Glossary
Plurality voting
The director-election rule under which the nominees with the most votes win, so an unopposed nominee is elected even with mostly withheld votes.
Plurality voting is the rule that the nominees with the most votes win the open seats. In a US director election where there are exactly as many nominees as seats, which is the usual case, every nominee is elected even if most shareholders withhold their votes: one vote for is enough. Shareholders cannot vote against under plurality, only "for" or "withhold".
The default and the alternative
- Plurality is the default in Delaware: §216 says directors are elected by a plurality of the votes of shares present, unless the charter or bylaws say otherwise.
- Majority voting requires a nominee in an uncontested election to receive more votes for than against. Most large US companies switched to it in the 2000s after investor campaigns. Apple's bylaws, for example, require a majority of the shares present and voting.
- Contested elections, with more nominees than seats, usually revert to plurality, since otherwise too few nominees might win, as in a proxy fight.
The holdover problem
Under Delaware §141(b) a director keeps the seat until a successor is chosen, so a director who fails a majority vote does not leave on their own. Companies therefore pair majority voting with a resignation policy: the director tenders a resignation and the board decides whether to accept it. Boards often decline.
Why it matters
Plurality voting turns a director election into a signal rather than a choice. A high withhold count still makes news and often leads to change, but it removes no one. The proxy statement says which standard applies, and the Proxy voting: how shareholders vote at the annual meeting lesson walks through a real ballot.
