Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Indicators · Momentum oscillators

MACD vs. RSI: trend momentum or overbought and oversold

How MACD and RSI measure momentum differently, what two years of SPY show about their signals around the April 2025 low, and how to use them together.

On this page
  1. The two indicators side by side
  2. Two years of SPY, both indicators
  3. How they fail
  4. Which to use when
  5. How Finabase does it
  6. Frequently asked questions
  7. Summary
  8. Check your understanding

MACD (moving average convergence divergence) and the RSI (relative strength index) are the two most used momentum indicators, and they often appear together under a chart. They are not two versions of the same thing. MACD measures the gap between two moving averages of price, in dollars, and so tracks the strength and direction of a trend. The RSI measures how much of the recent price movement was up rather than down, on a fixed scale from 0 to 100, and so flags moves that have gone unusually far in one direction.

The difference shows clearly in a real sell-off. As SPY, the largest S&P 500 fund, fell 19% from February to April 2025, the RSI dropped below its oversold line of 30 on March 11, four weeks and another 10.7% before the bottom. MACD said nothing about "oversold" at all; it turned up with a bullish crossover on April 15, five sessions after the low and 8.3% above it. One warned early, the other confirmed late. This page compares the two on two years of SPY data and shows how they fit together.

The two indicators side by side

MACD (12, 26, 9) RSI (14)
What it measures Distance between a fast and a slow EMA Share of recent moves that were up
Scale Unbounded, in price units 0 to 100
Main signals Signal-line crossovers, zero-line crosses, divergence 70/30 extremes, the 50 line, divergence
Character Trend-following, slower Oscillator, quicker to extremes
Compare across stocks? Not directly (depends on price) Yes (same 0–100 scale)
Built from Exponential moving averages Wilder's smoothed gains and losses
Best in Trending markets Ranges, and to spot stretched moves
Full lesson MACD indicator: signal line, histogram and divergence Relative Strength Index (RSI): how to read and use it

Because MACD is in dollars, a $500 stock has a far larger MACD than a $50 stock with the same trend, so MACD values cannot be compared across stocks or across long periods for one stock. The RSI's fixed scale makes "above 70" mean the same thing on any chart. That is also why the RSI can be put in a Overbought or Oversold condition and MACD cannot.

Two years of SPY, both indicators

SPY daily, 2024-10-30 to 2026-10-29: RSI (14) and MACD (12, 26, 9) $500 $600 $700 Low close 2025-04-08 Price 30 50 70 RSI (14) -10 0 10 Bullish cross 2025-04-15 MACD (12, 26, 9) MACD Signal Nov Jan 2025 Mar May Jul Sep Nov Jan 2026 Mar May Jul Sep
SPY daily bars, 2024-10-30 to 2026-10-29, with RSI (14) and MACD (12, 26, 9). Source: Finabase chart data.

The RSI did its job, which is to say "this move is stretched", but a stretched move can stretch further, and anyone who bought on the first oversold reading sat through a 10.7% further fall. MACD did its job, which is to say "momentum has turned", and gave up the first 8.3% of the rebound as the price of that confirmation.

Over the full two years:

MACD (12, 26, 9) RSI (14)
Buy-side signals 23 bullish crossovers 5 crosses back above 30
Judged (20 sessions of data after) 22 5
Higher 20 sessions later 15 (68%) 3 (60%)
Sell-side readings 23 bearish crossovers RSI at or above 70 on 35 days, in 12 visits

Two things stand out. MACD signals are frequent, 23 each way in two years, because the signal line crosses whenever short-term momentum wobbles. RSI extremes are rare on a broad index fund: it spent only 8 days at or below 30. And neither hit rate beats the market itself: SPY was higher 20 sessions later on 318 of the 481 days in the snapshot (66%), so in a rising market a coin-flip entry did about as well. Neither indicator is a system on its own.

How they fail

RSI in a trend. In a strong uptrend the RSI can sit above 70 for weeks; SPY entered that zone 12 times. Selling each one would have meant selling strength. The same is true of oversold readings in a crash.

MACD in a range. When the price moves sideways, the two EMAs converge and the signal line is crossed again and again. Each crossover arrives after the move it reports, so in a range MACD buys near the top of each swing and sells near the bottom.

Divergence on both. Both indicators can show Divergence: regular and hidden, bullish and bearish, with RSI and MACD, where price makes a new extreme and the indicator does not. Divergences can persist through several new highs or lows before anything happens; they are a warning, not a timing signal.

