Crypto · How blockchains work
Hard forks and soft forks: how blockchains change their rules
How a blockchain changes its rules with no owner, why some changes split it in two, what Bitcoin Cash and Ethereum Classic are worth now, and the US tax rule.
On this page
A fork is a change to the rules of a blockchain. Because no company owns a public chain, nobody can simply push an update to everyone. A new rule takes effect only for the computers whose operators choose to run software that enforces it. When everyone moves together, the chain upgrades. When they do not, the chain can split into two, each with its own coin.
The words soft fork and hard fork describe how a change relates to the old rules, and that decides whether a split is possible. The distinction matters to a holder for practical reasons: a split can leave you owning coins on both chains, exchanges may pause deposits and withdrawals around the event, and in the United States the new coins can be taxable income.
This lesson explains both kinds of fork, walks through the two splits that created lasting second coins, and shows what those coins are worth today beside the originals.
Who decides the rules
Three groups hold a piece of the decision, and none can act alone (see How a blockchain works: blocks, hashes and nodes):
- Developers write the software and propose changes. They cannot make anyone run it.
- Block producers, miners or validators, choose which rules to build blocks under.
- Node operators, including exchanges, wallet providers and businesses that accept the coin, decide which blocks they will accept as valid.
A rule change is real only when all three have, in effect, agreed. Miners who produce blocks under rules that the exchanges' nodes reject are mining a coin nobody will buy from them. This is slow and messy by design. It is what makes a promise such as bitcoin's supply limit hard to break, and it is also why disputes sometimes end in a split, since there is no authority to settle them.
Soft forks: tightening the rules
A soft fork makes the rules stricter: some blocks or transactions that used to be valid become invalid, and nothing that used to be invalid becomes valid. Blocks produced under the new rules still pass every old check, so nodes that have not upgraded keep following the same chain. They simply do not understand or enforce the new restriction.
For this to hold, a majority of block producers must enforce the new rules. If they do, any block that breaks them is left out of the longest chain, and old nodes follow along without noticing.
Bitcoin has made its major changes this way:
- Segregated Witness (SegWit) activated at block 481,824 on August 24, 2017 (UTC). It restructured how signatures are stored, which raised capacity and made layer 2 systems such as Lightning practical (see Layer 2 networks: rollups, Lightning and how they scale).
- Taproot activated at block 709,632 on November 14, 2021. It added a newer signature scheme and more private, flexible spending conditions.
In both cases users who did nothing kept using bitcoin as before, and no second coin appeared.
Hard forks: changing the rules
A hard fork makes valid something the old rules forbid: larger blocks, a different reward, a new transaction type, a reversal of history. Software that has not been upgraded rejects the first such block and everything built on it. From that block on, old and new nodes are following different chains.
What happens next depends entirely on whether anyone stays behind.
Everyone upgrades. The old chain stops growing and is forgotten. This is the normal case. Ethereum schedules hard forks as its ordinary way of upgrading: the Merge of September 15, 2022, which replaced mining with staking, was one, and so were the Pectra upgrade of May 7, 2025 and the Fusaka upgrade of December 3, 2025. Each was announced months ahead, and node operators updated their software before the activation point. Holders had nothing to do.
Some refuse. If a group of miners or validators keeps building on the old rules, and some exchanges and users keep accepting their blocks, both chains survive. They share every block up to the split and diverge after it. Two ledgers now exist, and so do two coins.
What a split does to your coins
The two chains have identical history before the split. So every address that held coins at that moment holds the same balance on both chains, controlled by the same private key (see Public and private keys: how crypto ownership works). Nobody is "given" anything by a company. The second ledger is a copy that went its own way.
Three practical consequences:
- Whoever holds the keys holds both. If your coins were on an exchange at the split, the exchange controls both sets, and it decides whether and when to credit the new coin to customers. Exchanges are not obliged to support every fork.
- Replay risk. If the two chains accept the same transaction format, a payment you sign on one can be copied and broadcast on the other, moving your coins there too. Well-prepared forks add replay protection that makes transactions valid on one chain only. Until you know it exists, moving coins after a split is risky.
- The value is set by the market. The split creates no wealth by itself. Two coins now divide whatever demand exists, and the market decides the ratio.
Two splits that lasted
Ethereum and Ethereum Classic, 2016
In 2016 an investment fund run as a program on Ethereum, called The DAO, had collected about 12 million ether from investors. A flaw in its code let an attacker divert about 3.6 million of it, a third of the total. The code held the diverted ether at the attacker's address for 27 days, which gave the community time to argue about what to do.
The majority chose a hard fork at block 1,920,000 on July 20, 2016 that moved the drained ether to a contract from which the original investors could withdraw it. In effect it edited the ledger to undo the theft. A minority objected on principle: the code had run as written, and a ledger that can be edited when enough people dislike an outcome is not the ledger they had signed up for. They kept running the unaltered chain, which became Ethereum Classic (ETC). The forked chain kept the name Ethereum (ETH).
The episode is the clearest illustration of what "immutable" means in practice. A blockchain's history is as fixed as its participants' agreement to keep it that way.
