Schools of economic thought Lesson 8 of 9
Economics · Schools of economic thought
Modern monetary theory (MMT): claims, critiques and 2021–22
What MMT says about currency issuers, deficits, inflation and a job guarantee, the mainstream objections, and what US deficits, inflation and interest costs show.
On this page
Modern monetary theory (MMT) is a school of thought that starts from how money works for a government that issues its own currency, such as the United States, Japan or the United Kingdom. Its central claim is that such a government cannot run out of its own money, so the question to ask about a budget is not "how will we pay for it?" but "does the economy have the workers, materials and capacity to absorb the spending without inflation?"
MMT grew out of work by Warren Mosler, L. Randall Wray, Stephanie Kelton, Pavlina Tcherneva and others from the 1990s on, building on Abba Lerner's 1943 idea of functional finance: judge a budget by its effects on jobs and prices, not by whether it balances. It reached a wide audience with Kelton's The Deficit Myth (2020), just before the largest US deficits relative to GDP since the Second World War and the highest inflation in four decades.
This lesson states MMT's claims in its own terms, the mainstream critique, and what US data on deficits, inflation and interest costs show. It is a debate among economists; the aim is to make both sides clear.
What MMT claims
- A currency issuer cannot run out of money. The US government spends dollars that it (with the Federal Reserve) creates. It can always pay obligations denominated in dollars, so its debt is not like a household's or a state's. Countries that borrow in a foreign currency, or share one (as euro-area members do), are different.
- Spending comes first. When the Treasury pays a contractor, new deposits and bank reserves appear. Taxes later remove money from the economy; they do not "fund" spending in an accounting sense.
- Taxes have other jobs. They make people need the currency (you must pay taxes in dollars), they free up real resources by reducing private spending, and they are the main tool to restrain inflation. They also shape behavior and inequality.
- Bond sales manage interest rates. Selling Treasuries swaps bank reserves for interest-paying securities. In MMT's view this is a monetary operation, and the interest rate is a policy choice.
- Inflation is the constraint. Deficits are too large when total spending exceeds what the economy can produce. Below that point, a larger deficit buys more output and jobs.
- A job guarantee. The government would offer a job at a fixed wage to anyone who wants one. The pool of guaranteed jobs would grow in slumps and shrink in booms, stabilizing employment and putting a floor under wages, and MMT economists argue it would anchor prices better than unemployment does.
What the arithmetic looks like
The mainstream critique
N. Gregory Mankiw's 2020 survey, "A Skeptic's Guide to Modern Monetary Theory", concluded that MMT contains some kernels of truth but that its most novel policy prescriptions do not follow from its premises. The main objections:
- The no-default point is old news. Mainstream economists agree a currency issuer need not default in its own currency. The question is what happens instead: if a central bank creates money to pay for deficits once markets balk, the result can be inflation, as in episodes of hyperinflation.
- Inflation control depends on politics. MMT would fight inflation with tax rises or spending cuts. Critics doubt that Congress would vote for them quickly enough, and point out that the Fed can raise rates in weeks while tax laws take months.
- Interest rates are not free to choose forever. If the central bank holds rates low while the economy overheats, inflation rises; if it raises them, interest on the debt rises with them.
- Capacity is hard to see in real time. The output gap and natural rate of unemployment are estimated with large errors (see The Phillips curve: unemployment, inflation and expectations), so "spend until inflation appears" risks finding the limit only after crossing it.
- The job guarantee raises questions of cost, management and what work would be done.
On March 13, 2019, the Clark Center (IGM) panel of leading US economists was asked whether governments that borrow in their own currency need not worry about deficits because they can create money, and whether such governments can finance as much real spending as they want by creating money. Of the 38 who answered, none agreed with either statement.
What the data show
Deficits alone do not predict inflation. Across fiscal 1960–2024 the correlation between the deficit as a share of GDP and CPI inflation the following year (December to December) was 0.04, essentially zero (our calculation). Deficits averaged 2.2% of GDP in fiscal 1970–1982, when inflation averaged 7.7% a year, and 5.2% in fiscal 2009–2019, when inflation averaged 1.9%. That fits MMT's point that a deficit's size matters less than the state of the economy: the 2009–2012 deficits came with a large output gap (Keynesian economics: demand, the multiplier and the evidence).
2020–22 was the test case.
| Year | Deficit, % of GDP (FY) | CPI inflation (Dec–Dec) | Fed funds (Dec) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2019 | 4.6% | 2.3% | 1.55% |
| 2020 | 14.7% | 1.3% | 0.09% |
| 2021 | 11.7% | 7.2% | 0.08% |
| 2022 | 5.3% | 6.4% | 4.10% |
| 2023 | 6.1% | 3.3% | 5.33% |
Inflation rose in 2021 after two years of very large deficits with the policy rate at zero, which is what critics of MMT warned about. How much the deficits caused is contested:
- Economists at the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco (Jordà and coauthors, March 2022) estimated that US pandemic fiscal support raised inflation by about 3 percentage points by the end of 2021, with considerable uncertainty.
