Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

How Wall Street really works Lesson 1 of 14

Hedge funds and AI · Hedge funds

What is a hedge fund? Structure, fees and who can invest

How a hedge fund is set up, who may invest, what "2 and 20" and a high-water mark cost in dollars, the main strategies and how hedge funds differ from mutual funds.

On this page
  1. Where the name came from
  2. How a hedge fund is set up
  3. Who can invest
  4. What 2 and 20 costs
  5. The high-water mark
  6. Getting money out
  7. The main strategies
  8. Hedge funds and the funds most people own
  9. Where hedge funds fail
  10. How Finabase does it
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. Summary
  13. Check your understanding
  14. Exercise

A hedge fund is a private investment fund that pools money from a limited group of wealthy or institutional investors and can invest in almost anything, using techniques that ordinary funds are restricted from using: short selling, heavy borrowing and derivatives. In exchange for that freedom, it is closed to most of the public, publishes little about itself and charges far higher fees than a typical mutual fund or ETF.

The name is older than most of what hedge funds do today. This lesson explains how a hedge fund is set up, the US rules on who may invest, what the classic "2 and 20" fee structure costs in dollars, the main strategies, and how hedge funds compare with the funds most people own.

Where the name came from

The first fund usually called a hedge fund was started in 1949 by Alfred Winslow Jones, a sociologist and journalist. Jones bought stocks he expected to rise and sold short stocks he expected to fall, so that a fall in the whole market would be partly offset, or hedged, by the short positions. He also borrowed to increase his bets, and took 20% of the profits as his fee. A 1966 Fortune article by Carol Loomis, "The Jones Nobody Keeps Up With", made his record famous and the idea spread.

Many hedge funds today do not hedge in Jones's sense at all. The term now describes a legal and fee structure more than a strategy: a private fund, open to a limited set of investors, that can do almost anything and charges for performance. Short selling explained: borrowing, fees, rules and unlimited risk explains the short side of Jones's idea.

How a hedge fund is set up

A typical US hedge fund is a limited partnership or limited liability company:

  • The manager (the investment adviser) runs the portfolio and is usually the general partner. Most managers of any size are registered with the SEC as investment advisers.
  • The investors are limited partners. They own shares of the fund's assets and share in its gains and losses, but have no say in individual investments.
  • Many funds also have an offshore version for non-US and tax-exempt investors, often feeding into one master portfolio.

The fund is not registered as an investment company the way a mutual fund is. It relies on one of two exclusions in the Investment Company Act of 1940: section 3(c)(1), for funds with no more than 100 beneficial owners that are not publicly offered, or section 3(c)(7), for funds owned only by qualified purchasers. Because it is not a registered fund, it is not bound by the mutual fund limits on leverage, short selling, concentration and illiquid holdings, and it does not have to publish a daily price or a public prospectus.

Who can invest

US law keeps most hedge funds to investors who are presumed able to bear the risk and to evaluate the fund without the protections of a public offering. The shares are sold in a private placement, usually under Regulation D, to accredited investors. An individual generally qualifies with:

  • income above $200,000 in each of the two most recent years, or above $300,000 together with a spouse or spousal equivalent, and a reasonable expectation of the same this year; or
  • net worth above $1 million, alone or with a spouse or spousal equivalent, not counting the primary residence; or
  • since the SEC's 2020 amendments, certain professional credentials, such as the Series 7, 65 or 82 licenses, in good standing.

Funds that rely on section 3(c)(7) need a higher bar, the qualified purchaser: for an individual, generally someone who owns at least $5 million in investments. Pension funds, endowments, insurers and other institutions provide much of hedge funds' money.

A rule on fees adds one more test: an adviser charging a performance fee generally may do so only to "qualified clients", a definition with higher dollar thresholds than accredited investor status. The practical effect is that a hedge fund is not something most people can buy, even if they want to.

What "2 and 20" costs

The classic fee structure is 2 and 20: a management fee of 2% of assets each year, charged whether the fund gains or loses, plus a performance fee (also called an incentive fee) of 20% of the profits. Many funds now charge less, and some of the most sought-after charge more or pass their running costs through to investors, but 2 and 20 remains the reference point.

Fees compound like returns. The chart applies the same 8% gross return each year to $100,000 for 20 years under three cost structures.

The same 8% gross return for 20 years, after fees: $100,000 invested $0k $100k $200k $300k $400k $500k 0y 5y 10y 15y 20y Before any fee Index fund, 0.05% a year "2 and 20" with a high-water mark $249,236 $461,457 Years
Finabase calculation on an invented, constant 8% gross return. Management fee on year-end assets; performance fee on gains above the high-water mark; no hurdle rate, taxes or other costs.

