Fraud and security · Cyberattacks in finance
The Equifax data breach of 2017: what happened and what it changed
How an unpatched flaw exposed data on about 147 million Americans, what the 2019 settlement paid, how the stock reacted and what the breach taught consumers.
On this page
On September 7, 2017, Equifax, one of the three nationwide credit bureaus in the United States, announced that criminals had taken personal data on about 143 million Americans. The count later grew to about 147 million people, according to the Federal Trade Commission: names, dates of birth and, for 145.5 million of them, Social Security numbers. Most of those people had never signed up for anything at Equifax. A credit bureau collects data about consumers from the lenders they deal with.
That is what made the breach different from a hack of a shop or a website. You can close a store card or change a password. You cannot change your date of birth, and replacing a Social Security number is rare and difficult. This lesson walks through what happened, using the timeline that a US House committee built from Equifax's own records, how the company and its regulators responded, what the 2019 settlement paid, how the stock reacted, and the habits the breach taught consumers.
What a credit bureau holds
Equifax is a consumer reporting agency, often called a credit bureau. Lenders, landlords and others send it information about how people borrow and pay, and it sells credit reports and scores built from that information. The House Oversight Committee's staff report on the breach makes the point plainly: consumers do not give their data to these agencies voluntarily and cannot opt out, so the agencies have a heightened responsibility to protect it.
The data a bureau holds is exactly what a criminal needs to pretend to be you: your name, address, date of birth and Social Security number. With those, a fraudster can apply for a credit card, a loan or a phone contract in your name. That makes a breach at a credit bureau more dangerous than most.
What happened
The account below follows the House Oversight Committee's majority staff report of December 2018, which draws on Equifax's internal documents and interviews, and Equifax's own announcement. It describes the failures, not the attackers' techniques.
A known flaw that was not fixed
On March 7, 2017, a critical vulnerability in Apache Struts, open-source software for building web applications, was made public. The next day the Department of Homeland Security alerted Equifax. On March 9 Equifax's security team emailed the alert to more than 400 people, telling anyone running Apache Struts to apply the fix within 48 hours.
One system was missed. Equifax's Automated Consumer Interview System (ACIS), the internet-facing portal consumers used to dispute items on their credit reports, ran a vulnerable version of Apache Struts. It was a custom application first built in the 1970s, and it was not patched.
76 days inside
On May 13, 2017, attackers got into ACIS through that unpatched flaw. Once inside, they found a file of usernames and passwords stored without encryption, which let them reach 48 other databases that had nothing to do with disputes. Over the following weeks they located and copied personal data.
Equifax did not see the data leaving. The device meant to inspect traffic from ACIS had been inactive for 19 months because a security certificate had expired. On July 29, 2017, staff renewed the certificate and immediately saw suspicious traffic. On July 30 Equifax took the portal offline, which ended the attack, 76 days after it began. On August 2 it hired the security firm Mandiant to investigate and alerted the FBI.
The US Government Accountability Office, which reviewed the breach in August 2018, summed up the causes Equifax itself identified in four words: identification, detection, segmenting of access to databases, and data governance. In plain terms: a vulnerable system was not found and fixed, the intrusion was not detected, one foothold gave access to too many databases, and sensitive data was not well controlled.
The announcement
Equifax made the breach public on September 7, 2017. Its press release, filed with the SEC, said about 143 million US consumers were potentially affected, that the access ran from mid-May through July 2017 and that it had found the intrusion on July 29. The data included names, Social Security numbers, birth dates, addresses and, in some cases, driver's license numbers. Credit card numbers for about 209,000 US consumers and dispute documents with personal data for about 182,000 were also taken, along with limited data on some UK and Canadian residents. Equifax offered a year of free credit monitoring and identity theft protection.
The House report found that Equifax was not ready for the response. Its breach website and call centers were overwhelmed, and many people could not find out quickly whether they were affected. The committee's conclusion was blunt: such a breach was "entirely preventable."
The response
People
Equifax's chief information officer and chief security officer both retired on September 15, 2017, eight days after the announcement, and chief executive Richard Smith left on September 26, according to the House report. The count of people affected was revised upward over the following months.
