Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Crypto · DeFi and staking

Crypto staking: how rewards work and what can go wrong

How proof-of-stake rewards are earned on Ethereum, what slashing, exit queues and liquid staking tokens add in risk, and what a 3% reward did against ether’s price.

On this page
  1. Where staking rewards come from
  2. The life of a validator
  3. Four ways to stake
  4. What can go wrong
  5. US tax and regulation, as of November 2026
  6. Staking compared with other ways to earn on crypto
  7. How Finabase does it
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. Summary
  10. Check your understanding

Staking means locking up a cryptocurrency so that it can be used to help run a proof-of-stake blockchain, and being paid in the same coin for doing so. On Ethereum, the largest such network, people who stake ether operate or fund validators: computers that propose and vote on blocks. The network pays them with newly issued ether and a share of transaction fees.

It is often sold as interest on crypto. It is closer to a job with a deposit. The reward is payment for work the validator must keep doing correctly, the deposit can be cut if it does not, and the staked coins cannot be withdrawn on demand. Above all, the reward is paid in a coin whose price moves far more in a month than the reward adds in a year.

This lesson explains where the reward comes from, the four ways of staking and who holds the keys in each, the specific ways money is lost, the US tax rule, and what two years of ether's price did to a staker.

Where staking rewards come from

A blockchain needs someone to order transactions into blocks and a way to stop them from cheating. Bitcoin uses proof of work: miners spend electricity. Proof of stake replaces the electricity with money at risk. Validators lock up coins, and the protocol can destroy part of that stake if a validator breaks the rules. Ethereum switched to this system on September 15, 2022, an event covered in Ethereum and smart contracts: how ether, gas and staking work.

On Ethereum, time is divided into slots of 12 seconds and epochs of 32 slots, or 6.4 minutes. In each slot one validator is chosen at random to propose a block, and the others vote on it. Those votes are called attestations. A validator earns:

  • Attestation rewards for voting correctly and on time, every epoch. This is the steady part.
  • Proposal rewards when it is chosen to build a block, including the tips users attach to transactions. This part is occasional and uneven.

The protocol sets the first part by formula. The base reward for each validator is proportional to its own balance and inversely proportional to the square root of the total ether staked by everyone. If total stake quadruples, the reward rate per coin halves; if it doubles, the rate falls by about 29%. Nobody votes on this and no company decides it. It follows that a staking rate is not a fixed coupon: it drifts down as staking becomes popular and up when stakers leave.

Two consequences are easy to miss.

The reward is paid by dilution, at least in part. New ether issued to stakers increases the supply. A holder who does not stake owns a slightly smaller share of the total each year. So part of a staker's reward is not a gain over other holders but the avoidance of a loss against them. Ethereum also burns the base fee of every transaction, so when the network is busy the burn can offset the new issuance.

The reward is denominated in the coin. A 3% reward means 3% more ether, not 3% more dollars. Whether the staker ends the year richer depends almost entirely on the price.

The life of a validator

The life of an Ethereum validator Deposit 32 ETH or more sent to the deposit contract Activation queue Wait for a slot; no rewards yet Active Attest and propose; earn rewards, risk penalties Exit queue Asked to leave; still on duty while waiting Withdrawable Balance is swept to the withdrawal address Both queues are rate-limited by the protocol: the wait grows when many validators enter or leave at once, which is when a staker is most likely to want out.
The stages an Ethereum validator passes through. Entry and exit are both rate-limited by the protocol.

A validator is created by sending at least 32 ETH to Ethereum's deposit contract. Since the Pectra upgrade of May 7, 2025, one validator can hold up to 2,048 ETH and earn on all of it; before that, every 32 ETH needed its own validator.

