that two-way door keeps the market price near $1: if the token trades at $0.995, a firm can buy tokens and redeem them for a profit, lifting the price. Stablecoins: how dollar tokens hold a $1 peg and how they fail walks through the arbitrage in numbers.

Three things must hold: the reserves exist and are safe, the bank or custodian holding them stays solvent, and redemptions keep working. The GENIUS Act, signed on July 18, 2025, writes these into US law. Once it takes effect, on January 18, 2027 (18 months after enactment, the date regulators' final rules also name), a permitted US issuer must hold reserves of at least one dollar per token in a short list of assets, publish their composition monthly, have that report examined by a registered public accounting firm, and may not pay holders interest. Until then the large issuers publish reserve reports on their own terms. The reserve income stays with the issuer, which is how these companies make money.

How a crypto-backed stablecoin holds $1

Nobody holds dollars. A user locks crypto, say ether, in a smart contract called a vault, and the contract lets the user create stablecoins up to a fraction of the collateral's value. The user has, in effect, borrowed dollars against ether. To get the ether back, the user returns the stablecoins plus a fee.

The protection is over-collateralization. Each vault type has a minimum ratio of collateral to debt, such as 150%. If the collateral falls below it, the protocol liquidates: it sells the ether, repays the debt and charges the user a penalty. As long as liquidations get done before the collateral is worth less than the debt, every token remains backed by more than a dollar of crypto. MakerDAO, now called Sky, built the best-known version, DAI, launched in 2017.

Worked example: a vault at November 2026 prices

A crypto-backed vault: 10 ETH locked, 9,000 dollar tokens borrowed 100% 150% 200% 250% $1,000 $1,400 $1,800 $2,200 $2,400 Minimum ratio 150%: liquidation ETH on Nov 18, 2026: $1800 Collateral value ÷ debt Liquidation at $1,350 Ether price
A crypto-backed vault: 10 ETH locked, 9,000 tokens created, minimum ratio 150% (illustrative; real vault types set their own ratios and penalties). Ether price from the Finabase crypto list, November 18, 2026.

On November 18, 2026 ether traded at $1,800.26. A user locks 10 ETH:

  • Collateral value: 10 × $1,800.26 = $18,002.60.
  • Most the user could create at a 150% minimum: $18,002.60 ÷ 1.5 = $12,001.73.
  • What the user creates instead: 9,000 tokens, keeping a cushion. The ratio is $18,002.60 ÷ $9,000 = 200%.
  • Liquidation price: the ratio hits 150% when 10 ETH are worth $13,500, at $1,350 an ether, a fall of 25%.

Ether has fallen 25% within a few days many times. At liquidation, the protocol sells enough of the 10 ETH to repay the 9,000 tokens plus a penalty, and the user keeps what is left. The holders of the 9,000 tokens, who may have no idea this vault exists, are unaffected as long as the sale raises at least $9,000.

How each one has failed

Crypto-backed, March 2020. On March 12, 2020, ether fell by more than 40% in a day. The Ethereum network clogged with transactions, and some of MakerDAO's liquidation auctions closed with bids of zero, so vaults were sold for nothing and the system was left with debt not backed by collateral. MakerDAO covered the shortfall by creating and selling new MKR governance tokens. The design held, but only because a backstop existed outside it. Afterwards Maker allowed USDC as collateral, and for long stretches fiat-backed coins made up a large part of DAI's backing, which ties DAI's fate partly to the fiat-backed coins it was meant to be an alternative to.

Fiat-backed, March 2023. On Friday, March 10, 2023, Silicon Valley Bank failed. Circle disclosed that $3.3 billion of USDC's reserves, out of about $40 billion, were deposited there. Over the weekend USDC traded as low as well below $1, and DAI, then heavily backed by USDC, fell with it. On Sunday the Treasury, the Federal Reserve and the FDIC announced that all SVB depositors would be protected; USDC returned to $1 within days. The reserves were real; the problem was a bank.