- Ben Bernanke and Olivier Blanchard (2023) found that most of the surge that began in 2021 came from shocks to prices, such as energy, food and shortages in particular sectors, given wages, rather than from overheated labor markets.
- Kelton (May 2022) argued that deficits can be too large and inflation can be the sign, but that the American Rescue Plan had only a modest effect, that the deficit was already shrinking fast, and that supply problems were the better target.
Both camps can claim part of the record. Inflation did rise when spending outran capacity, which MMT says is the limit, but the US did not respond the way MMT proposes: the Fed raised the policy rate from 0.20% (March 2022) to 5.33% (August 2023), while fiscal policy was not tightened to fight inflation. So 2021–23 tested the mainstream toolkit, not MMT's.
Interest costs are rising. Interest outlays were 1.3% to 1.5% of GDP in fiscal 2009–2014 as rates sat near zero, then rose to 3.86% in fiscal 2024 and 3.94% in fiscal 2025, above the previous high of 3.16% (fiscal 1991 and 2023). In dollars, gross interest on Treasury securities in the FYOINT series reached $1.36 trillion in fiscal 2026, about 25% of federal receipts, against 15% in fiscal 2020 (our calculation). That gross figure includes interest paid to the government's own trust funds; net interest, the cost to taxpayers, was about $1.05 trillion (Interest on the national debt: net interest, rates and r versus g). MMT's answer is that the rate is a policy choice; critics answer that keeping it low in an inflation would conflict with price stability. Either way, the cost of the debt now depends heavily on the Fed's rate path (Government debt and deficits: how US federal borrowing works).
MMT compared with mainstream views
| Question | MMT | Mainstream |
|---|---|---|
| Can the US default? | Not in dollars | Not in dollars (agreed) |
| Limit on deficits | Inflation, real capacity | Inflation and debt dynamics |
| Who fights inflation | Congress: taxes, spending | Central bank: interest rates |
| Role of bond sales | Set interest rates | Finance the deficit |
| Jobs policy | Job guarantee | Demand management, safety net |
How Finabase does it
Finabase does not chart deficits or interest costs; the figures on this page are ours, from public OMB, BLS and Fed data. What the app shows is where the debate meets markets:
- The Treasury page lists yields from 1 month to 30 years, the rates at which the government sells its debt, and the 10-year Treasury yield has its own chart.
- The Economy page charts CPI inflation (year over year), the unemployment rate and the Fed funds rate over the last five years, and its calendar lists the Treasury's monthly budget statement.
- Treasury auctions: how the US sells its debt and how to read results explains how the debt is sold.
Frequently asked questions
What is modern monetary theory in simple terms?
MMT says a government that issues its own currency can always pay its bills in that currency, so the real limit on spending is inflation, not the deficit. Taxes are used to control inflation and shape the economy rather than to "pay for" spending.
Do mainstream economists agree with MMT?
Partly. Most agree that a currency issuer need not default on debt in its own currency, but they reject the claim that it need not worry about deficits. None of the 38 economists on the Clark Center panel in 2019 agreed with MMT's core budget statements.
Did MMT cause the 2021–22 inflation?
No: the US never adopted MMT's framework, though it did run very large deficits. Estimates of how much those deficits raised inflation range from modest to about 3 percentage points by the end of 2021, with supply shocks responsible for much of the rest.
What is a job guarantee?
It is a standing government offer of a job at a fixed wage to anyone who wants one. MMT economists argue it would stabilize employment and prices; critics question its cost and whether useful work could be organized at that scale.
Summary
MMT starts from a point most economists accept: a government that issues its own currency cannot be forced to default in it. From there it argues that inflation, not the deficit, is the true limit on spending, that taxes and a job guarantee should manage that limit, and that interest rates are a policy choice. Critics accept the first point but doubt that tax rises would come in time and stress that interest costs and inflation constrain deficits long before default. The data are mixed: deficits and inflation are almost uncorrelated over 1960–2024, yet the deficits of 2020–21 were followed by 9% inflation, and interest outlays reached 3.9% of GDP in fiscal 2025, a post-1940 high, once rates rose.
Check your understanding
4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
Country A borrows in its own currency and has a floating exchange rate. Country B is a euro-area member that borrows in euros. Both have debt of 120% of GDP. On MMT’s own terms, which faces a risk of being forced to default?
- Both equally, since debt is the same share of GDP
- Country B, because it borrows in a currency it does not issue
- Country A, because it can print money
Show the answer
B. Country B, because it borrows in a currency it does not issue MMT’s no-default claim applies only to a currency issuer borrowing in its own currency. A euro member cannot create euros, so it can face a funding crisis like a state or a household. Mainstream economists agree on this point.