This does not mean hedge funds earn the same gross return as an index fund; their aim is different, often lower volatility or returns that do not move with the stock market. It shows how much better a fund must do before fees for its investors to come out ahead.

The high-water mark

A high-water mark is the highest value at which the fund has already charged a performance fee. If the fund loses money, it must climb back above that mark before it can charge the performance fee again. Without it, investors would pay a fee on the recovery of their own losses.

Fees on $1,000,000 in a "2 and 20" fund with a high-water mark Management fee (2%) Performance fee (20% above the mark) $24k $35k Year 1 (+20%) $19k $0 Year 2 (−15%) $21k $0 Year 3 (+10%) $23k $0 Year 4 (+12%) $24k $3k Year 5 (+5%) Invented gross returns. Management fee on year-end assets; no hurdle rate.
Finabase calculation on invented gross returns of +20%, −15%, +10%, +12% and +5%. Management fee on year-end assets; no hurdle rate.

In this example, a $1,000,000 investment ends year 1 at $1,140,800, which becomes the high-water mark. A 15% fall in year 2 takes it to $950,286. Years 3 and 4 are good years, up 10% and 12%, but the account is still below $1,140,800, so no performance fee is charged; the 2% management fee is charged every year regardless. Only in year 5, when the account passes the old mark, is a small performance fee of $3,240 charged on the gain above it.

Some funds also set a hurdle rate, a minimum return, such as the Treasury bill rate, that must be beaten before any performance fee applies.

Getting money out

Hedge funds trade daily, but investors cannot leave daily. Typical terms include:

  • a lockup, often a year, during which money cannot be withdrawn;
  • redemptions only monthly or quarterly, with 30 to 90 days' notice;
  • gates, which let the manager limit how much can leave at once in a rush; and
  • side pockets, which set aside hard-to-sell holdings until they can be sold.

These terms protect the remaining investors from forced selling, but they mean an investor may not get money out when they most want it.

The main strategies

Hedge funds are usually grouped by what they do:

Strategy What it does
Long/short equity Buys stocks expected to rise and shorts those expected to fall; Jones's original
Global macro Bets on interest rates, currencies, commodities and indexes based on economic views
Event-driven Trades around mergers, bankruptcies, spin-offs and other corporate events
Relative value Exploits small price gaps between related securities, often with heavy leverage
Quantitative Uses statistical models and computers to choose and size trades
Multi-strategy Runs many teams and strategies under one roof, with central risk limits

Jim Simons and Renaissance Technologies: the Medallion Fund record tells the story of the most famous quantitative fund, and Long-Term Capital Management (1998): how leverage sank a genius fund of a relative-value fund whose leverage nearly broke the bond market in 1998.

Hedge funds and the funds most people own

Hedge fund Mutual fund or ETF
Who can buy Accredited or qualified investors Anyone
Minimum Often $100,000 to $1 million or more Often a single share
Typical fees Management fee plus performance fee An expense ratio; index funds very low
Getting money out Monthly or quarterly, after a lockup Daily
Short selling, leverage Few limits Limited by law
Public information Little; private reports to investors Prospectus, daily price, holdings

Where hedge funds fail

  • Leverage cuts both ways. Long-Term Capital Management lost most of its capital in a few weeks in 1998, and Amaranth Advisors collapsed in 2006 after losses of about $6 billion on natural gas.
  • Fees eat returns. As the chart shows, a fund must beat a cheap index fund by a wide margin before fees just to match it after them.
  • Published performance flatters. Hedge fund indexes are built from returns that funds choose to report. Funds that close after losses stop reporting (survivorship bias), and funds that start reporting after a good run add a flattering history (backfill bias).
  • Little transparency. Investors may not see what the fund holds, and the leverage it carries can be hidden from them. The 2021 collapse of Archegos, a family office rather than a hedge fund, showed how concentrated, hidden leverage can hurt banks as well as the investor (The Archegos collapse (2021): swaps, hidden leverage and bank losses).

How Finabase does it

Hedge funds do not publish daily prices, so Finabase cannot quote them. What is public is their long US stock positions: managers with at least $100 million in qualifying securities file a quarterly Form 13F with the SEC, and the Holders tab on any Finabase symbol page, such as Apple's, shows the top institutions and funds that hold the stock. 13F filings: what institutional holdings reports show and miss explains what those filings show and why they are always weeks out of date.

Frequently asked questions

Can an ordinary investor buy a hedge fund?