The two designs at a glance

Feature Fiat-backed (USDT, USDC) Crypto-backed (DAI)
What backs each token $1 or more of cash and short T-bills More than $1 of crypto in a vault
Who you trust The issuer, its banks, its auditors Smart contracts, oracles, liquidators
How new tokens are created Customer sends dollars to the issuer User locks collateral and borrows
Can be frozen by the issuer Yes, both USDT and USDC can freeze addresses Not by a company; governance sets rules
Main failure mode Reserves, bank or redemption trouble Collateral crash faster than liquidations
Efficiency $1 in, one token out $1.50 or more locked per token
US rules GENIUS Act, in force from January 18, 2027 Depends on how regulators apply the law
Size, November 18, 2026 USDT $175.2B, USDC $68.9B DAI $4.4B
The largest dollar stablecoins by market value, November 18, 2026 Tether USDt (fiat-backed) $175.2B · price $0.9988 USDC (fiat-backed) $68.9B · price $0.9997 Ethena USDe (synthetic) $4.8B · price $0.9993 Dai (crypto-backed) $4.4B · price $0.9997 USD1 (fiat-backed) $2.9B · price $0.9987 Ripple USD (fiat-backed) $2.8B · price $0.9999 Global Dollar (fiat-backed) $2.6B · price $0.9997 PayPal USD (fiat-backed) $2.5B · price $0.9998 Market value = circulating tokens × price, from the Finabase crypto list.
The largest dollar stablecoins by market value, November 18, 2026. Fiat-backed in dark bars. Ethena USDe is a third design, backed by crypto with an offsetting futures position. Finabase crypto list.

The market has chosen. Of the eight largest dollar stablecoins, six are fiat-backed and worth about $255 billion together. DAI, the largest purely crypto-backed coin, is under 2% of that. A third design, Ethena's USDe ($4.8 billion), holds crypto and an offsetting short futures position, so its value depends on futures markets and exchanges as well. On the day of the snapshot all eight traded within 0.2 cents of $1.

Which to use when

This describes how each design behaves, not which coin to hold.

  • Moving dollars between exchanges or wallets quickly: fiat-backed coins have the deepest markets and the most venues.
  • Wanting no single company able to freeze or redeem your tokens: a crypto-backed coin removes the issuer, though not the risks of its code, its governance or its collateral.
  • Borrowing against crypto without selling it: opening a vault is borrowing, with liquidation risk. Keep a wide cushion above the minimum ratio (Crypto leverage and liquidations: futures, perpetuals and margin).
  • Holding cash for months: no stablecoin pays its holders the interest its reserves earn, and none is insured by the FDIC. A Treasury bill or money market fund pays the yield instead.

Pitfalls

  • "Backed" is not "insured". Neither design has deposit insurance or SIPC protection.
  • Reserve reports are not all equal. Look for monthly, independently examined reports and what the reserves hold (Proof of reserves: what an exchange audit does and does not show).
  • Crypto-backed coins can hold fiat-backed coins. A decentralized label does not mean independence from banks if the collateral includes USDC.
  • Liquidation is a sale at a bad time. A vault liquidated in a crash locks in the loss and pays a penalty.

How Finabase does it

The crypto list includes the largest stablecoins, among them USDT.X, USDC.X and DAI.X, priced against the dollar like any other coin. On a quote page such as USDC.X or DAI.X the useful numbers are the day's low and high and the 52-week range, which show how far the market price has strayed from $1. Finabase does not show reserve reports or vault data; for those, use the issuer's disclosures or the protocol's own dashboards. The figures here are ours, from the crypto list as frozen on November 18, 2026.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between fiat-backed and crypto-backed stablecoins?

A fiat-backed stablecoin is backed by dollars and Treasury bills held by an issuer that redeems tokens at $1. A crypto-backed stablecoin is backed by more than a dollar's worth of other crypto locked in smart contracts, which are sold if their value falls too far.

Which is safer, USDC or DAI?

