Glossary
Internalization
When a broker or market maker fills a customer's order from its own inventory instead of sending it to an exchange.
Internalization means an order is filled inside a firm without reaching a public exchange. The firm takes the other side itself, as a principal, or matches it against another of its customers.
Retail orders in the US
Most marketable orders from individual investors in US stocks are internalized by a small number of large market-making firms called wholesalers. Brokers send orders to them, often in exchange for payment for order flow. The wholesaler fills the order at or better than the national best bid and offer, keeps a small spread, and offsets its position over time.
Why it exists
Retail orders tend to be small and are unlikely to come from traders with short-term information, so market makers can fill them at narrow spreads with little risk. Brokers can offer commission-free trading partly on the strength of this arrangement.
The debate
- For: retail investors often receive prices better than the public quote, and trading costs for individuals have fallen sharply.
- Against: orders that never reach exchanges do not contribute to public price discovery. Wholesalers see a great deal of order flow. Whether investors would get even better prices if orders competed openly is disputed.
In late 2022 the SEC proposed rules to send many retail orders to open auctions. In 2024 it adopted narrower changes to disclosure and tick sizes, and it later withdrew the auction proposal.
Limits
The best execution duty applies, but measuring it depends on reports produced by the firms themselves.
