Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Asset classes · Commodities one by one

Crude oil as a commodity: OPEC+, shale, inventories and spreads

How the crude oil market works: OPEC+ quotas and spare capacity, US shale, weekly EIA stocks at Cushing, the day WTI went negative, and the Brent–WTI spread.

On this page
  1. Oil as a traded commodity
  2. Who sets supply: OPEC+ and spare capacity
  3. US shale: the fast responder
  4. The weekly report everyone watches
  5. Worked example: the day WTI went negative
  6. The Brent–WTI spread
  7. Pitfalls when reading oil prices
  8. Crude oil compared with related energy markets
  9. How Finabase does it
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. Summary
  12. Check your understanding
  13. Exercise

Crude oil is the largest commodity market in the world and the one most people feel directly, at the gas pump and in the price of almost everything that moves by truck, ship or plane. As a traded asset it is unusual: a handful of governments can change its supply by agreement, its price is set at a few physical storage hubs, and in April 2020 the main US futures contract settled below zero.

This lesson looks at oil the way a commodity trader does. The economics lesson Oil prices and the economy: WTI, Brent, gasoline and inflation explains the difference between WTI and Brent, how oil reaches gasoline and inflation, and 40 years of price history, so we only recap it. Here the focus is on what moves the market week to week: OPEC+ and spare capacity, the quick response of US shale, the Wednesday inventory report, the storage squeeze that sent WTI negative, and the spread between the two benchmarks.

Oil as a traded commodity

Physical crude is bought and sold in cargoes and pipeline batches under private contracts. Those contracts price off a benchmark: a specific grade at a specific place whose price is visible every day. The two that matter most are West Texas Intermediate (WTI), delivered at Cushing, Oklahoma, and Brent, a basket of North Sea crudes loaded onto tankers. The basic difference is covered in Oil prices and the economy: WTI, Brent, gasoline and inflation; what matters here is that WTI is a landlocked, pipeline price and Brent is a waterborne, seaborne one. That distinction explains most of their spread.

Most of the trading happens in futures. The NYMEX light sweet crude contract, ticker CL, covers 1,000 barrels and is physically delivered at Cushing. A one-cent move is worth $10, and a $1 move is worth $1,000. ICE's Brent contract is the same size but cash-settled against an index. For how futures work in general, see Futures contracts explained: specs, clearing, expiry and settlement and Futures margin and leverage: initial, maintenance and margin calls.

Because crude is costly to store, the shape of its futures curve swings between Contango (later months dearer, storage is plentiful) and Backwardation (later months cheaper, oil is scarce now). That shape decides what an investor in a futures-based oil fund actually earns, which is the subject of Contango, backwardation and roll yield: why USO lags oil.

Who sets supply: OPEC+ and spare capacity

The Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC), founded in 1960, agrees production targets for its members. Since late 2016 it has coordinated with about ten other producers, Russia the largest, under a "Declaration of Cooperation". The combined group is called OPEC+. It meets regularly, sets quotas for each member and announces cuts or increases.

Quotas matter less than one number: spare capacity. The EIA defines it as production that can be brought online within 30 days and sustained for at least 90 days. Almost all of it sits in a few Gulf producers, Saudi Arabia above all. When spare capacity is large, a supply outage elsewhere can be offset quickly and prices tend to stay calm. When it is thin, the same outage has no cushion and prices jump.

Two things limit OPEC+'s power. Members do not always produce at their quota, so the announced cut and the real cut can differ. And every barrel OPEC+ holds back is a barrel that higher-cost producers elsewhere, above all US shale, may be happy to supply at the higher price.

US shale: the fast responder

Shale oil comes from horizontal wells and hydraulic fracturing in formations such as the Permian Basin in Texas and New Mexico. Compared with a deepwater platform that takes years to build, a shale well is drilled and producing in months. Its output also falls steeply in the first year or two, so producers must keep drilling just to hold production flat.

