Glossary
Price improvement
Getting a better price than the best publicly quoted one: paying less than the ask when buying, or receiving more than the bid when selling.
Price improvement occurs when an order is filled at a price better than the national best bid or offer (NBBO) at that moment. A buy order improved fills below the best ask. A sell order improved fills above the best bid.
Where it comes from
- Wholesalers. Most US retail stock orders are sent to market-making firms that fill them from their own inventory. Retail orders are small and carry little information, so these firms can profit while giving a slightly better price than the public quote.
- Hidden and midpoint orders. Exchanges and dark pools hold undisplayed orders priced inside the spread.
- Auctions. In options, many orders are briefly exposed to competing market makers before they are filled.
How to judge it
US market centers must publish monthly execution statistics, and many brokers summarize them: the share of orders improved, the average improvement per share, and the "effective spread" paid compared with the quoted spread.
What to keep in mind
- It is linked to payment for order flow. The wholesaler pays the broker for orders and also gives some improvement to the customer. Critics argue customers might do better still if those orders competed openly.
- Wide spreads leave more room. A cent of improvement on a stock with a ten-cent spread is modest. The useful comparison is with the midpoint.
- Odd lots. Quotes smaller than 100 shares inside the spread have historically not counted in the NBBO, so some "improvement" was measured against a stale benchmark.
- Limit orders set your price in advance and do not depend on any of this.
