Asset classes · Forex
Safe-haven currencies: the yen, Swiss franc and dollar in a crisis
Which currencies rise when markets panic and why, measured in 2008, March 2020, 2022 and August 2024, and why the yen failed as a haven in 2022.
On this page
When markets panic, money does not just leave stocks. It moves between currencies too, and a small group of them have tended to rise when everything else falls: the Japanese yen, the Swiss franc and the US dollar. They are called safe-haven currencies, and their behavior in a crisis is one reason a global investor's losses in a crash can be smaller, or larger, than the headline index suggests.
The label is a tendency, not a law. The yen gained 17% against the dollar in the second half of 2008 and lost 23% in 2022, a year of falling stocks. The franc rose against the euro in the euro crisis but fell against the dollar in March 2020. This lesson measures the three havens and one risk currency, the Australian dollar, across four stress episodes and explains what makes a haven work, and fail.
What makes a currency a haven
A safe-haven currency is one that tends to gain value when global risk rises, often measured by falling stock prices or a jump in volatility (see risk-on, risk-off). Ranaldo and Söderlind (2010) found that the yen and the Swiss franc, and to a lesser degree the dollar, appreciated against other currencies when US stocks fell and volatility rose. Three mechanisms explain why.
Net foreign assets and repatriation
Japan and Switzerland own far more foreign assets than foreigners own of theirs: both have among the largest positive net international investment positions relative to their economies, according to Japan's Ministry of Finance and the SNB. In a crisis, investors in those countries sell some foreign holdings and bring the money home, or hedge more of it, which means buying yen or francs. Exporters may also convert foreign earnings sooner.
Funding currencies and carry unwinds
Low interest rates make the yen and franc cheap to borrow, so they are common funding currencies in carry trades. When risk rises, carry traders close their positions by buying back the funding currency. That buying is a mechanical source of haven strength, and it explains the speed of moves like August 2024.
Liquidity and the dollar
The dollar is a haven for a different reason. Much of the world's borrowing, trade invoicing and collateral is in dollars, and US Treasury bills are the deepest safe asset (see The dollar as reserve currency: COFER data and de-dollarization). In a scramble for cash, borrowers outside the US need dollars to repay dollar debts, and investors sell almost everything else to hold them. That demand can overwhelm the repatriation pull of the yen and franc, as in March 2020.
Four stress episodes on Federal Reserve data
The figure compares each currency's change in value against the US dollar, and the broad dollar index's change against a basket of 26 currencies, using monthly averages.
| Episode (monthly averages) | Yen | Swiss franc | Broad dollar | Australian dollar |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2008 crisis (Jul → Dec 2008) | +17.1% | −9.8% | +15.3% | −30.2% |
| Covid shock (Feb → Mar 2020) | +2.2% | +1.8% | +3.7% | −6.7% |
| Rate shock (Dec 2021 → Oct 2022) | −22.6% | −7.4% | +10.1% | −11.0% |
| Carry unwind (Jun → Aug 2024) | +7.9% | +4.2% | −0.9% | +0.2% |
2008: yen and dollar up, Aussie down
As the financial crisis deepened (see The 2008 financial crisis: housing, Lehman, TARP and the 57% fall), the yen and the dollar both surged. The yen's rise was a classic carry unwind: on the Fed's monthly averages it gained 34.4% against the dollar from June 2007, when a dollar bought ¥122.69, to December 2008 (¥91.28). The Australian dollar, a carry target and commodity currency, fell from $0.962 in July 2008 to $0.687 in October. The franc fell against the dollar in the second half of 2008, though it rose against the euro: a haven against one currency is not a haven against all of them.
March 2020: the dollar's dash for cash
Monthly averages hide the speed of March 2020 (see The COVID crash of 2020: the fastest bear market and recovery). On daily data the Fed's broad dollar index rose from 116.50 on March 3 to 126.13 on March 23, an 8.3% rise in three weeks. The franc, a supposed haven, fell 5.6% against the dollar from March 9 to March 19 (0.9296 to 0.9847 francs per dollar) as investors and banks everywhere sought dollars. The surge eased after the Federal Reserve widened its dollar swap lines with other central banks and launched emergency programs.
