Glossary
Best execution
A broker's legal duty to seek the most favorable terms reasonably available when carrying out a customer's order.
Best execution is the obligation of a broker to get customers the best terms it reasonably can when it handles their orders. In the US it comes from the broker's duties to its customer and is spelled out in FINRA rules.
What "best" means
Price matters most for a small order in a liquid stock, but it is not the only factor. A broker must use "reasonable diligence" and weigh:
- the price, including any price improvement
- the speed of execution
- the likelihood that the whole order is filled
- the size and type of the order
- the character of the market for that security
The duty does not guarantee the best possible price on every trade. It requires a sound process.
How brokers meet it
Most retail brokers do not examine each order one by one. They conduct what the rules call a regular and rigorous review, at least quarterly, comparing the execution quality they received from each venue with what other venues offered, and adjusting their routing.
Why it is debated
Many brokers are paid by market makers for sending them orders, known as payment for order flow. That gives the broker a financial reason to choose a venue. Regulators have fined firms that let such payments shape routing without checking whether customers were getting good prices.
What you can check
- Routing reports. US brokers must publish quarterly where they send orders and what payments they receive.
- Your own fills. Compare execution prices with the quote at the time.
- Order type. A limit order controls price directly.