Entry and exit are deliberately slow. The protocol limits how much stake may join or leave in each epoch, so that the set of validators cannot change so fast that the chain's security guarantees break. Since Pectra that limit is counted in ether: between 128 and 256 ETH per epoch, rising with the total staked and reaching the cap of 256 once about 16.8 million ETH is staked. At the cap:

256 ETH per epoch × 225 epochs per day = 57,600 ETH per day

If holders of 1,000,000 ETH ask to leave at the same time, the last of them waits 1,000,000 ÷ 57,600 = about 17 days in the exit queue, during which the validator must keep working and remains exposed to penalties. After exiting there is a further delay of 256 epochs, a little over 27 hours, before the balance can be withdrawn. Ethereum's own documentation says only that exiting "takes variable amounts of time, depending on how many others are exiting at the same time".

The queue is longest exactly when it matters: after bad news, when many stakers want their coins back at once and the price is falling. Withdrawals of staked ether were not possible at all until April 12, 2023; people who staked before then had locked their coins for an unknown period.

Four ways to stake

Route Who runs the validator Who holds the keys Minimum What it adds
Solo staking You You 32 ETH Hardware, uptime and software duties; all penalties fall on you
Staking service A company, for a fee You keep withdrawal keys Usually 32 ETH An operator who can get your validator slashed
Liquid staking token A protocol's operators A smart contract Any amount Contract risk; a token that can trade below the coin
Exchange staking The exchange The exchange Any amount Full custody risk: you hold a claim on the company

Solo staking is what the protocol was designed for. It needs a computer online around the clock and some skill. Downtime costs small penalties; running two copies of the same validator by mistake is the classic way to be slashed.

Liquid staking pools deposits in a smart contract, hands the ether to professional operators, and gives the depositor a token that represents the staked position. Lido's stETH is a widely used example. Its balance grows daily as rewards arrive (the documentation calls this rebasing), it can be sold or used as collateral without waiting in the exit queue, and the protocol keeps 10% of the rewards, shared between its operators and its treasury. The fee can be changed by a vote of the protocol's token holders.

Exchange staking is the simplest to use and puts everything in one company's hands. The customer does not own a validator or a token on chain. They own a line in the exchange's database, with the consequences described in Crypto wallets and custody: keys, seed phrases, hot and cold storage.

Fees come out of the reward, not the principal. At an assumed gross rate of 3%:

Fee on rewards Net rate Reward on $10,000 of ether in a year, at a constant price
None (solo) 3.00% $300
10% 2.70% $270
25% 2.25% $225

The 3% is an assumption for the arithmetic, not a current rate. Finabase has no data source for staking rates, and a quoted rate is in any case a recent average of an uneven stream.

What can go wrong

Price

This is the largest risk by far and has nothing to do with staking mechanics. Take 32 ETH staked at the close of November 18, 2024, when ether was $3,209.21, with rewards accruing at an assumed 3% a year in ether.

Dollar value of 32 ETH, staked at an assumed 3% a year and unstaked $50k $100k $150k Staked: coins grow 3% a year (assumed) Not staked: 32 ETH throughout Dec Feb Apr Jun Aug Oct Dec Feb Apr Jun Aug Oct
ETH.X daily closes, November 18, 2024 to November 18, 2026. The staked line adds coins at an assumed 3% a year; the gap between the lines is the entire effect of staking.
After Ether's price Change in price Coins held Dollar value staked Dollar value unstaked
Start $3,209.21 32.00 $102,695 $102,695
1 year $3,121.74 −2.7% 32.96 $102,893 $99,896
2 years $1,802.30 −43.8% 33.92 $61,134 $57,674

In the first year the reward almost exactly offset a small fall in price. Over two years the staker earned 1.92 ETH, worth $3,460 at the end, and was still down 40.5% in dollars. During those two years ether's daily close ranged from 54% below the starting price to 50% above it.

