Glossary
Phantom stock
A cash bonus plan that pays employees the value of a set number of company shares, or its growth, without giving them any actual stock.
Phantom stock is a promise to pay an employee cash equal to the value of a number of company shares, at a future date, without ever issuing those shares. The employee follows the stock's value like an owner but has no vote, no dividends unless the plan adds "dividend equivalents", and no shares to sell. Private companies, family firms and partnerships use it to share growth without giving away ownership.
Two designs
- Full-value units pay the whole value of the shares at payout, like a cash-settled RSU.
- Appreciation-only units pay only the rise over the starting value, like a cash-settled stock appreciation right.
A private company usually values its units by a formula or an annual appraisal, since there is no market price.
Tax and the 409A rules
In the US, phantom stock is taxed as ordinary income when paid, and the company deducts it then. If payment is deferred past the short-term window below, Social Security and Medicare tax is generally due when the units vest rather than when they are paid.
Because payment is deferred, a phantom plan is nonqualified deferred compensation under section 409A unless it fits the short-term deferral exception: payment no later than the 15th day of the third month after the end of the year in which the units vest, so March 15 for calendar-year vesting. Plans that pay later must fix the payment date or event in advance.
Trade-offs
The company keeps its cap table unchanged, but must pay in cash, sometimes a large sum at a bad moment. The employee gets no shares and is an unsecured creditor until paid.
