Asset classes · Commodities one by one
What drives commodity prices: supply, storage, demand and the dollar
The forces behind commodity prices: supply shocks, inventories and the theory of storage, seasons, the business cycle and the dollar, measured over 20 years.
On this page
Commodity prices move for reasons that are easier to list than to weigh. A frost, a war, a recession, a strike at a mine, a change in interest rates and a move in the dollar can all hit the same market in the same month. This lesson sorts those forces into a few families, explains the one idea that ties them together, inventories, and measures the most often quoted one, the dollar, with 20 years of monthly data.
The introduction to the asset class, its three groups and the ways to own it, is in Commodities explained: energy, metals, crops and how to own them. The single-commodity lessons (Corn prices: feed, ethanol, exports and the crop calendar, Wheat prices: classes, Black Sea exports and the 2022 spike, Soybeans: the crush, China’s imports and the Brazil-US seasons, Coffee prices: arabica, robusta and Brazil’s weather, Sugar prices: Sugar No. 11, Brazil’s cane mix and India, Live cattle and lean hogs: the herd cycle, seasons and disease) show these forces at work in one market each. Here the aim is the general frame, and a table of which drivers matter most for which commodity.
Supply shocks
Commodities are produced by fields, mines, wells and herds that take months or years to expand. When something cuts output, there is no quick replacement, so the price must rise until enough buyers back away. The main sources of supply shock:
- Weather. Drought, frost, floods and heat. The 2012 US drought, Brazil's coffee frosts and the 2024 drought in Vietnam's robusta region are examples in the crop lessons.
- War and politics. Russia's 2022 invasion of Ukraine hit wheat, corn, sunflower oil, natural gas and fertilizer at once. Sanctions and export bans work the same way.
- Disease. African swine fever, PEDv and screwworm reshaped livestock markets (see Live cattle and lean hogs: the herd cycle, seasons and disease).
- Accidents and strikes. Mine collapses, refinery outages and pipeline failures hit metals and fuels.
- Policy decisions by producers. OPEC+ output targets for oil, India's sugar and rice export rules, Indonesia's export restrictions on nickel ore and palm oil.
Supply shocks tend to be sharp and then to fade, because high prices bring out more supply. KC wheat lost about half its value within two years of its 2022 peak, ending below its pre-war level; coffee nearly tripled from 2023 to 2025 and was a third off its peak by late 2026.
Storage, inventories and the convenience yield
The most useful single idea in commodity economics is that storable commodities link today's price to tomorrow's through inventories. Holding a commodity from now until a future date costs interest on the money tied up plus storage and insurance. A futures price for that date should therefore sit no more than that cost of carry above the spot price, or traders would buy spot, store it and sell the future.
When inventories are plentiful, futures trade close to full carry above spot: the curve slopes up, the condition called contango. When inventories are scarce, users will pay a premium to have the commodity now rather than later, because running out would stop a refinery or a feed mill. Spot rises above futures and the curve can slope down. That premium for holding the physical commodity is the convenience yield. The idea was developed by Nicholas Kaldor (1939) and Holbrook Working (1949) and is known as the theory of storage. The slope of the curve and what it costs futures investors are covered in Contango, backwardation and roll yield: why USO lags oil.
The practical point: inventory data move prices. Traders watch the US Energy Information Administration's weekly petroleum stocks, the USDA's monthly ending-stock projections in the WASDE, and the exchange warehouse stocks for metals. A surprise draw on inventories lifts spot prices and steepens backwardation; a build does the opposite. The crop version, the stocks-to-use ratio, is worked through in Corn prices: feed, ethanol, exports and the crop calendar.
Seasons
Many commodities have a calendar. Crops are planted and harvested at fixed times, natural gas demand peaks in winter, gasoline in summer, and hog supply dips in summer. Seasonal patterns are real, but most are already in the futures curve: a December corn contract or an October hog contract is priced for the season it delivers in. That is why a front-month chart shows regular jumps at each contract switch that no one earns (see Live cattle and lean hogs: the herd cycle, seasons and disease). What moves prices is a season that turns out different from the one the curve expected.
Demand and the business cycle
Demand for most commodities grows with the world economy, and swings with the business cycle. Industrial metals and energy are the most cyclical: factories, construction and transport use them directly. Agricultural demand is steadier, since people eat in recessions, though feed and biofuel demand can shift.
Our data show the ordering. Monthly changes in front-month copper had a correlation of 0.41 with SPY's from 2006 to 2026, and copper and WTI crude correlated 0.38 with each other. Corn's correlation with WTI was only 0.14, gold's 0.15. The broad basket, DBC, correlated 0.44 with SPY, which is why commodities fell with stocks in 2008 and 2020 even though they rose while stocks fell in 2022.