An insider trading case
The breach also produced a securities case. On March 14, 2018, the SEC charged Jun Ying, a former chief information officer of an Equifax US business unit, with insider trading. The SEC said he concluded from confidential information that Equifax had suffered a serious breach, then exercised his vested stock options and sold the shares for nearly $1 million before the public announcement, avoiding more than $117,000 in losses. The case is a reminder that a breach is also material inside information until it is disclosed.
The 2019 settlement
On July 22, 2019, Equifax agreed to a global settlement with the Federal Trade Commission, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) and 50 US states and territories. The FTC described it as at least $575 million and potentially up to $700 million:
- $300 million to a fund for affected consumers, covering credit monitoring and reimbursement, with up to $125 million more if that was not enough.
- $175 million to 48 states, the District of Columbia and Puerto Rico.
- $100 million to the CFPB in civil penalties.
Affected consumers could claim free credit monitoring or cash, and Equifax agreed to give every US consumer six free credit reports a year for seven years starting in January 2020, on top of the free annual report. The deadline to file a claim was January 22, 2024. The FTC's settlement page says payments are still being made, and that people affected by the breach can get free help restoring their identity through January 2029 without having filed a claim.
What it did to the stock
Equifax's shares are listed on the New York Stock Exchange under the symbol EFX, and the company is in the S&P 500. The House report, citing market data, gives the outline:
- The company's market value was $17.02 billion the day before the announcement.
- In the first week after it, the stock fell 35%, wiping out about $6 billion of market value.
- By mid-September 2018 the shares had nearly returned to their pre-announcement price, reaching $138.06.
- After third-quarter 2018 results on October 24, 2018 missed estimates, with breach costs still rising, the stock fell more than 17% and closed that week at $97.19.
Two lessons sit in those numbers. The first is that the market's first reaction was large and fast. The second is that the recovery was real but fragile: a year later the stock was close to where it started, until the costs showed up in the earnings and it fell again. Equifax's 2017 revenue still rose 7% from 2016, according to the same report. Cyberattacks and stock prices: what happened after five disclosures compares this with recent cases measured on Finabase's own price data.
What it taught consumers
Freeze your credit
The single most useful habit to come out of the Equifax era is the credit freeze. A freeze closes your credit report to most new lenders until you lift it, so a criminal holding your Social Security number cannot easily open new credit in your name.
On September 21, 2018, a federal law, the Economic Growth, Regulatory Relief, and Consumer Protection Act, made freezes free at all three nationwide bureaus (Equifax, Experian and TransUnion), extended fraud alerts from 90 days to one year and let parents freeze the files of children under 16 at no cost. A freeze must be placed at each bureau separately. Credit freezes and fraud alerts: how they work and how they differ explains how freezes and fraud alerts work, how fast they take effect and how to lift one for a loan.
Check your reports, and expect phishing
After any large breach, read your credit reports for accounts or inquiries you do not recognize. How to check your credit report for free, and dispute errors shows how. Expect fake messages, too: a famous breach is a perfect excuse for a phishing email that claims to be about your "compensation" or "settlement claim." Go to the official site yourself rather than following a link.
Assume the data is out there
With about 147 million people affected, most American adults should assume that their basic identifying data has been exposed at some point. That is not a reason to panic. It is a reason to rely on controls that work even when a criminal knows your details: a freeze, strong unique passwords, and sign-in codes from an app rather than by text.
Limits of this account
- One main source for the inside story. The detailed timeline comes from a House committee's majority staff report, written by the staff of the party then in the majority. It was based on Equifax documents and interviews, but it is one committee's account.
- Counts changed. Equifax first said 143 million; the FTC uses 147 million and the GAO "at least 145.5 million" for Social Security numbers. This lesson uses each number with its source and date.
- Stock figures are approximate. The share-price numbers come from the House report, which cited market data services. Finabase's own frozen price history does not include daily Equifax prices for 2017, so this lesson does not draw its own chart of that period.
- The costs are still settling. Benefits from the settlement are still being paid, so any total cost to Equifax quoted today is incomplete.
How Finabase does it
Finabase does not hold credit data and cannot freeze credit; only the bureaus can. What it can show is the investor's side of the story. The Equifax symbol page has the price history, a News tab with headlines about the company and a Comparison tab that plots EFX against SPY and QQQ by default. Set the range to MAX to see where 2017 sits in the stock's long history, then read the company's own filings before drawing conclusions.