Unemployment is 3.5%, job openings far exceed job seekers, and inflation is 7%. An MMT economist is asked whether the deficit is too large. What does the theory say?
- Deficits never matter for a currency issuer
- The deficit may be too large: inflation with no spare capacity is the signal MMT treats as the limit, and taxes or spending would be the tools
- The central bank should raise interest rates, and fiscal policy is irrelevant
Show the answer
B. The deficit may be too large: inflation with no spare capacity is the signal MMT treats as the limit, and taxes or spending would be the tools MMT does not say deficits never matter; it says inflation is the limit. With no slack, extra demand mainly raises prices. MMT would look first to taxes and spending; the mainstream would look first to the central bank.
Across fiscal 1960–2024 the correlation between the US deficit as a share of GDP and the next year’s CPI inflation was about 0.04. Which conclusion does this support?
- Deficits never cause inflation
- The size of the deficit alone is a poor guide to inflation; what matters is how much slack the economy has and what else is happening
- Large deficits always cause inflation with a one-year lag
Show the answer
B. The size of the deficit alone is a poor guide to inflation; what matters is how much slack the economy has and what else is happening A near-zero correlation means deficits by themselves do not predict inflation: the 2009–2012 deficits came with a large output gap and low inflation, while 1970s inflation came with modest deficits. It does not rule out deficits causing inflation when the economy is at capacity, as many economists think happened in 2021.
The Fed raises its policy rate from near zero to over 5% to fight inflation. In the OMB data, what happens to federal interest outlays over the next few years, and why?
- They fall, because higher rates lower inflation
- They rise, as maturing debt is refinanced at higher rates; they reached 3.9% of GDP in fiscal 2025
- They do not change, because the coupon on existing debt is fixed
Show the answer
B. They rise, as maturing debt is refinanced at higher rates; they reached 3.9% of GDP in fiscal 2025 Existing coupons are fixed, but bills roll over within a year and notes and bonds mature over time, so the average rate on the debt rises with a lag. Interest outlays rose from 2.5% of GDP in fiscal 2020 to 3.94% in fiscal 2025.
Exercise
One task to do in Finabase. Nothing is graded or saved.
Open the five-year chart of the 10-year Treasury yield and note its level in late 2021, then where it has been since 2023. Then open the Economy page and read the Fed funds chart: the policy rate went from 0.20% in March 2022 to 5.33% in August 2023. The lesson says interest outlays reached 3.9% of GDP in fiscal 2025, the highest since at least 1940. Who fought the 2021–22 inflation: Congress with taxes, as MMT proposes, or the Fed?
Open the 10-year yield chartWhat you should find
Yields rose sharply in 2022 and have stayed well above their 2021 levels, so maturing debt is refinanced at higher rates and interest costs climb. The Fed did the fighting with rates; taxes were not raised to cool demand. So 2021–23 tested the mainstream toolkit, not MMT’s, and showed the interest-cost trade-off critics stress.
Sources and further reading
- Kelton, The Deficit Myth: Modern Monetary Theory and the Birth of the People’s Economy (PublicAffairs, 2020)
- Wray, Modern Money Theory: A Primer on Macroeconomics for Sovereign Monetary Systems (Palgrave Macmillan, 2012)
- Lerner, Functional finance and the federal debt, Social Research 10(1), 1943
- Tcherneva, The Case for a Job Guarantee (Polity, 2020)
- Kelton, Should Congress shrink the deficit to fight inflation? (May 27, 2022), retrieved 2026-11-18
- Mankiw, A skeptic’s guide to modern monetary theory, AEA Papers and Proceedings 110, 2020, retrieved 2026-11-18
- Clark Center (IGM) US Economic Experts Panel — Modern monetary theory (March 13, 2019), retrieved 2026-11-18
- Jordà, Liu, Nechio and Rivera-Reyes, Why is U.S. inflation higher than in other countries?, FRBSF Economic Letter 2022-07, retrieved 2026-11-18
- Bernanke and Blanchard, What caused the US pandemic-era inflation?, NBER Working Paper 31417 (2023), retrieved 2026-11-18
- OMB — Federal receipts, net outlays and interest outlays as % of GDP (FRED series FYFRGDA188S, FYONGDA188S, FYOIGDA188S), downloaded 2026-11-18
- OMB / Treasury — Federal receipts and interest outlays, $ (FRED series FYFR, FYOINT), downloaded 2026-11-18
- BLS — CPI-U all items, SA (FRED series CPIAUCSL), downloaded 2026-10-30
- Federal Reserve Board — Effective federal funds rate (FRED series FEDFUNDS), downloaded 2026-10-30