Bitcoin and Bitcoin Cash, 2017
Bitcoin's split came from a multi-year argument about capacity. One camp wanted to raise the limit on block size so that more transactions fit in each block, keeping fees low for everyday payments. The other argued that larger blocks would make nodes too costly to run, concentrating control, and preferred the SegWit soft fork with payment channels built on top.
The big-block camp launched its own chain. Its software enforced a block larger than 1,000,000 bytes from an activation time of 12:20 UTC on August 1, 2017, and the chains separated after bitcoin block 478,558. The new coin was Bitcoin Cash (BCH). Bitcoin activated SegWit three weeks later and kept the name and the ticker BTC.
What the market decided
At the moment of each split, a holder had equal numbers of both coins. Here is what one unit of each was worth on the Finabase crypto list on November 18, 2026.
| Coin | Price | Market value | Coins in circulation | Per-coin price vs. the original |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bitcoin (BTC) | $64,188.30 | $1,291.1 billion | 20,113,584 | |
| Bitcoin Cash (BCH) | $208.25 | $4.19 billion | 20,118,375 | 0.32% |
| Ethereum (ETH) | $1,800.26 | $220.0 billion | 122,230,380 | |
| Ethereum Classic (ETC) | $5.99 | $0.95 billion | 159,063,950 | 0.33% |
Someone who held one bitcoin through the 2017 split and kept both coins had, on that day, $64,188 of bitcoin and $208 of Bitcoin Cash. The fork added 0.32% to the position. Both splits ended the same way: the side that kept most of the developers, exchanges and users kept almost all of the value, whichever side one thinks had the better argument.
Bitcoin and Bitcoin Cash have nearly the same number of coins outstanding, 20.11 and 20.12 million, because they share bitcoin's issuance schedule and its 21 million limit. Ethereum and Ethereum Classic do not: ETC kept the original proof-of-work design and has a capped supply of 210.7 million, while Ethereum moved to proof of stake (see Proof of work vs proof of stake: how they differ).
A copy of a successful coin's ledger does not copy its network. The lesson generalizes: many later forks of bitcoin were launched mainly to hand a new coin to existing holders and attract attention, and a fork's existence says nothing about its worth.
How the IRS treats forked coins
This section describes US federal income tax as set out in IRS Revenue Ruling 2019-24, issued in October 2019 and still the governing guidance when this page was reviewed on November 18, 2026. It is general education, not tax advice.
The ruling addresses two situations:
- A hard fork where you receive no new coins. There is no income. A protocol change that leaves you holding what you held is not a taxable event.
- A hard fork followed by an airdrop of a new coin that you receive. The value of the new coins is ordinary income, measured at their fair market value when you receive them.
"Receive" has a specific meaning. Income arises when you have dominion and control: the ability to transfer, sell or otherwise dispose of the coins. The ruling's example is a holder whose coins sit with an exchange that does not support the new coin. That holder has no income until the exchange credits the coins and they can be moved or sold.
The amount included in income becomes the holder's cost basis in the new coins, and a later sale produces a capital gain or loss measured from that basis. The original coins keep their original basis and holding period.
A point the ruling leaves uncovered: it deals with airdrops that follow a hard fork, not with promotional airdrops unconnected to a fork. Routine upgrades in which no new coin is created, such as Ethereum's Pectra and Fusaka forks, fall in the first situation.
| Event | New coin created? | What a holder must do | US tax under Rev. Rul. 2019-24 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Soft fork (SegWit, Taproot) | No | Nothing | No income |
| Agreed hard fork (the Merge, Pectra) | No | Nothing, if using a wallet or exchange that upgrades | No income |
| Contested hard fork (Bitcoin Cash, ETC) | Yes | Decide whether to claim; beware replay | Ordinary income when the new coins are received and controllable |
Pitfalls around a fork
- Fork scams. Announcements of a fork attract fake wallets and websites that ask for your private key or seed phrase "to claim your coins". Claiming forked coins never requires giving a key to a website.
- Rushing to move coins. Without replay protection, a transaction on one chain can be replayed on the other. Waiting until wallets and exchanges publish their handling costs nothing.
- Assuming your exchange will credit the new coin. It may not, or may do so months later. If receiving a forked coin matters to you, the only certain way is to hold your own keys at the split.
- Deposits and withdrawals pause. Exchanges commonly suspend transfers around any hard fork, planned or contested, until the network is stable.
- Treating free coins as free. In the US they are income at the value when received. A coin that then falls sharply can leave tax due on value that no longer exists.
- Reading the name as the verdict. "Classic" or "Cash" in a name is branding. Which chain is the original is partly a matter of opinion, and the market's answer is the price.
How Finabase does it
Finabase lists the original and the forked coins as separate symbols with their own prices and history: BTC.X and BCH.X, ETH.X and ETC.X. The crypto list shows each one's price, market value and supply, and the comparison tab can plot a forked coin against its parent, for example Bitcoin Cash against bitcoin.