That makes shale a short-cycle supply. When prices rise, operators add rigs and production follows within months; when prices fall, drilling stops and output starts to slip just as fast. According to the EIA, the United States has been the world's largest crude oil producer since 2018. The practical result for prices is a softer ceiling than in the 1970s or 2000s: a rally that lasts long enough brings new barrels. It also made the 2014–2016 bust deeper, when OPEC chose to defend market share rather than cut, and WTI's monthly average fell from $105.79 to $30.32 (see the economics lesson for that history).

The weekly report everyone watches

The single most watched data release in oil is the EIA's Weekly Petroleum Status Report, published on Wednesdays at 10:30 a.m. Eastern (a day later in holiday weeks). It reports, for the week ended the previous Friday:

  • Commercial crude inventories, excluding the Strategic Petroleum Reserve.
  • Stocks at Cushing, the WTI delivery hub.
  • Refinery runs, imports, exports, and stocks of gasoline and distillates.
  • Estimated US crude production.

Traders compare each figure with forecasts. A larger-than-expected build in crude stocks usually weighs on prices; a draw lifts them. The weekly numbers are noisy: imports and exports bounce with tanker timing, so one week rarely means much. The trend over a month or a season is more informative.

Cushing gets special attention because it is where the CL contract is delivered. If storage tanks there fill up, holders of an expiring long contract have no place to put their oil. That is exactly what happened in April 2020.

Worked example: the day WTI went negative

WTI crude oil spot, Cushing, daily, January to July 2020 (US dollars per barrel) $0 $50 $0 Apr 20: −$36.98 Jan 6: $63.27 Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul
WTI crude oil spot price at Cushing, Oklahoma, daily, January 2 to July 31, 2020, US dollars per barrel. Source: EIA via FRED (DCOILWTICO).

The EIA's daily WTI spot price shows the sequence:

Date WTI spot ($/bbl) What was happening
Jan 2, 2020 61.17 Normal market
Mar 2, 2020 46.78 Demand falling as the pandemic spread
Apr 1, 2020 20.28 Travel stopped; storage filling
Apr 17, 2020 18.31 Last business day before the expiry squeeze
Apr 20, 2020 −36.98 Day before the May contract's last trading day
Apr 21, 2020 8.91 Back above zero
June 1, 2020 35.49 Recovery under way

On April 20 the May 2020 CL contract settled at −$37.63; it expired the next day. Anyone still holding a long May contract had to take delivery of 1,000 barrels at Cushing within days, and storage there was almost fully booked. With no tank to receive the oil, holders paid others to take the contracts off their hands. The CFTC's staff later published a report on that trading. The later-dated June contract stayed above zero throughout, which is the key lesson: the negative price was a delivery and storage problem in one expiring contract, not a statement that oil had no value.

What it meant in dollars, measured on the spot prices above: a fall from $18.31 on April 17 to −$36.98 is $55.29 a barrel, or $55,290 on one 1,000-barrel contract, in a single session. That is far more than the margin deposited on one contract. Futures funds that held front-month contracts were forced to change how they rolled, a story told in the commodity ETF lesson.

The Brent–WTI spread

Brent minus WTI, monthly average spot, May 1987 to September 2026 (US dollars per barrel) $50 $100 Brent and WTI spot Brent WTI $0 $10 $20 2011-09: $27.31 Brent minus WTI 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025
Brent and WTI spot prices, monthly averages, and Brent minus WTI, May 1987 to September 2026, US dollars per barrel. Source: EIA via FRED (MCOILBRENTEU, MCOILWTICO).

For more than two decades WTI usually cost a little more than Brent, because it is a lighter, sweeter crude. From May 1987 to December 2010, Brent averaged $1.37 below WTI, and WTI was the higher price in most months. Then the relationship flipped.