2022: when the yen failed
2022 was a year of falling stocks and bonds, but the trigger was inflation and rising interest rates, not a funding panic. The Fed raised rates rapidly while the Bank of Japan kept its policy rate at −0.1%. The rate gap dominated: from January 3 to October 20, 2022 the yen lost 23.1% of its dollar value on daily noon rates (¥115.27 to ¥149.82), even as stocks fell, until Japan intervened (see Currency intervention: how central banks move exchange rates). The franc lost 7.4% on monthly averages, while the dollar rose 10.1% against the broad basket. A haven that is also the lowest-yielding currency works when rates are falling or stable worldwide, not when one central bank raises them and the haven's does not.
August 2024: a carry unwind
The yen's 2024 jump was a haven move driven by positioning. On daily noon rates the yen rose 12.4% against the dollar from July 10 to August 5, 2024, and the franc 5.4% (0.8992 to 0.8528 francs per dollar), as yen- and franc-funded carry trades were closed (see Currency carry trades: how they pay and why they crash). The broad dollar index barely moved on monthly averages, because the dollar gained against risk currencies while losing against the funding ones.
The pattern behind the episodes
- Funding panics and carry unwinds favor the yen and franc, especially when US rates are falling or expected to fall.
- Dollar-funding stress favors the dollar over everything, havens included.
- Inflation and rate shocks can turn the low-yielding havens into the weakest currencies.
- Risk currencies such as the Australian dollar fall in almost every stress episode; pairs like AUD/JPY are often used as a gauge of risk appetite for that reason.
Some analysts describe the dollar's behavior as a "smile": strong when the world is in crisis, weak when the world grows steadily, and strong again when the US outgrows everyone. It is a description, not a law, and 2022's dollar strength had more to do with US rates than with panic.
Pitfalls
- Assuming a haven always rises. The yen fell 23% in 2022 and the franc fell against the dollar in March 2020.
- Ignoring the cross. A currency can be a haven against the euro and not against the dollar, as the franc was in 2008.
- Using monthly averages for fast episodes. March 2020 and August 2024 played out in days; monthly data understate the moves.
- Forgetting intervention. Japan and Switzerland have both acted to stop haven appreciation they considered excessive, as in the SNB's 2011–2015 euro floor.
- Owning a haven costs carry. In calm years, low-yielding havens pay little or nothing and tend to weaken against higher-yielding currencies.
Havens compared
| Currency | Why it can rise in stress | When it has failed |
|---|---|---|
| Japanese yen | Net foreign assets, carry unwinds | 2022 rate shock |
| Swiss franc | Net foreign assets, stable policy | March 2020 vs the dollar |
| US dollar | Liquidity, dollar debts, Treasuries | Calm, strong-growth abroad |
| Gold | No credit risk (see the gold lesson) | 2013, rising real yields |
For gold's record, see Gold and precious metals: how gold is priced and what drives it.
How Finabase does it
The forex page lists the haven and risk pairs this lesson uses: USD/JPY, USD/CHF, EUR/CHF, AUD/USD and AUD/JPY, each with a chart and returns from one week to two years. You can compare a haven pair's chart with a stock index over the same dates to see the pattern. Finabase does not compute safe-haven betas or show investment positions; the figure and table here are ours, built from Federal Reserve data.
Frequently asked questions
Which currencies are safe havens?
Historically the Japanese yen, the Swiss franc and the US dollar. They tend to rise when global stocks fall, though each has failed in some episodes.
Why does the yen rise in a crisis?
Japan owns large foreign assets that investors bring home or hedge in a crisis, and the yen is a common funding currency for carry trades, which are closed by buying yen. Both create demand for yen when risk rises.
Why did the yen fall in 2022 when stocks fell?
Because the shock was rising inflation and interest rates. The Fed raised rates sharply while the Bank of Japan held at −0.1%, and the widening rate gap pushed the yen down 23.1% against the dollar from January 3 to October 20, 2022.
Is the US dollar a safe haven?