They carry different risks. USDC depends on Circle, its reserves and its banks, as March 2023 showed. DAI depends on its collateral, its liquidation system and, in practice, on fiat-backed coins it holds. Neither is insured.

Why lock $1.50 of crypto to make $1 of stablecoin?

Because crypto prices fall fast. The extra collateral is the cushion that lets the system sell a vault before its collateral is worth less than its debt.

Do stablecoins pay interest?

Not to holders directly. From January 18, 2027 the GENIUS Act bars permitted issuers from paying interest or yield for holding the token; the reserve income goes to the issuer. Yields offered on stablecoins come from lending them out, which adds risk.

Summary

Fiat-backed and crypto-backed stablecoins both aim for $1 but trust different things. A fiat-backed coin trusts an issuer's reserves, banks and redemptions; on November 18, 2026 USDT and USDC together were worth $244 billion, and USDC's brief fall below $1 in March 2023 showed that a bank failure can break the peg. A crypto-backed coin trusts over-collateralization and automatic liquidation: 10 ETH backing 9,000 tokens is safe until ether falls 25%, and in March 2020 that machinery needed an outside rescue. The first design is simpler and dominates the market; the second removes the company but not the risk.

Check your understanding

4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. What stands behind each token of a fiat-backed stablecoin such as USDC?

    1. More than $1 of ether locked in a smart contract
    2. Dollars and short Treasury bills held by the issuer, which redeems tokens at $1
    3. A promise by the FDIC to repay holders
    Show the answer

    B. Dollars and short Treasury bills held by the issuer, which redeems tokens at $1 The issuer holds reserves of cash and short government debt and redeems tokens for dollars. Stablecoins are not FDIC-insured.

  2. A vault holds 10 ETH and has created 9,000 stablecoins. The minimum collateral ratio is 150%. At what ether price is it liquidated?

    1. $900
    2. $1,350
    3. $1,800
    Show the answer

    B. $1,350 150% of $9,000 is $13,500. Divided by 10 ETH, that is $1,350 an ether, 25% below the November 18, 2026 price of $1,800.

  3. Why did USDC trade well below $1 in March 2023?

    1. Its smart contract was hacked
    2. Circle disclosed that $3.3 billion of its reserves were at Silicon Valley Bank, which had just failed
    3. Ether crashed and vaults were liquidated
    Show the answer

    B. Circle disclosed that $3.3 billion of its reserves were at Silicon Valley Bank, which had just failed The risk in a fiat-backed coin sits with its reserves and the banks that hold them. The price recovered once all SVB depositors were protected.

  4. Why did DAI also lose its peg in March 2023, although it is crypto-backed?

    1. Because a large share of its collateral was USDC
    2. Because DAI is issued by Circle
    3. Because the GENIUS Act banned it
    Show the answer

    A. Because a large share of its collateral was USDC After 2020 MakerDAO accepted USDC as collateral, so DAI's backing depended partly on the fiat-backed coin it was meant to be an alternative to.

Sources and further reading

  1. Public Law 119-27, the GENIUS Act (July 18, 2025): reserve, disclosure and redemption rules for payment stablecoin issuers
  2. Office of the Comptroller of the Currency — Final rule implementing the GENIUS Act (Federal Register, October 23, 2026): the Act is effective January 18, 2027
  3. Circle — USDC transparency and reserve reports
  4. Circle — An update on USDC and Silicon Valley Bank (March 2023)
  5. FDIC — Joint statement by the Department of the Treasury, Federal Reserve and FDIC on Silicon Valley Bank (March 12, 2023)
  6. Tether — Transparency: reserve reports and attestations
  7. MakerDAO (now Sky) — The Maker Protocol: vaults, collateral ratios and liquidation (whitepaper and documentation)
  8. MakerDAO — The market collapse of March 12–13, 2020: how it impacted MakerDAO (zero-bid auctions, MKR debt auctions)
  9. Finabase crypto list (stablecoin prices and market values), November 18, 2026