An assumed 3% staking reward against the change in ether’s price Reward, year 1 (in ETH) +3.0% ETH price, year 1 −2.7% Reward, 2 years (in ETH) +6.0% ETH price, 2 years −43.8% ETH daily closes, November 18, 2024 to November 18, 2026. The 3% rate is an assumption, not a quote.
An assumed 3% a year staking reward, paid in ether, beside the change in ether’s dollar price over the same one and two years.

Staking does not make a volatile asset less volatile. It adds a few percent a year to whatever the price does, in either direction.

Slashing and penalties

  • Slashing punishes provable attacks on the chain: proposing two different blocks for one slot, or casting contradictory votes. The validator is ejected. A small amount is burned at once (1/4,096 of its balance since Pectra, which is 0.0078 ETH for a 32 ETH validator), a 36-day removal period begins, and a further penalty is applied at the midpoint that scales with how many other validators were slashed around the same time. Ethereum.org's wording is that if many are slashed together "they could lose their entire stake". An isolated mistake is cheap; a failure shared by a large operator is not.
  • Inactivity penalties apply to validators that are offline. For the two main votes the penalty equals the reward the validator would have earned, so a day offline costs roughly a day's reward.
  • The inactivity leak is the exception. If the chain fails to finalize for more than four epochs, the stake of validators that are not voting with the majority is drained until the remaining validators hold the two-thirds majority that finality needs.

A solo staker controls these risks. A pooled, liquid or exchange staker does not, and shares in whatever the operator loses.

Liquidity

Staked coins are not cash. Leaving takes the exit queue plus the withdrawal delay, and on an exchange it also takes whatever notice period the exchange sets. A liquid staking token avoids the queue only by selling the token to someone else, at the market's price. Since the token can be redeemed for ether only through that same queue, nothing forces it to trade at exactly the value of the ether behind it. When many holders sell at once, it can trade at a discount, and anyone who borrowed against it in a lending protocol can be liquidated on the gap. Crypto lending and yield: where the interest comes from shows how those liquidations work.

Custody and contracts

Liquid staking adds the risk of a bug in the protocol's contracts. Exchange staking adds the risk that the exchange fails, freezes withdrawals or lends out what it holds. Neither is covered by FDIC insurance or SIPC.

The word itself

"Staking" is also used as a marketing label for products that have nothing to do with validating a blockchain: fixed-term deposits of a token with its issuer, or lending programs. If a "staking" reward does not come from a network's block rewards and fees, it is a different product with a different source of yield, and the test in Crypto lending and yield: where the interest comes from applies: who is paying, and why?

US tax and regulation, as of November 2026

Tax. The IRS treats digital assets as property. Revenue Ruling 2023-14 holds that a cash-method taxpayer who receives staking rewards must include their fair market value in gross income in the year they gain "dominion and control" over them, meaning the ability to sell or transfer them. The ruling says the same applies to staking through an exchange. It was still listed as current guidance on the IRS digital assets page dated September 2, 2026. Congress has considered bills that address how staking rewards are taxed. We found no enacted change in the tax code as published through November 10, 2026.

The effect is a second layer of price risk. Suppose a reward of 1 ETH arrives when ether is $3,000. That is $3,000 of ordinary income, and $3,000 becomes the coin's cost basis. If it is sold a year later at $1,800, the result is a $1,200 capital loss, but the income tax on the $3,000 was already due. A staker who never sells still owes tax on rewards as they become available. This is general information, not tax advice.

Funds. IRS Revenue Procedure 2025-31, effective for tax years ending on or after November 10, 2025, is a safe harbor that lets a trust holding a single digital asset, the structure spot crypto funds use, stake it without losing its tax status. Some US-listed ether funds now stake: the Grayscale Ethereum Staking Mini ETF reports that it began staking on October 6, 2025, and the iShares Staked Ethereum Trust ETF launched in early 2026. Whether a particular fund stakes, how much of its ether, and what it keeps of the reward are stated in that fund's prospectus.

