Schools of economic thought Lesson 7 of 9
Economics · Schools of economic thought
Supply-side economics: tax rates, incentives and the Laffer curve
What supply-siders claim about taxes and growth, how the Laffer curve works, and what the 1981 and 2017 tax cuts and CBO’s dynamic scoring showed about revenue.
On this page
Supply-side economics is the view that the best way to raise output, jobs and living standards is to raise the incentive to produce: to work, save, invest and start businesses. Its main tool is lower marginal tax rates, the rate on the next dollar earned, because that is the rate that changes whether the extra hour, the new machine or the risky venture is worth it.
The idea rose in the 1970s, when high inflation and slow growth discredited demand management and pushed many households into higher brackets. Economists and writers such as Robert Mundell and Arthur Laffer argued that cutting top rates would unleash growth, and the argument shaped the 1981 and 1986 tax laws and the 2017 tax act. Its best-known and most disputed claim is that some tax cuts raise so much growth that they pay for themselves.
This lesson sets out the theory in its own terms, the Laffer curve that sits behind it, and what IRS tax-rate history, federal receipts and the Congressional Budget Office's (CBO) estimates of the 2017 act show.
What supply-siders claim
- Incentives at the margin drive behavior. A person deciding whether to work more, invest or expand a firm compares the after-tax return with the cost. Lowering the marginal rate raises the after-tax return.
- Supply, not demand, sets long-run growth. Output depends on labor, capital and productivity. Policies that raise them raise income permanently; demand stimulus only moves output around its trend (Keynesian economics: demand, the multiplier and the evidence for the opposite emphasis).
- High rates shrink and distort the tax base. People respond to high rates by working less, but also by shifting income into lightly taxed forms, deferring gains, using shelters or moving activity abroad.
- Broad bases and low rates beat narrow bases and high rates. The 1986 Tax Reform Act, which cut the top rate to 28% (from 1988) while broadening the base, is the model many supply-siders point to.
- Some cuts partly or fully finance themselves through faster growth and a larger reported tax base.
The first four are mainstream economics; disagreements are about size. The fifth is the contested one.
The Laffer curve
The curve associated with Arthur Laffer in the 1970s starts from two certain points: at a 0% tax rate the government collects nothing, and at 100% no one bothers to earn taxable income, so it also collects nothing. In between revenue is positive, so there must be a rate that maximizes it. Above that rate, a cut raises revenue; below it, a cut loses revenue, though less than the static arithmetic suggests.
The modern way to locate the peak for top earners uses two numbers: how much reported income responds to the after-tax share (the elasticity, e) and how thick the top of the income distribution is (the Pareto parameter, a).
With a = 1.5 and a mid-range e of 0.25, the peak is 1 ÷ (1 + 0.375) ≈ 73%. Diamond and Saez also show 54% with e = 0.57 (the response of the current, deduction-filled tax base) and 80% with e = 0.17 (a broad base with no deductions). These are combined rates, counting federal and state income taxes, payroll and sales taxes; the combined top rate they computed for 2011 was 42.5%. On their numbers, the US was on the rising side of the curve, where cuts lose revenue. Their formula implies 42.5% is the peak only if e were about 0.9.
Worked example: how much of a cut comes back
The example counts only the direct response of the taxed income. Faster economic growth would add revenue from other taxes too; shifting income from other tax bases would subtract. Measuring both is what "dynamic scoring" tries to do.
What the data show
The top statutory rate has moved by more than 60 points since the 1950s. Receipts as a share of GDP have not followed it in either direction:
| Period | Top rate | Receipts, % of GDP |
|---|---|---|
| FY1981, before the cuts | 70% (1980) | 18.7% |
| FY1983–84, after 1981 act | 50% | 16.5% |
| FY1989, after 1986 act | 28% | 17.6% |
| FY2000, after 1990/1993 | 39.6% | 19.8% (the post-1950 high) |
| FY2017, before 2017 act | 39.6% | 16.9% |
| FY2018–19, after 2017 act | 37% | 16.1% both years |
Two lessons come out of the table. First, the 91% and 70% top rates of the 1950s–1970s applied only to the top slice of income, and receipts then were no higher than today's: they averaged 16.6% of GDP in fiscal 1954–1963, when the top rate was 91%. Second, after each major cut (1981, 2001–03, 2017) receipts fell as a share of GDP, and after the 1993 increase they rose, to 19.8% by FY2000. Recessions, inflation and booms move the series too: the dip to 14.4% in FY2010 was the recession, and CBO attributes the jump to 18.8% in FY2022 mainly to high inflation, higher capital gains realizations and other temporary factors.