Which to use when

Question Use Why
Is the trend up or down, and strengthening? MACD (zero line, histogram) Built from trend-following averages
Has this move gone unusually far, unusually fast? RSI (70/30) Bounded scale designed for extremes
Has a sell-off actually started to reverse? MACD crossover, after an RSI extreme Combines warning and confirmation
Comparing momentum across many stocks RSI Same 0–100 scale everywhere
Range-bound, sideways market RSI MACD whipsaws when averages converge
Strong, persistent trend MACD (and RSI's 40–50 support zone) RSI extremes are unreliable sell signals here

A common combined reading: the RSI reaches an extreme (or shows divergence) to say a move is stretched, then MACD's histogram turns or its line crosses the signal line to say momentum has actually changed. On SPY in 2025 that sequence ran from the March 11 oversold reading to the April 15 crossover. Together they would have kept a trader out of the last 10.7% of the fall without waiting for a new uptrend to be obvious.

How Finabase does it

Both indicators are standard studies on every Finabase chart, computed with TA-Lib: RSI with a 14-day default and MACD with 12, 26 and 9 (the study title lists the slow period first, as the original Stock Master app did). The link above opens SPY with both panels. On each symbol page's technical gauge, RSI above 70 counts as overbought and below 30 as oversold; MACD counts as bullish whenever its histogram is at or above zero and bearish below it. The Scanner lists stocks at RSI extremes and stocks whose MACD histogram has just crossed zero, with the date. These are readings of where each indicator stands, not recommendations.

Frequently asked questions

Which is better, MACD or RSI?

Neither. They answer different questions: MACD whether the trend's momentum is rising or falling, the RSI whether a move has gone unusually far. Many traders use both on one chart.

Can MACD show overbought and oversold?

Not in the usual sense, because it has no fixed upper or lower bound. Very large MACD readings compared with the stock's own history do suggest a stretched move, but there is no standard "overbought" MACD level.

Should I buy when RSI is below 30?

An oversold RSI says the recent fall has been steep, not that it is over. SPY's RSI went below 30 on March 11, 2025 and the fund fell another 10.7% before turning. Waiting for confirmation, such as a MACD crossover, trades a later entry for fewer false starts.

What settings should I use?

The defaults, 14 for the RSI and 12, 26, 9 for MACD, are the most widely watched. Shorter settings give earlier and noisier signals. The Relative Strength Index (RSI): how to read and use it and MACD indicator: signal line, histogram and divergence lessons compare alternatives.

Summary

MACD measures the gap between a fast and a slow moving average and is a trend-momentum tool; the RSI measures the balance of recent gains and losses on a 0–100 scale and is an overextension tool. In SPY's 2025 sell-off the RSI warned on March 11, 10.7% before the bottom, and MACD confirmed the turn on April 15, 8.3% after it. Over two years MACD gave 23 buy-side crossovers and the RSI only 5 oversold recoveries. Use the RSI to see that a move is stretched, MACD to see that momentum has turned, and neither as a stand-alone trading system.

Check your understanding

4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. Why can you compare RSI readings across different stocks but not MACD readings?

    1. RSI is bounded from 0 to 100, while MACD is measured in price units and grows with the share price
    2. MACD uses more data
    3. RSI is calculated on volume
    Show the answer

    A. RSI is bounded from 0 to 100, while MACD is measured in price units and grows with the share price MACD is the dollar gap between two EMAs, so a $500 stock has a bigger MACD than a $50 stock with the same trend. RSI is a ratio on a fixed 0–100 scale.

  2. In SPY’s 2025 sell-off, the RSI first reached 30 on March 11 and MACD crossed bullish on April 15. What did each tell a trader?

    1. Both marked the exact bottom
    2. RSI warned the move was stretched, 10.7% before the low; MACD confirmed the turn, 8.3% after it
    3. MACD warned early and RSI confirmed late
    Show the answer

    B. RSI warned the move was stretched, 10.7% before the low; MACD confirmed the turn, 8.3% after it An oversold RSI says a fall has been steep, not that it is over. A MACD crossover reports a change in momentum after it has happened, so it is late but confirmed.

  3. In a strong, persistent uptrend, what is the main risk of selling every time RSI goes above 70?

    1. RSI cannot go above 70 in an uptrend
    2. MACD will turn negative
    3. Selling strength repeatedly: RSI can stay above 70 for weeks while the trend continues
    Show the answer

    C. Selling strength repeatedly: RSI can stay above 70 for weeks while the trend continues Overbought readings are common in strong trends. SPY’s RSI entered the zone 12 times in two years of a mostly rising market.

  4. Which market condition makes MACD crossovers least reliable?

    1. A sideways, range-bound market
    2. A strong trend
    3. A market with high volume
    Show the answer

    A. A sideways, range-bound market When price moves sideways the two EMAs converge and the MACD line keeps crossing the signal line, each time after the swing it reports.

Sources and further reading

  1. J. Welles Wilder Jr., New Concepts in Technical Trading Systems (1978), the Relative Strength Index
  2. Gerald Appel, Technical Analysis: Power Tools for Active Investors (2005), MACD
  3. TA-Lib — RSI and MACD function definitions
  4. Finabase chart data — SPY daily bars, 2024-10-30 to 2026-10-29; indicators computed with the Learn indicator code, which test/learn-labs.test.ts holds to the chart’s TA-Lib output