Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Fraud and security · Cyberattacks in finance

Cyberattacks and stock prices: what happened after five disclosures

How Equifax and four recent stocks moved against SPY after their companies disclosed cyber incidents, measured on Finabase price data, and the limits of so few cases.

On this page
  1. How the cases were measured
  2. First reaction: the filing day
  3. The next few weeks
  4. Equifax, 2017: the large, slow case
  5. What the cases suggest, and what they do not
  6. Limits of this comparison
  7. How Finabase does it
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. Summary
  10. Check your understanding

When a company says it has been hacked, does its stock fall, and does it stay down? People often answer with a confident "a little, and not for long" or "a lot, and for years". Both answers usually come from someone else's study. This lesson does something more modest and more checkable. It takes five disclosed incidents whose dates can be pinned to the companies' own filings, looks at how each stock moved against the market around those dates, and says plainly what so few cases can and cannot tell you.

The cases are Equifax in 2017, UnitedHealth Group in February 2024, Krispy Kreme in December 2024, Coinbase in May 2025 and United Natural Foods (UNFI) in June 2025. For the last four, every number comes from Finabase's own price history, frozen on November 18, 2026, compared with SPY, the exchange-traded fund that tracks the S&P 500. For Equifax it comes from a congressional report, because Finabase's frozen data does not include daily prices for 2017. None of this is a trading signal, and the lesson does not suggest one.

How the cases were measured

The method is the simplest one that is still fair, and every step is stated so you can repeat it.

  1. The event date is the filing date of the company's first Form 8-K about the incident, read from SEC EDGAR along with the time the SEC accepted it. Krispy Kreme, Coinbase and UNFI filed before the market opened, so the filing day is the first day the market could react. UnitedHealth filed after the close on Thursday, February 22, 2024, so the first reaction was on Friday, February 23.
  2. The starting point is the closing price on the last trading day before the event.
  3. The return is the percentage change in the closing price from that starting point over a window: the first trading day, five trading days and twenty trading days (about a month). For UnitedHealth, which is in the weekly data, the windows are the first week, two weeks and four weeks.
  4. The benchmark is SPY over exactly the same dates. The difference between the two, in percentage points, is the stock's market-adjusted return: how much better or worse it did than the market. A stock that fell 7% on a day the market rose 0.5% did 7.5 points worse.

Prices are split-adjusted closes without dividends, which barely matters over a few weeks.

First reaction: the filing day

First trading day (UNH: first week) after a disclosed cyber incident: stock vs SPY The company’s stock SPY (S&P 500 ETF) +1.1% +1.7% UnitedHealth, Feb 2024 −0.8% +0.8% Krispy Kreme, Dec 2024 −7.2% +0.5% Coinbase, May 2025 −6.9% +0.1% UNFI, Jun 2025 Close before the filing to the close of the filing day (UNH: weekly bars). Finabase price data, frozen Nov 18, 2026.
From the last close before the 8-K filing to the close of the first trading day the market could react (UnitedHealth: the first week, weekly bars). Finabase price data, frozen November 18, 2026.

All four stocks did worse than SPY in the first window, but by very different amounts.

Company (filing) First day or week SPY Stock minus SPY 5 days (UNH: 2 weeks) minus SPY 20 days (UNH: 4 weeks) minus SPY
UnitedHealth (Feb 22, 2024) +1.1% (week) +1.7% −0.6 points −8.8 points −8.0 points
Krispy Kreme (Dec 11, 2024) −0.8% +0.8% −1.6 points −4.0 points −4.7 points
Coinbase (May 15, 2025) −7.2% +0.5% −7.7 points −0.9 points −11.2 points
United Natural Foods (Jun 9, 2025) −6.9% +0.1% −7.0 points −23.2 points −22.3 points

Read across a row and each case tells its own story. Read down a column and there is no neat pattern: the first reaction ranged from almost nothing to about seven points, and the later windows did not simply extend the first one.

The next few weeks

The first day is only part of the story. The chart below follows each daily case from ten trading days before the filing to twenty after it, always as the stock's return minus SPY's return since the last close before the filing.

Stock minus SPY around the filing, in percentage points (0 = close before the filing) −30 −20 −10 0 +10 +20 +30 −10 −5 0 +5 +10 +15 +20 last close before the 8-K DNUT (2024-12-11) COIN (2025-05-15) UNFI (2025-06-09) Trading days from the last close before the 8-K (+1 = the first day the market could react)
Stock return minus SPY return since the last close before the 8-K, daily cases. Krispy Kreme (December 2024), Coinbase (May 2025) and UNFI (June 2025). Finabase daily price data, frozen November 18, 2026.

Krispy Kreme: a slow drift

Krispy Kreme's filing said online ordering was disrupted in parts of the US while shops and deliveries kept working, and that the costs were reasonably likely to be material. The stock fell 0.8% on the filing day, while SPY rose 0.8%. It kept slipping: 3.8% down after five trading days and 8.4% down after twenty, against an SPY loss of 3.7% over the same month. A gap of about five points opened slowly, not in one shock.