Over longer spans, demand from one fast-growing economy can lift prices for a decade: China's industrial build-out in the 2000s is the usual example of a "supercycle" (see China’s economy: growth, property, the yuan and US trade). Those are visible only in hindsight.
The dollar
Most commodities are priced in US dollars. When the dollar strengthens, the same dollar price costs more in euros, yen or reais, so buyers abroad buy less; and producers abroad, whose costs are in local currency, earn more per dollar and may sell more. Both effects push dollar prices down. A weaker dollar works the other way.
How strong is the effect? We compared monthly changes in DBC with two dollar measures: UUP, a fund that tracks the dollar against six major currencies (like the DXY), and the Federal Reserve's broad dollar index, which weights 26 currencies by trade (see The US dollar and exchange rates: indexes, drivers and earnings for how the two differ).
| Period | DBC vs UUP | DBC vs Fed broad dollar |
|---|---|---|
| Apr 2007–Oct 2026 | −0.42 | −0.56 |
| 2007–2011 | −0.69 | −0.80 |
| 2012–2016 | −0.57 | −0.61 |
| 2017–2021 | −0.34 | −0.53 |
| 2022–Oct 2026 | +0.10 | −0.08 |
From 2007 to 2016 the relationship was strong and negative: commodities tended to fall in months when the dollar rose. The two big commodity crashes came with dollar rallies: from June to December 2008 DBC fell 53% while UUP rose 10%, and from June 2014 to December 2015 DBC fell 50% while UUP rose 21%.
Since 2022 the link has nearly vanished. From December 2021 to May 2022, DBC rose 39% and UUP rose 6% at the same time: a war-driven supply shock overwhelmed the dollar effect. In 2026 to October, DBC rose 51% and UUP 7%. A correlation is an average over many months; when one force is large, it can swamp the others.
By commodity
The dollar matters most for the commodities that trade most globally and are held as financial assets: gold and copper (−0.51 each), then crude oil and wheat (−0.39) and corn (−0.34). It matters least for sugar and lean hogs (−0.14) and hardly at all for live cattle (−0.03), a mostly domestic market. Stocks, for comparison, also moved opposite to the broad dollar (−0.59), a reminder that the dollar often rises when markets are under stress and every risky asset falls.
Which drivers matter for which commodity
| Commodity | Main supply risk | Main demand driver | Dollar link (monthly, 2006–2026) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Crude oil | OPEC+ policy, war, outages | Global growth, transport | −0.39 |
| Copper | Mine outages, strikes | Construction, manufacturing | −0.51 |
| Gold | Little (stocks are huge) | Investors, central banks | −0.51 |
| Corn, wheat | Weather, export policy | Feed, food, biofuel | −0.34, −0.39 |
| Sugar | Brazil weather, India export rules | Food; Brazil's ethanol | −0.14 |
| Live cattle | Herd cycle, drought, disease | US beef demand | −0.03 |
Volatility follows the same lines. Annualized monthly volatility from 2006 to 2026 was about 40% for front-month WTI and 40% for lean hogs, around 30%–33% for corn, wheat and sugar, 26% for copper and about 17%–18% for gold and live cattle, against 19% for DBC and 15% for SPY.
Pitfalls and limitations
- Correlation is not a lever. A −0.5 correlation with the dollar leaves most of each month's move to other forces, and the 2022–2026 period shows it can disappear.
- Two dollars. UUP tracks six major currencies, the Fed's index 26; they give different answers (−0.42 and −0.56 for DBC overall).
- Front-month data. Single-commodity correlations use spliced front-month prices with some missing months, so they describe prices, not returns anyone earned.
- Hindsight stories. After a big move, every driver looks obvious. Before it, the same facts supported several outcomes.
- Seasonality is mostly priced in. Expect the season the curve already shows.
How Finabase does it
The Futures page lists energy, metal, grain and soft commodity futures in one table with returns from one week to two years, which is the quickest way to see whether a move is broad (the dollar, the economy) or confined to one market (weather, policy). The Forex page lists 51 currency pairs, and dollar funds such as UUP and commodity funds such as DBC have ordinary symbol pages you can chart side by side. The app does not show inventory reports; those come from the EIA, the USDA and the exchanges. The correlations in this lesson are our own calculations from frozen Finabase price snapshots and the Federal Reserve's dollar index.
Frequently asked questions
Why do commodity prices go up when the dollar goes down?
Because they are priced in dollars: a weaker dollar makes them cheaper for buyers using other currencies and reduces what foreign producers earn in their own currency. In our data DBC's monthly changes correlated −0.57 with the Fed's broad dollar index from 2006 to 2026, but only −0.08 in 2022–2026.