Securities law. Whether staking is an offering of securities was disputed for years. SEC staff said in statements of May 29 and August 5, 2025 that protocol staking and liquid staking, as they described them, are not. An interpretation adopted by the Commission on March 17, 2026, jointly with the CFTC, replaced those statements; its fact sheet says that protocol mining, staking and wrapping "do not involve the offer and sale of a security". The interpretation covers the activities as it describes them. A product that merely uses the word staking, or promises more than the network pays, is not made safe or lawful by it.

Staking compared with other ways to earn on crypto

Staking Lending on a protocol Providing liquidity to a pool
Who pays The network: new coins and fees Borrowers Traders, through swap fees
Paid in The staked coin The lent asset Both pool tokens
Rate set by Protocol formula and total stake Supply and demand for loans Trading volume against pool size
Main extra risk Slashing, exit queue Contract or oracle failure, bad debt Impermanent loss
Exposure to price Full, to one coin Full, to the lent asset To both tokens, rebalanced against you
Exit Queue plus delay, or sell a token When the pool has unlent funds Any time, at the current pool ratio

How Finabase does it

Finabase shows the price of proof-of-stake coins and nothing about staking itself. The crypto list and quote pages such as ETH.X and SOL.X show price, change over one week to two years, volume and market cap. They do not show a staking rate, the amount staked, validator counts or queue lengths, and Finabase offers no staking.

That matters when comparing coins. A coin's quoted price return leaves out staking rewards, much as a stock chart leaves out dividends. A fair comparison of two proof-of-stake coins would add each one's reward, net of fees, to its price change. With rewards of a few percent and yearly price changes of tens of percent, the correction is usually small next to the price move, as the tables above show. The example on this page was computed from the daily ether closes behind the ETH.X chart, frozen on November 18, 2026.

Frequently asked questions

Is staking crypto safe?

It is safer than lending coins to a company in one respect, since a solo staker keeps control of the coins, and no safer in the respect that matters most: the staked coin's price can fall far more than the reward adds. On top of that come slashing, exit delays and, for pooled or exchange staking, the failure of whoever holds the keys.

Can you lose money staking?

Yes. The dollar value falls if the coin's price falls, which in the two years studied here turned a 6% gain in coins into a 40.5% loss in dollars. Coins themselves can be lost to slashing, to a failed liquid staking contract or to a failed exchange.

How much ether do you need to stake?

A validator of your own needs 32 ETH. Pools, liquid staking tokens and exchanges accept any amount by combining many deposits, in exchange for a fee on the rewards and control of the keys.

How long does it take to unstake ether?

It varies with how many others are leaving. The protocol lets at most about 57,600 ETH exit per day, then adds a delay of a little over a day before withdrawal. With an empty queue that is a day or two; with a million ether ahead of you it is more than two weeks.

Are staking rewards taxed when received or when sold?

In the US, when received: IRS Revenue Ruling 2023-14 treats rewards as income at their fair market value once you can sell or transfer them. A later sale produces a separate capital gain or loss measured from that value.

Summary

Staking pays validators in new coins and fees for keeping a proof-of-stake chain running. On Ethereum the rate is set by formula and falls as total stake rises, a validator needs 32 ETH, and exits pass through a queue limited to about 57,600 ETH a day. Pools, liquid staking tokens and exchanges lower the minimum and add fees, contracts and custodians. The reward is small next to the price risk: at an assumed 3% a year, 32 ETH staked in November 2024 was worth 40.5% less in dollars two years later despite holding 6% more coins. In the US the reward is taxed as income when it becomes available, whatever the price does afterward.

Check your understanding

5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. On Ethereum, the total amount of ether staked doubles. What happens to the base reward rate per staked coin, other things equal?

    1. It doubles
    2. It stays the same
    3. It falls by about 29%
    4. It halves
    Show the answer

    C. It falls by about 29% The base reward per coin is proportional to one over the square root of the total staked. 1 ÷ √2 = 0.71, a fall of about 29%. The rate is set by formula, not by a company, and drifts down as staking grows.