The 2017 act and dynamic scoring
The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (Public Law 115-97) cut the corporate rate from a top of 35% to a flat 21% and lowered individual rates through 2025. CBO's April 2018 outlook was its first full dynamic estimate: it projected how the act would change the economy and then how that would change the budget.
In September 2025 CBO checked that projection. Actual revenues were 99.8% of its April 2018 projection in fiscal 2018 and 99.2% in fiscal 2019, and real growth over 2018–2019 averaged 2.7% a year against a projected 2.8%. Revenues later ran above the projection, by $1.5 trillion over 2018–2024, but CBO attributed that to inflation and to higher output from the pandemic stimulus and the immigration surge, not to the act. On CBO's reading, the 2017 act delivered roughly the growth it expected, and it did not pay for itself.
The critics' case
- Revenue. In the US range of rates, the evidence above says cuts lose revenue, though less than static estimates. Claims that a broad cut would pay for itself have not been borne out by CBO or by the receipts data.
- Distribution. Cuts in top rates go mostly to high earners. Diamond and Saez argue that since very high earners value an extra dollar less, a higher top rate costs society less than it raises.
- Growth is hard to find. Many forces move growth; the effect of a given cut is a few tenths of a percent of GDP in most estimates, not a step change.
- Deficits and interest. A cut that is not paid for adds to debt, and the interest on it (Government debt and deficits: how US federal borrowing works).
Supply-siders reply that tax changes do have large effects on output, and the evidence supports part of that: Christina and David Romer (2010) found that tax increases taken for reasons unrelated to the economy are highly contractionary, and Valerie Ramey's (2019) survey puts most tax multipliers between −2 and −3. Those are short-run effects on demand and supply together, and they do not by themselves make a cut self-financing.
Supply-side and other schools compared
| School | Engine of growth | Tax view |
|---|---|---|
| Supply-side | Incentives to produce | Cut marginal rates |
| Keynesian | Demand in the short run | Cut or spend in slumps |
| Public finance | Efficiency and fairness | Broad base; top rate below peak |
| MMT | Real resources, jobs | Taxes to curb inflation |
How Finabase does it
Finabase does not chart tax rates, receipts or deficits; the figures on this page are ours, built from IRS and OMB data. The Economy page lists the Treasury's monthly budget statement in its economic calendar when it is released, with actual, forecast and previous figures. Where tax policy meets markets is in Treasury yields, which the Treasury page lists from 1 month to 30 years, and in the news, which Discover collects under economy.
Frequently asked questions
Do tax cuts pay for themselves?
Not in the US evidence so far. CBO estimated that growth would offset about 31% of the 2017 act's cost, and receipts fell as a share of GDP after the 1981, 2001–03 and 2017 cuts. A cut can raise revenue only if the rate starts above the revenue-maximizing level, which most estimates put well above current US rates.
What is the Laffer curve in simple terms?
It is a hump-shaped curve of tax revenue against the tax rate: zero revenue at 0% and at 100%, with a peak in between. Above the peak, lower rates raise revenue; below it, they lose some.
What is dynamic scoring?
Dynamic scoring is a budget estimate that includes a law's effects on the economy, such as higher output or interest rates, and feeds them back into revenue and spending. CBO, Congress's budget scorekeeper, produced such estimates for the 2017 tax act and for the 2025 reconciliation bill.
Is supply-side economics the same as trickle-down economics?
"Trickle-down" is a critics' label for the claim that cutting taxes on high earners and businesses benefits everyone through investment and jobs. Supply-siders reject the label and describe their goal as better incentives for everyone.
Summary
Supply-side economics holds that lower marginal tax rates raise the incentive to work, save and invest, and so raise long-run output. The Laffer curve shows that some tax rate maximizes revenue; the debate is where the US sits on it, and estimates such as Diamond and Saez's 73% combined rate put current rates on the side where cuts lose revenue. US data agree: the top rate fell from 70% to 28% in the 1980s and is now 37%, while receipts stayed near their 16.9% average and fell as a share of GDP after major cuts. CBO's dynamic estimate of the 2017 act found growth that recovered about 31% of its cost, a projection its 2025 review found broadly accurate for 2018–2019.