Period Average Brent minus WTI Main story
1987–2010 −$1.37 WTI priced as the higher-quality crude
2011–2014 +$12.61 US output trapped at Cushing by pipeline limits
2015–2019 +$4.19 New pipelines; US export ban lifted in Dec 2015
2020–2025 +$3.94 Gap set mainly by the cost of shipping US crude
Jan–Sep 2026 +$8.29 Wider gap during the 2026 price spike

In 2011 rising output from North Dakota and Canada flowed into Cushing faster than pipelines could carry it to Gulf Coast refineries. WTI became a local glut price while Brent reflected the world market. The spread peaked at $27.31 in September 2011 on monthly averages and stayed above $10 for most of 2011 to 2013. As new pipelines reversed flows toward the Gulf, and after Congress ended the ban on most US crude exports in December 2015, US crude could reach world markets and the gap narrowed. Since 2011, WTI has averaged more than Brent in only four months, all in 2016.

In 2026 the spread widened again during the price spike. Brent's monthly average reached $117.29 in April against WTI's $100.32, a gap of $16.97, and in September Brent averaged $114.16 against $97.31. This lesson does not attribute causes to those moves. On the futures side, the WTI front month closed at $69.16 on November 18, 2024, hit a two-year closing low of $55.27 on December 16, 2025 and a high of $112.95 on April 7, 2026, and stood at $83.42 on November 18, 2026.

Pitfalls when reading oil prices

  • Spot, front month and monthly average are three different numbers. The April 2020 monthly average WTI spot price was $16.55, nowhere near the −$36.98 daily print. Always check which one a chart shows.
  • A continuous futures chart is not a holding. It splices contracts at each roll and hides the roll cost or gain. See Contango, backwardation and roll yield: why USO lags oil.
  • One inventory report is noise. Weekly changes swing with ship arrivals; trends over several weeks carry the information.
  • OPEC+ headlines overstate real cuts. Compare announced quotas with reported output.
  • Physical delivery is real. Retail brokers usually force-close expiring energy positions; a long CL contract held into delivery is an obligation to receive oil.
Market Quote Delivery point Typical driver
WTI crude (CL) $/barrel Cushing, Oklahoma US supply, Cushing storage, exports
Brent crude $/barrel North Sea, cash-settled World supply, OPEC+, shipping
Natural gas (NG) $/MMBtu Henry Hub, Louisiana Weather, storage, LNG exports
RBOB gasoline $/gallon New York Harbor Refinery output, summer driving demand

Natural gas trades very differently from crude despite sharing drilling rigs; see Natural gas: Henry Hub, storage seasons and extreme volatility. For energy companies rather than the commodity, see Commodity producer stocks vs the commodity: miners and drillers.

How Finabase does it

The Futures page lists both benchmarks next to other energy contracts: CRUDEOILWTI=F for WTI, BRENTOIL=F for Brent, along with NATURALGAS=F and GASOLINERBOB=F. Each shows the last price, the daily change and returns from one week to two years, and opens a symbol page with a chart of the continuous front-month price. Energy funds and companies have ordinary symbol pages, for example XLE. The app does not show the EIA inventory report or the futures curve; the figures in this lesson are ours, built from EIA data via FRED and Finabase price history.

Frequently asked questions

Why did oil prices go negative in 2020?

Because one expiring contract ran out of buyers who could store oil. On April 20, 2020, storage at Cushing was nearly full, and holders of the May WTI contract paid to avoid taking delivery; it settled at −$37.63. Later contracts stayed positive.

Why is Brent usually more expensive than WTI?

Since 2011, mainly because of location. WTI is priced inland at Cushing and must be piped to the coast and shipped to reach world buyers; Brent is already seaborne. From 1987 to 2010 WTI was usually the dearer of the two.

What is OPEC spare capacity?

Oil production that OPEC members, chiefly Saudi Arabia, could start within 30 days and sustain for 90 days. It is the market's buffer against supply disruptions; when it is small, prices react more to outages.

When is the EIA oil inventory report released?

Wednesdays at 10:30 a.m. Eastern time, covering the week that ended the previous Friday. In weeks with a federal holiday it usually comes a day later.