Generally not directly. Most US hedge funds accept only accredited investors or qualified purchasers. Some mutual funds and ETFs use hedge-fund-style strategies, often called liquid alternatives, under the rules for public funds.

What does "2 and 20" mean?

A management fee of 2% of assets per year plus a performance fee of 20% of the profits. On a constant 8% gross return, it turns 8% into about 4.67% a year for the investor.

Why are they called hedge funds?

The first one, started by Alfred Winslow Jones in 1949, sold some stocks short to hedge against a falling market while it bought others. Many modern hedge funds do not hedge in that sense.

Do hedge funds beat the market?

Some do, for a while, and a few for a long time. As a group, after fees, the record is mixed, and the published indexes overstate it because funds choose whether to report.

Summary

A hedge fund is a private fund that trades freely, with few of the limits on public funds, in exchange for accepting only wealthy and institutional investors. Its fees, classically a 2% management fee and 20% of profits above a high-water mark, take a large share of gross returns, and its money is locked up for months at a time. It is a structure, not a promise of better returns: what matters is what the fund does, how much it charges and how much risk it takes to do it.

Check your understanding

4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. A fund charges "2 and 20" with a high-water mark and no hurdle. $1,000,000 grows to $1,100,000 before fees in its first year. Roughly what are the two fees?

    1. A $22,000 management fee and a $15,600 performance fee
    2. A $20,000 management fee and a $20,000 performance fee
    3. Only a $22,000 management fee, because performance fees start in year two
    Show the answer

    A. A $22,000 management fee and a $15,600 performance fee The management fee is 2% of the $1,100,000 year-end assets, $22,000, leaving $1,078,000. The performance fee is 20% of the $78,000 gain above the $1,000,000 starting mark, $15,600. Together they take $37,600 of a $100,000 gross gain.

  2. After a loss year, a fund sits below its high-water mark. The next year it gains 10% but is still below the mark. What fees are charged?

    1. The management fee only
    2. Both the management fee and the performance fee
    3. No fees at all until the mark is passed
    Show the answer

    A. The management fee only The high-water mark stops the performance fee until the fund climbs above its previous peak, so investors do not pay twice for the same gains. The management fee is charged every year on assets, whatever the return.

  3. Which person generally meets the US accredited investor test for individuals?

    1. Someone with a $1.5 million net worth not counting their home
    2. Someone with a $1.2 million net worth, all of it in their primary home
    3. Someone who earned $250,000 last year and $90,000 the year before
    Show the answer

    A. Someone with a $1.5 million net worth not counting their home Net worth above $1 million counts only without the primary residence, so a net worth made up of the home does not qualify. The income test needs more than $200,000 (or $300,000 jointly) in each of the two most recent years, not just one.

  4. Why is a published hedge fund index likely to overstate how hedge funds did as a group?

    1. Funds choose whether to report, failed funds stop reporting, and new funds add only good histories
    2. Index providers are required to leave out funds that beat the market
    3. Hedge funds report their returns before management fees only
    Show the answer

    A. Funds choose whether to report, failed funds stop reporting, and new funds add only good histories Reporting to hedge fund databases is voluntary. Survivorship bias removes funds that closed after losses, and backfill bias adds the good early record of funds that start reporting only after a strong run. Both push the index above what investors actually earned.

Exercise

One task to do in Finabase. Nothing is graded or saved.

Open Apple’s Holders tab and read the list of top institutional holders. Sort the names into two groups: firms best known for index funds and ETFs, and any you recognize as hedge fund managers. Then note the date each holding was reported.

Open Apple’s holders
What you should find

The top of the list is usually index fund and ETF giants, not hedge funds. A hedge fund shows up here only through its quarterly Form 13F, filed by managers with at least $100 million in qualifying securities. It lists long US stock positions only and is always weeks out of date, so it never shows a fund’s short sales, borrowing or fees.

Sources and further reading

  1. SEC Investor.gov — Hedge funds
  2. eCFR — 17 CFR 230.501, Definitions for Regulation D (accredited investor)
  3. SEC — Accredited investors
  4. SEC — Press release 2020-191, SEC modernizes the accredited investor definition (August 26, 2020)
  5. US Code (Cornell LII) — 15 U.S.C. 80a-3, definition of investment company; sections 3(c)(1) and 3(c)(7)
  6. US Code (Cornell LII) — 15 U.S.C. 80a-2(a)(51), definition of qualified purchaser
  7. Loomis, C. J., "The Jones Nobody Keeps Up With", Fortune, April 1966
  8. Finabase calculations: fee arithmetic on invented returns (no hedge fund index data is used)