  2. A staker holds 10 ETH at $3,000 and earns 3% in ether over a year. The price ends the year at $2,400. What is the position worth?

    1. $30,900
    2. $24,720
    3. $24,000
    Show the answer

    B. $24,720 10 ETH becomes 10.3 ETH, and 10.3 × $2,400 = $24,720, a loss of 17.6% in dollars. The reward added 3% to the coin count; the price took 20% off the value of every coin.

  3. Holders of 576,000 ETH ask to exit while the protocol allows 57,600 ETH to leave per day. Roughly how long does the last of them wait in the exit queue?

    1. About 27 hours
    2. About 10 days
    3. There is no wait; withdrawals are instant
    Show the answer

    B. About 10 days 576,000 ÷ 57,600 = 10 days in the queue, before the further delay of about 27 hours that applies after exiting. The queue is longest when many stakers leave together.

  4. Why can a liquid staking token trade below the value of the ether behind it?

    1. Because its issuer sets the price each day
    2. Because it can be redeemed for ether only through the exit queue, so sellers in a hurry must accept the market’s price
    3. Because staking rewards are taxed
    Show the answer

    B. Because it can be redeemed for ether only through the exit queue, so sellers in a hurry must accept the market’s price Nothing converts the token to ether instantly. When many holders want out at once, the only fast route is selling to another buyer, who may demand a discount for waiting in the queue.

  5. A US taxpayer receives a staking reward of 0.5 ETH when ether is $2,000 and sells it later at $1,500. Under Revenue Ruling 2023-14, what is reported?

    1. Nothing until the sale, then $750 of income
    2. $1,000 of ordinary income when the reward became available, then a $250 capital loss on the sale
    3. A $250 loss only
    Show the answer

    B. $1,000 of ordinary income when the reward became available, then a $250 capital loss on the sale The reward is income at its fair market value when the taxpayer gains control of it: 0.5 × $2,000 = $1,000, which becomes the cost basis. Selling for $750 produces a $250 capital loss. The income was taxable even though the price later fell.

Sources and further reading

  1. Ethereum.org — Proof-of-stake (slots, epochs, validators, the 32 ETH deposit)
  2. Ethereum.org — Proof-of-stake rewards and penalties (base reward formula, slashing, inactivity leak)
  3. Ethereum.org — Staking withdrawals (enabled April 12, 2023; exit times vary)
  4. Ethereum.org — Pectra upgrade (activated May 7, 2025; EIP-7251 raises the maximum effective balance to 2,048 ETH)
  5. Ethereum consensus specifications — Electra beacon chain (churn limit, slashing penalty quotient)
  6. Lido documentation — stETH and wstETH (rebasing token, 10% fee on staking rewards)
  7. IRS — Revenue Ruling 2023-14 (staking rewards are income when the taxpayer gains dominion and control)
  8. IRS — Revenue Procedure 2025-31 (safe harbor for trusts that stake digital assets)
  9. SEC — Fact sheet: Application of the federal securities laws to certain types of crypto assets (Release 33-11412, adopted March 17, 2026)
  10. Federal Register — SEC and CFTC interpretation, Application of the Federal Securities Laws to Certain Types of Crypto Assets (91 FR, March 23, 2026; supersedes the May 29 and August 5, 2025 staff staking statements, footnote 100)
  11. SEC Division of Corporation Finance — Statement on certain protocol staking activities (May 29, 2025)
  12. Grayscale Ethereum Staking Mini ETF — annual report on Form 10-K for 2025 (staking commenced October 6, 2025)
  13. iShares — iShares Staked Ethereum Trust ETF (fund page)
  14. IRS — Digital assets (current guidance list), page dated September 2, 2026
  15. Finabase chart data — ETH.X daily closes, November 18, 2024 to November 18, 2026; reward arithmetic computed by Finabase at an assumed 3% a year