Glossary
Stock appreciation right (SAR)
An award that pays an employee the rise in a share price above a set base price, in cash or shares, without buying any stock.
On this page
A stock appreciation right (SAR) is an award that pays an employee the increase in a company's share price over a fixed base price, for a set number of shares. It works like an employee stock option without the purchase: the employee never pays the exercise price, and simply receives the gain, in cash or in shares.
Tax
In the US there is no tax when a SAR is granted or vests. At exercise the gain is ordinary income, reported on the employee's W-2 with withholding. Shares received then start a new holding period, with a cost basis equal to their value at exercise.
A SAR stays outside the strict deferred-pay rules of section 409A only if its base price is at least the stock's fair market value on the grant date and it carries no other deferral feature (Treasury Regulation §1.409A-1(b)(5)). A discounted SAR becomes nonqualified deferred compensation and must meet 409A's timing rules.
Compared with options
- No cash needed. The employee does not fund an exercise price or sell shares to cover it.
- Less dilution. A stock-settled SAR issues only the shares equal to the gain, 384 in the example, where an option would issue 1,000 shares in exchange for $40,000.
- Accounting. A stock-settled SAR is expensed like an option, based on its grant-date value. A cash-settled SAR is a liability that the company remeasures every quarter until it is paid.
SARs are sometimes granted alongside options ("tandem SARs") or by private companies as an alternative to phantom stock.