Coinbase: a fall that was erased the next day

Coinbase's filing, before the open on May 15, 2025, described an extortion attempt using data obtained by paying support staff, and a preliminary cost estimate of $180 million to $400 million. The stock fell 7.2% that day while SPY rose 0.5%. The next day it closed 1.2% above its pre-filing level.

The reason this case is hard to read sits just before it. On May 12, S&P Dow Jones Indices announced that Coinbase would join the S&P 500 before the open on May 19. The stock rose 24.0% on May 13 and was up 32.2% from May 9 to May 14, the last close before the filing. That is why the line in the chart starts far below zero: the starting point for the measurement was a price that had just jumped on index news. Was the May 15 fall a reaction to the incident, a pause after a 32% run, or both? Prices alone cannot say. Twenty trading days later the stock was 8.5% below its pre-filing close while SPY was up 2.8%.

United Natural Foods: the incident and earnings on back-to-back days

UNFI's first filing, under Item 8.01 before the open on Monday, June 9, 2025, said systems had been taken offline and its ability to fill and deliver orders was temporarily affected. The stock fell 6.9%. The next morning the company reported quarterly results, lowered part of its outlook for reasons it tied to a contract exit and network changes, and left the rest of its outlook unchanged while it assessed the incident. The stock fell another 10.2% that day. By June 13 it was 23.5% below its June 6 close, while SPY was down 0.4%.

When UNFI later filed under Item 1.05 on June 26, saying a material hit to fiscal fourth-quarter profit was reasonably likely, the stock moved only 0.9% lower. By then the market seemed to have absorbed the news, but the earnings release the day after the first filing makes it impossible to separate the two shocks cleanly.

UnitedHealth: the week after the week

UnitedHealth's Item 1.05 filing after the close on February 22, 2024 said a suspected nation-state actor had access to some systems of its Change Healthcare unit, and that it had not determined the incident was reasonably likely to have a material financial impact. In weekly data, the stock rose 1.1% in the week of the filing, a little less than SPY's 1.7%. The following week it fell about 7%, leaving it 6.1% below its pre-filing level against an SPY gain of 2.7%, and it was still 8.0 points behind SPY after four weeks.

Weekly data hides which day the fall came and what else was in the news that week. All the data shows is that the stock lagged the market in the weeks after the filing.

Equifax, 2017: the large, slow case

Equifax announced its breach on September 7, 2017, and it remains the case people remember. According to the House Oversight Committee's December 2018 staff report, which cites market data services:

  • Equifax's market value was $17.02 billion the day before the announcement.
  • The stock fell 35% in the first week, wiping out about $6 billion in market value.
  • By mid-September 2018 it had nearly returned to its pre-announcement price, reaching $138.06.
  • After third-quarter 2018 results on October 24, 2018 missed estimates, with breach costs still rising, it fell more than 17% and closed that week at $97.19.

The Equifax pattern, a large first fall, a long recovery and a second fall when the costs showed up in the results, is a useful warning against judging an incident by its first week. The Equifax data breach of 2017: what happened and what it changed tells the full story.

What the cases suggest, and what they do not

With so few cases, the honest conclusions are short.

  • The market usually notices. In all four measured cases the stock trailed SPY in the first window, and Equifax fell 35% in its first week. That fits the idea that a disclosed incident is unwelcome news. It does not tell you how much worse to expect.
  • Size varies enormously. First reactions ran from under one point (UnitedHealth's first week) to 35% (Equifax's first week). The incidents differed too: a data theft at a credit bureau, an extortion attempt, a shutdown of online ordering, a distributor's systems going offline.
  • Operations seem to matter. UNFI could not ship orders normally and lagged SPY by more than twenty points within a week; Krispy Kreme kept its shops open and lagged by about five points over a month. That is consistent with the idea that disruption to the business, not the word "cyberattack", drives the price. Two cases cannot prove it.
  • Costs arrive later. Equifax's second fall came more than a year after the breach, when costs showed up in earnings.

Limits of this comparison

  • Five cases. These were chosen because their dates could be checked in the companies' own filings and Finabase has the price data. They are not a random sample, and five examples cannot support an average.
  • Other news. Coinbase's index inclusion and UNFI's earnings landed in the same windows as their incidents. Many other things that move a stock (sector news, analyst changes, the company's other announcements) were not checked for each day.
  • A simple benchmark. Subtracting SPY's return assumes the stock would otherwise have moved like the market. A volatile stock such as Coinbase normally swings far more than SPY on any day, which makes a single day's difference noisy. More careful studies adjust for each stock's typical sensitivity to the market (beta); this lesson does not.
  • Data granularity. UnitedHealth is measured on weekly bars, and Equifax on a congressional report's figures rather than Finabase data. Neither is as precise as the daily cases.
  • Leaks before disclosure. Prices can move before a filing if news spreads first. Equifax's own case produced an SEC insider trading charge against an employee who sold before the announcement.

How Finabase does it

Every number for UnitedHealth, Krispy Kreme, Coinbase and UNFI comes from the same price history that the Finabase chart uses, frozen on November 18, 2026 so this page does not change as new prices arrive. You can repeat the comparison on the live site: open a chart with SPY overlaid, such as Coinbase against SPY over two years, or a stock's Comparison tab, which plots it against SPY and QQQ by default. Compare stocks side by side on finabase.io explains the comparison tools. The News tab on a symbol page lists the headlines from the same days, which is the quickest way to see what else the market was hearing.