Summary

Crude oil is priced through benchmarks, mainly WTI at Cushing and seaborne Brent, and traded mostly in futures of 1,000 barrels. Supply decisions by OPEC+ and the size of its spare capacity set the backdrop, US shale responds within months, and the EIA's Wednesday report gives the weekly read on stocks, especially at Cushing. Storage is not a detail: when Cushing filled in April 2020, the expiring WTI contract settled at −$37.63 and the spot price printed −$36.98. Location explains the Brent–WTI spread, which flipped from a $1.37 WTI premium before 2011 to a $12.61 Brent premium in 2011–2014 and has stayed positive in almost every month since.

Check your understanding

4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. On April 20, 2020 the expiring May WTI contract settled at −$37.63 while the June contract stayed positive. What does that tell you?

    1. Oil itself had become worthless for a day
    2. Holders of the expiring contract could not find storage at Cushing for oil they would have to receive
    3. OPEC+ had announced a production increase that morning
    Show the answer

    B. Holders of the expiring contract could not find storage at Cushing for oil they would have to receive CL is physically delivered at Cushing. With tanks there nearly full, longs in the expiring contract paid others to take it. The next month, with time to arrange storage, never went negative.

  2. Why does large OPEC+ spare capacity tend to keep oil prices calmer?

    1. It can replace barrels lost to an outage elsewhere within about a month
    2. It forces US shale producers to stop drilling
    3. It lowers the cost of storing oil
    Show the answer

    A. It can replace barrels lost to an outage elsewhere within about a month Spare capacity is output that can start within 30 days and last 90. When it is large, a disruption has a quick offset; when it is thin, prices must rise to ration demand.

  3. From 1987 to 2010 Brent averaged $1.37 below WTI; in 2011–2014 it averaged $12.61 above. What changed?

    1. Brent became a lighter, sweeter crude
    2. Rising US and Canadian output was trapped at inland Cushing by pipeline limits, so WTI traded at a local discount
    3. WTI futures switched to cash settlement
    Show the answer

    B. Rising US and Canadian output was trapped at inland Cushing by pipeline limits, so WTI traded at a local discount Location drives the spread. WTI is priced inland; when it could not reach the coast, it reflected a local glut while seaborne Brent reflected the world market. New pipelines and the end of the export ban narrowed the gap.

  4. The EIA reports a crude inventory build twice as large as forecasts one Wednesday. How much should you read into it?

    1. A lot: one weekly build sets the trend for the quarter
    2. Little on its own: weekly figures swing with tanker timing, so trends over several weeks matter more
    3. Nothing: the report does not include crude stocks
    Show the answer

    B. Little on its own: weekly figures swing with tanker timing, so trends over several weeks matter more Prices often react on the day, but imports and exports move with ship arrivals. Several weeks in the same direction, especially at Cushing, carry more information.

Exercise

One task to do in Finabase. Nothing is graded or saved.

Open the WTI crude futures page (CRUDEOILWTI=F) and note its last price and its one-year return. Then open Brent (BRENTOIL=F) and note the same two numbers. Subtract WTI from Brent to get today's spread, and compare the two one-year returns.

Open WTI crude futures
What you should find

Brent normally sits a few dollars above WTI, the cost of getting inland US crude to the sea. The two one-year returns are usually close, because both track the same world market; a gap much wider than usual points to something local, such as pipeline or storage limits.

Sources and further reading

  1. EIA — Cushing, OK WTI spot price, daily (FRED series DCOILWTICO), January 2019 to November 2026
  2. EIA — WTI and Brent spot prices, monthly averages (FRED series MCOILWTICO and MCOILBRENTEU), 1987 to 2026
  3. Finabase chart data — WTI front-month futures (CL=F), daily closes, November 2024 to November 2026
  4. EIA — Weekly Petroleum Status Report
  5. EIA — What drives crude oil prices: supply (OPEC) and spare capacity
  6. CFTC — Interim staff report on trading in NYMEX WTI crude oil futures around April 20, 2020
  7. CME Group — Light Sweet Crude Oil (CL) futures contract specifications