Often, especially in funding panics. In March 2020 the Fed's broad dollar index rose 8.3% in three weeks as investors and borrowers worldwide sought dollars.
Summary
Safe-haven currencies are those that tend to rise when markets fall: the yen and Swiss franc because of large net foreign assets and their role as carry-trade funding currencies, the dollar because of its liquidity and the world's dollar debts. In 2008 the yen rose 17.1% and the broad dollar 15.3% from July to December while the Australian dollar fell 30.2%; in March 2020 the dollar beat even the franc; in August 2024 a carry unwind lifted the yen 12.4% in under four weeks. In 2022 the yen lost 23.1% as rates rose everywhere but Japan. A haven is a tendency with conditions, not a guarantee.
Check your understanding
4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
Why does the yen often rise when global stocks fall?
- Because Japan’s economy grows fastest in recessions
- Because Japanese investors bring money home and carry traders buy back yen they borrowed
- Because the yen is pegged to gold
Show the answer
B. Because Japanese investors bring money home and carry traders buy back yen they borrowed Japan holds large net foreign assets, and the yen is a cheap funding currency. In a sell-off, repatriation and the closing of carry trades both create demand for yen.
In March 2020 the Swiss franc fell about 5.6% against the dollar in ten days. What explains it?
- The franc stopped being a currency
- A worldwide scramble for dollars to repay dollar debts and hold Treasuries outweighed the franc’s haven pull
- Switzerland raised interest rates
Show the answer
B. A worldwide scramble for dollars to repay dollar debts and hold Treasuries outweighed the franc’s haven pull In a dollar-funding panic the dollar beats every other currency, havens included. The pressure eased after the Fed widened its swap lines with other central banks.
Stocks fell in 2022, yet the yen lost about 23% against the dollar by October. Why did it fail as a haven?
- The shock was rising inflation and rates, and the gap between US rates and Japan’s −0.1% rate kept widening
- Japan sold its foreign assets
- The yen became a commodity currency
Show the answer
A. The shock was rising inflation and rates, and the gap between US rates and Japan’s −0.1% rate kept widening Havens work best in funding panics and carry unwinds. In a rate shock where one central bank stays put, the low-yielding haven becomes the obvious currency to sell.
Which pair is often used as a quick gauge of global risk appetite, and why?
- EUR/CHF, because both are havens
- AUD/JPY, because it pairs a risk and carry currency with a haven and funding currency
- USD/HKD, because it is pegged
Show the answer
B. AUD/JPY, because it pairs a risk and carry currency with a haven and funding currency The Australian dollar tends to fall in stress and the yen to rise, so AUD/JPY drops sharply when investors cut risk, as in 2008 and August 2024.
Exercise
One task to do in Finabase. Nothing is graded or saved.
Open the AUD/JPY chart on its longest range. Find the falls around late 2008, March 2020 and early August 2024. For each, measure the drop in percent and compare it with the yen’s move against the dollar (USD/JPY) over the same weeks. Then look at 2022: what did AUD/JPY do while stocks fell that year?
Open the AUD/JPY chartWhat you should find
AUD/JPY should fall sharply in 2008, March 2020 and August 2024, the risk-off episodes, by more than USD/JPY because the Aussie falls while the yen rises. In 2022 it did not collapse even though stocks fell, because the shock was rising rates and the yen itself was weak.
Sources and further reading
- Federal Reserve Board (G.5) — yen and Swiss francs per dollar, dollars per Australian dollar, monthly averages (FRED series EXJPUS, EXSZUS, EXUSAL), downloaded 2026-11-18
- Federal Reserve Board (H.10) — nominal broad dollar index and daily yen and franc rates (FRED series DTWEXBGS, DEXJPUS, DEXSZUS), downloaded 2026-11-18
- Ministry of Finance, Japan — International Investment Position of Japan
- Swiss National Bank — Swiss international investment position
- Angelo Ranaldo and Paul Söderlind, “Safe Haven Currencies,” Review of Finance, vol. 14, no. 3 (2010)
- Bank for International Settlements — BIS Quarterly Review, September 2024: the market turbulence of early August 2024
- Federal Reserve Board — central bank liquidity swap lines (March 2020)