Check your understanding
4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
A country’s combined top tax rate is 85%. Its economists estimate the Pareto parameter at 1.5 and the elasticity of top incomes at 0.25. What does the Diamond–Saez formula say about cutting the top rate to 75%?
- Revenue from top earners would rise, because 85% is above the peak of about 73%
- Revenue would fall by the full static amount
- Nothing can be said without knowing GDP growth
Show the answer
A. Revenue from top earners would rise, because 85% is above the peak of about 73% The peak is 1 ÷ (1 + 1.5 × 0.25) ≈ 73%. At 85% the country is on the falling side of the Laffer curve, where a cut raises revenue. This is the case supply-siders have in mind; the evidence says US rates are below the peak.
A tax cut has a static cost of $100 billion a year. A dynamic estimate says faster growth will bring back $30 billion. What is its net cost, and does it pay for itself?
- $130 billion; no
- $70 billion; no
- $0; yes, because growth covers it
Show the answer
B. $70 billion; no Feedback reduces the cost but does not erase it unless it reaches 100%. CBO’s estimate for the 2017 act was of this kind: growth offset about 31% of the cost, and the act still added about $1.9 trillion to deficits over 2018–2028.
Federal receipts were 16.9% of GDP in fiscal 2017 and 16.1% in fiscal 2018 and 2019, after the 2017 tax act. Which reading is fairest?
- The act raised revenue, since dollar receipts kept growing
- The act lowered revenue relative to the economy, consistent with CBO’s estimate that it was not self-financing
- Tax rates have no effect on revenue
Show the answer
B. The act lowered revenue relative to the economy, consistent with CBO’s estimate that it was not self-financing Dollar receipts nearly always grow with prices and output, so the share of GDP is the fair yardstick. It fell after the act, and CBO’s 2025 review found revenues in 2018–2019 within 1% of its post-act projection, which assumed the act lost revenue.
Why do supply-siders focus on the marginal tax rate rather than the average rate?
- Because the marginal rate is what most people pay on all their income
- Because decisions about extra work, saving or investment depend on the tax on the next dollar
- Because the average rate is not published
Show the answer
B. Because decisions about extra work, saving or investment depend on the tax on the next dollar Whether an extra hour of work or a new investment is worth it depends on how much of the extra income you keep. A cut in the top marginal rate changes that calculation for people in the top bracket even if their average rate changes little.
Exercise
One task to do in Finabase. Nothing is graded or saved.
The 2017 tax act, passed in December 2017, cut the top corporate rate from 35% to 21%. Open SPY’s full-history chart and zoom in on 2017 to 2019. Note how the price moved while the bill was debated in 2017, and where it ended 2018. Then compare what you see with CBO’s estimate that the act would raise real GDP by about 0.7% on average and recover about 31% of its cost.
Open the SPY chartWhat you should find
Much of the rise came during 2017, before the law took effect, and 2018 ended lower after a fourth-quarter fall. A lower corporate rate raises after-tax profits directly, which shares price quickly, so a stock rally is not evidence of the economy-wide growth supply-siders expect. CBO’s 2025 review found growth near its projection and no self-financing.
Sources and further reading
- IRS Statistics of Income — Historical Table 23: personal exemptions and lowest and highest bracket tax rates, tax years 1913–2018 (histab23.xls), retrieved 2026-11-18
- IRS — Federal income tax rates and brackets (2025 schedule), retrieved 2026-11-18
- CBO — The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2018 to 2028, Appendix B, the effects of the 2017 tax act (April 2018), retrieved 2026-11-18
- CBO — Estimates of the 2017 tax act: growth and revenues (September 18, 2025), retrieved 2026-11-18
- Diamond and Saez, The case for a progressive tax, Journal of Economic Perspectives 25(4), 2011, retrieved 2026-11-18
- Romer and Romer, The macroeconomic effects of tax changes, American Economic Review 100(3), 2010, retrieved 2026-11-18
- Ramey, Ten years after the financial crisis, Journal of Economic Perspectives 33(2), 2019, retrieved 2026-11-18
- OMB — Federal receipts as % of GDP, fiscal year (FRED series FYFRGDA188S), downloaded 2026-11-18