Finabase does not announce forks, track activation heights or handle forked coins, because it holds no customer crypto. The table above uses the figures shown on the crypto list on November 18, 2026; the percentages are each forked coin's price divided by its parent's.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a hard fork and a soft fork?
A soft fork tightens the rules, so old software still accepts the new blocks and the chain stays whole. A hard fork changes the rules in a way old software rejects, so every node must upgrade, and if some refuse, the chain splits in two.
Do I get free coins in a hard fork?
Only in a contested hard fork that leaves two live chains, and only if you controlled the keys at the split or your exchange chooses to credit you. The new coins may be worth very little, and in the US they count as ordinary income when you receive them.
Is a hard fork bad for a coin?
Not in itself. Most hard forks are planned upgrades that everyone adopts, with no split and no effect on holders. A contested fork signals a serious disagreement in the community and brings practical risks around the event.
Is Bitcoin Cash the same as bitcoin?
No. Bitcoin Cash is a separate chain and coin that split from bitcoin on August 1, 2017 over block size. It shares bitcoin's history before that date and its 21 million limit. On November 18, 2026 one BCH was priced at 0.32% of one BTC.
Can a blockchain reverse a hack with a fork?
Technically yes, if enough of the network agrees, and Ethereum did so after The DAO was drained in 2016. That decision split the community and created Ethereum Classic. It is not something a large chain can be counted on to repeat.
Summary
A blockchain changes its rules only when the people running its software adopt new software. A soft fork narrows the rules and keeps one chain, as bitcoin's SegWit and Taproot did. A hard fork changes them incompatibly: when everyone upgrades it is an ordinary update, as with Ethereum's Merge, Pectra and Fusaka, and when some refuse it leaves two chains and two coins, as with Ethereum Classic in 2016 and Bitcoin Cash in 2017. Holders at a split own both coins under the same keys, but the market has valued the two lasting forks at about a third of one percent of the originals. In the United States, new coins from a fork are ordinary income once you can dispose of them.
Check your understanding
5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
A change makes some previously valid transactions invalid and makes nothing new valid. What kind of fork is it?
- A hard fork
- A soft fork
- A chain split
Show the answer
B. A soft fork Tightening the rules is a soft fork. Blocks made under the stricter rules still pass every old check, so non-upgraded nodes stay on the same chain.
You hold 2 coins in your own wallet when a contested hard fork splits the chain. What do you hold afterward?
- 1 coin on each chain
- 2 coins on the original chain only
- 2 coins on each chain, controlled by the same private key
Show the answer
C. 2 coins on each chain, controlled by the same private key Both chains share the full history before the split, so every balance exists on both, under the same keys.
Your coins were on an exchange at the split, and the exchange does not support the new coin. Under Rev. Rul. 2019-24, when do you have income from it?
- At the moment of the fork
- Not until you can actually dispose of the new coins
- Never
Show the answer
B. Not until you can actually dispose of the new coins Income arises when the holder has dominion and control. Coins sitting in an exchange wallet that does not support them are not yet received in that sense.
What is a replay attack after a chain split?
- A transaction signed for one chain being broadcast on the other, moving the coins there too
- A miner producing the same block twice
- An exchange crediting the forked coin twice
Show the answer
A. A transaction signed for one chain being broadcast on the other, moving the coins there too If both chains accept the same transaction format, a signed transaction is valid on both. Replay protection makes transactions chain-specific.
On November 18, 2026, Bitcoin Cash traded at 0.32% of bitcoin’s price per coin. What does that best illustrate?
- That the fork destroyed bitcoin’s value
- That copying a ledger does not copy the network of users, developers and exchanges that gives a coin its value
- That forked coins always go to zero
Show the answer
B. That copying a ledger does not copy the network of users, developers and exchanges that gives a coin its value Both chains started with identical balances. The market assigned nearly all of the value to the side most participants kept using.
Sources and further reading
- Bitcoin developer glossary — Hard fork and soft fork definitions
- Bitcoin Core source — chainparams.cpp (SegWit activation height 481,824)
- BIP 341 — Taproot (activated at block 709,632)
- Bitcoin Cash — UAHF technical specification (activation time August 1, 2017, 12:20 UTC; block size above 1,000,000 bytes)
- Ethereum.org — History of Ethereum (DAO fork, block 1,920,000, July 20, 2016; later network upgrades)
- Ethereum.org — Pectra and Fusaka upgrade pages (May 7, 2025; December 3, 2025)
- Ethereum Foundation — Fusaka mainnet announcement (activation December 3, 2025; blob-parameter forks December 9, 2025 and January 7, 2026)
- SEC — Report of Investigation: The DAO, Release No. 81207, July 25, 2017 (about 12 million ether raised, 3.6 million diverted, 27-day hold)
- IRS — Revenue Ruling 2019-24 (hard forks and airdrops following a hard fork), October 2019
- Blockstream block explorer — timestamps of bitcoin blocks 478,558, 481,824 and 709,632
- Finabase crypto list — price, market value and supply of BTC, BCH, ETH and ETC on November 18, 2026; ratios computed by Finabase