What is convenience yield?
It is the benefit of holding a physical commodity now rather than a futures contract for later, highest when inventories are scarce. It explains why futures can trade below the spot price despite storage and interest costs.
What causes commodity price spikes?
Usually a supply shock when inventories are already low: a drought, a war, a disease or an export ban. With little stock to draw on, the price must rise far enough to cut demand.
Do commodities follow the stock market?
Partly. Industrial metals and energy rise and fall with economic growth; copper's monthly changes correlated 0.41 with the S&P 500's in 2006–2026. Supply shocks, as in 2022, can send commodities up while stocks fall.
Summary
Commodity prices are set by supply that adjusts slowly, inventories that cushion or amplify shocks, seasons that the futures curve already prices, demand that follows the business cycle, and the dollar they are priced in. The theory of storage ties these together: scarce stocks lift spot prices and create a convenience yield. The dollar's influence is real but uneven: a −0.57 correlation with DBC over 2006–2026, near zero since 2022, strongest for gold and copper and almost absent for cattle. When a large supply shock arrives, it outweighs everything else.
Check your understanding
4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
Spot crude is $70, interest is 5% a year and storage costs $2.50 a barrel a year. The one-year future trades at $72. What does that suggest?
- Inventories are plentiful and the curve is at full carry
- The future is about $4 below full carry, implying a convenience yield: stocks are relatively tight
- The future is mispriced and will be corrected by the exchange
Show the answer
B. The future is about $4 below full carry, implying a convenience yield: stocks are relatively tight Full carry would be 70 × 1.05 + 2.50 = $76. Trading at $72 means users pay about $4, or roughly 6% a year, for holding oil now, the sign of scarce inventories.
From 2007 to 2016 DBC’s monthly changes correlated strongly and negatively with the dollar; from 2022 to 2026 the correlation was near zero. What is the best reading?
- The dollar stopped affecting commodity prices
- The dollar effect still exists, but large supply shocks such as the 2022 war can swamp it in the average
- The data are wrong
Show the answer
B. The dollar effect still exists, but large supply shocks such as the 2022 war can swamp it in the average A correlation averages many months. In early 2022 DBC rose 39% while the dollar also rose; a supply shock outweighed the usual dollar effect.
Which commodity in our data had almost no relationship with the dollar, and why is that plausible?
- Gold, because it is not traded abroad
- Live cattle, because it is a mostly domestic US market
- Copper, because it is priced in yuan
Show the answer
B. Live cattle, because it is a mostly domestic US market Live cattle correlated −0.03 with the broad dollar. Gold and copper, traded and held worldwide, were the most dollar-sensitive at −0.51.
A front-month chart of natural gas rises every autumn. Why is that not a free seasonal trade?
- Natural gas futures cannot be bought in autumn
- The futures curve already prices winter demand: winter contracts trade above summer ones, so the chart’s rise is largely the switch between contracts
- Seasonality only applies to crops
Show the answer
B. The futures curve already prices winter demand: winter contracts trade above summer ones, so the chart’s rise is largely the switch between contracts Seasonal patterns are known to everyone and are built into the prices of each contract month. What moves prices is a season that differs from what the curve expected.
Exercise
One task to do in Finabase. Nothing is graded or saved.
Open the DBC chart and the UUP dollar fund chart, both at the longest range. Find mid-2008 to early 2009, mid-2014 to late 2015, and the first half of 2022. In which of these did the two move in opposite directions, and in which did they rise together?
Open the DBC chartWhat you should find
In 2008 and 2014–2015 commodities fell sharply while the dollar rose, the classic inverse link. In early 2022 both rose together: the war-driven supply shock overwhelmed the dollar effect, which is why the correlation was near zero after 2022.
Sources and further reading
- Finabase chart data — DBC (March 2006 to October 2026) and Invesco DB US Dollar Index Bullish Fund (UUP, March 2007 to November 2026) monthly closes, price only
- Finabase chart data — front-month futures monthly closes: gold (GC=F), copper (HG=F), WTI (CL=F), corn (ZC=F), KC wheat (KE=F), sugar (SB=F), live cattle (LE=F), lean hogs (HE=F), 2000–2026; SPY monthly closes
- Federal Reserve Board — Nominal broad U.S. dollar index (FRED series DTWEXBGS), downloaded 2026-11-18
- Working, H. — The theory of price of storage, American Economic Review 39 (1949)
- Kaldor, N. — Speculation and economic stability, Review of Economic Studies 7 (1939)
- USDA Office of the Chief Economist — World Agricultural Supply and Demand Estimates (WASDE)
- U.S. Energy Information Administration — Weekly Petroleum Status Report
