Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Glossary

Naked short selling

Selling shares short without first borrowing them or arranging to borrow them, which is restricted in the US by Regulation SHO.

On this page
  1. What US rules say
  2. Why it is restricted
  3. Common misreadings
  4. Related terms

In an ordinary short sale, the seller borrows shares and delivers them to the buyer. In a naked short sale, the seller has not borrowed the shares and has not arranged to. If none are found by settlement, the result is a failure to deliver.

What US rules say

  • Locate requirement. Under Regulation SHO, a broker must have reasonable grounds to believe the shares can be borrowed before it accepts a short sale. Shares on the hard-to-borrow list may not be available at all.
  • Close-out requirement. Fails must be closed out quickly by buying or borrowing the shares.
  • Market maker exception. Firms genuinely making markets may sell short without a locate, because they must fill customer orders at once. They remain subject to the close-out rule.
  • Fraud rule. Since 2008, SEC Rule 10b-21 makes it fraud to mislead a broker about your ability or intention to deliver shares.

So naked shorting is not banned outright. Selling short with no intention of delivering is the abusive form, and that is illegal.

Why it is restricted

A seller who never has to deliver could sell unlimited shares and push a price down. During the 2008 crisis the SEC issued emergency orders against naked shorting of financial stocks and then tightened the close-out rules permanently.

Common misreadings

  • Short interest above 100% of the float does not prove naked shorting. A borrowed share can be sold, lent again by its new owner, and sold again.
  • Fails to deliver arise from many causes.

Enforcement cases do occur, but claims that naked shorting explains a falling share price are far more common than findings that it did.

Sources and further reading

  1. SEC: Key points about Regulation SHO

Written and fact-checked by Finabase Research. Last reviewed . Spotted an error? Tell us.

Educational content, not investment advice. Finabase Learn explains how markets and tools work. It does not recommend any security or strategy, and examples are for illustration only. Investing involves risk, including the loss of principal. Rules and figures are for the United States unless stated and can change — check the cited source before you act. Data and corrections policy.