Frequently asked questions
How many people were affected by the Equifax breach?
About 147 million people, according to the FTC. Equifax first announced about 143 million on September 7, 2017. The FTC counted 145.5 million Social Security numbers and 209,000 payment card numbers among the data taken.
How did the Equifax breach happen?
Equifax did not patch a publicly known flaw in Apache Struts on its online dispute portal. Attackers used it on May 13, 2017, then found unencrypted passwords that opened other databases, and stayed undetected for 76 days.
Can I still claim money from the Equifax settlement?
No new claims are accepted. The deadline was January 22, 2024. The FTC says affected people can still get free identity restoration help through January 2029 without having filed a claim.
Is a credit freeze free?
Yes. Since September 21, 2018, US law has required Equifax, Experian and TransUnion to place and lift freezes for free. You need to freeze your file at each of the three bureaus.
Summary
The Equifax breach began with a publicly known flaw that was never patched on one old web portal, grew because stored passwords opened dozens of other databases, and went unseen for 76 days because a monitoring device had been switched off for 19 months. It exposed data on about 147 million people, cost Equifax a settlement of at least $575 million, cut a third off its stock in a week, and led to the departure of its top technology, security and executive leaders. For consumers, its lasting lesson is the free credit freeze, a defence that works even when criminals already know who you are.
Check your understanding
4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
Equifax emailed an alert about the Apache Struts flaw to more than 400 staff on March 9, 2017. Why did the attack still succeed?
- One internet-facing system, the consumer dispute portal, was never patched
- The flaw had no fix available until after September 2017
- The attackers guessed the chief executive's password
Show the answer
A. One internet-facing system, the consumer dispute portal, was never patched A fix existed and the alert went out, but nobody confirmed it was applied everywhere. The old dispute portal kept running the vulnerable version, and attackers got in on May 13, 2017.
Why did the Equifax intrusion go unnoticed for 76 days?
- A device that monitored the portal's traffic had been inactive for 19 months because a certificate expired
- The attackers deleted Equifax's logs every night
- Equifax had no security team at the time
Show the answer
A. A device that monitored the portal's traffic had been inactive for 19 months because a certificate expired According to the House report, staff saw the suspicious traffic as soon as they renewed the expired certificate on July 29, 2017. Detection that silently stops working gives no warning that it has stopped.
Your Social Security number was in a breach. Which step best stops a criminal from opening a new credit card in your name?
- Place a free credit freeze at Equifax, Experian and TransUnion
- Change the password on your email account
- Check your credit score once a year
Show the answer
A. Place a free credit freeze at Equifax, Experian and TransUnion A freeze closes your credit report to most new lenders, so an application in your name is likely to fail. It has been free at all three bureaus since September 21, 2018, and must be placed at each one.
Equifax's stock fell 35% in the week after the announcement and nearly recovered a year later. What does its later fall after the October 2018 earnings show?
- The costs of a breach can reach the share price long after the first shock, when they appear in results
- A breach never affects a company's earnings
- The first week's fall fully priced in every later cost
Show the answer
A. The costs of a breach can reach the share price long after the first shock, when they appear in results The House report says the stock fell more than 17% after third-quarter 2018 results missed estimates, with breach costs still rising. A recovery in the price does not mean the costs are over.
Sources and further reading
- US House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform — The Equifax Data Breach, Majority Staff Report (December 2018)
- Equifax Inc. — Form 8-K, press release "Equifax Announces Cybersecurity Incident Involving Consumer Information" (September 7, 2017, SEC EDGAR)
- US GAO — GAO-18-559, Data Protection: Actions Taken by Equifax and Federal Agencies in Response to the 2017 Breach (August 2018)
- Federal Trade Commission — Equifax to pay $575 million as part of settlement with FTC, CFPB, and states (July 22, 2019)
- Federal Trade Commission — Equifax Data Breach Settlement (refunds page: claims deadline, identity restoration)
- Federal Trade Commission — Free credit freezes and yearlong fraud alerts take effect (September 21, 2018)
- SEC — Press release 2018-40, Former Equifax executive charged with insider trading (March 14, 2018)