Frequently asked questions

Do stocks always fall after a data breach is announced?

Not always by much, and not by a predictable amount. In the four cases measured here every stock trailed SPY in the first window, by 0.6 to 7.7 percentage points, Equifax fell 35% in its first week in 2017, and other news often arrived at the same time.

How long does a breach affect a company's share price?

It varies. Coinbase's first-day fall was erased the next day; UNFI was still more than 20 points behind SPY a month later; Equifax took about a year to nearly recover, then fell again when breach costs hit its results.

What is a market-adjusted return?

It is the stock's return minus the market's return over the same dates. If a stock fell 7% while SPY rose 0.5%, its market-adjusted return was −7.5 percentage points, a rough measure of the move that the market as a whole does not explain.

Should I sell a stock when the company reports a cyberattack?

This lesson does not give trading advice. It shows that reactions differ widely and are mixed with other news. Reading the company's filing, which explains what is affected and what is still unknown, tells you more than the first day's price move.

Summary

Measured against SPY on Finabase price data, four stocks did worse than the market right after their companies disclosed cyber incidents, by anywhere from less than one to almost eight percentage points on the first day or week, and Equifax fell 35% in its first week in 2017. Beyond that, the cases disagree: some gaps closed within a day, others widened for weeks, and index news or earnings arrived in the same windows. Five cases make good examples and poor statistics; read the filing, check what else happened the same week, and judge each incident on what it does to the business.

Check your understanding

4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. A stock fell 4% on the day its company disclosed a cyber incident, while SPY rose 1%. What was its market-adjusted return for the day?

    1. About −5 percentage points
    2. About −3 percentage points
    3. About −4 percentage points
    Show the answer

    A. About −5 percentage points Market-adjusted return is the stock's return minus the market's over the same dates: −4% − (+1%) = −5 points. The stock did five points worse than the market as a whole.

  2. Coinbase fell 7.2% on the day of its May 2025 filing. Why is that number hard to pin on the incident alone?

    1. The stock had just jumped about 32% on news that it would join the S&P 500
    2. The filing was made on a day the market was closed
    3. Coinbase did not file a Form 8-K about the incident
    Show the answer

    A. The stock had just jumped about 32% on news that it would join the S&P 500 S&P Dow Jones Indices announced Coinbase's inclusion on May 12, and the stock rose 32.2% from May 9 to May 14. A fall right after such a run can be partly a reversal, and price data alone cannot separate the causes.

  3. UNFI disclosed its incident on June 9, 2025 and reported quarterly results on June 10. What does that do to a measurement of the incident's effect on the stock?

    1. It mixes two pieces of news in the same window, so the effect of each cannot be separated cleanly
    2. Nothing: earnings never move a stock as much as a cyberattack
    3. It proves that the whole fall was caused by the earnings report
    Show the answer

    A. It mixes two pieces of news in the same window, so the effect of each cannot be separated cleanly Confounding news is the main weakness of simple event comparisons. UNFI fell 6.9% on the disclosure day and another 10.2% on the earnings day, and its results release itself referred to the incident.

  4. What is the most defensible conclusion from the five cases in this lesson?

    1. Stocks tended to trail the market right after a disclosure, but the size and duration varied too much to predict
    2. A cyberattack always costs a company about 7% of its value
    3. Buying a stock the day after a breach is a reliable strategy
    Show the answer

    A. Stocks tended to trail the market right after a disclosure, but the size and duration varied too much to predict The reactions ranged from under one point to 35% in a week, some reversed within a day and others widened for weeks. Five cases chosen for their checkable dates are examples, not a rule, and they say nothing about a trading strategy.

Sources and further reading

  1. Finabase price history (daily bars for DNUT, COIN, UNFI and SPY from November 2024; weekly bars for UNH and SPY from November 2021), frozen November 18, 2026
  2. UnitedHealth Group — Form 8-K, Item 1.05 (filed February 22, 2024, after the close; SEC EDGAR)
  3. Krispy Kreme, Inc. — Form 8-K, Item 1.05 (filed December 11, 2024, before the open; SEC EDGAR)
  4. Coinbase Global, Inc. — Form 8-K, Item 1.05 (filed May 15, 2025, before the open; SEC EDGAR)
  5. S&P Dow Jones Indices — Coinbase Global set to join S&P 500 (May 12, 2025)
  6. United Natural Foods, Inc. — Form 8-K, Item 8.01 (filed June 9, 2025, before the open; SEC EDGAR)
  7. United Natural Foods, Inc. — Third quarter fiscal 2025 results (June 10, 2025; SEC EDGAR)
  8. United Natural Foods, Inc. — Form 8-K, Items 1.05 and 7.01 (filed June 26, 2025; SEC EDGAR)
  9. US House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform — The Equifax Data Breach, Majority Staff Report (December 2018; Equifax market value and share price)
  10. SEC — Press release 2018-40, Former Equifax executive charged with insider trading (March 14, 2018)